My husband and I each ordered an 12" Italian sub to eat at the beach. Both had very little meat inside - one or two pieces of what looked like mortadella and a few small pieces of pepperoni. There was also some shredded mozzarella with lettuce and tomato on it. We waited 30 minutes for them, then went to the beach before we opened them. We should've gone back and asked for our $25 back. Would not recommend this establishmen. read more

First visit, had a bad experience here on a weekday afternoon. The restaurant is seat yourself or you can order at the counter. It took a while for anyone to notice us at our table. The server was very nice but their clothes looked dirty, which is not comforting at a food-service establishment. We really only wanted to order a couple slices but the menu says that the lunch special Pizza By The Slice runs from only 11-3, and since it was around 430p we did not order slices. However the next two customers who came in ordered and received single pizza slices, so we were quite disappointed by that bc we felt that our only option was to order whole pizzas. We ordered two pies; they were not the worst pizzas we've ever had, but definitely not good quality. The Greek pizza had good ingredients but every item was crunchy/undercooked. The pizza was hot but there were so many toppings that water dripping from our pizzas. After removing a slice or two from the pan, the other slices were sitting in water... The other pizza was pep and sausage, and after picking up the slice, all the meat and cheese toppings slid right off the dough. This one was also a very wet pizza. This restaurant says it's New York style pizza but it was not what you'd expect: thick crust, normal size slices. Would not return. read more

It was our last night in St., Augustine we decided we wanted to try a pizza place. I'm glad we did. Food was great. Service was great. The young man even helped us out with a care package of forks, napkins, and condiments went back to the hotel with the pizza. read more

Stopped in here after a short stay at the beach and it was great; simple yet tasty NYC style pizza. By the slice combo was good; 2 slices plus a drink for $6. Staff (cook, maybe owner???) was super friendly and personable and accommodated our gluten free request thoughtfully and proactively, which was super cool. Thanks! read more

Antonio's Pizza at the Beach - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

See all

Pizza was just ok. They were understaffed and food took longer than anticipated. Dough had nice crispness. Meats are average quality read more

The cashier is also the pizza prep person, handling money and the cash register as well as putting toppings on an already dry pizza and sliding it in the oven. The slice looked disgusting and had to throw it away. Informed the cashier that he should use gloves when switching between food prep and handling money, he pretended he didn't speak English. Unsanitary and disgusting. Stay away. read more

Antonio's Pizza at the Beach - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

The staff was friendly when ordering and the pizza exceeded our expectations. Definitely a legit New York style pie with thin, yet crispy crust and very fresh tasting sauce and toppings. Little gem of a pizza place that we will frequent in St. Augustine Beach when visiting. read more

Antonio's Pizza at the Beach - XL pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Awesome pizza and salads! My family loved it! We ordered two XL pepperoni pizzas, one XL cheese, one XL deluxe pizza and a few side salads. This pizza place is my kids fav pizza now. Don't know what we will do when we get back home and don't have access to it. Great customer service and the family that owns it are super kind! read more

Great gluten free pizza! The best gf crust I have ever had! Just wish the AC worked a little better. A fan might help.

Meh. Was hoping my $20+ pizza would be as good as the comparably high priced pie from my favorite pizzeria on Long Island but alas, it just was not. Had pepperoni & mushroom with onion on half. Mushrooms were small, onions were pretty much raw. Was a called in pick-up & take out so was surprised there wasn't a set-up to facilitate that. Had to scrounge small paper napkins out of a dispenser, no offer of plasticware or even beverages. Right next door to a pretty nice Hilton property with lots of families staying & only one real restaurant on property. Great opportunity being missed by just being average. read more

Pizza was okay. Crust wasn't bad but not a fan of the sauce and cheese. I don't think anything was really made there. Sauce, cheese (commercially shredded, crust..all bought. We live on Long Island and worked in NYC for decades, so definitely pizza snobs. But if you are going to advertise pizza a NY, slices should be 2x larger and foldable and everything should be made in house. read more

Until today I was a reqular eating at this place 3 to 4 times a month. While the food is good especially their gyros. However, the customer service is extremely poor. Being that I am a regular and with my restaurant and customer service background I would never treat a customer the way I was treated tonight. Me and my wife always come in to order their gyros along with the occasional pizza to take home. I always order something to drink regardless of what I order. Tonight they were a little busy and they were out of ice which would be acceptable if the server or kitchen staff would tell the customer first before they order something to drink rather than wait till the bringing the customer their drinks. The server on duty failed to tell me that there was ice before ordering my drinks. I wasn't told there was no ice till she brought the drinks to my table. If I was the server and I forgot to mention that when the customer placed the drink order I would not make my customer pay for it. To make matters worse I asked if I could get some ice the moment their was even the littlest amount of ice. When I saw the server bringing drinks to customers who came in well after me with ice my wife asked the server if we could get ice and we were told that she ran out of ice once again and she was very rude in how she said it. Due to the poor customer service I asked to have my order to go when I originally ordered it to dine in like I normally always do. Not to mention drinking warm ice tea without the ice is pretty horrible as it is and why would I want to stay their just to drink warm ice tea? My wifes warm Dr. Pepper was no better as Dr. Pepper that is warm and has no ice is pretty disgusting as it is. I was willing to stay and eat in had I been given even the smallest amount of ice like I originally asked. I ordered a gyro which if you have ever had a gyro you know that they get soggy pretty quick if the are not eaten right away which is why I always choose to dine in. This time after being treated so poorly I decided to leave knowing that the chances of me making it home without having a soggy mess was slim to none. Sure enough the bread, lettuce and meat were so soggy that for me it was an entire waste of money. My wife ate some of the meat but for the most part it went into the trash and we went back out and ordered a pizza from a local pizza joint even though Antonios serves pizza too as its the main part of their business. The sad part is I am a resident of St. Augustine and I came in a lot until tonight as they are losing my business forever. I know that won't make a huge dent to their business due to all the traffic they get from tourists. However, over the long term I am the one that has friends and family that comes into town to visit often and I am the one they turn to first when they want me to recommend a good place to eat based on what they want to eat at that time. Not to mention they know me and my wife are foodies and will not recommend a place that we would not ho ourselves. Up until tonight I was planning on taking family that will be visiting me next week to Antonios however I now will be taking them someplace else. Whats even worse is this whole thing could have been avoided if I was told about not having ice before placing my drink order as I might have gone somewhere else to return on a night they weren't near as busy. Or I would have just ran across the street to get a cup of ice for myself. The best scenario for all of the customers that were dining in would have been to send one if the staff members across the street to buy a bag of ice rather than serve everyone warm drinks. I can tell you that if I owned a restaurant and I ran low of ice I would have been sending someone across the street to get some. The gas station is literally less than the length of a whole football field away from the restaurant which means someone could have ran and got a bag of ice in 5 minutes or less. This was poor service and even though Antonios has the best gyro in town for the price I will not be back as I would rather pay more for a less superior gyro or pizza than be treated the way me and my wife were treated tonight which should never happen to anyone. I did call and request that the owner call me when he comes in but I have yet to hear anything from this issue. read more

We saw the window were it says they have Gyro, so we decided to try them. OMG! The gyro is huge and perfectly seasoned with plenty zatziki sauce very good. Very polite and courteous in here. We Recommend this casual spot! read more

Antonio's Pizza at the Beach - Front of the menu - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Great Pizza! Good prices! Fast and good service! Didn't answer the phone for a call in order, ended up having to walk to the restaurant to order and we decided to just eat in, the environment isn't the best, a little dated, but the food and service was great, super nice people. Will go again! read more

Antonio's Pizza at the Beach - XL extra cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

See all

I love this place! Food is fresh and hot and delicious. I come here every time I'm on the island. You def need to get the lunch special of 2 slices and a drink for $5.99. It smells so good in their. Sometimes I just buy a pizza and leave it in my car so it smells good. read more

Antonio's Pizza at the Beach - Lunch special - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

The pizza was one step up from a store bought frozen pizza. Bland and uninspiring and not even close to New York style. Regrettable decision. read more

What a joke....pizza from Antonio's at the beach. We ordered two 18 inch pizzas at $25.00. I would pay more if you had fresh ingredients and cooked properly. This place is convenient for us tourist but the pizza is not good. read more

This pizza was fantastic. Crust is great and tasty. We had the Deluxe, we were fighting each other for the last piece. I simply do not understand any bad review of their pizza! read more

This place needs a major makeover. The decor is outdated and the benches are falling apart. Pizza is yum. Huge slices, crispy crust, and cheap prices. Cheesy bread is good, but it's hard to mess up bread with cheese. The wings were dry. The lemon pepper barely had any flavor. The Philly cheesesteak wrap was a joke. Interesting meat, lettuce, and a few onions wrapped in a pizza crust dough. It didn't come with cheese... it had little flavor. Service was decent. Really nice guy but looks like he's running the place by himself. read more

See all

Best pizza we have had in a long time and great service done to perfection! Highly recommend

Stayed in a local hotel. Delivery was on time and the pizzas were warm and delicious as. Great garlic knots and Cesar salad

The pizza was cooked perfect! No skimping on the toppings! Huge New York slices! Would go back again!

I should've listened to the red flags in the comments and scrolled on by but since this place was close to where we're staying and it's pouring rain, we decided to take a chance. Wish we wouldn't have. I called ahead to order and specifically asked if it was thin crust ... well, it's not. We ordered a red sauce pizza, a white sauce pizza, and Cajun shrimp fettuccini. I'm being nice when I say that the red sauce pie tastes one step above frozen. The white pizza is bland - the only seasoning was overwhelming salt from the sausage I added. It's hard to believe that my Italians forget how to use seasonings! The crust was burnt. The Cajun pasta was the biggest disappointment - literally just a TON of salty Cajun seasoning added to what tasted like frozen, thawed fettuccini Alfredo. The pasta was wayyyyyyy over cooked. The shrimp was rubbery. Simply inedible!! Think Swanson TV dinners. The "garlic bread" was an over baked hoagie roll with butter and garlic seasoning. Overall, for the price, very disappointing!! read more

Antonio's Pizza at the Beach - Burnt thick crust on supposedly thin crust pizza - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

The kids really liked the pizza I found it could be quite pleasing as well. We order the wings they told us they were baked and not fried which was a plus because if they would have hit the table baked I probably would have sent them back. The kids enjoy them I've never been a fan of baked chicken read more

Antonio's Pizza at the Beach - We ordered the wings and meat lovers 18 inch pizza - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Great pizza. Generous size of slices for a reasonable price. Also pretty quick. We were picking up within 15-20 minutes of calling in our order. read more

Visited this place looking for some good pizza. Did not disappoint. Adam took care of us. Toppings were generous and the slice portions were enormous. read more

It's just ok. We got a large pizza which was decently good, garlic bread with cheese which was ok at best, jalapeño poppers that tasted like they came from the frozen section at dollar general, and cheesecake that was partially frozen. All of which was like $60 so it was kinda disappointing. The customer service was wonderful through! read more

Yes! Do yourself a favor and try the pizza. So good! Like the type of pizza you smell it cooking in the air and you just arrive at the door hungry! Very pleased! read more

Great pizza with a very good crust and real mozzarella. The staff was great people very friendly. We shall return.

Definitely don't recommend this place if you're a walk in and wanting it to be done within a reasonable time. We ordered a chicken wrap and breadsticks and it took over 25 minutes while I watched them cook and serve over 6 full pizzas for pick up orders. They told people ordering on the phone to be here in 10 minutes but when they arrived they had to wait additional time, overall just not an organized business... read more

i'm giving this place 5 stars simply because the pizza was ready in a timely manner, the facility was clean, and the pizza was exactly what we all wanted. absolutely no complaints! read more

Best Pizza in town hands down! I've tried their Gyros too and they are big, fresh and delicious!!!

However long they tell you the wait, double it. Pizza is pretty decent, everything else (salad, pasta, sub) don't waste your time. In fact for your time, just go to a restaurant. read more

Visited this mom and pop pizza place to order a pizza to go during lunch hour and I made the mistake of not calling ahead. It was packed as this seemed like a spot where a lot of local people who work nearby eat lunch at. It took me roughly 30 minutes to get my pizza, but that's my fault. I ordered a medium cheese pizza and after seeing everyone order the lunch special and how big the slices were, I was looking forward to digging into this pizza. I got up to my hotel room and the pizza slices looked nothing like the lunch slices. They were smaller, which is typical, but they were thicker and I was expecting it to be thinner. The pizza was good, although it could have used more sauce in my opinion. I was starving, so any pizza would have made me happy and as I like to mention in most three star reviews: it got the job done. The pizza and the menu in general were fairly priced and the portions were fair. The lunch special that they offer for $6 has good value to it especially with the beach being a few hundred yards away. I recommend calling in your to go order as well as taking your food to go as there are only 5-6 tables in this very small storefront that splits a location with a Rita's Italian Ice. read more

This is one of our favorite pizza places on the island if not all of St. Augustine. The Deluxe pizza is amazing. We substitute the green peppers for jalapeños. If you like a crispy crust ask for it to be well done. You won't be disappointed. The manicotti is one of the best I've ever had at a restaurant. It's enough for two people to share. The owner is always extremely friendly and goes above and beyond for his customers and his community. You can't go wrong at Antonio's. read more

Great antipasto salad. The extra large pizza is huge. We enjoyed their pizza. Ordered Hawaiian. Nice crust , ample toppings. They included paper plates, napkins and silverware. read more

We ordered after a long day in the city walking around and went with the basic pepperoni, it's your classic cheap pizza. Nothing special. It was really cheap which was a great change of pace because everything in town was pricey. If you need a cheap meal, the pizza here is worth the order. read more

Not to impressed with the pizza. The slices were big but way overpriced for sure. I ordered 3 slices of cheese & got 2. Was charged 7.99. For pizza in a pinch it's a ok spot but not for the price of basic pizza. I don't think I'll be back. read more

Antonio's is kind of good. The pizza needed a lot more sauce and the wings were not very good. The calzone was very good. I would not go back to this place but it was very conveniently located by the Embassy Suites (which is were we were staying) and we were able to walk there and bring it back. It was a large pizza for size. And the calzone is huge. The price is moderate and it is not expensive. Overall I would not come back here. read more

This pizza was truly terrible. Not much more to say. If you get pizza here, your best bet is to buy it then throw it away without eating it. Yes it's that bad. read more

Antonio's Pizza at the Beach - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida