Great pizza. Picked up pizza so don't know about ambiance. Price acceptable for close to beach.

DO NOT WASTE YOUR MONEY! This was literally the worst pizza I've ever had and certainly not "New York style". I really have no idea how this place is so highly rated. It must be because of the lack of options in the immediate area. Supporting small businesses is so important and I absolutely hate to be so harsh but this was not only horrible but also expensive. People need to be warned. 1.) the watery sauce had zero flavor. Literally almost to the point that I couldn't taste it at all. 2.) this place doesn't understand moderation. The soggy pizza was topped with WAY too many toppings and it's really took away from the pizza. 3.) SALTY. This crust/dough was incredibly salty. Almost inedible. Crust is my favorite part of the pizza and this was just yuck. 4.) Poor quality ingredients. The mozzarella was especially bad. It looked and tasted so low quality. 5.) It truly did not taste fresh at all. We were pretty hungry so we practically force fed ourselves two pieces before sadly just throwing away the rest of it - which is not in our nature to waste food. Do yourself a favor and pick up some cheap frozen pizzas. You'll be happier and save money. read more

So excited find this pizza muslim friendly in St Augustine, FL. This is very good and helpful restaurant. For muslim, we can't eat pork. They have everything like pepperoni and ham made of HALAL beef. No alcohol too. The pizza tastes so delicious and not dry at all. The restaurant ambience is nice. Good for family. read more

See all

What a fantastic place My son told us so we went Don't be fooled by the appearance just go in order a pie and the rest is history I love there raviolis If you never had a Sicilian pie go for it read more

Tony's Pizza - Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

See all

This place was a need was about to stop and get a tattoo and had to grab some food before I WAS NOT DISAPPOINTED! GREAT FOOD! GREAT SERVICE! If a place could give 6 stars this man should have it, Pizza was fresh and good ingredients, and if ur a ranch lover like me GET THE RANCH CUP!! read more

Tony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

The pizza and salad were both fresh and yummy. The pizza was crispy and perfectly cooked. Haley's service from order to food delivery to checking on us was perfect. This is a chill, homey place, you will love it here. read more

Tony's Pizza - Medium Vegetarian Pizza leftovers in a box - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

10/10 super great service and delicious Calzone! Very happy customers. We'll be back soon! Thanks! read more

Tony's Pizza - Pepperoni Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

See all

Pizza is huge and delicious. Ingredients are fresh and plentiful. I would suggest take out only as they don't really have the establish ment to cater to eat in customers. We also had a calzone and it was incredible. The blend of cheeses were out of this world read more

Good pizza ! When most definitely stopping eating again when I'm this way. I'm always looking for great pizza

We had take out and the pizza was delicious. Friendly service at pick up. Been a fan of Tony's for years and still serving great pizzas.

Waited 7 hours for a tattoo next door to this place. The pizza was the highlight of my day, very good! Customer service was awesome as well!

We ordered a medium supreme pie and a chicken parmigiana sub. The pizza was delicious but the chicken on the sub tasted off. Definitely recommend getting their pizza! read more

Tony's Pizza - Medium Supreme - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

So many restaurants in the area are closed on Mondays so this was a good and easy week-night option! We got a pepperoni pizza with Pepperoncini. It was good and kind of true to new york style (I wish they cut our slices bigger). It wasn't too greasy either which is usually my biggest complaint when it comes to pizza. The crust held up to the toppings and the sauce was pretty solid. 4/5 stars because the dough wasn't my favorite but that might be because we got take out and it had a little too much time to sit and get hard/stale. I bet it would be great right out of the oven read more

Tony's has amazing food and a very cozy atmosphere! The whole staff are very sweet and happy to help you with anything! Would definitely recommend to anyone who's hungry. read more

Super nice family serving up great pizza. Carry out seems to be the popular option here. If you're craving a good large pizza pie, this place will cure your needs. Welcome staff. read more

Pretty much the only real food option off of Crescent Beach, but that is ok because Tony's serves a quick, hot and tasty slice! We usually order a large pizza and carry it over to the beach for lunch or dinner. It's such an easy treat to feed a family. read more

We are visiting on vacation and saw how close Tony's was near us which prompted a delivery to our beach house. The order was perfect, but I had no idea the pizzas were so large! Wonderful price, great service and exactly as ordered! Even had left overs for lunch the next day and it was still awesome! Though I'm a pizza lover, my wife is hit or miss and absolutely loved it, too! We're lifelong fans from a single order! read more

The food here is amazing. I've been eating here for 30 years and I'm never disappointed. Excellent service from the friendly staff. The eat in options are pretty limited but it's great for take out! read more

Definitely not Italian. NY Pizza? LoL. An occasional Lasagna to go when desperate. It's ok. Add seasonings at home

Absolutely delicious. Love this locally owned place. Such wonderful people and the food is top notch! Will recommend to anyone who asks!! Just wow! read more

Tony's Pizza - a menu for a restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

See all

When I walked in I was taken back by how ugly this place is. The ceiling tiles alone made me think I might need an antibiotic upon leaving. BUT, don't let first impressions fool you. Grandpa is in the back making pizza's and his granddaughter, who is adorable, is out front giving incredible customer service. The pizzas are good especially compared to the trash Domino's and Pizza Hut are throwing out there these days. It may look ugly but the tables are clean and the food is good! When you get sick of seafood give this place a try. read more

Stopped in after a trip to the beach Very friendly, and the pizza was delicious. Best crust! Would order from there again!!

The best pizza around!! Every time we come to St. Augustine we have to eat pizza from here. Unmatched!!!

We were on vacation and we saw a pizza shop and want to try it out. I'm not kidding this is THE BEST PIZZA I have EVER had!!! The pizza was so fresh and just JAW DROPPING DELICIOUS!!! When we walked in the workers were just the best! They were so kind and polite and efficient! They were very fast and hard working!!!! The place is great! It is in the perfect area and is very nice inside! So overall it was the BEST EVER and I totally recommend it to try and get a large pizza! When we got a small pizza we just wanted so much more of it!!! DEFINITELY WORTH IT!!!!! read more

We grabbed takeout the other night. Pizza was soggy, wings were small and meh and they forgot our dressing. Out of the dessert we wanted which was a bummer ... maybe an off night? read more

Arrived in the area for a few days. Wanted to go to the local seafood places but it appears they are all closed on Monday's. So we went with a time old favorite: pizza. Looked on yelp for a local run place and picked Tony's Pizza. Sigh. I thought ok New York style. Nope. Same thickness/thickness as normal pizza crust. Ordered xl sausage and pepperoni. Sausage was all exactly the same size- that made me think frozen right away. I read reviews that the sauce was good. I don't know what these people are used to but this sauce had no flavor. The entire pizza was blah. We eat A LOT of pizza lol, it's my fave food. And we threw away 3/4 of this pizza. It hurt my heart putting pizza into the trash. We also ordered garlic knots. Same thing: no flavor. Very disappointed read more

See all

This place is amazing. The pizza, garlic rolls, and desserts were so good. Highly recommend the baklava, it was fresh, crispy, and delicious! The ambiance was cozy and inviting. The service was probably one the best we received in a long time. Our family was in town for a wedding, the cashier was extremely kind, polite, and patient as we had a large order and decided to add on more food. They even gave us a free dessert. The owner of the restaurant was so sweet! He personally carried our pizza to the car and accommodated it in our trunk (suv). We offered a tip on top of everything and he refused, asking us to put it in the tip jar for his staff. World class man, and we would absolutely recommend this place to anyone that comes here. I'd give ten stars if I could, great service! read more

Tony's Pizza - XL Meat Lovers - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

See all

Visiting the area, needed a quick bit to eat. Saw Tony Pizza on the map. Best decision we so far on our trip! Got a large half cheese half pepperoni with a meatball sub and some garlic knots. So delicious. Seasoned very well good cheese pull on every bite, but not an overly amount. My 4 year old daughter (who's very picky) had 3 slices. The meatball sub was awesome! Garlic knots a little too salty but still delicious to me. read more

Delicious NY style pizza and kind employees. Great stop on A-1-A. Big menu too for non pizza eaters.

The supreme pizza we ordered was amazingly delicious. The order was ready when promised and the service was courteous. We picked up the pizza but the inside of the restaurant looked like they mainly did take out as there weren't many places to sit. read more

As tourists, we checked around and Tony's was always given a nice description. So, we tried it...twice! It was delicious both times. We can recommend the pizza, Stromboli, and wings. They delivered within 45 minutes- which worked for us. read more

Rode our motorcycles on a route we mapped out with all back roads ending up at Tony's Pizza for lunch. We picked it from the reviews we read. Owner is friendly and the pizza was great. I am from NYC and it is just as good. We will be back. read more

Thick sliced meat on really good toasted sub bread. Perfect for a grab and go on a beach day. Antipasto was also good, everything nicely sliced. Didn't try the pizza but would return for it based on the other items we tried! read more

Clean restaurant over a deli. Good air conditioning, decent price for a decent pizza. And the server was pleasant!

Tony's had the exact NY style pizza I was looking for. Their pepperoni had crispy edges and the cheese stayed on the slice without sliding off. The owners were really great to chat with. read more

Small kitchen so service won't be fast. You're best to order pick up in advance. Food is OK if you need something simple in Crescent Beach.

Pizza was very good! Excellent service and great customer service. I would definitely recommend this pizza.

Great pizza! Accurate order when we picked it up and everything was good. Would recommend that you try it.

The last time we were in St. Augustine we had Tony's pizza and it was fantastic. We were looking forward to having it again. To our surprise we called this evening and were greeted by a rude young lady who informed us that they were out of pizza dough and were closing. Don't understand how u can run out of pizza dough. It's literally flour , warm water and yeast, but who am I? And on a Saturday afternoon to boot. Pretty sad. read more

Great slice of pizza at a good cost hot and fresh dough, consistency of the cheese is great. Small little mom and pop shop. Great place to have a pie after being at the beach all day. read more

Tony's Pizza - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida