Great sunset views, good service and the food was delicious. We ordered mahi tacos, a watermelon salad with chicken and Arnold Palmer's. All was very good and left me wanting more. Waitress was attentive and jovial. The outdoor space is large and confortably accommodated big families. We would definitely be back. read more

Morada Bay Beach Café - Mahi tacos - Caribbean Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

See all

Beautiful setting. Terrible service! Arrived at 7:30 with a reservation. Booked a table for two by the water. Was given a large party table at the entrance, the only one held for us - no words!!! Found a high top table that didn't seem to get any service. 40 minutes in, still no drinks. Go somewhere else, folks! read more

Great location with a beautiful view. Just make sure to sit in the shade because the sun gets hot. The food was fresh and came out fast. We had a small mix-up with the wings since we wanted them naked, but they fixed it quickly and they were delicious. Maria was a great server, attentive and kind. The sangria and desserts were very good, the bathrooms were clean, and they also have a kids menu, which is a plus. Good pricing and overall a really nice place to eat. read more

See all

Amazing sunset, food is good. We had the wings and fish tacos and both were delicious, and service was adequate. The only thing I didn't care for is the small high top table they sat us at. I would have preferred a table with regular chair with a back, not the high top as im old and my back needs support. They put us there because we had no reservations but there were plenty of open tables , so not sure what was up with that nonsense! We have been here many many times and never had a reservation so not sure what changed. Of course we will come back but I will make sure I make a reservation and ask for a.table with an umbrella. Maybe they need to pit on their website , reservations required. read more

See all

We requested to seat near the shaded area, there was no one attend to us. We have to wait for water, wait for some one to take our order and wait for dessert and wait for check. I have to walk to the host to get someone to attend to us. Horrible service. we had pino colada, whole fried fish (quite bland), half lobster for $18 (the only thing I like), watermelon salad (refreshing, but small portion) and key lime pie (the worst key lime pie I had in FL, not authentic, they put whipped cream instead of meringue, the pie is so sour). There is a cute cat which is very friendly and we tried to share some fish meat with the cat, even the cat didn't like the fish. Ironic. read more

See all

Booked a 6:45pm reservation here and what a great view! The service was excellent, no rushing, place filled up fast after we were seated. Saw the beautiful sunset. Food was awesome, Lobster fritters were very good! Mahi mahi tacos were great and the grilled snapper was superb. So much food we could not eat it all but so good. read more

Service has not been as dependable as it used to be. Our last two visits staff was setting up for private parties later in the day, and did not ensure the paying customers already there were being served in a timely manner. We watched a few people leave. On this last visit, we stood at the host station for 15 minutes, and then finally had to walk around and look for someone to seat us. They no longer list the 32 oz giant Morada Margarita or Pierre's Punch on the menu, instead they list all the drinks and you can get any of them in the larger size. We decided to go with the Painkiller and the Morada Essence which were completely different than our usual, of course in the 32 oz size. A half hour later, our server brought us the Morada Marg and the Pierre's Punch. We had our hearts set on something different, but went with it since it took 30 minutes to get them and we didn't want to wait another 30. RJ ordered the lobster fritters and I had the snapper special with plantains. His fritters were a little overcooked but my snapper was on point. Service was really a 2 this trip but you can not beat the drinks and the view, even if the drinks weren't even what you ordered. read more

See all

I always love coming here and I recently came with my boyfriend. It's right on the water and the service is always amazing. The staff are great. read more

Morada Bay Beach Café - Caribbean Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

I think this may be the best fried shrimp basket I've ever had. The shrimp are butterflied then wrapped in a tasty tempura blanket before being fried in a delicate oil. I mention this oil because there's no aftertaste of old oil - the flavors of the shrimp and the tempura seasoning comes through perfectly. Our server was polite, professional and pleasant. We chose a table on the beach and thoroughly enjoyed watching the water birds and boats. I will definitely pin this location in the hopes that I get a chance to come back some day. read more

Will never go back! I'm disgusted the food was horrible. The fish dip was mostly mayo and very runny extremely tasteless and bland. The taco Tuesday fish tacos were also tastes less just tasted like fried food. We also ordered the lobster fritters and side of fries not pictured because I just wanted to get out of there. Again fritters tasted just like fair fried food and the fries were cold and stale. The only thing going for this place is the location/view. Service was good our waitress came around multiples times checking up on us and refilling our waters. read more

See all

It was a hot day starting our Bachelorette Party in the drive to Key West from Miami and we were in desperate need of food and drink. So I Yelped on the road and we took a detour in Islamorada, and found an amazing start to our Keys celebration!!! Morada Beach Cafe is a wonder! Right on the water the sights are beautiful. It's low key, outside and such a hang out spot. We ordered immediately in famish and had the Best Meal!!! Let me say, the food critic in me even if starved, would not post a 5-star unless it's legit. And this place is legit. A ten-star really on the greatest spicy margarita I have ever had. I had the frozen mango one and it hit the spot. Delicious. We ordered our food and around the table was satisfaction. My first meal in the Keys had to be conch! When in Rome. The conch ceviche was a delight. And the discovery of shrimp chips accompanying through, it over the edge in amazement. Two other fish sandwiches ordered with fries- crisped up great. And the seafood mac and cheese we all tried to steal from my bestie! Huge pieces of scallop, lobster, you name it. All food was flavorful and cooked to perfection. An awesome memory to our trip! read more

See all

This was our first time here. The food was delicious, the service impeccable and the sunset view was stunning. We will definitely be returning the next we are in the Keys! read more

Morada Bay Beach Café - View - Caribbean Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

I got the chicken sandwich on focaccia bread. I make focaccia myself and wow they knocked it out of the park!! I loved the chickens/ roosters around the property- it's a true keys experience! The property itself was magnificent on the water. They have 2 stages so I'm sure they play live music but we got there around 12pm and there wasn't any music playing. Our service was a disappointment unfortunately. Our server didn't even give us silverware or napkins. He also disappeared until we were waiting for the check. I would come back for the food but not the service. read more

See all

We're staying at the Cheeca Lodge and Spa across the street. Morada Bay Beach Cafe is part of the Lodge. We went for lunch and it was a very nice experience. Everyone was super friendly, the view was amazing and the food was very good. We had Mahi tacos and watermelon salad. Both were excellent. read more

Morada Bay Beach Café - Mahi Taco's and watermelon salad. - Caribbean Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

See all

What a disappointment! The parking is pitch black and you can't even see where you're going. We checked in because we used opentable and the hostess could have cared less. We were seated by the water away from people. After 5 minutes they dropped off water. NO ONE came back to take our order!!! We obviously left- wait staff watched us leave as they were talking amongst themselves. Horrible service and no ambiance. read more

The food and atmosphere was excellent, service was horrible! Our waiter didn't seem to know what the fish of the day was and didn't care to ask. He said it was grouper when we first ordered and then said it was mahi and snapper when he brought us our food... if it's the fish of the day you'd think it would be the same fish. We came around 8:30 and there were plenty of people there, but most of them were finishing up their meals. Once it his 9 we were the only couple seated outside. Our waiter seemed annoyed and frustrated that we were still eating, even though they close at 10. Maybe he was having a bad day, but overall he had a bad attitude with us for no apparent reason. Regardless of the service, we had a great time. Very romantic spot, and i'd definitely recommend trying to make it here in time for the sunset. read more

See all

We waited one hour after getting our drinks waiter disappeared and never came back We ended up walking out. I even asked another waitress to bring my father in law a beer and it didn't come out either. He was visiting from Holland. I'm a local so I won't be coming back. read more

Awesome atmosphere. We had the blackened tuna tacos and the mahi tacos. Both were delicious! Our server was very personable and pleasant.

Not so much.. Parties, weddings and oh yea.. customers. Was once a great spot.. now? Nice sunset.. parking tough read more

Was pleasantly surprised about lunch at this location. The outdoor seating was expansive and lots of room for big groups. Another restaurant is connected next door. Had an excellent lunch with perfect service. Had the mahi tacos and seafood dip. Everything was excellent. Would go back for sure. read more

See all

Went here for my first dinner this week. Lovely place. Linda was my server and she sold me on the Catch of the day. Wow, it was great, packed with flavor and the pico on top was perfect. Couldn't ask for anything better to start a great week. read more

Morada Bay Beach Café - Catch of the day. - Caribbean Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

See all

We stopped in for our last dinner of our trip because we saw a sign out front that said fish fry Fridays. Unfortunately, the fish fry isn't all night, and it's only 5-8pm. We ended up just missing it and stayed anyway. We ordered a pan-fried red snapper dish and fish & chips. Both were good, and the plus was that the fish that came with the fish & chips wasn't oily. For dessert, we ended up ordering the blonde, which was very good and sweet. The place is very open and nicely set up. read more

See all

Was recommended this place by a friend. We were on our way down to Key West and ended up stopping off here. The location is great and the atmosphere is really nice. It is right on the water with some amount of little Sandy covering. Even though it was really hot outside, the umbrella kept is really nice and cool. Problem number one was how long we had to wait for anyone to acknowledge at a table. Then eventually we were given water. Then about another 8 to 10 minutes after the waiter come over and introduced himself and asked for drinks. Drinks were blah. Fish was the best part, but just ok. Good batter. . The seafood macaroni and cheese was OK. Nothing special, nothing to write to him about. The fish and chips were OK. The fish was the best thing about it, the batter was really good but the fries were rubbery and overseasoned. All and all, definitely an experience I will not need to probably ever again. read more

Morada Bay Beach Café - Fish and chips - Caribbean Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

Wonderful experience sitting right on the beach watching the sunset. Food was wonderful. Service exceptional. Can't wait to return.

Went to the keys for a day trip to celebrate my birthday with my daughter and my bf and only wanted 2 things!!! To eat a whole fried snapper and watch the sunset, and I got both with this place!!! We got there on a Friday around 4:45pm and it was pretty empty so we got to sit wherever we wanted. We picked a table closest to the water of course. And since it's December it wasn't so hot out so it was nice. Fridays they do a fish fry that seemed like a vibe for real. Next time we go that's what I'll do but I was on a mission this time for that whole fried snapper. Our waitress was amazing and so funny with super high energy, I loved her!!! lol. For drinks I got a blueberry mojito and I can't remember what my bf got but we both liked them. For our meals I got the whole fried snapper with the rice and beans, plantain and piklis and it was EVERYTHING I NEEDED! It was delicious and so worth it. My bf got the Rasta pasta and was really disappointed unfortunately. Didn't really have much flavor. The main flavor I actually tasted when I tried it was the coconut milk they add in it. My bf is Jamaican so he's a tough critic to Rasta pasta and rated it 1/10. I'll give it a 3/10 lol. But the view for the sunset was absolutely beautiful. Please if you wanna watch the sunset but don't know where to go please go here. Such a cutesie restaurant with great vibes, beautiful views and honestly a great place to take pictures whether you have the water as the background or the restaurant with its colorful tables and chairs. It would be great for a date night! I would def love to come back here and try other things on the menu next time we come down to the keys. read more

See all

I would give 0 stars to this place, burned burguer, fries with fish flavor, fish came undercooked. Worse food in the Keys, nice view but will never go back. read more

We were headed to a food truck, but they weren't open and we were directed to the Beach Cafe. The view and the surroundings are amazing! I had quite a good lunch - a rice & beans bowl. Wayne had an ahi tuna club - on bread that is usually used for the chicken club. so that is what it come on and we had to ask the waiter to send it back - all good, just made a bit more of a wait! read more

See all

Average "bar" food, but amazing views!! You'll be able to sit inside, or a small bar outside, or at a table right on the sand (with a view of the water). I ordered the zesty organic wings and the mahi mahi street tacos- nothing special about either. Also tried the strawberry shortcake for dessert, which was a bit too sweet for me (lacking tartness). The service was friendly and accommodating- but veryyyy slow- don't come here if you're in the rush. Also, it was a little difficult because the waiter did not speak much English, so it was hard to even order anything off the menu. Would return again, but just for the atmosphere. read more

See all

Great food. We got there early so we were able to sit under the covered porch. Service was prompt. The food was great and the atmosphere was beautiful. read more

See all

I've been coming to Morada Bay Beach Café for years and it's always been one of my favorite spots in the Keys, but my most recent visit was extremely disappointing. The quality has really gone downhill. Food: The food was far below the standard I've experienced here in the past. Dishes that used to be flavorful and fresh came out poorly prepared, and honestly felt rushed. It didn't taste like the same kitchen at all. Service: Service was the biggest issue. Our server was inattentive, slow, and seemed overwhelmed despite the restaurant not being particularly busy. We waited far too long for drinks, food, and even basic check-ins. It felt like no one was really managing the floor or paying attention. Ambiance: The view is still beautiful, but the overall atmosphere has slipped. It used to feel warm and welcoming--now it feels neglected and unorganized. read more

Morada Bay Beach Cafe was the perfect birthday dinner to end our stay in the keys. Not only was the atmosphere stunning right on the bay, we were lucky to see a beautiful sunset as well. The food was impeccable! I had the yellow tail and it was seriously the best seafood meal I've had. Our experience was made even better by the amazing service. Kellesh, our server, went above and beyond to ensure my mom had the best birthday dinner. She was attentive, accommodating, funny, and so kind. Thank you to everyone at Morada Bay. Can't wait to come back soon! read more

See all

This is a great stop for a drink and a peaceful view when in the Keys. We decided to take a break from the driving and park here for a bit. they have a really nice outside area with colorful tables and chairs, and also colorful beach chairs to sit, relax, and enjoy the ocean view. If you want to add to your experience, they have a good menu and some tasty drinks to go with that view. Real "vacation" vibes here, as you would expect and want. read more

Morada Bay Beach Café - Blueberry vodka-mojito - Caribbean Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

I can't believe we've never visited this amazing beachside oasis. Firstly the grounds are beautifully maintained with lots of trees and foliage. Then their drinks are ready for a party GINORMOUS. Definitely order the best fish dip in the keys. The watermelon salad was also refreshingly delicious. We shared the fried fish with a coconut rice, black beans and the best platanitos I've had in a long time. Servers were very friendly eventhough they were a bit scared of our big dog. read more

Morada Bay Beach Café - Views - Caribbean Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

Honest opinion: I was excited for this restaurant on our last night in Islamorada, but the service was extremely disappointing. We were initially seated in a corner behind a hedge and told we could grab drinks and sit by the chairs for the sunset. However, we waited 15 minutes with no acknowledgment while 3 servers stood around chatting or 2 others walked by without saying one single word. Literally no one even acknowledged us. A simple "hello" or "someone will be right with you" would have gone a long way. I understand that maybe the chatting servers weren't responsible for our table, but it felt extremely rude and such an uncomfortable experience. I went to the front to ask the host if we could grab a drink inside then sit, but I had to wait another 5 minutes due to the inefficient seating process. The host had to walk each group individually, creating long waits. So now this is the second time going through this just to talk to the host. I didn't want to cut when people were also waiting. It wasn't her fault--she was doing her best--but the system clearly needs improvement for such a large restaurant with so many people arriving for sunset. The host knew we had waited 15 minutes but only asked "where we were sitting" and said "sorry" without any follow-up, which just made the situation even more awkward. After being ignored, we ordered at the bar and sat outside, but eventually decided to leave. The Sauvignon Blanc was good, and the view was nice, but the lack of service made the experience so uncomfortable and honestly a waste of time. This review is based on service alone since we didn't eat. Unfortunately, I won't be returning or recommending this spot. read more

Sad- no staff or servers anywhere. Been here before and it was great. Today...last time ever. The hostess comes over and chastises us and 10 other people we can't sit without going through them. Tells us if just drinks have to sit at bar with no staff, if we want food we can stay. 20 mins later server comes with no rush not apology for delay, confused by simple order. SLOOOOOOOOOOOW to get food with empty restaurant! read more

Morada Bay Beach Café - EMPTY AND BAD SERVICE - Caribbean Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

We dined today at Morada Bay Beach Cafe and it was a fantastic experience from start to finish. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, with tasteful decor and comfortable seating. The staff were attentive, friendly, and knowledgeable about the menu. Our server Francine was the best server. Very attentive and charismatic. The view is amazing. If you want to see the sunset this is the best place! Each bite was well-seasoned and cooked to perfection. The drinks were also impressive--especially the PINA colada and The Keke colada. Service was prompt without feeling rushed, and the staff made sure our needs were met throughout the meal. Prices were fair for the quality of food and overall experience. I highly recommend this restaurant or anyone looking for a great meal and excellent service. I'll definitely be returning! read more

Service was so good and everyone was so friendly! Highly recommend for the sunset. Really enjoyable thank you!

Great food!! Amazing service from Thania ... best waitress ever. Be sure to request her. Sunsets amazing... atmosphere incredible. Do not miss this. ! read more

Morada Bay Beach Café - View of water - Caribbean Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

Food : ok Options : limited Cocktails : ehhh Sunsets : BREATHTAKING. Order the conch fritters watch the sunset and walk over to Pierre's for craft cocktails. read more

Had lunch here around 11:30 on a Sunday. Wasn't many there yet so had a great selection of seating. Obviously the atmosphere is a big draw with the outdoor seating and water views. I had the mahi tacos based on the photos on yelp. They were nicely seasoned and the aoili gave them great flavor. I loved that they come with tortilla chips and salsa (I am not sure the menu mentions that). I also had the golden margarita which was tasty and not super sweet or overly acidic. It's a little pricey (normally order a glass of wine but most were $19 to $20 a glass). But I would say it's a lovely atmosphere and worth a visit. read more

Morada Bay Beach Café - Golden margarita - Caribbean Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

See all