Five Star Pizza

4.1 (223 reviews)

InexpensivePizza, Italian

Open • 10:00 am - 2:00 AM (Next day)

Add Review

Call

Directions

Website

Order Five Star Pizza Takeout or Delivery

Order Takeout or Delivery

Five Star Pizza Photos

Five Star Pizza - Pepperoni and black olives, good - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Five Star Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Five Star Pizza - Awesome cheese pull on my double pepperoni!! - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

+66

Five Star Pizza - Thin crust pizza - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Business Info

Health Information

Powered by Local Health Department

View Health Score

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Five Star Pizza

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.

Start your review...

Browse more easily on the app

Reviews With Photos

Elyssabeth P.

I absolutely love five star pizza! They are always quick, affordable, and delicious. They always have deals going on so there's something for every price point. I only live about 15 minutes away-- I just wish they'd deliver to my home. The pepperoni rolls are my all time favorite.

Rob B.

We stopped by late one night to pick up a pie we ordered because nothing else was opened. The pizza we got had mushrooms and jalapeños and it tasted very good. My girlfriend also got buffalo wings and she loved them. It was a very tasty pizza, but typical for places like this that are opened late. I wouldn't say no to it if someone put it in front of me. The inside area is for take out and delivery and nothing more. I enjoyed it though, so all love. It's a solid 6.9 Enjoy :D

Emily C.

We ordered late night as we got back from being out and were starving! The delivery arrived quickly and it was easy to pick up. We ordered a thin crust pizza with pepperoni and bacon. I can appreciate a good thin crust pizza but it was a little too greasy for me. Overall satiated our hunger and hit the spot.

Jo S.

We're stuck in the hotel while visiting family in St. Augustine area and since we were hungry, I called the front desk to ask for a local pizza place recommendation. So, they told me Five Star is great, they order from them also and delivers to the hotel, they know the drill and come up to your room. So I called them, I got nice service over the phone and ordered a large pizza with black olives and pepperoni. Delivery isn't the fastest, but they did show up and did their job OK, I know distances are a tad longer. We were happy to see the delivery guy. No frills. Pizza is good, better than expected, had 2 slices left over. For 2 people I'd get a Medium instead of Large if you don't eat a lot. Glad we tried a local pizza joint. They misspelled my name to a ridiculous degree on receipts, but that turned into a family joke, no offense taken. Good, solid pizza if you live or travel in the area. Glad they came to deliver right to our door!

It's been over a year since I ordered from five star Pizza. I felt that their quality and their taste had really gone downhill I received a $12 coupon and decided okay let's give them a try one small Hawaiian pizza 10 wings mild. The Pizza showed up with a side of blue cheese dressing. No wings. The pizza arrived at 5:43 and the things arrived at 6pm. Both warm, not hot, warm. A free large 1 topping pizza to make up for the lousy meal that you sent out in the first place. I won't be using your free coupon as I will simply be DISAPPOINTED again with what should now be named 1 star pizza. If I had not had a glass of wine i would be in my vehicle driving to your location to show you just how disgusting your food is. The pizza was not even cut all the way on ANY slice.

Meatball pizza with onions and banana peppers

Wendy P.

We just got home from 2 weeks in Cancún with delayed and re-routed flights, an overnight in Charlotte and long hours waiting around in airports. No energy for making dinner or going out so we ordered from these guys and the pizza was here in a flash! Couldn't believe how fast they delivered our well done meatball pizza with 1/2 onions and banana peppers. It was a perfect thin crust and crispy. We also ordered the hot wings (which to me weren't very hot) but still very good. It's not our first time ordering from them and we liked it before as well. I just wanted to say thanks for making coming home tired, grumpy, and hungry a little bit better. Thanks Five Stars!

I called and asked if they have the back to school special and rather than answer my question the employee on the phone had a childish attitude and kept saying that it was self-explanatory and that it was only for kids going to school and it was pretty self-explanatory what's funny is if I drove up there that same idiot would not keep the same energy and say the same thing this place is really trashy and stupid And so are the idiots that they have answering the phone

The three types of pepperoni made up for lack of flavor in the crust or sauce.

Ed S.

If it's 230am and everything is closed- this is your place. The pizza was basic on flavor and toppings, the staff was super friendly, but the layers of grease on the ceiling were gross.

See all

Teresa F.

0

1

0

2 months ago

We have ordered many times from here . Taste excellent, temp -hot, delivery service good.Today we ordered a 12 in cheese & 16 in with onions. Both were a little chewy & greasy! Not happy today. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Stacey C.

Elite 26

3

90

183

3 months ago

One of the few places in St Augustine open late for food other than Denny's or an Americana restaurant. I ordered the chicken bites and garlic knots. The knots were drowned in a flavourless oil with some garlic. I threw them out. They did however have good ranch and hot sauce for the chicken. I would give them a second chance w the pizza if I was in a pinch for a late night meal. read more

Five Star Pizza - Moon over the pizza joint - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

MaryLou B.

Elite 26 All-Star

73

719

6557

7 months ago

Shoutout to our local community heroes!!! We are so grateful for this venues fast delivery of quality products!!! We needed this today! A busy weekend after weeks of holiday travel... thank you for this amazing save Five Star Pizza! We had a flyer in the mail for a free large pizza and the reviews have been fantastic. We opted for the family special once I created a pizza profile. A large 2-topping, garlic bread, and a 2-Liter soda!!! My husband made it home just in time to get the pizza hot and fresh!!! He made me look forward to my first bite as he enthusiastically said, "We can order from this place anytime! This is some of the best pizza that I've had in a while!". I definitely do agree!!! The cheese pull was perfect!! I loved the spice level in the pepperoni!!! And it was thin slices so they crisped up magnificently!!! The crust was the quality!!! Cooked well and the texture was wonderful!!! Not burnt or gooey... I am very picky. I was impressed! Their garlic bread (made daily) was generously swimming in their secret recipe garlic butter! Yummm! Then, the hot wings that we added to our dinner were cooked well-done as we ordered. Yay!!! This all washed down perfectly with our cold bottle of Pepsi!!! Yay!! And they added a sheet of coupons on our pizza box that lead us to a QR code that gave us yet ANOTHER coupon!!! Talk about a win win!!! As a veteran pizza maker (@2 years at Pizza Hut)... I am proud to support the masterpieces coming from this venue! And shoutout to exceptional speedy delivery time and the professionalism of the delivery person!!! He was very presentable and personable! God bless! 5 stars indeed!!! read more

Five Star Pizza - Double pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Five Star Pizza - GARLIC ROLLS: Handmade daily with secret signature garlic sauce! - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Five Star Pizza - Hot wings and blue cheese dressing - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Dennis B.

Elite 24

231

59

118

3 months ago

Great late night Pizza delivery after a show at The Amp!! Fast and Hot just the way we wanted it. Thaks!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Elyssabeth P.

7

72

229

10 months ago

I absolutely love five star pizza! They are always quick, affordable, and delicious. They always have deals going on so there's something for every price point. I only live about 15 minutes away-- I just wish they'd deliver to my home. The pepperoni rolls are my all time favorite. read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Rob B.

Elite 26

668

669

2844

2 years ago

We stopped by late one night to pick up a pie we ordered because nothing else was opened. The pizza we got had mushrooms and jalapeños and it tasted very good. My girlfriend also got buffalo wings and she loved them. It was a very tasty pizza, but typical for places like this that are opened late. I wouldn't say no to it if someone put it in front of me. The inside area is for take out and delivery and nothing more. I enjoyed it though, so all love. It's a solid 6.9 Enjoy :D read more

Five Star Pizza - Mushrooms and Jalapeños - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Five Star Pizza - Buffalo Wings - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

See all

Helpful 6

Thanks 0

Love this 3

Oh no 0

Emily C.

0

8

15

1 year ago

We ordered late night as we got back from being out and were starving! The delivery arrived quickly and it was easy to pick up. We ordered a thin crust pizza with pepperoni and bacon. I can appreciate a good thin crust pizza but it was a little too greasy for me. Overall satiated our hunger and hit the spot. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jo S.

Elite 26 All-Star

667

2407

15283

3 years ago

We're stuck in the hotel while visiting family in St. Augustine area and since we were hungry, I called the front desk to ask for a local pizza place recommendation. So, they told me Five Star is great, they order from them also and delivers to the hotel, they know the drill and come up to your room. So I called them, I got nice service over the phone and ordered a large pizza with black olives and pepperoni. Delivery isn't the fastest, but they did show up and did their job OK, I know distances are a tad longer. We were happy to see the delivery guy. No frills. Pizza is good, better than expected, had 2 slices left over. For 2 people I'd get a Medium instead of Large if you don't eat a lot. Glad we tried a local pizza joint. They misspelled my name to a ridiculous degree on receipts, but that turned into a family joke, no offense taken. Good, solid pizza if you live or travel in the area. Glad they came to deliver right to our door! read more

See all

Helpful 8

Thanks 1

Love this 7

Oh no 1

Lisa C.

0

35

20

6 months ago

Cheap and easy delivery. Consistent and never let us down. They all have specials and coupons.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Laurie Y.

3

24

10

1 year ago

Everything was great! Food, service, and the fun atmosphere! Thank you for a good time!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Robert H.

0

15

20

2 years ago

It's been over a year since I ordered from five star Pizza. I felt that their quality and their taste had really gone downhill I received a $12 coupon and decided okay let's give them a try one small Hawaiian pizza 10 wings mild. The Pizza showed up with a side of blue cheese dressing. No wings. The pizza arrived at 5:43 and the things arrived at 6pm. Both warm, not hot, warm. A free large 1 topping pizza to make up for the lousy meal that you sent out in the first place. I won't be using your free coupon as I will simply be DISAPPOINTED again with what should now be named 1 star pizza. If I had not had a glass of wine i would be in my vehicle driving to your location to show you just how disgusting your food is. The pizza was not even cut all the way on ANY slice. read more

Five Star Pizza - Road kill Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Macy C.

Elite 26

81

45

58

2 years ago

The pizza debate will live on forever, but Five Star is definitely my favorite in town. Their consistency of quality is astounding, their pricing incredibly sound, and their accuracy is always on point. When I'm craving pizza, I can eat all the frilly types I like but it never satisfies my need like they do. Their employees are always helpful and they are truly a pleasure to speak with. I love Five Star! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Wendy P.

254

121

154

3 years ago

We just got home from 2 weeks in Cancún with delayed and re-routed flights, an overnight in Charlotte and long hours waiting around in airports. No energy for making dinner or going out so we ordered from these guys and the pizza was here in a flash! Couldn't believe how fast they delivered our well done meatball pizza with 1/2 onions and banana peppers. It was a perfect thin crust and crispy. We also ordered the hot wings (which to me weren't very hot) but still very good. It's not our first time ordering from them and we liked it before as well. I just wanted to say thanks for making coming home tired, grumpy, and hungry a little bit better. Thanks Five Stars! read more

Five Star Pizza - Meatball pizza with onions and banana peppers - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Helpful 2

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Rose-Marie C.

0

11

1

2 years ago

We visited StAugustine for the Christmas Lights and the Hilton where we stayed recommended you, it was Delicious Thank you

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Sierra L.

0

1

0

1 year ago

Service, food, and atmosphere AMAZING !! Loved how inviting they are and our food was correct fast and HOT. Definitely recommend !!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jodeen G.

0

1

0

2 years ago

Couldn't find anywhere to eat after we checked into hotel. Called here and placed a late night order. Pizza came super fast and was awesome! Staff were friendly and they even ran back out to get us sodas! Highly recommend! Garlic nuggets were great too! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Matt B.

0

1

2 years ago

I called and asked if they have the back to school special and rather than answer my question the employee on the phone had a childish attitude and kept saying that it was self-explanatory and that it was only for kids going to school and it was pretty self-explanatory what's funny is if I drove up there that same idiot would not keep the same energy and say the same thing this place is really trashy and stupid And so are the idiots that they have answering the phone read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Michael G.

5

44

0

2 years ago

Amazing pizza and the pies are huge! Delivery on time and loved everything we tried - pepperoni, meat lovers, supreme.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Caleb S.

0

14

0

1 year ago

I've been ordering from these folks for over 15 years, early, mid day, dinner rush, and even the late nights, and they absolutely refuse to let me down. Don't let some purchased magazine article tell you different, this is the best pizza in town. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Rebecca G.

Elite 26

177

678

2065

5 years ago

This is the only pizza places we found open on a Saturday night after 9pm. Seriously! This place rolls up the sidewalks early. 5 star is a small shop, not in the historic district but close enough to get to in about 10 minutes. They may deliver as well, we didn't ask because we were already in the car coming back from a sunset boat tour. Anyway, we called it in and picked up. We got two large pizzas, one meat lovers and one supreme because I like veggies on my pizza. The crust is good, the toppings are fresh and we were very happy it wasn't like the big chain pizza places because we don't like most of those. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Reuben M.

Elite 26

39

272

475

4 years ago

Great pizza that lives up to their name. The pizza sauce is on point and lots of fresh veggie toppings. Real mozzarella cheese and fresh crust. The best part is delivery. Our order was here within 20 minutes! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ed S.

17

84

85

4 years ago

If it's 230am and everything is closed- this is your place. The pizza was basic on flavor and toppings, the staff was super friendly, but the layers of grease on the ceiling were gross. read more

Five Star Pizza - The three types of pepperoni made up for lack of flavor in the crust or sauce. - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Joe A.

0

1

2

2 years ago

Had a pizza delivered locally at a hotel. Got the Everything without pineapple...The pizza was outstanding and the driver was great, very quick delivery!! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Eric Ori H.

147

32

10

4 years ago

It's 2am and your blasted in St Augy after a night of boozing. Nothing is open except 5 star pizza and they produce elite level drunken pizza. Please don't ask me to give a legitimate pizza review because it will not be so kind. For what they are and what you're looking for at a very late hour it is convenient and during the moments of inebriation it is good pizza for sure. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Hannah W.

Elite 26

228

701

2563

8 years ago

Takeout order. I was not expecting a football field sized pizza to be delivered!! The size is just massive. Surprisingly the taste was not sacrificed like most places that create monster foods and the quality goes downhill. The pizza was large enough to feed 9 of us, with two smaller pieces to spare. The garlic knots were my favorite. Hard crust, soft dough on the inside sitting in a puddle of oil and garlic. Addicting. The sauce has a little bit of sweetness and overall pretty good for a local takeout joint. read more

Five Star Pizza - Pizza-Zilla! - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Five Star Pizza - Garlic Knots - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Five Star Pizza - Half cheese, half pineapple & bacon - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

See all

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 3

Oh no 0

Officer O.

0

3

0

2 years ago

five star pizza has your back when no one else does. theyve gotten me through bouts of depression and breakups, and the only way i can think of thanking them is by ordering more pizza and tipping the hell out of their drivers. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Monika S.

0

23

3

2 years ago

Really good pizza!!! Definitely worth a try. Really tasty and fast service. Try the pepperoni rolls!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Larry B.

1

15

0

2 years ago

After going to three pizza places that were closed in St Augustine on a Monday night, We went to Five Star Pizza and was alarmed that they didn't have dine in. Then we were shocked to learn that 5 star pizza had only 4 stars on Yelp. Then we ordered our pizzas, and we laughed at by the young staff for my friends names which were Larry, Habersham and Elmo. After sitting in the parking area waiting for the pizzas, the employee had to go across the street to get mushrooms for everyone else's pizza after us. After this great adventure, the pizza was amazing and the staff was a lot of fun with us. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Craig C.

5

14

1

3 years ago

It's really Four Star Pizza which isn't a bad score at all. The cheese and the crust are good, just not great.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kevin R.

0

1

0

2 years ago

Great restaurant very quick and reliable the service was amazing the staff very welcoming .

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Gary H.

1

49

9

2 years ago

Terrible bunch of kids that don't care. Delivered to wrong house, when I called they blew me off.

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Vinca R.

12

32

0

3 years ago

We flew in from Montana and got to our VRBO at 11 pm. We ordered pizza and wings and it was all delicious and delivery was extra quick.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Maria S.

Elite 26

379

464

1704

7 years ago

My group and I ordered from five star pizza delivery after going to a bar one night. We ordered plain cheese and pepperoni. Everyone was satisfied and the prompt delivery was very Impressive. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Tiffany B.

Elite 19

5

145

46

5 years ago

Pretty dang good pizza! The cheese on the pizza was so good!! It arrived piping hot and fast. We ordered and got our pizza less than 20 minutes and it was fresh!! Super good and will definitely order again when in town. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Alexandra H.

23

2

0

2 years ago

My husband and I ordered pizza twice on our vacation. The first time was around midnight and they were one of the only places still open. The pizza was ready when we got there 15 min later and it was good! The second time we got it delivered to our condo and I could not believe how fast the delivery was, it came within 25 minutes of placing our order and we are 10-15 minutes away. We also got the garlic rolls the second time and they were awesome. The pizza is some of the best I've had anywhere and the prices are reasonable! We will definitely order again when we are back in town!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jeremy R.

27

5

1

2 years ago

Pizza rolls were good, the pizzas.was Good and delivery was fast. Good value for the money

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Mark B.

0

21

0

3 years ago

Their delivery service is outstanding; quick and friendly. The pizza is pretty good. It is reminiscent of Papa John's, but it is better.

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Victoria F.

2

80

13

4 years ago

Good local pizza for takeout. Love the sauce and crust. We do the thin crust pepperoni. Watch for specials as worth it.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Carol G.

7

18

0

3 years ago

Ordered a thin crust pepperoni pizza for dinner this evening. It was the worst pizza I have ever had. Don't know what happened to this place as we have ordered from here many times over the years and have enjoyed many good pizzas. We will find another place if we ever order again. It was just so bad that it could not be eaten. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ashley G.

192

3

1

5 years ago

Wanted a late night snack and saw some decent reviews for this place. Decided to give it a shot and we were pleasantly surprised! Delicious pizza and garlic rolls!! Nice people and delivery was super fast! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Page 1 of 6

See more reviews

More info about Five Star Pizza

987 S Ponce De Leon St
Saint Augustine, FL 32084
Directions
(904) 824-9868
Call Now
Visit Website
http://fivestarpizzasaintaugustine.com/

Full menu

Hours

What time does Five Star Pizza open?

Five Star Pizza opens at 10:00 AM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Sunday, Friday and Saturday.

What time does Five Star Pizza close?

Five Star Pizza closes at 2:00 AM (Next day) on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday and Sunday.Five Star Pizza closes at 3:00 AM (Next day) on Friday and Saturday.

Mon-Thu, Sun 10:00 AM - 2:00 AM (Next day)Fri-Sat 10:00 AM - 3:00 AM (Next day)

Payment methods

Does Five Star Pizza take credit cards?

Yes, Five Star Pizza takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Five Star Pizza have catering options?

Yes, Five Star Pizza does have catering options.

Does Five Star Pizza serve alcohol?

No, Five Star Pizza does not serve alcohol.

Indoor Amenities

Does Five Star Pizza have TVs?

Yes, Five Star Pizza has TVs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Five Star Pizza have bike parking?

Yes, Five Star Pizza has bike parking.

Does Five Star Pizza have outdoor seating?

No, Five Star Pizza does not have outdoor seating options.

Does Five Star Pizza have parking?

Yes, Five Star Pizza has parking options. Private Lot Parking

Other Amenities

Does Five Star Pizza have free WiFi?

No, Five Star Pizza does not have free WiFi.

More Info

Health Score

Five Star Pizza Reviews in Other Languages

Spanish
1 Review

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 3,619 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Explore benefits

St. Augie's Pizza

oh my. this is THE best place to get a new york thin crust slice of pepperonI! perfectly seasoned…read more excellent undercarriage, fabulous sauce and cheese!! I have gone to other local spots but came in here when my regular stop wasn't answering their phone. so glad I tried this place. perfect!!!!!!

Amazing authentic pizza/italian food. Family owned and everyone there is eager to serve the second…read moreyou walk through the door. If you're hungry and heading down town to see the nights of lights or just to walk around on the bay front and take in all the sites downtown has to offer, stop here first and fill up your belly with some delicious food!

See all

Pizza Time

This place is ranked 2nd best pizza in America located in the heart of St Augustine! Super crowded…read morelike a New York Town Square Joint ! Slices are huge and delicious like everything else in the menu, just expect a loud and exciting crowd! My rating 9.7 out of 10

I was excited to try this place after seeing the huge sign claiming it has the "2nd Best Pizza in…read morethe USA." Unfortunately, the experience didn't come close to living up to the hype. The pizza itself was extremely disappointing. The crust was bland, the sauce lacked flavor, and the overall taste was nowhere near what I would expect from a restaurant making such a bold claim. I've had far better pizza from small local shops with no awards hanging on the wall. To make matters worse, the staff was rude and unwelcoming. Customer service seemed to be an afterthought, and interactions felt more like an inconvenience to them than an opportunity to serve paying customers. A great pizza place can sometimes survive mediocre service, and great service can sometimes make up for average food. Unfortunately, this place had neither. The "2nd Best Pizza in the USA" sign may get people through the door, but the food and attitude will make sure they don't come back. I definitely won't be returning.

Photos

Margaritas

See all

Meat Balls

Carmelo's

We visited this location on our spring break vacation and the waiter attending us. Her name was…read moreMontana. she was great with the service and helped us on the questions we had about the food. The food was delicious, we ordered a large supreme pizza, order of wings, meatballs, and 2 deserts to take out for hotel. Overall, I had a great experience with my family and this restaurant looks to be a family owned business and I will recommend them and will come again. The prices were decent and the atmosphere was good. Once again, thank you Montana for the great service and I hope to come again in the near future

Carmelo's is one of the last non corporate holdouts in Saint Augustine, still delivering honest…read morevalue and great pizza. With two dining areas, you can relax more "restaurant style" with comfortable booths and wood paneling and good beer on tap, or eat more quickie style at a few modest tables inside the convenience store section. Prices have gone up but still affordable compared to other pizza joints and at Carmelo's the quality is obvious. My one complaint is that I want MORE CHEESE ON MY CHEESE SLICE PLEASE but otherwise no notes! Thank you to the owners of Carmelo's for providing the joy of pizza in an affordable way!

Photos

May 2023

"Pizza by the Slice" Pepperoni

See all

June 12, 2024

Pizzalley's Chianti Room

Walking into the restaurant, it smelled so good!! The service was great. Was a little loud from…read morenearby tables so we were almost shouting to hold a conversation however, the food was delicious!! The breadsticks were to die for.. so so good!!! Everything else was exceptional and will absolutely be back!

It's gone downhill so much. I get having to adjust for inflation but man, if you're going to charge…read moremore, at least make the food good. I don't know if it's sold, or changed ownership, but this place is nothing like it used to be. Been coming in randomly for about 10 years. Been a while since I've come in. It's nothing like it used to be. Charged $6 for bread sticks "used to be complimentary" cold and hard. Waitress wasn't good. Would rather put on chapstick than take our order. Almost 10 minutes after her chapstick, she decided to take our order. We told her we were ready after she put in the bread stick order initially. Bring back the old Chianti room.

Photos

See all

Nonna's Trattoria

Best food, best service, great atmosphere!!!!! Definately would recommend, and will return!!!!!!read more

Such great food! I had the spaghetti and meatballs and it was wonderful. Great customer service!…read moreHighly recommend!

Photos

Bathroom

Delicious Spaghetti Meatballs Chef Specialty

See all

Real Peel Pizza

4.9

(11 reviews)

0.8 mi

THE BEST PIZZA IN STA!! We were absolutely blown away by the pizza here, there's nothing even close…read moreto compare! Real Peel pizza is a food truck located next to Muggsy's bar. We ordered the beesting (hot honey and pepperoni) and Bianca (Gorgonzola and lemon zest). I wish I could give more than 5 stars for how incredible they both were. The pizzas were cooked to perfection and the ingredients tasted so fresh, They also use sourdough so it is naturally more gut healthy! We got our pizzas in about 15min, the service was great! Muggsy's also has a nice selection of seating, with a front and back patio, and some indoor seating as well. The back patio is very cute and a great space to hang out. We will definitely be back for more, the pizza was amazing!!!

Hands down the best pizza around. The crust is sourdough perfection. The toppings allow all the…read moreflavors to shine through instead of glopping them on and weighing down the pizza. There is no greasiness either. Normally I find mushroom pizzas tasteless but not this one. Garrett is the pizza master and you should definitely check out his food truck. There is indoor and outdoor seating at Muggsy's Bar where the truck is parked.

Photos

See all

Uptown Pizza

The young lady working out front, pleasant and helpful, food cake out quickly and served at the…read moreperfect temperature. The food was large portions , however only mediocre. My soda from the fountain machine was totally flat, almost like there was no soda water at all, I couldn't drink it and had to change to iced tea. The garlic knots were huge but not much garlic butter used on them. The two meatballs that were served with the spaghetti were pretty large , menu stated they were 3 oz each. The marinara sauce with very tomatoey but not much of any other flavor in the profile

We stumbled upon this charming hole-in-the-wall pizza joint just a couple of minutes away from the…read morebustling downtown area of St. Augustine, and it turned out to be a delightful surprise. This place offers a refreshing escape from the crowds, which was exactly what we were looking for. The pizza was served fresh and piping hot. The quality of the ingredients was pretty good. We shared a 10-inch pizza and that was enough for 2. On a Saturday night, just before Christmas, it's no surprise that the place was very busy. Despite how busy they were, the servers I interacted with were an absolute delight, super friendly, and attentive. Their outdoor area is great and we were very pleased to see that they had plenty of outdoor heaters outside!

Photos

See all

Mellow Mushroom - Saint Augustine

Stopped in here with the family to have some fresh made pizza and some pretzel and cheese bites,…read moreeverybody just felt like pizza that night, but they also have some really good food on the menu. this restaurant is a busy place, but the service is very prompt.

Coldest draft beer in town! I tried the gluten-free pizza crust and honestly, it wasn't too bad…read more(especially for gluten-free). The best part? We scored front-row seats to the live music while sitting at the bar--great vibes all around! The bartenders were very attentive and made a wicked Gin and Tonic!

Photos

The House Special: Red sauce base with mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, sausage, ground beef, ham, Applewood smoked bacon, mushroom

Stuffed Portobella Mushroom

See all

Avocado Hogie

Prohibition Kitchen

Weekend nights are the busiest here so had to wait thirty minutes but got a great table with a…read moreperfect view of the live band "Thelonious Crunk" playing classic cover songs. The male server was attentive and competent but my craft beer was poured as a low abv sour and not my Swamphead IPA hazy request, which was switched out quickly. My Prohibition Burger & Egg was seasoned perfectly and the boiled cajun peanuts had a nice unexpected spicy kick. Aside from the tasty eats, the beautiful 1920's themed bar is notably a mixologists dream. Maybe add a true Speak Easy to the place which would be a cool addition. There was a walk thru to a pricey steakhouse, but not hidden so not really a Speak Easy concept if that was the intent.

We stopped at Prohibition Kitchen in St. Augustine and had a really solid experience overall. The…read moreplace has a great atmosphere dark, vintage speakeasy vibe with live music, neon accents, and a lively energy that makes it feel more like a night-out destination than just a restaurant. The food was good across the board. The burgers stood out as the highlight juicy, flavorful, and cooked well. The fries and appetizers were also solid, and portions were generous enough to leave satisfied. The drink menu is extensive too, with a strong cocktail selection that fits the whole Prohibition theme. Service was friendly and generally on point, even though it was busy. The staff kept things moving and checked in without being intrusive.

Photos

Interior

My friend had this Peanut butter milk shake with whiskey

See all

Shrimp and grits

180 Vilano Grill & Pizza

Amazing!!! The food was so delicious and the service was great! The pizza was delightful and…read morestretchy too. Also the portions were huge and crazy!If your hungry I definitely recommend this place! ( Cori was awesome!!!!!)

We are staying at North Beach RV resort and wanted pizza …read more We wanted take out. They do not deliver but you can call 15 -20 minutes before you want to pickup. Was ready when promised !! Very friendly staff. The restaurant is very small and seems quite popular. We ordered the Caprese with fresh mozzarella, tomatoes , and basil and added meatball. Also asked for a side of Marinara. This was an awesome pizza very tasty although hubby said it needed more meatballs and tomatoes. We will definitely return and highly recommend.

See all

Catch 27

Catch 27 - St. Augustine, FL…read more Came to St. Augustine with a group and Catch 27 was suggested for dinner. Great choice. I checked the Yelp reviews ahead of time and it definitely lived up to them. People in our group started with drinks and everyone at the table seemed happy with what they ordered. I had the red wine braised beef brisket for my main and it was excellent, very tender and full of flavor. My friend Damon next to me had the red snapper and I tried some of that too. Also very good. Someone else at the table had the Rockefeller crusted snapper and that looked and tasted great as well. For appetizers, I had the shaved pear and blue cheese salad. It was really good and honestly enough for two people to share as an appetizer. People at the table also ordered the Devils on Horseback and liked them. I do not eat bacon, but they were happy with that dish. The deviled eggs with southern fried oysters looked really good, and I had the smoked salmon spread, which was very good too. I also saw the shrimp and grits come out for someone else and that dish looked excellent. For dessert, I had the sticky toffee pudding and it was a strong finish to the meal. Others at the table ordered the seasonal crème brûlée, which was chocolate that night. It looked great and everyone who had it said it was very good. Sunny was our waitress and she did an exceptional job. Attentive, kind, and on top of everything the whole night. In my mind this is about a 4.7 star experience, and I am rounding it up to a full 5 stars. Catch 27 is a great choice in St. Augustine.

More like a 3.5 but I'm rounding up - we came here for Valentine's Day, so I do want to take that…read moreinto account of our experience. There was no one at hostess stand because system was down and they were having troubles which I felt bad for the hostess who seemed stressed on obviously a busy night. They were out of both of the entrees we wanted, which was unfortunate but I ended up getting the catch beurre blanc and it was delicious. I ordered a sangria but our drinks took a very long time to come out, after our appetizer (crab, an heirloom tomato bruschetta which was yummy and more filling than regular bruschetta!) Overall, the food was really good and waitress was nice, but water was never refilled and everything took a really long time to come out. Would love to try it again on a regular night and hopefully they have the entrees we wanted to try:)

Photos

Shrimp & Grits

See all

Sarbez

Our experience here was so great that we returned the following night!…read more After arriving to St. Augustine, we decided to visit Sarbez as an option to get a quick dinner and also have some fun before heading back to our AirBnB. Our highlights include: - The ability to create customized grilled cheese sandwiches with tons of options to choose from. (And they were quite delicious) - The atmosphere and environment. - The firm stance in letting people know that ALL are welcome, and hatred of any kind would not be tolerated. No excuses. - Many gaming options in multiple rooms. - Being open late enough for us to return for a second visit after an evening concert at the ampitheatre.

Stopped by Sarbez while in town for the Fort Mose Jazz and Blues Series, and this spot was such a…read morevibe. I went with the Hashton Kutcher and wow. This grilled cheese is stacked with cheddar, sausage, a fried egg, crispy hash browns, and their spicy mayo. It is hearty, rich, and packed with flavor in every bite. Comfort food done right and then taken up a notch. They also have a solid cider lineup. I tried the Cider Boys Strawberry and it was crisp, refreshing, and a perfect match with the sandwich. Add in classic arcade games and a laid back atmosphere, and Sarbez! easily becomes a must stop when you are in St Augustine. Great food, fun drinks, and good energy all around.

Photos

See all

Great place to enjoy a cold draft on a lovely day

Asado Life

Great food, excellent service by Alex, plus she took the time to answer our questions about St…read moreAugustine. The prices are exactly what you're willing to spend, very reasonable for items that should be reasonable and priced appropriately for the more extravagant menu items. Great family atmosphere, music. Can't go wrong.

Fantastic experience and my new favorite in St. Aug. Made a reservation and sat on the patio…read more Great service, great atmosphere, and the food was absolutely incredible. That focaccia may be the best bread I've ever eaten, steaks were perfect, and drinks very reasonably priced. Will absolutely be back.

Photos

Bar dining and kitchen

House salad

See all

Porterhouse

A1A Crab House

4.8

(39 reviews)

1.0 mi

The crabs are the best and pretty much the only place I found them…read more The owner will hook you up! He is the best too. Plus you're supporting a small business. I loved my crabs. I'll be back for sure. It's (to go only ) but he cooks them for you. They were juicy. I got them without seasoning and I put my own on.

So me and my wife just got the snow crab and shrimp combo. Here's the honest view the flavor of…read morethe crab, and the shrimp was tasting good, but some of the crab was cold, looks like they heated on the microwave. the shrimp had no head, but they didn't remove the poop, was disgusting, we couldn't eat. And the sides, we didn't try. Those didn't seem to look very good.

Photos

Decor

Maryland style Steamed with Old Bay Seasoning So good

See all

It's about to go down!

Obi's Fillin Station

While doing a day trip to Saint Augustine and looking for a place to grab breakfast this themed…read morecafe caught my eye, the outside definitely will grab anyone's attention with it brightly painted exterior so we decided to pull into the parking lot, it's a small parking lot and relatively tight so I highly recommend backing into your space and pray someone doesn't dink your vehicle while exiting theirs. The inside is just as impressive with it's "oil and gas" theme, it's rather small but we were able to get seated without a wait even though it was nearly filled. The staff here was very inviting and attentive, the menu is also themed and fairly priced, we ordered "The Ford Galaxie" two eggs your way, a choice of meats, choice of toast or biscuits and home fries or grit - although the winner here in my opinion is the coffee it's delicious, strong and robust. Unfortunately everything here wasn't perfect the "West Creek Whipped Spread Butter Blend" is an abomination, it ruined everything we put it on, my bad for not asking for real butter after applying it to my toast, my grits and the English Muffin we ordered, it was inedible to the point we left everything on the plate this stuff touched it wasn't refrigerated as suggested on the label I'm guessing. I usually eat only real butter so what was I thinking - so my dilemma is how do I review this place fairly based on that stuff and the fact it ruined our food since we loved everything else. Well I guess they'll get three stars for now and I'll return and maybe bring my own butter because this place is a place you really want to love...

I was at the beach for a couple of hours this morning and wanted to get some lunch afterwards. I…read morehad driven past this place many times in the past and the outside looked really bright and fun so I decided to give it a try. The outdoor painting said it was one of top 25 places in the country for burgers so I felt like I had to try a burger. The menu has about ten different burgers to choose from, as well as other sandwiches , salads, and even about ten breakfast items. All of the names of the items have a car reference since the restaurant was previously a filling station. The decor also has a car ambiance. I chose the mustang burger. It had American cheese, bacon, bbq sauce and an onion ring on it. It was very tasty. Side options were fries, coleslaw, sweet potato fries or onion rings. I went with the onion rings. Portions on the burgers and the sides were very good.

Photos

Fabulous! It's the 1/2 lb. The Rolls Royce Burger!! Blue cheese, bacon and grilled onions! Don't miss Obi's!

See all

Coffee mugs for sale.

Tacos My Blessing

4.7

(55 reviews)

0.8 mi

When my wife took her first bite, she said "Are these the best tacos I've ever had in my life?" I…read morelaughed. Girl, hush. There's no way. We're not doing this. We're not talking "best ever." Then I took my bite... We went to this food truck months ago, and we're still talking about Tacos My Blessing. It's a perfect blend of flavor and seasonings, but there's a crunch to these tacos that sets them apart for us. Especially when eaten fresh. That's the key. We didn't wait too long to receive our meals. Plus, the area is a great place to sit and relax! It's beautiful.

Food and service were great. While the flavor profile was solid, I feel that the price paid for my…read moreburrito was a little steep based on the size of the burrito. Chicken was little skimpy too but nonetheless, the meal hit the spot after a day at the beach. While I appreciated the side of chips and 2 sauces included, the chips were bordering on being stale.

Photos

Pambazo $11.99 with chorizo, potato and cheese

See all

Mahi tacos and Mexican street corn

Georgie's Diner

We stopped in for the first time while on a vacation! Staff was friendly and a cute typical Old…read moreSchool Diner but very nicely done! We had the French toast which was amazing with a side of bacon, sausage, eggs, coffee & tea as well as a side of their home made corn-beef hash. It's was all very good. I was not a huge fan of the hash but I think it was very well made but it had green peppers which are not my fave. But I would highly recommend this place! Very nice covered seating area out front as well!

Had a great meal on June 1st. The staff were helpful and quick. Was such a nice full menu of…read moreoptions. I would definitely visit again.

Photos

Interior

See all

Coke in bottle

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

29 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Joe C.

0

10

0

11 years ago

Going downhill. They are still the best pizza delivery in town: quality, quantity and speed. They should have stuck to pizza. They recently introduced wings to their menu. A little pricy, but I've ordered them several times. The consistency is improving as far as size and cooking times go. I've always ordered mine plain with the hot sauce on the side. HOWEVER, the last time I ordered, the cost had increased slightly over $1. It turned out that they were charging 50 cents for each side, and I was getting 2 10-wing orders. Spoke to a "manager" , since this had never happened before; he didn't charge me for the sauces "this time". but would check to confirm the policy. I called back a few days later to check on the issue, and was told by a different "manager" that that was indeed the policy. If they poured the sauce on the wings, there would be no charge, but putting it in a SMALL plastic cup was 50 cents. Why? It was their policy. I could understand if it was extra sauce, but it wasn't. I asked which cost them more, the little cup of sauce or the container of Ken's blue cheese dressing (which comes with it at NO extra charge). He acknowledged it was the blue cheese, which I don't usually even get. He wanted to sell me some wings, but on his terms; he'd comp it, he'd give me special treatment, he'd substitute the sauce for the dressing. He was "winging" it as he went.:) The policy is simply wrong-headed. When you're charging almost $1 per wing, don't nickel-and-dime the customers over the sauce. Bottom line: If you must order out a pizza, do call them. If you want hot wings, call a Publix deli and pick up the order at half the price. read more

Zane W.

2

197

17

2 years ago

A Slice of Heaven at Five Star Pizza! In St. Augustine's heart, where the flavors unite, Five Star Pizza shines, oh, what a delight! With crusts that are crispy and toppings galore, Every single slice leaves you craving for more! From classic pepperoni to veggies so fresh, Each pie is a masterpiece, simply the best! The cheese melts in harmony, a glorious affair, You'll savor each bite, with joy in the air! The folks at Five Star are friendly and bright, They'll greet you with smiles that feel just right. With every delivery and dine-in joy, You'll find a warm welcome, oh boy, oh boy! A cozy little spot where the laughter flows, Gather your friends, watch their happiness grow! With pizza that's magic and vibes that uplift, Five Star Pizza is truly a gift! So if you're in St. Augustine and craving a treat, Head over to Five Star, where flavors compete! In a world full of choices, this one's a keeper, For a slice of pure joy, you'll feel like a sleeper! read more

Angela A.

0

1

0

9 years ago

This was the first time we have ordered in a while. I placed the order online, and drove in to pick up. When I walked in they were very busy and still greeted me as I came in. My order was ready and they offered me plates. As I was leaving one of the staff ran to open the door and also helped with my car door. What great service they offered, the pizza and pepperoni rolls were excellent. Great job to the management and staff at this location. read more

Breanay R.

12

1

0

9 years ago

This is the best pizza place in town. The pizza is always fresh and friendly service and very fast delivery and the prices are very reasonable. they are open everyday of the year including Christmas till 3am. We always order the piezilla which is a beast of a pizza it is literally a two foot pizza, and fresh made garlic knots. They make the garlic butter and cinnamon butter from scratch in the store every day read more

Mike T.

0

3

0

11 years ago

We ordered delivery and I've never had a pizza delivery order come so quick and arrive so hot. We got a large pizza and garlic rolls and both were great. The guy on the phone when I ordered was friendly and explained all the current specials when I asked about them, and the delivery driver was also very friendly, we'll definitely order again. read more

Cameron N.

0

1

0

9 years ago

First of all whoever i spoke to on the phone was so super sweet. Her name was jasmine? And I simply ordered a huge jumbo Zilla pizza as I do almost every Friday. Pizza got delivered in 35 minutes and the food was still hot. My friends and I love Five Star for this exact reason. Great service overall. And great food dome right. You guys ROCK read more

Kimberly S.

253

3

6

9 years ago

By far my favorite pizza place in town. The ingredients are always fresh and delicious. The employees are super nice and accommodating. The Piezilla is amazing feeds my whole family for such a great price!Always has deals for those of us on a budget.They also do wonderful things for our community. Thanks Five Star crew you are all truly read more

Gary S.

0

5

2

13 years ago

whilst staying a hotel we viewed an add for Pizza as we did not wish to order from the larger box stores we thought we would give them a try..... well we can only say that we were very disappointed and that's being nice... they claim to be cheaper for a good reason they use cheap products period... read more

Tammi H.

0

3

0

8 years ago

We just ordered a deluxe pizza, when it arrived and we began to eat the pizza was warm not hot like it has been in the past. We were not happy. The Hatfields 198 Plaza Del Rio Drive St Augustine, FL read more

Tcajacksonville J.

0

1

8 years ago

Best pizza ever. Have been ordering for several years. Delicious crust, sauce is amazing. We are from Buffalo & know pizza and wings. Best we can get delivered & well worth it. Our son loves i read more

Scott P.

0

1

0

8 years ago

Great service from the phone call to order to the guy that delivered our order. Service was super fast. A 70 dollar order to the door in less 15 minutes and the pizza and wings were perfect. read more

Heather S.

1

4

0

9 years ago

Literally my favorite pizza place. They deliver late at night and they never burn the pizza! Lots of topping choices and its not too greasy. Not overpriced. I prefer this to Dominoes read more

Alaina L.

0

2

0

8 years ago

Love their pizza and wings!!! Delivery is excellent and timely and Jerome, who took my order, is the man!! Great personality and clearly enjoys his job! Five Stars to Jerome!!! read more

Lisa P.

1228

1227

6

17 years ago

Went here with my friend and her parents. My gosh this pizza was good. The bacon was perfect. We got the pepperon i rolls also. My gosh was so good. wish i lived near this place. read more

Megean N.

84

6

0

9 years ago

We were so happy to find great tasting Gluten Free pizza right in the middle of town. The manager was so helpful to answer all our questions. Thanks for a great dinner read more

Lauren H.

294

2

0

9 years ago

Very impressed with this late night food choice! Food showed up hot and fresh and our delivery guy was very nice. Will definitely recommend to our friends! read more

Julia N.

3

1

0

11 years ago

AMAZING !!!!! Pizza, pepperoni rolls and garlic nuts !!! I don't have enough words to express my kids reaction when they tried it , simply the BEST ! read more

Tina B.

2

20

40

4 years ago

Excellent food, excellent service and fast pizza was absolutely delicious if you're ever in the area I would highly recommend

Lydia C.

0

1

0

11 years ago

Pizza was pretty good but the pepperoni bites were delicious! Speedy delivery, friendly staff and reasonably priced.

J F.

1

22

7

6 years ago

Best pizza delivery in town. Never have had any issues to speak of, they're pretty fast and the pizza is so good!

See more unrecommended reviews

Five Star Pizza - pizza - Updated July 2026

People who viewed Five Star Pizza also viewed

900 Degrees Pizza and Pasta

79 reviews

Antonio's Pizza at the Beach

149 reviews

$

Antonio's New York Style Pizza

29 reviews

$$

Rufino's Pizza

41 reviews

$

Vinny's Pizza

116 reviews

$

Main St Pizza & Ice Cream

24 reviews

Pirate Pizza

76 reviews

Nonna's Trattoria

423 reviews

$$

Jersey Slice

53 reviews

$$

Hammock Pizza

35 reviews

$

Five Star Pizza

Order Five Star Pizza Takeout or Delivery

Five Star Pizza Photos

Business Info

Five Star Pizza Popular Dishes

FIVE STAR PIZZA ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Five Star Pizza

Reviews With Photos

More info about Five Star Pizza

Payment methods

Food & Alcohol

Indoor Amenities

Outdoor Amenities

Other Amenities

Five Star Pizza Reviews in Other Languages

Ask the Community - Five Star Pizza

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

More businesses like Five Star Pizza

St. Augie's Pizza

Pizza Time

Carmelo's

Pizzalley's Chianti Room

Nonna's Trattoria

Real Peel Pizza

Uptown Pizza

Mellow Mushroom - Saint Augustine

Prohibition Kitchen

180 Vilano Grill & Pizza

Trending businesses in Five Star Pizza's area

Catch 27

Sarbez

Asado Life

A1A Crab House

Obi's Fillin Station

Tacos My Blessing

Georgie's Diner

29 Five Star Pizza reviews that are not currently recommended

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

29 reviews that are not currently recommended

Five Star Pizza - pizza - Updated July 2026

Best of Saint Augustine

People found Five Star Pizza by searching for…

Trending Searches in Saint Augustine, FL

Browse Articles

Browse Nearby

Browse Brands

Related Searches in Saint Augustine, FL

People who viewed Five Star Pizza also viewed