We had Christmas dinner at Nonna's Trattoria, tucked away on a narrow cobblestone street near the Spanish Military Hospital--a lovely historic setting. The food was delicious. We enjoyed the House Salad, Fried Ravioli, Chicken Piccata, and Limoncello Cake. Service was slow, but it was Christmas evening, which is understandable. We appreciate the staff for working on the holiday. Note that a 20% service charge is automatically added (even for small parties), so we did not leave an additional tip. Other than that, no negative read more

If you love great Italian food, do yourself a favor and keep driving -- preferably fast. Nonna's appears to specialize in "Italian-inspired disappointment." The cooked penne was sitting on the counter uncovered, just vibing at room temperature like it had officially given up. The sauce? Scooped from a container and reheated with all the passion of a microwave at 2 a.m. The complimentary bread arrived looking hopeful... until we realized it was a square dinner roll slathered in what tasted like imitation garlic and oil -- less Italian trattoria and more middle school cafeteria meets olive oil cosplay. The Chicken Marsala arrived undefeated in battle against any form of tenderizing. This chicken was not pounded thin -- it clearly lifts weights. I needed a steak knife, determination, and possibly a waiver to cut through it. We shared one entrée and a bottle of wine that tasted like grapes filed a formal complaint, and somehow the bill still hit $65. I checked twice to make sure we hadn't accidentally invested in the business. And just when you think the experience is complete, surprise! There's a debit card fee. Don't worry though -- the owner's son (also waiter, host, busboy, and possibly assistant regional manager) will loudly explain it from across the restaurant so the entire dining room can stay informed. read more

Food was ok and ambiance is nice but the service was absolutely awful. They include a 20% tip and don't let you know beforehand. You can find better Italian elsewhere. Not worth it at all. So sad. read more

Visiting the St. Augustine island is a must and the variety of food options is overwhelming. Every meal was great but some locals recommended Nonna"s as the best Italian food on the island. They were right, but I'd say it was some of the best Italian food I've had in all my travels. The menu changes slightly as they rotate chef specialty dishes. You start with a basket of fresh homemade bread but I urge you to only eat one serving because your meal portions are humongous. We ate half our portions and took the rest home for her next day. I recommend sharing an entree if you can't take home your leftovers and then you might have room for a dessert! Our group had spaghetti and meatballs, some of the largest ones I've ever seen and filled will flavor. We had a chicken fettuccine with pink sauce, honestly did not know that's basically alfredo and red sauce mixed equally, which I loved. The chicken on this dish was well seasoned and perfectly cooked. Our third dish was pasta bolognese and this is a personal favorite. The sauce was perfection and I loved the capers as an added bonus. I wish I had you to try a dessert but I'm confident it would have also been delicious. Everything tasted like a genuine Italian family recipe. This adorable place is a bit tiny so try to go at opening to avoid a line, but either way it's worth the wait. read more

See all

Celebrated my daughter's 30th birthday. They had a large staff and always on top of anything we asked for. The food was very good! The meal portions are very big here. The only disappointment was the calamari. It was not good. All the pastas had great flavor. I can see the cook from where I was sitting in the kitchen. The place was clean and has a lot of character. I've eaten here several times it's a go to place for us. read more

See all

Let's start with our server Paul. Engaging and welcoming. I thought he was they owner he was so friendly. The food was very good. The shrimp pasta was a very big portion. The chicken piccata was with just the right amount of lemon. Despite being cold outside we sat under the heat lamps and couldn't have been more cozy. Would say a solid dinner if you want Italian food. read more

See all

I really wanted to like this place. We are local and just happened to walk by one beautiful night. The place is quaint and atmosphere is amazing on the oldest street in the U.S. and they had Italian music playing, so we came back a few nights later. Rolls were great, chicken parm was okay, interestingly not breaded. Chicken piccata was bland and shrimp scampi was nothing special. I understand everyone has different tastes but our party of 3 felt the same way. The waiter was a young kid who mumbled and was difficult to understand. He came to the table once and didn't return to ask if we wanted more drinks, etc. Prices are very inflated because it's a tourist town and it appears the add the 20% tip after tax which is not the industry standard. Tips should be based on pre tax subtotal. We tried it but wouldn't return. read more

See all

The service was great and the food was even better. Stop here for great Italian cuisine!

We finally visited Nonna's Trattoria on a spur of the moment date night in St. Augustine. Things were pretty quiet after the storm, so we were excited to get some authentic Italian. The weather was gorgeous, so we enjoyed our meal outside on the sidewalk. The inside of the restaurant is pretty small, so it was nice to have room to spread out a little. Service was perfection. Our server was friendly and polite, and everything came out wonderfully. We started with warm garlic rolls, that were soft and soaked in butter, garlic, and herbs. Delicious. We also each enjoyed a glass of pinot, which was perfect on a fall night. I did find the menu a little limited, but ordered the chicken marsala with a side of penne Alfredo, while my husband got the chicken parm with penne and red sauce. Both plates of chicken were tender and well cooked and seasoned. And the pastas were great as well. I would have liked some different kinds of pasta on the menu, but it was a solid meal and a lovely night! read more

See all

Nonna's is a fantastic neighborhood, homey restaurant. We were outside before opening time, were greeted promptly at opening time and were thanked for waiting. The service was friendly and attentive. The serving sizes were very generous. I had the vegan pasta puttanesca, which was chock full of tomatoes, olives and capers and the flavor was incredible! They also prepared a vegan version of garlic rolls for me. I also had a small salad that was very fresh and the balsamic dressing was delicious. My husband had the shrimp pasta - he is very particular about seafood, and said the shrimp were fantastic! The pasta for both dishes was done perfectly. We highly recommend this restaurant. read more

Let's just say "Go to Nonna's!" Do not hesitate! This small Italian Trattoria makes you feel like you're in Nonna's kitchen in Italy. The smells, the ambience and the food all are excellent. The chicken piccata was tender, juicy and nicely lemony. The chicken Alfredo was probably the most flavorful creamy version of this dish I've ever had. One of us had the shrimp scampi which was full of flavor, succulent shrimp, garlic and herbs. And last but not least, the chicken Marsala. This was probably the best version of this dish I've ever tasted. Slightly sweet from the Marsala and balanced nicely with a savory, almost beefy flavor, that was complemented by the generous amount of mushrooms accenting the dish. The staff was very welcoming and friendly and service was wonderful. All in all, a perfect experience! Highly recommend. read more

This place lives up to its name! The food and ambience were 10 out of 10. We had Nino as our server and he was very personable and knowledgeable about the menu. It is hard to find great service like that nowadays. We live about 45 minutes from this place, but would come to St Augustine just to eat here again. I would certainly recommend this place to anyone! Must try! read more

Nonna's Trattoria - Sauv Blanc and Primativo Red - Italian Near Me - St Augustine, Florida

This place is an embarrassment. Looking for a high quality locally-owned restaurant run by a discerning owner? Keep looking. Don't stop here. The food was below average - everything seemed thrown together with seemingly no thought given to either the preparation nor the presentation. Our serviceperson was virtually non-existent. We were never given a second glance once our lukewarm food was delivered on cold plates. And the mandatory 2% con(?) junk fee + automatic 20% tip was highly offensive. Shameful. We love St Augustine. There are many good restaurants in town - we've found several that have become favorites who are run by caring and conscientious chefs. Not here. Our mistake was trying an unfamiliar place with an empty dining room. Needless to say, we won't go back. read more

The food and ambience were amazing! The location is easy to get too. The small yet cozy restaurant has an authentic Italian feel. There is also outdoor seating. read more

Got take out, staff was on point and got us squared away quickly. Food was amazing, I'm second gen Italian and I loved my chicken parm and my wife loved her Alfredo. Highly recommend this place! A must stop in St. Augustine. read more

What an AMAZING restaurant. The staff and food, just a wonderful. Our server's name was Nino, and he was kind enough to share the history of his family restaurant. It was started by his late grandfather 15 years ago, and although it is sad that he is no longer with us, his legacy lives on through his original recipes still used today, to be enjoyed by every patron. For starter's, I'm not the biggest fan of Italian food. My wife is though, and well, you know how that goes. We had the spaghetti and meatballs and penne a la bolognese and they were both delicious. Even the bread was terrific. They kept bringing more because we couldn't get enough. And then we finished our meal off with their tiramisu, was one of the BEST tiramisu I have ever had. Can't say enough good things about this place. Thank you so much Nino for a memorable anniversary dinner, and thank you to your Dad for being so warm and welcoming when we walked in. See you again soon! read more

See all

The ravioli appetizer was. Good, the salad & tiramisu were great. the chicken piccata was bland, cold and not cooked well. Many bad reviews on this dish. The killer was 2% con fee with a 20% forced tip. $11 for a bottle of water. The total was $111 total bill for 3 things of below average Italian food. Atmosphere was nice. Service was very good. read more

Although a small family restaurant that doesn't take reservations in downtown St. Augustine that is constantly busy with Tourists, everything is amazing. The ambiance, staff, service, food, etc., makes you feel like you're in a little village in Positano. Large portions and very authentic, NOT touristy - so deal with the wait and line. You get what you wait for (prices are also reasonable)! read more

Bread and ravioli were good. That's about all the positives I can give this restaurant. The bolognese had a ton of cream in it for some reason and almost no meat. The chicken piccata was terrible. The breading was soggy. The sauce was okay. Our server was not friendly at all. Almost $40 for each poorly made entree is not okay. The mandatory 20% tip is insulting. read more

Fantastic Italian Food! i am a Sicilian from Chicago. My Nonna made the best Siciliano food. This comes pretty close. mmmmmm read more

Nonna's Trattoria - Pasta Bolognese and a giant delicious meatball? - Italian Near Me - St Augustine, Florida

Nino was our server. Pleasant and professional. Not a large menu which I liked it allows them to put out flavorful plates. Spaghetti and meatballs looked soooo good! I had the chicken piccata with capers. Loved it. Small inside but still can accommodate at least a party if 8. Tables outside. Quaint interior. read more

Nonna's Trattoria - Chicken piccata - Italian Near Me - St Augustine, Florida

See all

Called twice. No answer. Looks like a good spot but really should come down to the other side of Cathedral PL. food looks good. Really can't handle to amount of people. read more

We stopped in for an early dinner. The place was 100% empty. We were 2 but were going to he joined by our daughter & her boyfriend. The girl told us she couldn't seat us because we were an incomplete party...mind you there were no 2 top tables in there, all the tables seated 4 or more. So she wouldn't seat us at a 4 top even though had we said we were a party of 2 she would have. Rude stupid and bad for business. We are local and we will not be back. read more

Excellent food, amazing service and overall a great experience. Good authentic Italian food. We were seated immediately and had great service from start to finish. We will be back. read more

Divine little place with delicious food. We went in during a thunder storm last year. They were so kind to us. On our return to St. Augustine this year, we came as a group of 12. The waiter, an Irish guy who was really efficient and nice, put 3 tables together and effortlessly accommodated us. They don't take reservations. We enjoyed it just as much this time around. read more

The restaurant is in small quaint area of the district. We came at night and it was a really cute vibe overall. The table we had was also facing the gentlemen cooking our food, which was really cool to see. The service was extremely quick and accommodating. I saw the food completed and walked over to my table within seconds, so it was nice and fresh. My bolognese pasta was insanely good. This is my staple dish to test out an Italian spot and I'm glad I did. It's also a huge portion and the bread that comes with the meal is A1. Highly recommend! read more

See all

Highly recommend. Best Italian food in Saint Augustine. Highly recommend. We had the Puttanesca (chefs kiss), Bolognese pasta, Chicken piccata. It stated pouring mid-meal and they brought everyone in until it passed. Dried every chair and sat us to finish. FIVE STARS read more

Nonna's Trattoria - Sangiovese red wine - Italian Near Me - St Augustine, Florida

See all

We went on a Monday night, no wait to sit. The plates were a bit pricey but the portion huge, definitely shareable. Kids plate was also abundant. Service was quick, the menu was very limited. But it also said Holiday Menu so I'm not sure if this is only a during the week thing. Overall, the food was very tasty but a bit expensive. read more

Nonna's Trattoria - Italian Near Me - St Augustine, Florida

See all

This was hands down the best dinning experience of my life. Service was fantastic. Sparkling sweet wine and dessert wines were 12/10. Family style dining for my sister's rehearsal dinner. Staff went above and beyond. Atmosphere is beautiful. Food was fantastic. I can only think of good things to say. Highly recommend. read more

THERE IS A 20% SERVICE FEE/AUTOMATIC TIP!!!!!! And the service was HORRID. Idk if he's an owner, he definitely acts like an ass, his name was Nino. The food was not that good, service was terrible, and there was absolutely ZERO mention of this weird gratuity crap. He tried telling us everyone in St Augustine does this because I think he thought we were tourists, we live an hour away and go here all the time and literally no one has ever done that. Just to add there's also a $7 fee for sharing food. Horrible place read more

Nonna's Trattoria - Italian Near Me - St Augustine, Florida

Had a wonderful dinner! Chicken Parmesan! I forgot about taking a picture. Sorry about that. It was phenomenal!

We erred in arriving two minutes before opening time and were asked to wait outside. The service was slightly brusque but "OK." Overall, the food was good, but not extraordinary. One may note that the menu (see photo) is significantly different than that shown on-line on various web sites and the while the current prices are probably fair given this is a tourist destination and they're not feeding locals, today's prices are markedly higher than those shown elsewhere. Would we return? Hmmm. I think we'd continue our search and probably go elsewhere. But, the place is not "bad." read more

Nonna's Trattoria - Menu as of 03/25/24 - Italian Near Me - St Augustine, Florida

We didn't plan on discovering the best Italian food we've ever had...but that's exactly what happened. We met Adomo, the owner of Nonna's Trattoria, just a few blocks away while walking downtown St. Augustine. After telling him my wife is Italian and I've been all over Italy, he said, "Then you're going to love my restaurant," and personally walked us there. He called ahead to his son Nino (who runs the place) and told him to get a table ready and spoil us. Nino greeted us warmly and did just that; from the hospitality to the food, everything was perfect. I told Nino to bring out whatever appetizer he thought best. He delivered ravioli in a rich marinara sauce that was absolutely divine...like handmade pillows of heaven. For dinner, I refused to look at the menu and said, "Bring me whatever your dad would recommend." Nino brought out a chicken parmigiana with fettuccine Alfredo. One bite and I audibly sighed in delight..my daughter even commented she'd never seen me react that way to food before. Everyone else at the table had a similar reaction. For dessert, we let Nino surprise us again: tiramisu and a cannoli. Both were flawless. Light, creamy, authentic. Bottom line? This isn't just a meal--it's a family-run culinary experience that rivals anything I've had in Italy. Friendly, passionate, authentic. Nonna's is now the gold standard by which we'll judge all other Italian restaurants. "A tavola non si invecchia." (At the table, one does not grow old) ...and at Nonna's, you'll want time to stand still. read more

Watch your credit card statement when it comes in. The waiter inflated his tip and it showed up on my cc statement. Just WOW in a really bad way. read more

This place is amazing. The food is great and on a perfect little quite street in St. Augustine.

This was an amazing restaurant. We visited on Saturday during the busiest time of year with all the people in town for nights of lights. We did have a wait because of the number of people looking for a place to eat. The service once seated was very fast and efficient. The food was delivered quicker than expected. Everything we tried was exceptional. Our party of 4 had a variety of dishes Spaghetti and meatballs. Meatballs the size of a tennis ball. Great marinara sauce Penne bolognese with Italian sausage was very delicious with the cream and wine infused in the sauce. The Chicken Marsala was a great dish with extra large helping of chicken that was very tender Chicken Alfredo was very creamy with an excellent flavor We definitely would go back if we are in the area read more

This place deserves a better rating! I discovered this gem thanks to the irresistible smell of garlic wafting down the street. I literally followed the scent -- and it led me to Nonna's. At first, I was a bit skeptical. The prices were on the higher side, and some of the reviews weren't exactly glowing. But my wife was craving Italian food, so we decided to give it a shot -- and I'm so glad we did. We grabbed a table outside, where Frank Sinatra played softly from a speaker, setting the perfect mood. Horse-drawn carriages passed by as we dined -- classic St. Augustine charm. As soon as we sat down, they brought out complimentary garlic bread that was absolutely phenomenal. My wife ordered the Chicken Alfredo, and I went with the Chicken Marsala plus a side of Pasta Marinara. The food came out in about 10 minutes -- impressively quick. Everything tasted fresh and flavorful, and they didn't skimp on the portions. My "side" of Pasta Marinara could've been a full meal on its own. Since I was already going all in, I ordered a glass of wine -- and it turned out to be one of the heaviest pours I've ever received at an Italian restaurant. Honestly, that might've been my favorite part. All in all, we left completely satisfied and pleasantly surprised. Beyond the great food and atmosphere, this is a family-owned and operated spot with a beautiful backstory. I'm always happy to support small local businesses and this one deserves the love. If you're ever in St. Augustine and in the mood for quality Italian, you know where to go. read more

The hospitality was top tier. Amazing Italian cuisine. They made accommodations for children's meals. Taste and quality was very worth the price and atmosphere added to the experience. 1000% recommend this restaurant for all ages. read more

Nonna's Trattoria - Nonna's Trattoria Italian Cuisine - Italian Near Me - St Augustine, Florida

See all

Pros: Food is better than many Italian restaurants. Large portions. Cons: Small space with a shabby atmosphere. Staff does not bother to toss the salads with dressing; dressing is just drizzled on top. Waiter was curt and NOT friendly. Automatic 20% tip is excessive for the cheerless service and the $7 charge for a split is also a rip off--especially as patrons are not told about these charges. Everything seems to be done by rote with no visible enthusiasm or effort. This restaurant needs to try harder. Interior needs sprucing up and waiters need to be taught kindness. read more

Love the service here. We had a wine tour and one stop was here and the servers were chatting it up with us and quick with checking up on us. Cute little restaurant inside and out and the pasta was fantastic read more