Are you looking for incredible pizza in the far west valley? You'll find it at Argento's in Old Town Buckeye. Right on MC85, (I think the address is 805 Monroe), Tommy and his team make really delicious pizza. They use the freshest ingredients and your pizza will be served up with a smile. We ordered a large pepperoni, sausage & onion pie today and paid less than $20. Go get one. Delicious! read more

Great sicilian pie or like how we call it in NY a square.If you want real deal NY style pizza you get it from a real deal ex New Yorker.Owner is from New York.Not like one of these pretend to be NY pizza places.Check it out. read more

Moved to the area less than a year ago and there is no other place that I will go in this area for pizza, subs, etc. I'm glad that I found my place! Ingredients are fresh, and the owner and staff are the best. read more

The 18" one topping pizza and 20 wings special is a great deal. Wings were small but tasty, and pizza was decent. Doesn't match the pizza I get back home in Chicagoland, but not a bad option nonetheless. I did place an order to pickup an hour in advance and had to wait about 20min after that, but I understand timing in the kitchen isn't always perfect. Employees were also wearing blue lives matter merchandise, and I felt that was a little inappropriate. read more

Great food. Nice people. We always have great service and they deliver! Don't miss out on the wings.

I live in Buckeye and Argentos has the best pizza around. However their wings are not up to par with their pizza. The wings are small, slimy, and dry. If you want wings I would advise you to order from any other fast food pizza chain not only to save money but to have better quality wings. Booty's which is just down the road is a much better choice for wings. read more

Food's always fresh & it's ready in a timely manner. Employees are very friendly, do recommend!

Argentina is always my family's go to pizza place! Never disappointed! They are very friendly and the pizza slices are always huge!

Not only is the food amazing and authentic, the customer service is unbeatable. We did an online order and they accidentally forgot to include the dessert. They called us before we even noticed it was missing, and delivered the dessert to us at home at no cost. They also included a free two liter soda. Quality food and quality service. read more

This place never disappoints, fast delivery, hot food and the sauce on the pizza and spaghetti !! So good!

We were on our back back home and my husband and I wanted to grab a quick bite . Found them on yelp and we don't regret it! They have good bundles. I put 4 stars only bc the wings we bought taste like they overheated the sauce and it left that burnt taste in your mouth but other than that it was really good! The pizza was delicious! read more

I ordered for carry out and someone else picked up. We didn't realize we were missing anything until the restaurant called me. They apologized a number of times and brought out missing items plus a bonus item right away. Excellent food AND customer service! read more

Aw, these people are the best! We were driving thru town and my driving buddy asked if I could find pizza. Argento's came up and the high star rating is on point! Everyone was so friendly working there. They have GLUTEN FREE CRUST! I did a dance of gratitude for them. My friend requested extra tomato sauce and they nailed it. I stuffed an extra slice into me just cuz it was delicious. I had a GF pizza with half Hawaiian & half mushroom/spinach/garlic . Amen! read more

If you haven't eaten here yet-- drive yourself down and get some pizza. Or a Stromboli. Or a salad. Or a calzone. Or literally ANYTHING on their menu. Tommy (the owner) is freaking awesome, and the pizza is the best I've had outside of NYC. Really great food-- they house make their ranch!! If you like wings, the buffalo chicken pizza or strombolI is fantastic!! Goooooooooo!! It's a little dive-y in the absolute best way possible!! read more

One of the best pizza places around. The pizza actually has the perfect amount of cheese, they dont skimp here. It's like New York pizza, but way better. Not too thin and unfilling like normal, but actually has some sustenance to it. The wings were average, my husband LOVED his calzone. I really want to try some of the more Italian dishes as they looked so good while they went out to other tables! read more

Tried take out and loved it! Will be back. Argentos special, it was great! The crust did get a little dry but the pizza itself was delicious. Update: Dropping the stars for this! 3 strikes - Your out! Have been back several times and each time our order was wrong!!! This has happened now 3 times. We will NOT order takeout from there ever again. The pizza is great when it's correct so if we do choose to eat here again it will only be in the restaurant where we can make sure our order is correct (not wasting our time driving all the way there and then home before seeing it's wrong as we have when ordering takeout). read more

Amazing Italian food and pizza. Ordered my first pizza from them and I would say the best pizza spot on Buckeye.

I really need to stop using Yelp and trusting that their rating system is an accurate representation of good and bad. Once again, I was fooled into believing that I was about to eat some of the best pizza I have ever had. Sadly, it was all a lie. Their first offense was putting mushrooms on my pizza. There appears to be an issue when you view their website through the Yelp app. If you use a laptop or desktop, you are presented with their updated 2017 website that shows a different menu. When I attempted to view their website using my phone, it shows an older menu from 2015. The obvious discrepancy is that the 2015 pizza I ordered didn't come with mushrooms. So, that pissed me off, but perhaps Argentos is not at fault. However, if I were them I would contact Yelp and have them look into this. Their second offense was making a pizza that was practically inedible that cost me over $21.00. I don't know if it was the quality of ingredients or cooking process, but it wasn't good and I don't know why people think it is. I have had very good pizza and very bad pizza and this ranks toward the bottom with Dominoes and Papa John's. It's unfortunate, because the service is great and the people are very nice and accommodating. I was even offered a free slice of pizza or something because of my bad experience, but I won't be returning to take advantage of their offer. The first impression is incredibly important and when a restaurant fails to impress I cross them off my list. With that being said, Argentos is locally owned so if you want to take a risk at having a bad experience, be my guest. read more

Absolutely FABULOUS Pizza and salad delivered! Great customer service! (Might even have to order some 2nite hehe)

Best little Italian restaurant outside of New York and they run a close second to Nonna's Sunday dinner!!! Pizza is delicious with the right amount of sauce, cheese and toppings, pasta dishes are so good and shareable and the salads are great. They have such a friendly staff who give great suggestions on what to get. If you want great Italian food this is the only place to go to in AZ!! read more

I have been here at least 10 times in the last 6 months......it just doesn't get any better! From Pizza to salads.....it's all fantastic. My favorite is the Stromboli and the Anti pasta salad......oh, and they make the best Italian dressing.....like non other. One time I did have a problem (due to the cashier) with the order not being made.....but the guys took ownership of the situation and fixed it FAST! They were sincerely sorry for the miscommunication and so very apologetic. Mistakes happen......but all it takes is someone to own up to it and make it right......and that they did! Still my favorite place to go for pizza and subs. Keep up the good work! read more

This place is amazing! The workers are really nice and the atmosphere is friendly. The restaurant was super clean. Now, onto the food. The food is delicious! The appetizers were good portions and delicious. The mozarella sticks were so good. I can only describe it as having a tart fresh taste. I had the chicken parmigiana and I wish I could have eaten it all! I can't wait to visit our friends again just to come here! I wish we had this place back in California! read more

Went to this place based on a review and will definitely be back. I only wish that it is s lot closer Sundance to where I live! We had the Buckeye Veggie because it was Ash Wednesday but would have it again! It was loaded with veggies including broccoli and the crust was thin and crisp. We did eat in so the pie didn't live in a box before being served. It's not fancy but the pizza is excellent! read more

After searching for a place to eat for 2 hours, my friend and I came across Argentos here on Yelp. Im fairly new to Buckeye so I am not fully sure what is around me. Being a native New Yorker I generally stay away from all pizza out here because it just truly is not the same. As I scrolled through the pictures of food I decided that I needed to give this place a shot. Boy oh boy am I glad I did! Of course I had to order a bunch of food to make sure that if I didn't like something I would have more options to eat. I loved every single bite! The pizza is amazing! Sold by the slice or by the pie which is a wonderful familiar feel for me. The Stromboli and Calzone were cooked to perfection! The dough is so perfect I can't even describe it! They were so nice to us they even gave us two cannoli's on the house! I will most definitely be returning for their amazing food! read more

First visit here and not my last. It was the closest place from where we looked at new homes. The price point was right, the staff was welcoming and the food.....Bada Bing! Large portions surprised all of us and they don't scrimp on the portions . The proprietor even helped us carry our orders out! Get over there....you'll enjoy it!! read more

one of the best pizza restaurants on the west side. there are many places closer, but i'll drive 20 minutes longer to get pizza from here.

Ordered twice, tried two different crusts, neither was fully cooked. Toppings are real quality, but soggy, doughy crust ruins it. Tasted better after heating in my oven, but shouldn't have to do that. read more

Found this place in the middle of nowhere Buckeye Arizona! I think it was owner gave me a water on the way out good man! Better pizza!

Best pizza, pasta, and service in Buckeye (Phoenix really). If you're a fan of NY style pizza, you will love Argentos.

Just a lucky stop on our way back from Indio, CA. A treasure. This guy knows how to make a New York pizza. One of the best I've had in AZ and that's great praise from a NY City native. The crust had a nice bite to it, the taste of the sauce came through, and the cheese felt just right, a good taste and feel. read more

I love their pizza and hot wings!! Their XL pizza and wing special is a great deal! Definitely the best pizza in Buckeye!!!

Just passing through town. 5 of us had 20 wings and 1 large pizza was perfect for us. Everything was totally on point when you hear the Guys in the back speaking Italian you know it's going to be great. Forgetaboutit! read more

Food was hot, fresh, good and inexpensive. Staff was polite and helpful. Kitchen looks clean. read more

See all

Outstanding food and service. Tommy the owner is a class act and gives back to the community! 5 stars.

We went in for the first time. We saw this place while eating at Native wings lol I said we are going here next! We're new to the area. So later that day we called in our order. Ordered wings, garlic knots, and pizza. Pictures on Yelp won us over to give it a try! Everything was amazing!! Including customer service. This place is on the top of our best restaurant list!! We will be back for sure! Not sure why these negative comments pop up. Especially Trish, my goodness, relax.. ! Put a couple of garlic knots in your mouth and enjoy!! :) read more

Excellent food and customer service. We had salads, fried mozzarella and dessert. Everything was great. Our first meal in Buckeye!

We order pizza came hot and just what we order it was very good so visit a local pizza store instead of a chain all the time.

Cute establishment. They are always very friendly and hasn't changed. The pizza is good it's NY style pizza so it's a traditional big pizza. It's child friendly and the parking is good. read more

The owner is the worse person to own a business he has a a crap attitude its not our fault yall messed up on our pizza and then to have rhe nerve to call me and say well we xan only give u a 5 dollar credit... i dont reccommend this place to anyone! read more

I have lived in Buckeye for a little over 10 years now and was looking for a new pizza place to try. I came across Argento's and read a specific review that said "true NY style pizza and wings." Being a New Yorker I became extremely skeptical. Let me tell you they were RIGHT! Pizza and wings were on point! Also, the staff were very friendly. You definitely earned a new customer! read more

Argentos Pizza - Argento's Special Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buckeye, Arizona

See all