Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Arthur’s Island Kitchen

    5.0 (4 reviews)

    Arthur’s Island Kitchen Photos

    More like Arthur’s Island Kitchen

    Recommended Reviews - Arthur’s Island Kitchen

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Feather F.
    7
    158
    151

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Amazing food. And reasonable prices . And I am going to go back to try everything else on the menu!!!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Skipper's Dockside

    Skipper's Dockside

    3.8(1.1k reviews)
    2.4 mi
    $$

    10/5 stars if I could! This was hands down one of the best meals we had during our trip to the…read moreKeys. We were seated immediately, and there was plenty of indoor and outdoor seating overlooking a beautiful channel with boats constantly coming and going. I ordered the mahi mahi sandwich with sweet potato fries, served on a coconut bun, and it was quite possibly one of the best sandwiches I've ever eaten. Everything came out hot, fresh, and surprisingly fast. You could tell the food was made to order. The staff was genuinely friendly and never made us feel rushed, which made it easy to sit back and enjoy the view. The outdoor seating was fantastic and added so much to the experience. The restaurant is a little tucked away and can be easy to miss, but don't let that stop you--it is absolutely worth finding. We spent about $54 for two people, and considering the quality of the food, generous portions, service, and atmosphere, it was worth every penny. If you're in Key Largo looking for a great meal with a waterfront view, put Skippers Dockside on your list. We'll definitely be back.

    You heard it right!!!!…read more One of THE BEST Key Lime Pies in the Florida Keys! I have been here a few times. VERY cool spot to hang out for a few beears or drinks. Food is excellent and customer service is exceptional. BUT........ What really stands out is their Key Lime Pie. I have been up and down the keys trying Key Lime Pie at almost every place I have stopped. Two have stood out: The version here at Skippers and the other at Captain Craigs in Tavernier. Both unbelievably delicious, both VERY different! RUN here today for your own slice!

    Photos
    Skipper's Dockside - Pool tables

    Pool tables

    Skipper's Dockside
    Skipper's Dockside - Bloody Mary

    See all

    Bloody Mary

    Key Largo Conch House - Key lime pie and key lime coconut cake.

    Key Largo Conch House

    4.1(953 reviews)
    2.1 mi
    $$

    Loved the lobster Loved the lobster bisque…read moreFriendly waitress and beautiful atmosphere!

    Casual. Comfy atmosphere. Friendly staff…read more We started with the Conch House sampler and swapped out the jalapeños for more shrimp and fritters. The sampler comes with two conch fritters, two coconut shrimp, two bacon wrapped items (which we replaced), cracked conch, and lobster and conch ceviche. I have to say this while it's fresh in my mind. The moment I had the lobster and shrimp ceviche, I got chills. Just an incredible burst of flavor. Tiny bit of heat at the end but nothing overwhelming. Just really, really good. The conch fritters are solid too. Chewy, not over breaded, and served with two sauces. One is sweet and one is more of a mayo style. There's also something that eats like a conch curry puff situation. I liked the cracked conch better personally, but both are worth trying. The coconut shrimp is also really good. The sampler also comes with tortilla chips on the side. The lobster bisque is delicious. Great flavor with little chunks of what I'm pretty sure is lobster throughout. Nothing more to add really. It's just good. The mahi and avocado dish has a nice seared taste to it. Not flame broiled exactly, but that kind of grilled sear that you want on fish. The pico de gallo is similar to what came with the ceviche, and it works really well here. All in at $75.

    Photos
    Key Largo Conch House - Conch House service area.

    Conch House service area.

    Key Largo Conch House - Lobster and conch ceviche

    Lobster and conch ceviche

    Key Largo Conch House - Lion fish metacumbe

    See all

    Lion fish metacumbe

    Sol by the Sea - Seating at Sol by the Sea

    Sol by the Sea

    3.7(291 reviews)
    4.7 mi
    $$
    Happy hour specials
    Casual dining

    After a long voyage through the waters of Key Largo, our crew arrived by boat and docked at SOL by…read morethe Sea, where visiting vessels are permitted to remain for two hours. Thus began our search for the fabled buried treasure of Captain Fats Montana. The restaurant is completely outdoors, covered, but without air conditioning. They did have fans and portable cooling units, though some of the older members of our expedition still suffered beneath the tropical heat. Thankfully, the incredible views, excellent service, and amazing drinks kept morale from collapsing entirely. I greatly enjoyed my grouper sandwich and thought the food was excellent overall. A few fellow adventurers had some complaints about their meals, but our service was consistently friendly and attentive. The drinks gave me enough strength to battle the cannibal tribe, uncover Captain Fats Montana's buried treasure, and claim my reward: 73 coupons for 10% off a footlong meatball sub at Subway. Sadly, they expire in 12 days, but that is a tale for another voyage. Beautiful views, great service, delicious drinks, and a memorable waterfront atmosphere. Just prepare for the heat if you're traveling with older companions.

    We were staying at the resort attached to this restaurant and we had one more full day to check it…read moreout. We popped in for lunch and lived the openness of the restaurant. We ordered a couple fancy drinks to try and the ceviche. It was absolutely amazing and a must try if you like seafood.

    Photos
    Sol by the Sea - Food at Sol by the Sea

    Food at Sol by the Sea

    Sol by the Sea - Water Table

    Water Table

    Sol by the Sea - Food at Sol by the Sea

    See all

    Food at Sol by the Sea

    Habanos On The Creek - Beef tacos and fries

    Habanos On The Creek

    4.5(207 reviews)
    11.0 mi
    $$
    Women-owned & operated
    10 years in business

    What a great little hidden gem! The staff made us feel right at home and has a family owned and…read moreoperated vibe. They offered great recommendations, and provided excellent service throughout our meal. The restaurant sits right on the water, creating a fun, laid-back atmosphere. In fact, if a boat goes by a little too fast, don't be surprised if you get a little splash--it just adds to the waterfront charm! I ordered the Ropa Vieja, and it was fantastic and a large portion. It was very flavorful, and tender. Overall, this was a great experience If you're looking for a cute spot for lunch or a casual dinner on the water with friendly service and delicious food, Restaurant on the Creek is definitely worth a visit.

    This is our go-to lunch spot every year during lobster season. After spending the morning out on…read morethe water catching lobsters, we always stop here to fill up the boat with gas and grab lunch before heading back out or calling it a day. We've tried quite a few dishes over the years, and my favorites are the loaded chicken wrap and the Cuban cheesesteak. Whatever you order, don't skip the fried plantains--they're the perfect side. I have tried the skirt steak before, and it just wasn't my favorite, but everything else we've ordered has been consistently good. You can choose to sit inside in the air conditioning or outside at one of the covered picnic tables. Since you're right on the dock, it's a great place to relax, watch the boats come and go, and enjoy the Keys atmosphere. Good food, convenient fuel for the boat, and a waterfront location make this an annual stop for us every lobster season.

    Photos
    Habanos On The Creek - Inside

    Inside

    Habanos On The Creek - Mahi tacos and plantains

    Mahi tacos and plantains

    Habanos On The Creek - View from table sitting outside

    See all

    View from table sitting outside

    O'Deeny's Caribbean Restaurant - Welcome to O'Deeny's Caribbean Restaurant

    O'Deeny's Caribbean Restaurant

    4.6(98 reviews)
    23.6 mi
    $$

    Excellent Haitian eatery with affordable prices. situated on Krome in the Rodeo plaza. The pleasant…read moreservice at this family-run restaurant is excellent. The restaurant is reasonably sized and tastefully, but simply, designed. The menu is concise, and you can always ask for something that isn't on it, and they will do their best to accommodate you. Lunch specials can fill you up without breaking the bank. Griot, or fried pig chunks, is their most well-known and traditional food. It's flavorful and a little oily, but you can add some pikliz, our Haitian chili sauce, and it will absorb it all, especially when served with rice, salad, and fried bananas or tostones. You can even switch up the sides.

    Stopped in around 5:30pm on a Saturday night and were surprised to find the front door locked with…read morea doorbell there to ring. Not sure if it's just a rough neighborhood, but we were clearly the first eat-in clients of the afternoon/evening. The hostess said they could accommodate our group of 7 and so we did end up staying, but our group had to do all the rearranging of tables, high chairs, and table wipe downs which was strange. Overall the service was just OK. One of our dishes didn't come out with the others which was unfortunate as everyone was done eating when it finally did come out. One nice thing was they prepared small plates of fries and ketchup for our youngest boys who weren't interested in the Caribbean fare offered. The food and presentation was nice, but seemed to be very overcooked and dry. Perhaps just an off-night for the staff. I was encouraged to see several takeout orders being picked up so seems like they're a local favorite.

    Photos
    O'Deeny's Caribbean Restaurant
    O'Deeny's Caribbean Restaurant
    O'Deeny's Caribbean Restaurant

    See all

    Arthur’s Island Kitchen - caribbean - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...