Back for a retry after a number of years. It's okay, nothing to write home about. I suppose a safe place to bring family. This time around our service was 5 . The pizza - dirty calm pie was good. The Italian chicken dish was a miss for us... tough chicken pieces and lacking flavor even though it had nice chucks of cut up vegetables. The lentil soup was adequate, it met base line flavor and presentation. I guess what locks and information is I noticed the population that's coming in. It's a much older crowd. Certainly the menu items are on the lower price side so it makes it affordable to go out. It's hard when you cook at home and you want to go out a couple nights a week at the weekend and for what we've been paying with inflation and the impact of tariffs we would expect a higher level of them when I'm putting out of my own kitchen. Again, a safe place a consistent place a busy place and if this is acceptable for you, then this is your go to. read more

Best pizza in New Jersey, great prices keep us coming back. Highly recommend getting a cheese pizza with extra cheese, it will blow your mind. read more

Stopped in on our way home. My husband and I were greeted and seated immediately. There is plenty of seating and the place looked pretty clean. We ordered some water along with mussels in red sauce, medium pizza with half onions. The mussels were very meaty with a delicious chunky tomato sauce. The pizza had a thin crust with more sauce than cheese, more of a tomato pie taste. It was okay but not the best ratio of tomato sauce to cheese. This place probably has a great tomato pie. I would definitely return just for the mussels alone. But if I ordered a pizza, I'd be a little more specific about its preparation. read more

Palermo's - Regular pizza/half onions - Pizza Near Me - Bordentown, New Jersey

See all

Cool local pizza and Italian spot Lots of seating inside Real great customer service Got the tomato pizza slice Also got the chicken Parmesan slice Real tasty pizza. Much flavor read more

The tomato pies are crazy good. This place is in my top 5 pizza places of all time. We don't live close but make the drive. It's that good. read more

Review for Palermo's Restaurant - Bordentown, NJ Palermo's Restaurant is a spacious, family-friendly pizzeria with plenty of seating, making it a great spot for dining in. My wife and I visited with the goal of enjoying some good garlic knots, and in that regard, we were pleased. The garlic knots were quite nice--warm, flavorful, and delicious. Unfortunately, the rest of our meal didn't quite live up to expectations. The cheese slice was a letdown--super thin, floppy, and lacking in both cheese and sauce. I was hoping for a more balanced and satisfying bite. We also tried the cheesesteaks, which were just okay. While not bad, they didn't stand out, and I've definitely had bigger and better ones elsewhere. That being said, Palermo's does have an extensive lunch and dinner menu, which makes me want to give it another shot. There's potential here, and I'm hoping a second visit will be more impressive. For now, I'd rate this place 2.5 out of 5. read more

See all

This was definitely one of the best chicken parm pizzas I've ever had. I've been going to Palermos for years now, I usually go with a tomato pie. I wanted to switch it up this time, definitely did not disappoint! read more

Palermo's - Chicken Parm Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bordentown, New Jersey

Very nice and friendly staff that was welcoming to me and my friends as we walked in a little before closing. The establishment was clean & gave the feels of a pizza joint. Guests that were already there recommended the pies that we got & they didn't steer us wrong. Thats always a good sign when guests do the selling for you. Pizza was very good and I'm not even a fan of thin slices. I would definitely come back and try the others that they offer and explore the menu. David Portnoy even visited and i saw he left his famous review! read more

Palermo's - Plain pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bordentown, New Jersey

See all

We live close to Palermo's and since we've moved in it has been our go to pizza spot. We typically stick to the tomato pies. Good sweet marinara with a tasty cheese blend. We've gotten bruschetta from there as well and have enjoyed it. We've yet to try specialty pizzas but plan on it. Will continue to keep coming beee. read more

See all

We stumbled upon this place on a whim as my 9yr old was starving and we were in the area. Wow a happy surprise, so delicious! Pizza, salads, breads, sauce, service, ambiance! This pizza has now become our #1 go too. And the total win is that it's so reasonable priced for quality delicious food. read more

I was online and came across Dave Portnoy's review video of Palermo's and WOW!! What an Impression it made! At first, I honestly thought he was being sarcastic or coy, But After watching this video, I literally could Not stop thinking about enjoying a pizza from Palermo's Pizza in Bordentown, NJ. After work, my family and I made a Beeline straight there. It was closer than we thought and at 2:30pm, there were several people dining in. We checked out the menu and settled on the Saturday and Monday special because this was our very first time here. Chrissy sat us and was attentive but Not bugging us. We ordered the plain pie and tomato pie. Holy cow!! It was so light, fluffy and Thin all at the same time. Unless you Try this masterpiece for yourself, you'd Never believe me. My mom, who eats like a bird ate 3 pieces of pizza and then, her sweet tooth got the best of her and she ordered dessert! She had the Black Forrest bomb and between my husband and my mom, they polished it Off! The place is Spotless and music at a great enjoyable level and we literally sat and ate and talked for 3 hours and time flew by and it was just a fabulous experience. They also had a nice side room that can entertain about 30-40 people and we cannot wait to come back!! read more

I normally don't leave reviews, but the service at Palermo's was honestly disappointing. Our server, Karla, made the whole sit-down experience uncomfortable. She came off very unfriendly and seemed bothered whenever we tried to ask anything about the menu. read more

I had a really disappointing sit-down experience at Palermo's. The food was okay, but the service from our server, Karla, completely ruined the visit. From the moment we sat down she seemed annoyed and uninterested in helping us. read more

Kinda just walked in and had no direction on where to go. Didn't know if we had to order in front or could be seated. Took about 5 minutes to get a guide and be seated in a bigger table for 8. After all the hype at work about this pizza joint, here I was, with the group! Tried their Classic Pizza with Eggplant and their signature Tomato Pie. We also sampled their Fried Zucchini and Jalapeño Poppers that had cheddar cheese. I have to say, the crust was thin and delicious. I'm a sucker for eggplant and was craving it that day, but their Tomato Pie, which was what they were known for, takes it! In regards to parking, somewhat limited, had to park in the gravel/dirt on a rainy day, since parking was shared. There is a good amount of seating and can host for bigger groups. Food came out in a timely manner, with the exception of one order, another penne vodka, but one of our party members didn't mind since the serving was generous and inhaled it in a few moments once it was received. To keep things simple, Venmo/Cashapp a single person to fork the bill for the table... took a bit to get out of there after eating. I apologize for the make shift pics, I was super hungry and needed the food to get in my belly! read more

See all

Good food good service , very friendly and the place was clean. It was my first time there and I'm sure I'll go back.

We been to Palermo's multiple times through out the years and it's always good. So much so that Dave Portnoy joined the party and make them one of his spots for his national reviews. Their pizza is always delicious, with a perfect balance of crispy crust, flavorful sauce, and toppings. Their gourmet pizzas are especially delightful, offering a great variety of creative and tasty combinations. If you ask for your pizza well done, (which my kids always do) the crust comes out extra crispy, adding a perfect crunch to every bite. Beyond the food, the service is always friendly and welcoming. Whether you're grabbing a quick slice or ordering for the family, Palermo's is a go-to spot for great pizza. Highly recommend! Don't wait, give them a try. read more

We live in North Carolina every time we come to New Jersey this is our go to place for great pizza. Went there the other night and had Brooklyn Pizza margarita pizza and their pizza with sausage has real sausage. It's not that cut up sausage as we call it. And Loretta and the Owner are awesome. read more

Palermo's - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bordentown, New Jersey

See all

A huge thank you to Palermo's especially Vince and his entire staff for helping make my early 50th birthday celebration so special! The food was absolutely delicious, the service was outstanding, and everything was perfect from start to finish. Highly recommend! read more

Palermo's - Pizza Near Me - Bordentown, New Jersey

It seems like a historic restaurant so it's not modern or trendy but it's classic. Apparently it's a BYOB... they don't have a bar or alcohol drinks. I have never been to a restaurant that is BYOB. The server (Miranda) was sweet. Young, energetic and nice. The Cesar salad was good. The pizza (pie) was good. We had a classic cheese pie. read more

See all

Passed by Palmermo's tomato pies today on my way to Atlantic City . I placed the order by phone and I wanted to arrive before it's done so it don't sit in the box and get soggy . My main reason why I do that is because I want the pie crispy . I've been here at least 5 or 6 times and it's always a home run . I took a pic of the pie when I got it and again as shown a pic of the under carriage to show that they put too much sauce in the middle of the pie which made it soggy . I was disappointed but not completely discouraged because the taste is there but the main allure of the pizza to me is the crispiness unfortunately I didn't get that today . I will definitely continue to stop by on my way to Atlantic City . This still remains my top 5 pizza shops in all of New York and New Jersey. read more

Palermo's - Small tomato pie added basil - Pizza Near Me - Bordentown, New Jersey

See all

Love their pizza For a large topped with clams-super fresh every time....$22.50 even my teenager loves it read more

Palermo's - Awesome Pizza-throw some clams on there and it's muah chefs kiss - Pizza Near Me - Bordentown, New Jersey

The food was great! But my only complaint was the serving problem! I had a server by the name of Maddie she was just the worst server I've ever had I hope to never have her as a server again! read more

Let's update this for 2021! Ok to start: this pizza would be amazing if you plunked it down in Florida or really anywhere else outside of NJ/NY/CT (yes, New Haven gets its due). But is it pizza? If you're interested in Palermo's, odds are you've read up on "Trenton style tomato pie." If you haven't, just know there are OTHER styles of tomato pie out there: The closest geographically is the Philly-style tomato pie, which (probably due to immigration patterns back in the day) is similarly to Utica, NY style tomato pie. The latter 2 are akin to taking focaccia or maybe a Sicilian style pizza crust, putting some yummy tomato sauce atop, and serving it at room temperature with a nice dusting of grated parm to finish it off. Despite being in the same Delaware Valley as Philly and having MUCH more in more common with its big brother to the south (Philly) rather than the north (NYC), Trenton's tomato pie is unique. It has a VERY thin and typically moderate to severe crispy crust. The umami from the tomato is the star of the show. Some people debate whether any of the aforementioned tomato pies qualify as pizza. I say: probably, but who cares? It's good in its own way. Palermo's definitely makes their pie THIN. I took advantage of the Saturday/Monday only deal. Said deal used to be 2 pies (sans topping, cheese or tomato variety) for $20. Now it's crept up to 2 for $22. I added garlic to my tomato pie, which cost...I think $3? Total damages for a plain cheese and tomato came to $25.54 and I didn't notice any BS card fees. That's a plus. Unfortunately, the amount of garlic wasn't sufficient, leading me to the tube of target's "good and gather" brand garlic powder in our kitchen cabinet. Otherwise, the tomato pie is quite tasty, albeit not very filling compared to other varieties of pizza. For reference: I'm 5'10" and weigh maybe 140 lbs soaking wet, I put away 5-6 slices of this easily! That would never be possible with pizza elsewhere. The plain pie (aka cheese)? It was good. Nothing special to report. It had cheese on it and the crust was the same as the tomato pie, very thin. All in all, $25 for 2 pizzas of this sort isn't bad these days. That said, I can't help but feel that I walked away with a little bit of fool's gold. The product looks great and eats so easily. It also pairs well with beer. But I'm left wanting for further satiety for my $. Maybe this style isn't for me? Perhaps I'm just cheap these days? My fiancée and I are soon moving up 55 miles to North Jersey: Hudson county. It would be interesting to see how this would fare up there, as you won't find pie like Palermo's once you get more than 25-30 minutes away from Trenton. Check it out and decide for yourself. P.S. When calling in the order, I did ask: "do you still have the 2 for $20 deal on monday?" The person on the other end clearly answered affirmatively and didn't disclose the $2 price increase. Money is money. Just be honest with me please. It's little things like this that drive people away. read more

See all

Ordered a tomato pie from Palermo's. The crust was thin and crispy. The rest was good. This is authentic and the best in the area.

Such a gluten free gem! So safe for celiacs. Pizza, pastas and entree all fresh and hot read more

Palermo's - Gluten free pepperoni pizza and chicken picante. So good! - Pizza Near Me - Bordentown, New Jersey

Ordered through door dash, but store delivered itself. Right after I ordered a quick storm came through. After an hour store order was still being prepared . I called the store and asked and they said they were waiting due to the weather. I asked if my pizza was going to be cold and they assured me no and that they waited to make it. An hour and a half later my ice cold pizza was delivered with blue cheese dressing for my Cesar salad. I was staying at a hotel, so could not heat it up. An 18 bucks for my very small cold pizza was not worth it. read more

Excellent food. Rude service. I recommend taking out. Came here for a funeral dinner yesterday after my mom lost her fiancé. My mom sat at the wrong table and the restaurant manager yelled at her. She's having a rough time of it. I attempted to resolve and ask that the manager make an accommodation. He chastised me about table settings, and when I shook my head at him, he reprimanded me for shaking my head. He raised his voice and it felt very abusive. I'm sorry, maybe the tough guy attitude is ok for some folks, but it's not appropriate to treat customers this way. Ziti was a+, salad was delicious. I suggest some customer service training and perhaps you'll have better outcomes. read more

Holy shit, that's a pizza! The red sauce and the crispy crust is crazy good. Damn! Classic NJ pie.

Tomato pie! Nothing extra. Just the tomato pie - large. Amazing! So good. I can't find anything like it in California. Don't know why.

Amazing people and great food. What a nice environment to eat. Was attended quick and service was fast.

We drove out of the way to try Palermo's due to the high ratings and it didn't disappoint! The crust was so thin and crispy with great taste. The sauce to cheese ratio was perfect for the tomato pie. The sauce was on the sweet side, if there would have been less sugar added it would've been amazing. The pizza is also extremely cheap, which was great! read more

Palermo's - Pizza Near Me - Bordentown, New Jersey

I have kept meaning to try this place as it is pretty close by. Called in an order for pickup. When calling we asked what is there most popular. The lady mentioned Portnoy and how he gave the tomato pie a high rating. We decided to go with the tomato pie. She said it would be ready in about 25 minutes. We got there in about 20 minutes and it was ready. The staff there were very pleasant and we said it was our first time. They assured us we will be back...lol. We got it home, and it was already lukewarm, but decided to eat it anyway without reheating. It was a very good pie. I would have liked it a little more hot, but we were starving and just wanted to eat. The crust was thin but not too thin. Had a good crisp to softness ratio. The sauce was excellent. It was sweet and had good flavor. The cheese to sauce ratio for the tomato pie was good. Not overly saucy at all. We pretty much finished the whole pie in one sitting. They were right, we will be back. Next time we will try the regular plain pizza. read more

Palermo's - Plain tomato pie - Pizza Near Me - Bordentown, New Jersey

See all

This is a wonderful local Italian place. Excellent service, delicious food, and the nicest staff. The BYO Alcohol policy is unique, so feel free to bring your own "adult beverages". We had a group of 9 and have no complaints from the group. It's worth a trip! read more

Such a beautiful pizza. Quick service and everything is ready when promised. The location is near many major roads which helps. read more

See all

Ok 4 stars for the pizza and the calzone. They definitely have the best calzones in the area and the pizza is also delicious. However, we ordered a large pie and were definitely sent a small pie. I mean tiny slices. This is not the first time it's happened and it's just very disappointing that you can't depend on the consistency. read more

See all

After a doctor's appointment and reading the reviews, we decided to give this place a try. We were immediately seated after checking in. Originally, we were given a short table in the corner and didn't understand why considering the place was empty when we got there. So, we requested another table. The restaurant is medium in size and separated into two dining rooms, with the color scheme consisting of various shades of brown. The floors and tables are made of polished brown wood and the walls are beige as well. Sconces decorate random areas of the walls and a pizza paddle can be seen hanging where the counter is. The counter also has a picture of the owner with Dave Portnoy as well. Framed photos also hang from the walls and because we went in December, there were fake Christmas garlands lining both a window and a dining room entrance. A wreath also hung in the vestibule as well. I feel this place looks more like a pizzeria than a restaurant and that makes me very happy. We ordered gnocchi marinara with red sauce and spinach egg drop soup , pepper and egg sandwich and a large harvest pie. We've been feeling that we needed vegetables and hubs ordered the harvest pie. It was delicious! The crust was nice and crispy with plenty of sauce and vegetables. At first, I thought the crust was going to be soggy with all the veggies but it didn't disappoint! The gnocchi was delicious and carby. LOL. Daughter liked the pepper and egg sandwich a lot and said that she would order it again. The soup was delicious, too. Daughter and I fought for every last drop of it. Service was friendly and quick. Will definitely return and try other items on the menu! read more

A packed parking lot for lunch on a weekday is a good sign of quality, and that's exactly what awaited me on my first visit to Palermo's. I had been looking forward to trying their pizza after seeing a glowing pizza review. The exterior may look a little rough around the edges, but the interior of the restaurant is very welcoming and tastefully decorated with plenty of seating. The pizza slices looked like they'd been sitting around a while, so we ordered a large traditional cheese pizza so we could try it freshly prepared out of the oven. The cheese pizza (5/5) was easily one of the best I've had in the area, with tomato sauce being the strong point perfectly accenting the cheese and crust...all high quality ingredients and fresh tasting. The pizza was cooked just right to make it firm without being burnt, and was light rather than heavy like most pizzerias in the area. It would definitely crack my rotation of regular pizza places I'd frequent if I lived closer to Bordentown. We also had a chicken parmigiana sandwich (4.5/5) with sauce on the side which was served on fresh tasting bread with ample decent quality chicken topped with the right amount of cheese. Both items hit all the right notes in the taste department. They had very tempting desserts including quite a large selection of cannolis, but we were filled up, so passed on them (this time). Service was attentive and friendly...overall a great pizza and dining experience which I hope to repeat in the near future. read more

See all

Went there to try as I follow pizza reviews and loved it. Went on a Monday for lunch w a buddy and had a tomato pie w anchovy's, my personal favorite topping. Loved the chewy, thin crust. The sauce had a slight sweetness to it which did well with the salty anchovy. Next time I'd ask for a bit more well done but it really was terrific. Our waitress couldn't have been nicer and someone from the back kitchen checked on us to make sure all was ok! Many competitors in the area have crispy type crusts but this one had more elasticity and flavor. Great crust! All in all I can't wait to go back and demolish another pie!! read more

My husband and I have been trying out a new local pizza joint every Friday. We recently tried out Palermo's. The dining room was cozy, and the staff was attentive. Everything was well-priced. The antipasti salad was excellent! The pizza itself was good, but I would not say the best I have had recently. It was a bit too greasy for me. read more

See all

First time having a tomato pie and it was great. The crust is 10/10. Crunchy with every bite, definitely one of my favorite. The Caesar salad was good, pretty simple. The fried calamari was okay, definitely not the best I've had. Without the sauce there isn't much flavor. Overall, it was great. Servers are nice and we went on a Sunday evening which was nice and calm. read more

See all