My husband and I decided to try Atlantic Grill last nite as we were staying at the Wentworth nearby. I ordered the baked haddock which was ok at best! That's the better of the two meals!! My husband ordered the Fisherman's Stew. It was described as having sausage, mussels, haddock , shrimp etc. What arrived was a bowl of tomatoe sauce with chunky onions and 2 very tiny pieces of sausage. ( dime sized) and three mussels on top! My husband tossed it around and found no other seafood. We dine out often and never complain, but this was insane! The waitress came back and we told her what we found. She took the dish back to the kitchen and it came back with a few pieces of shrimp and two quarter sized pieces of haddock... and explained to us the "chef forgot to put the seafood on top!!!" Seriously!!! The meal was awful. As soon as we were done, she dropped our bill at our table. At the very least, they should have taken half off... if not, the entire meal! Nope! Full price! Oh well.. lesson learned! We won't be going there again! read more

Dear Atlantic Grill, Why can't you be a better restaurant? I want to like you so much because we are neighbors. But every time I decide to give you another try, I am always disappointed. You just don't seem to understand the meaning of "flavor". A nice plate of fish with breadcrumbs, potatoes, and veggie arrives totally unseasoned. No herbs or spice anywhere to be found or tasted. It is no fun paying for bland. And please do not tell me the potatoes are "roasted" when they are clearly deep fried. That is just not fair. A surreptitious scan around me at nearby plates of food, only serves to give the same consensus. That there is no real chef in the house, only a cook who is not up to the task of delivering something worthy of your high prices. I really did try to make it work out. So near but not quite there! read more

Same owners as the River House. Nice place but overpriced for blah food. French onion soup was like turkey gravy and the bar tender was lost. Maybe because there still new. Will probably only have cocktails and a app.here. I won't have a lunch or dinner . That's for sure . Save your $$$and go to the wentworth instead . read more

Atlantic Grill - Seafood Near Me - Rye, New Hampshire

We recently had dinner at the Atlantic Grill in Rye, NH. The outside patio is beautiful- a great place to eat on a nice day. Service was good- our waitress was prompt and polite, but curt. The food was OK. The seafood chowder was very good- seasoned well and full of fresh seafood. The calamari was OK- the seasoning was fine, but the flavor was one-note, and the marinara with it was lukewarm, and not very interesting. The mussels with chorizo were OK as well; with so much chorizo, that's all that you could taste. The most disappointing part of the meal was the value: two drinks, two appetizers, and two cups of chowder for $65. If the food was great, it wouldn't be an issue, but with the food being as mediocre as it was, it left us wishing that we had gone to one of the many other great places in the area. read more

Had dinner at Atlantic Grill. They have a nice bar area with full food service. The Farmers Board (charcuterie plate) was pretty good. They have several types of oysters here. Their seafood chowder is apparently award winning and did live up to the expectation. read more

Atlantic Grill - Oysters - Seafood Near Me - Rye, New Hampshire

See all

I drive by the Atlantic Grill each morning, and witnessed the entire build. I was rather pleased that there would be a place about a mile from New Castle. Well, so far three meals, one good, one fair and one horrible. The chef is clearly not up to the job. One of the dishes, a combo of fish in a floury moray sauce, should have never made it out of the kitchen. The only thing worse than the taste was its dissecated appearance with a skin/film over the sauce. Fried haddock not bad. Pasta in one dish tasted more like mashed potatoes than the mashed potatoes did. The bar area is quite pleasant, with an elderly Rye contingent. Many televisions, and the drinks were good, as was the beer selection. Prices were quite high. After three trips, I may return, especially if the menu and chef revamped. Service was quite good, and apologetic ("I hate bringing things back to the kitchen all the time"). read more

First of all this review is long overdue! The management invited our party of 7 for a do-over to make-up for a very disappointing visit a month earlier. We're happy that they did. Our experience was a great improvement, particularly in service! Our server was very attentive and took great care in explaining the new menu items and in answering our many questions. She was attentive and effective without being over zealous. Our table shared the charcuterie platter and thoroughly enjoyed it. Appetizers such as the crab cakes and lobster salad were equally successful. My entree and my wife's - both seafood dishes- were wonderful. Only the two of our party who had pasta dishes weren't quite as well satisfied. Most of us ordered the outstanding (and large) bananas foster for dessert, which was one of the best renditions of the dessert we have had. We left the restaurant more than satisfied with the food and the service. read more

The Atlantic Grill is the WORST restaurant I have ever visited. Not only is the food overpriced but the service is horrendous. The general manager is a condescending and rude individual who knows nothing about running a restaurant. Save yourself the trouble and go somewhere else. read more

We tried this restaurant during NH restaurant week and were pleasantly surprised by how great the food was. Everything we ordered was fresh and so delicious! We are excited to have this gem right in our neighborhood. It is sure to be busy this summer with the beach tourists and it seems ready for the season. Only complaint was that it still smelled very much of fresh paint which was overwhelming at first. Once we got used to that I would say it was a great experience and I would definitely recommend this place. Amazing things we enjoyed: lobster ravioli (amazing!), oysters, lobster, and their bananas foster was to die for! read more

We have been looking to try this place for a while. There were eight people in our party which can make for a difficult experience The Decor was very nice and we chose it sit inside as it was a bit chilly outside. The waitstaff were helpful and attentive and there was something on the menu for everyone. One of the managers stopped by to check on us which I appreciated. They waitstaff brought out two meals and said the rest would follow which I am in favor of so everyone gets hot food. Unfortunately that was not the case and half the meals arrived barely warm bordering on cold. The fried haddock was piping hot but the Salmon was cold. I think the problem was in the kitchen as the waiters were delivering meals as they were ready and it was not overly busy. I had a bowl of French onion soup which had good flavor but was not hot. Overall a mixed experience as the waiters were good but the food was not read more

We stopped here for a quick lunch on a cold winter Sunday since we drive past it quite often and have wanted to give it a try. The building is relatively new and very nicely decorated. We were seated immediately at a high top in the bar area and given menus. Many yummy sounding items on the menu, but our eyes went to the lobster roll and seafood chowder combo---I think it was called Tall Ship, but not positive. We ordered and our food was delivered in a reasonable amount of time. The chowder was delicious---thick and full of yummy seafood. Loved it! The lobster roll was a good size with big chunks of lobster and no filler! It was a little bland and definitely could have used a little mayo. Probably should have asked for some, but didn't. Would I order the lobster roll again? Probably not, but would definitely get the chowder again. Service was ok. Didn't see much of our server, but that was ok. Might return if in the area, but there are many, many wonderful restaurants in the Portsmouth area. read more

Atlantic Grill - Tall Ship---chowder, lobster roll and fries! - Seafood Near Me - Rye, New Hampshire

Still kind of a disappointment, but 4+ stars for ambiance and service. We reluctantly returned with friends who hadn't tried it yet. It was a beautiful night so we ate on the patio. It was perfect!! We then ordered the seafood tower, ($90), and when it arrived, it had been assembled incorrectly so the entire top portion, (oysters, shrimp, sauces, etc), ended up on the table. We're an easy going group and so it didn't bother us. Plus they didn't hesitate to bring a new top tier. That being said, everyone agreed that none of the lobster or shrimp had any flavor.... As if it had been frozen for quite some time. I don't eat shellfish so I am just going by what the other three said. I ordered the chicken with chantrells. It was a busy plate, to say the least, but the chicken was cooked perfectly. Others had the lobster roll.... Same reaction my husband had when he first had it. Bland as hell. I really, really, love the service and ambiance here and Sooooo want to love it but alas, I cannot. read more

What a fabulous addition to Rye New Hampshire. Great establishment, fantastic food, kind and attentive staff and best of all an extremely personable owner. I have been there several times and plan on going back. Definitely a fabulous place to try. Looking forward to the spring at Atlantic grill on their patio enjoying good food, good people and a fabulous environment. I had the pleasure of meeting one of the owners this evening. He took the time to talk to us about the historical value of the pictures he had on his entryway walls. His genuine and heartfelt approach to reaching out to his customers resonated with me this evening. I look forward to my next visit. I highly recomend my peers check out this resteraunt; it will not disappoint you. read more

I finally found time to go to this restaurant and was hoping the food would be better than their other restaurant but Nope! Breaded bland fish, white potatoes with no flavor, very pricey wine list and then they started spraying the surrounding tables before we were done our meal because they were closing up. Won't go back. It is worth the extra mile drive into Portsmouth for so many other good choices !! read more

Ya know, sometimes it's not all about the superior food or over-the-top service. It's simply about being in the right spot that is fun, serves great food and drink, and where all the help (and customers) are genuinely happy and friendly. Atlantic Grill is just that place. We stopped in on Sunday Labor Day Weekend at 6:00 and after a short wait were seated at the most comfortable high tops we've ever sat at. The place is huge and really nice. Less than a year old and they have some timing issues to work out and hey, the menu is pretty much variations of surf and turf but, it's an awesome vibe and you will come away satiated. Put on your loudest Vineyard Vines, be prepared to roll with a few hiccups and you'll have a great evening. Oh, did I mention the oysters and great local beers on tap?? Dinner for 2, one drink each, $56.00 out the door included tip. read more

Please know, I would give them a FIVE for safety practices here, but the food.... We ordered the seafood chowder for an appetizer, it was like mud, literally as think at mud. Dinner, I ordered the lobster roll, it was very good, fries were hot. I am going to say I am not sure what was up with the ketchup, very funky taste (maybe they make their own). We also ordered the baked haddock. It had to be frozen piece of haddock, it was grey, and no flavor at all. There should have been sum butter on the breadcrumbs or something to give it flavor. The veggies were okay (definitely left from last night), but the mashed potatoes were a downright shame. They were so watery that they were not even an 1/2 inch on the plate. We were both shocked that they served this meal to him. Our waitress was great, and the hostesses were great. But for $93.00 with a tip, NOPE! Oh, we did each have one beverage from the bar, a mixed drink and a beer. read more

Britney the manager was extremely rude to us. I didn't realize we needed reservations to sit at the bar considering covid restrictions have been over for about a month now. I walked in and said I'm going to the bar and she yelled at my party and I and lectured us about making reservations. read more

The staff was very friendly and attentive. My husband and I sat in the main dinning room, and it was very cold and felt like an upscale nursing home. The bar area seemed to be more cozy and eye appealing. Our meal wasn't anything grand. To be honest I would rather go downtown if I'm going to pay those prices. Considering we live right around corner I'm sure we will try it again, and I will update my review if the food improves. Update- We have gone there a few times since my last review merely due to the location. The staff is always friendly and attentive. The outdoor patio is beautiful as well as the bar area is warm and cozy. However the food still stinks :-( I really wish they would correct this and hire a better cook. There have been many times my husband and I have passed on going because we don't want to spend an arm and a leg for a mediocre meal. The chowder is always fantastic but that is it. read more

I went into Atlantic grill today with my parents for lunch. We sat at the bar where Ryan (I believe that was his name) was very attentive and inviting. The bloody Marys were delicious and the beer was cold. The seafood chowder was one of the best we've ever had and the lobster rolls were great too! I got the Asian noodles with smoked salmon which was also very good. Our only disappointment was that we hadn't tried AG years ago when they first opened because we believed some bad reviews that we heard. We'll definitely be back! read more

Atlantic Grill - Seafood Near Me - Rye, New Hampshire

Distancing, excellent food, quality drinks, open concept and good natural lighting creates a great 4-season go-to restaurant. Easy to reach from all directions, beach, Portsmouth, Jenness Beach, Philbrook Cabins, Wentworth by the Sea Marriott Hotel & Spa. read more

My boyfriend and I drove up from boston to have dinner and will make the drive again in a heart beat. This is a beautiful and spacious restaurant with very friendly staff and management. Their food is fairly standard for a high end seafood but the flavoring twists were phenomenal. I would definitely try the Atlantic salmon it came perfect done with some of the best bristle spouts I have ever had in the side. Another must is the banana foster! read more

Atlantic Grill - Seafood Near Me - Rye, New Hampshire

This is a great addition to the Rye community! It is nice that they have finally done something with that corner. I came here a few weeks ago for dinner and sat at a high top table in the lounge. The jelly fish tank was really cool and they have a nice fireplace..the bar is huge! I got the statler chicken which was tasty and a generous portion (they also have really good rolls!). I do wish that they had a drink menu though, but I think they are working on it. Korina was our waitress and she provided great service. We were happy to hear they are opening for lunch and that they will have a patio in summer. read more

My wife made reservations for Mother's Day, party of 5. Unpleasantly surprised to find out it was buffet only. We sat for about 10 minutes waiting for someone to take drink orders. Drinks were fine, buffet was ok but not what we signed up for. Service was poor, food ok but overpriced. Had several good experiences previously but will not be in any hurry to return. read more

Stopped in for lunch, the service at the bar was great, had the panini which was very good, and the atmosphere was very nice. read more

Atlantic Grill - First visit, great spot. - Seafood Near Me - Rye, New Hampshire

See all

Overpriced and baked haddock was okay not great. Lots of outside seating for drinks and atmosphere was nice but drinks are also overpriced.

Staff were very nice. Great ambiance and decor. Food was mediocre and more importantly every fish dish was cold. The chowder arrived cold, was sent back and delivered cold again. There is a definite good safety issue. Avoid. I hope we don't get sick. read more

Oof. Where to start. Their lobster dip was phenomenal. Drinks were great. Service was good, but it was clear that servers were over-worked. I was thirsty a few times and couldn't find someone to help. Asian chicken salad was really drenched in dressing, I'd definitely recommend having it on the side. Also it was very spicy. Biggest complaint is that food took about an hour, a little bit above an hour. read more

Great atmosphere but unfortunately I am never wowed by the food or service. I was surprised that the famous chowder was not hot and was too flourie. Chicken fingers were good. read more

We were out for a drive yesterday and decided to stop for a lobster roll. We didn't have a reservation so we decided to get takeout and eat them in our car. We ordered chowder to go as well- to eat that evening. The staff packed our chowder in a big plastic container with bags of ice to keep it cold until we got home- what service! Hope to come back again when we can dine in! read more

Good food, nice layout. we were seated too close to the a/c and asked to move, no problem. we had appetizers, mussels (delicious), crab cakes ( delicious ), crab leg steamed (good, overpriced). entrees were lobster, which we asked to have lazy man style and they accommodated with no issue or extra charge, mussels (again delicious), scallops withcorn pudding and heb gnocchi (delicious, though the gnocchi got lost abit in the mushrooms ). our server, Tiffany, was great, she was fun, but not overbearing. the manager came around and asked how dinner was; we commented on the pricing of the crab appetizer and she discounted the bill for that item. overall, very nice restaurant, service was good, new place so they are adjusting. pricey, but worth a try. we will go back again. read more

Stopped in on a whim and had an upscale snack in a comfy booth near the large bar and a window. Food was great and interesting! We like to try small plates and we were definitely not disappointed. Service was friendly and quick. Room was packed which is always a good sign. We may return to try the outdoor seating on a warm night. read more

We had a great experience at Atlantic Grill with my wife and two young kids (age 5 & 7). This restaurant gets five stars from me for being brave enough to serve Kraft Mac & Cheese. Our kids never like the gourmet mac & cheese that most restaurants serve so the fact Atlantic Grill gets that is huge in my eyes. Thanks you Atlantic Grill for that. The restaurant gets more child-friendly bonus points for supplying a table full of kids books for children to read. Never seen that before - that was great. My wife started with the chowder which was one of the best she's ever had. Kids and I split the edamame with fried shallots - also very tasty. Wife had the Lobster Roll which was average. I had the Salmon Burger which was delicious. The waitress was friendly and attentive. The restaurant was clean and comfortable. That's it - a great lunch. Cheers. read more

We moved to the area a little more than a year ago, we have had the opportunity to sample most of the establishments in the area. This is the best balance of price vs. quality in the area only rivaled by a couple of (more expensive) restaurant/bars in downtown Portsmouth. Given our close proximity to the Atlantic, it is increasingly our go-to place for a meal or a drink with apps. We have tried much of the menu (which changes regularly) the wife's favorite is the Asian Noodle Salad, for me, the Australian Lamb chops.Their seafood is second to none, favorites for apps: the crab cakes and PEI Mussels, entree: Scallops, Salmon or Tuna. I have not yet tried their beef, tomorrow is another day. It gets crowded during the high season, if it is a destination, call first or make reservations. The patio usually has seating, but it is, of course, weather dependent. read more

Atlantic Grill has a great atmosphere and great food. Great night out. Filet mignon is to die for and the wait staff is awesome. I would recommend this resturant as a must. read more

We eat here occasionally and always find the staff to be very good and the facility to be clean and inviting. However, I always find myself disappointed with the food. The menu seems limited (pre-COVID as well) and the preparation is OK, but nothing special. I would expect more fresh seafood choices given the location - not more salmon. Some improvement to the menu and food prep and this place would merit a much better rating. read more

Sat at the bar. King crab app was incredible. Joe the bartender was great! Excellent service. We will be back. :)

Spoke with Caitlyn who reassured me that she was dropping a gift card in the mail to me on the day that I spoke with her. That was almost 2 weeks ago. Just received it today and it is for 1/4 of the amount that we spent on that miserable experience. Not only won't we use this, but we won't be returning here. read more

In this COVID environment the Atlantic Grill is a gem. The heated outdoor dining hit the sweet spot I needed hit. The food is great, the service fun and Brittany, the manager was so accommodating. Can't say enough good things! read more

So disappointed in restaurant. Have been there before and loved food and service. Went last night and service was cranky and food was awful. My husbands salmon was way over cooked and dry my halibut was cold and mashed potatoes looked like lumpy tapioca. Scampi dish was all pasta with no scampi. Would definitely not recommend. read more

Very pleasantly surprised. The salmon burger is fantastic as well as the mussels. The draft beer is really cold which just makes a beer all that much better. Really liked the open large bar area, didn't feel crowded at all. Will certainly be back. read more