Not New York Style. Average pizza style. They need more marinara and better quality ingredients. If you need pizza post-beach it will do the trick but not for discerning New York Pizzatarians. read more

It's a nice quaint little business where you sit down then they come take your order. The food is priced decently. I had awould come back again next time we're here at the beach. read more

Decent pizza, nothing I'd seek out but it was convenient and we didn't have any problems with it. They did offer a gluten free option as well...likely just an Udi's crust (or similar), but at least they had something available. read more

On vacation and ran into this small pizza place and by far the best..Amazing is an understatement!

Good location and quick service but Pepperoni pizza was overpriced and almost inedible.

Great prices, fast wait times, friendly service, and fantastic pizza. What more could you ask for?!

We were staying at the Marriott Courtyard and our pizza deliver guy brought the pizza directly to us by the pool. He was very friendly and professional. Then we opened the pizza box and I have to say this is the best pizza that I have ever tasted since I visited New York. The pizza was fresh, hot, the perfect amount of sauce, the perfect crust!!! I would tell anyone for a delicious pie you have to order from here, you will not be disappointed. I'm really thinking about stopping here for lunch today after we check out read more

I ordered a spinach and eggplant calzone, wings and pizza. The calzone was oily, and white milky stuff came out, there was no ricotta cheese in it, no spinach, and it tasted horrible. The wings were black, and burned . Called and complained and was told to drive back with it. Brought the food back and the cook stated there was nothing wrong with it and that it is how it is prepared. They refused to give me a refund and told me too bad. The staff was rude. I asked them if this is how they do business? Is this how you treat the tourists? I advised them that I live here and I will be writing a bad review. Stay clear, awful, awful food!!! read more

The pizza dough and gyro wraps are made in house--and freshly made makes a difference. Even better: I asked about the ingredients because I have a soy allergy and soy protein or soy lecithin is common in baked goods -- the bread is just flour, water, salt, and yeast. The young woman working behind the counter was friendly and helpful. read more

Antonio's Pizza at the Beach - The gyro is generous, filling, and soooo delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Thought the place was fantastic! Small place, can be a little wait but the pizza was WAY better than the pizza down on St George street that is Allegedly "the 2nd best pizza in the USA", which we were not impressed with. The gyros were so big at this place 2 people could split them and the pizza was fresh and good! Crust was very good and I don't usually eat the crust. read more

Whenever possible, I do try to patron smaller locally owned restaurants. I decided to order some to go from Antonio's on A1A, next to Ritas. We ordered a small white pizza, a large regular pizza with 2 toppings on half and 2 orders of wings. 46.00 The wings appear to have been boiled then thrown into a to go container with sauce on them. The white pizza was horrendous. It was like cardboard with the thinnest layer of ricotta, no marinara. (Not that it would have helped.) The regular pizza was edible , nothing spectacular. I don't make a habit of giving bad reviews. This is my first one. But I feel really ripped off!! I get that with Spring Break you can get away with serving crappy food and can make a living but , it would be helpful to have the support of locals in the off season. I will not be back. read more

I was not impressed with this pizza. The pizza arrived over-cooked. The bottom was very deal, almost impossible to bite through, and all the sauce had disappeared. The flavor of the crust was ok if you could get past the excessive corn meal used. We ordered plain pepperoni and there was also an excessive amount of cheese. We also got cheesy bread. It is made of a French bread loaf. Again, very hard to bite through due to over cooking. Dipping sauce was good. I don't have high standards of pizza, but this was exceptionally disappointing. read more

This place doesn't even deserve the star I had to give. I placed an order for pick up tonight and they told me 20 mins. I get there and the place is dark. They closed down for the night I guess. I wasted my time going to pick up food they probably never even prepared for me. This website states that they close at 10p. If they were going to close down at 9p they should've at least told me. I was looking forward to eating pizza with my S/O on Valentines because we really like their pizza and garlic knots. But they just lost my business. I do not understand why they couldn't just tell me they were going to be closed by 9p. It's not that hard to tell that to someone over the phone. That would've at least gave me other dinner options in time. read more

Antonio's Pizza at the Beach - It's states that they close at 10p they need to update this if that's not the case. This is rude! - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Not very tasty, very disappointed. Pizza was flavorless and crunchy. Pizza was large but very thin

Wow! The best NY style pizza I have had in years! I have had pizza all over the U.S. and this pizza slice beat them all. Right on the beach and next to a frozen custard shop, can't beat that. read more

Excellent pizza!!!! We loved it. They were doing take out only because of covid. Thank you for trying to be safe. We will be back.

This place was amazing! Greta location, nice workers. Overall 15/10. Price was fair, quality was outstanding. Great New York style pizza

Honestly this place doesn't even deserve one star. I took my family there only to be disappointed and frustrated due the incredibly poor service. We walked out and went to another place for lunch. read more

Used a old slice and put fresh cheese and pepperoni on top and threw it in the oven... wtf

Stopped by with the family, ordered a pepperoni pizza, garlic bread, and a salad. The food is par, not good but also not bad. Their portions are generous so you can feed a family of four for $30 and still have leftovers. read more

We had a great experience today! I was thrilled to find GF crust and it was very tasty! So much so, my husband at my other half of pizza I couldn't finish! Very homemade tasting with fresh ingredients. I would highly recommend it! Nice guy that made my pizza too. I could tell he was a pro! read more

I'm confused about the negative reviews here. Its a pretty standard pizza place, nothing fancy but good fresh, hot New York style pizza. The kids and I split a large cheese and pepperoni pizza and gobbled it up. Service was friendly and quick. My dad ordered a sub sandwich and it was fresh and tasty as well. Romaine lettuce, fresh tomato and turkey on a good quality sandwich roll. I'd gladly go back. read more

This place is amazing. Food has great taste not covered in to much sauce. Garlic knots are crunchy but soft all at the same time

Best pizza by the beach!! We have been regulars for years. While we always get a plain cheese pizza, it's the best damn cheese pizza! Its always fresh whenever we pick it up and most of the time its ready earlier than promised. What else can you ask for?! Sure the college kids who work there can occasionally have an attitude but the friendliness of the owner makes up for that in my book! (And the college kids seem to be like this everywhere nowadays so we dont mind.) This is our go-to pizza place we use on a weekly basis! We LOVE Antonio's! During the summer, we even have a pizza routine! Our ideal day is ordering pizza, enjoying it right there by the beach, topped off with ice cream from Rita's with a stroll on the beach. Antonio's has been incorporated into what we picture as our little slice of heaven. There's nothing more American than that: besides perhaps a slice of apple pie! read more

We ordered takeout from here on 6-22-19, we were staying in a condo across the street from this establishment, I've got to say it was one of the biggest pizza's I've ever seen. It was also the best pizza I've ever had, everyone in my family said it was by far the best pizza hands down! We will be back again! read more

Best pizza we had so far out of our two week visit. Tried others around area, but best one so far. Pizza was delivered the time they said it would be. read more

Order food with my kids coming off the beach and the resturant claims they don't have working bathrooms. I'm very sure this is violating permitting or operations of resturant. Where are employees using the bathroom and washing there hands??? read more

My husband and I were wanting pizza on our trip to st Augustine and Antonio's was within walking distance of our hotel so we decided to give it a try. We were very pleased. I ordered a calzone with mushrooms and my husband had a small meat lovers pizza. The calzone was so big I couldn't even eat it all. We will definitely be back! read more

Eating alone, so I ordered a small veggie pizza based on a previous review. It was $13 and change. Upon opening the box, it looked and smelled wonderful. Upon picking a slice up, however, the crust was so thin and soggy that it didn't hold the weight of the toppings. Very disappointing. The taste was ok, no better than a chain restaurant though. Won't be ordering here again. read more

Antonio's Pizza at the Beach - Picked up a slice and all the toppings slid off because the crust was thin and soggy. - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

See all

One bite everyone knows the rules. Lunch: 2 cheese slices and drink $5.89 First glance. Pizza looks great. Cooked just about right. Cheese sauce ratio is good. Although the sauce lacks in extra flavor. A combined bite with everything works decently well. Crust was ok, nothing too special. Overall, it's a pretty good slice, but marginally still like the rest. 6/10 That's a review. read more

For eight years we have been looking for an authentic New York style pizza in this area and we have finally found it here. It was fabulous and the crust was just a thin and crispy as you would ever want. read more

Excellent pizza and subs right next to the beach. Subs were toasted, with fresh romaine lettuce and plum tomatoes - big enough to split. Calzones were huge, also large enough for 2. Service is friendly. They take pride in their product. There is seating available, nothing fancy - you can eat in your swimsuit. read more

Awesome pizza, friendly workers, cool environment and again awesome pizza. Definitely suggest trying it out when in St Augustine.

Awesome pizza! Great service and great prices! Authentic New York style pizza. Right off the beach in a great location.

Bland food expensive and pis poor service. So much better for so much less here in st Augustine beach.

First try for pizza here. Ordered Antonio's Supreme style nice tasty toppings on their pizza. Crust center definitely needed about 5 more minutes baking. Some kind of issue between download menu price and actual charge which cost a few bucks more than expected. Service and attention was meh. Live and learn when things can be done better... read more

We ate there twice while in St Augustine! It was awesome both times! Food, service, atmosphere all excellent!!!

Worst pizza ever! This restaurant was awful. It was not very clean and took over 45 minutes for a small 12 inch pizza. The pizza was alright minus the hair. The customer service was terrible and they did not check up on us once. It wasn't until we were ready to pay did they know about the hair. To compensate for the hair on the pizza they offered a free drink when we never got our original drinks in the first place. How they've been in business 33 years is beyond me, definitely won't be going back. read more

Best pizza on the island. You can't go wrong at Antonio's. The NY Style pizza is fantastic. Spaghetti with meatballs, chicken parm and antipasto salad are all great. Good prices and friendly service. Small eating area is clean and nice. Highly recommended. read more

Pizza, and the rest of the food were delicious. The delivery was mixed up, and instead of receiving a Stromboli we received spaghetti and meatballs. After calling to mention the problem it was promptly corrected, at no charge. The spaghetti and meatballs were delicious and so was the Stromboli! Thank you for your fantastic customer service and food!! read more