Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Great Island Eatery

    3.9 (8 reviews)
    Open • 11:00 am - 8:00 pm
    Updated 1 month ago

    Great Island Eatery Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    More like Great Island Eatery

    Recommended Reviews - Great Island Eatery

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Specials Board (changes)
    Ian W.

    Located at the Safe Harbor Marina Wentworth By The Sea, Great Island Eatery is a seasonal open air and outside low-key restaurant serving breakfast, lunch and dinner with fantastic views of the marina waterfront. They offer full service dine-in and takeout. This place is not to be confused with another Great Island Eatery in Maine. For breakfast, they serve breakfast sandwiches, acai bowls and coffee. For lunch/dinner, they serve up salads, sandwiches, fish tacos, crab cakes, lobster rolls, fried seafood plates, chicken tenders, hot dogs, shrimp cocktail, oysters, and cold drinks from the cooler. They also serve Memories Ice Cream, beer, wine, liquor, and mixed drinks. The prices are moderate high. The seating areas are open air (seat yourself) with covered table seating in the eatery, adjacent patio table seating, a canopy covered table seating section along the waterfront and adjacent picnic table seating. I stopped by Great Island Eatery (NH) for a quick dinner. I sat myself at a table in The Eatery since the waterfront seating was full. I was given a laminated menu and a plastic cup of cold water. I went with the Fish & Chips ($19 plus tax), which came out to me about 6 minutes later, served in a paper takeout box with plenty of crispy salted golden fries (small pieces), house slaw, a good sized piece of deep fried haddock and lemon wedge. The haddock was hot and had a very crispy oily light breading (panko), dipping into the provided tartar sauce. There was also a ketchup squeeze bottle at the table which I definitely needed for the salted fries. The shredded slaw had a vinegary taste and pretty decent. After I finished everything, the server arrived with a Square portable electronic payment block which you pay for your check by card electronically. The check total was $20.62 with tax and before tip. Overall, the fish & chips were pretty good and I had a great view of the waterfront, even from my seat in the Eatery. NOTE: The nearby gravel/paved parking lot configuration is very short-sighted and poorly thought out, by limiting parking for folks who only want to patronize the waterfront marina restaurant outside of a gated parking area for marina members with plenty of open spots. It was difficult trying to leave as folks waiting to park were blocking exiting vehicles.

    college roommates enjoying a meal and the marina

    I first heard of this location while looking for restaurants in the area on a bike ride recently. With such mixed reviews, I hesitated to give it try. So glad I did! Fantastic experience, all around. I met two college roommate friends for lunch on a summer Monday. It was a perfect place for a beautiful day on the water. Note: there is a members gate at the parking lot. Park in any designated restaurant parking spot and walk down a short distance to the restaurant. Restrooms are housed between the parking lot and restaurant. Seating is all outside, or indoors open to air (it looked like there were plastic sides that could be rolled down for inclement weather). The server told us to sit anywhere we wanted. If you want to order alcohol there are designated areas (state regulation or some such rules). Every seat has a great view of all the fancy boats docked in the marina. An easy way to feel like you're rich, even if you're not. :) Flower plantings were beautiful. The strawberry lemonade was outstanding: sweet, tart, and refreshing. My friends enjoyed overflowing mai tais. The fish tacos were excellent - hot and crispy fried fish, with delicious slaw, pickled onions, and sriracha aioli. A wonderful spot for old friends to catch up and spend a few hours on our beautiful seacoast! I will definitely return, and hopefully have more time to walk down the docks to check out all the amazing boats.

    See all

    20 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 months ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    26 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 5
    Thanks 2
    Love this 5
    Oh no 1

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Erik D.
    0
    15
    21

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    I ordered a breakfast sandwich and there was one piece of bacon, for an 8 dollar sandwich. Outrageous.

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Great Island Eatery

    You might also consider

    Vida Cantina - Chips and salsa flight. It was delicious! The Salsa Verde had a nice touch of heat and the Mango Habanero Salsa was great too.

    Vida Cantina

    3.8(447 reviews)
    3.4 mi
    •$$

    Vida cantina hit the spot for me, as someone who just moved here from southern CA and has been…read moremissing the Mexican food we get down there! You walk in and the vibe is fun, colorful, and eclectic. It reminded me of a classic Mexican restaurant with a tasteful, funky modern touch. My watermelon margarita was incredible and we got the salsa trio that had a good mix of spicy mango salsa, a mild but flavorful green salsa, and fresh pico de gallo style. The chips did taste homemade but if not still enjoyed the thicker corn style chip you don't usually find in restaurants! We each got 3 street tacos and all were great, even the sweet potato taco! The chicken was chopped a bit thick for street taco style but it was still great flavor, and rice was a bit salty but not unbearable. The service was also incredible, I love a restaurant that boxes up your leftovers for you and our server was super super attentive and friendly. We will be back!!

    Ambiance is great! Lively interior with a wraparound bar and lots of booth seating…read more In terms of service, the host was not very attentive. We (parents and a toddler) arrived hungry after driving two hours and had a hard time getting his attention at times. We arrived before 6pm on a Friday but still there was a wait. Once we were seated, the server was pretty prompt and really friendly, though generally service was somewhat slow with a wait for food. We were waiting almost an hour for entrees and about to change our order to to-go because of stress with our exhausted toddler, but of course that's when the food arrived. We had to shovel it in and leave. The food was the most disappointing part. The chips are clearly not homemade. The salsa didn't have much flavor, and the guacamole was a huge letdown. It had a dull green color and very "slop" style texture (think sour cream texture, not chunky like real guac) that all pointed to store bought / not fresh. I had the chicken enchiladas, and the sides of rice (so salty) and beans (very soupy) brought down an already undesirable dish. The enchiladas were cooked nicely but far too cheesy. The green sauce was nearly tasteless, the red sauce is what made it all edible. Wouldn't ever really come back here. I wish I could say something more positive!

    Photos
    Vida Cantina - They were featured in Yankee Travel Magazine.

    They were featured in Yankee Travel Magazine.

    Vida Cantina - Lamb birria special

    Lamb birria special

    Vida Cantina - Fried avocado and fish tacos

    See all

    Fried avocado and fish tacos

    La Carreta Restaurante Mexicano - Espresso martini soft serve

    La Carreta Restaurante Mexicano

    3.8(186 reviews)
    2.2 mi
    •$$

    Stopped in between lunch and dinner to meet up with a friend. They have a large outdoor seating…read morearea, a huge bar that takes up much of the inside and booth seating along the outside walls. We chose to sit at the bar. A basket of tortilla chips and salsa was brought and we ordered beverages. We sat and chatted for a couple of hours. The restaurant was mostly empty during our visit with a few lunch diners still in house who left during our stay. Once we had drinks, the bartender was not in sight. They did come by once to ask if we would like to order another beverage. Our pre-paid parking time was running out and we needed to run. Could not find our bartender. We sorted that out and were able to get back to our cars as the parking maid was making the rounds. Portsmouth does not mess around with paid parking! The interior is festive Mexican. Single bathrooms for Female, Male and family, so 3 total restrooms. Parking is paid city lots. Entrance is up a set of steps. Outdoor dining in a pedestrian area.

    My friend's & I wanted to come here to try out their soft serve Margarita & wanted to sit outside…read more We went up to the hostess station & once we were finally greeted (a little bit of a wait) & told the young girl she said "we can't sit you outside, do you want to go inside?" & I immediately said "no." There were a couple of empty tables so not sure why we couldn't sit outside?? But she then says "oh, I found you a table!" lol Service took forever....soooooooo SLOW it was painful. It was busy & I saw @ least 3 servers and peeps running out food. Our waitress was very nice, Sophie but the wait for EVERYTHING was torture. Menus, silverware & chips and salsa did come out quickly but we weren't there to eat. Their salsa was horrible, it was sooo thin & tasted like a cheap spaghetti sauce or like a can of tomatoes puréed. Thumbs down for that. Our soft serve margaritas were super cute & colorful but also really, really small & for $13 not worth the $$$$. Those took forever to come out. She brought 2 out @ first & we had to wait for the machine to make more to get the other 2. It didn't taste like a margarita but tasted like an italian ice, a very sour one. This isn't on the menu, you have to ask for it. We ventured off to another Mexican bar to try their's out which was huge, creamy & tasted like a Margarita. We spent way more time in this place than we wanted to due to the very slow service. I doubt I will be back here to even try out their food, sorry guys......maybe inside the service may have been quicker?

    Photos
    La Carreta Restaurante Mexicano
    La Carreta Restaurante Mexicano - Complimentary chips and salsa

    Complimentary chips and salsa

    La Carreta Restaurante Mexicano - Fun patio

    See all

    Fun patio

    Street - WHAT ABOUT COBB

    Street

    4.0(696 reviews)
    2.5 mi
    •$$

    Passing through Portsmouth on the way up the coast and I was looking for something that the various…read morecarnivores, veggie leaning, etc. in my family would like. We also tend to skew all over the place regarding the ethnicity of foods we like. I go for Asian foods and that's not my husband and son's preference. I happen to love street food from all countries as I know that is usually the best! What fun to have a place to try various types. This place was perfect for multiple reasons. Everything we had was tasty and satisfying. The decor was fun and the service was friendly. They both got lamb shawarma, my kid had it with fries. They were both very satisfied. I had a an Asian salad with a protein of Korean bbq beef... There were a number or different proteins offered. One of the ways I can tell if I like a restaurant if they have good salad dressing (imho most don't) and the salad dressing was delicious. A nice lemon vinaigrette. Will definitely stop by again on another one of our trips to see Grandma.

    Overall, we really enjoyed the food here. The menu has a lot of exciting options that immediately…read moremake you want to order several things and try all the different Asian flavors. This was our first visit, and we tried the chicken sandwich, potstickers, and cauliflower. Everything had really good flavor and a nice level of spice, and the portions felt fair for the price. The chicken sandwich was tasty, although I thought the chicken itself could have been a little thicker and juicier. I also liked that they cut the sandwich in half, but the tape around it felt a little excessive and made it harder than it needed to be to actually eat. That said, the flavors were very good, the pricing felt reasonable, and I enjoyed both the food and the beer. From a value standpoint, I thought they did a lot right. The main thing that kept the experience from being better was the service on the patio. The staff was not unfriendly at all, but it was difficult at times to get someone's attention, and simple requests seemed to take longer than they should have. That's something I'm noticing more and more in restaurants lately. If guests are being asked to tip at full-service levels, there still needs to be consistent follow-through and attentiveness throughout the meal, especially on a patio where it can already be harder to get someone's attention. Overall, though, I would recommend the place. The food was flavorful, interesting, and reasonably priced, and I'd definitely be willing to come back and try more of the menu.

    Photos
    Street - Bar area

    Bar area

    Street - Curry Fries: Five stars!!

    Curry Fries: Five stars!!

    Street - Yeah, it's in the back part of a strip mall. But worth it

    See all

    Yeah, it's in the back part of a strip mall. But worth it

    Lexie's Joint - Complimentary after meal cookies!

    Lexie's Joint

    4.6(911 reviews)
    2.3 mi
    •$$

    We stopped here when we were visiting the area for the weekend after 4th of July rush was gone. We…read moredecided to eat in this a cute place with awesome food and staff! We love trying chef's own creative creations and this is exactly what we found her at Lexie's. We both ordered the Cucumber Mint Lemonade to start which were perfectly delicious for the hot weather that I'm not used too! We both ordered the Green Lantern Beanie - Vegetarian that was recommended to us when we couldn't choose. They were delicious and I will definitely get it again. My DH also got the French Fries which were Hot & Fresh but not for my mandatory low sodium, however the Green Lantern met! We usually don't get the same item so we can each try out something new - yes, just like Michael J Fox in Family Ties! We laughed when we saw that episode! Our server AM S and all the others were great! The restaurant and rest room were very clean! It was amazing the countless to go orders constantly being picked up while we were there! Thank you for a wonderful meal!

    On our way up to Maine from Rhode Island, my husband and I stopped in Lexie's Joint in Portsmouth,…read moreNH for some lunch... burgers as it turned out. I found them on Yelp, and highly rated, so that was enough for me !! Not a huge menu, but we easily found what we wanted. The burgers were on the slightly smallish side (compared to others I've had), but they were delicious, and with the accompanying fries for me and onion rings for him, we certainly didn't walk away hungry. The "classic" burgers that we ordered were well represented with the ingredients we like (beef, cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle with some "hush" sauce - essentially thousand island dressing). We loved every bite !! We'd return here in a heartbeat, so if ever we're up in that area, we'll be getting those burgers again. Yummm.

    Photos
    Lexie's Joint - Inside

    Inside

    Lexie's Joint - Half eaten burger

    Half eaten burger

    Lexie's Joint - Farmhouse burger

    See all

    Farmhouse burger

    Parkd - Fish taco and Chicken taco $12

    Parkd

    4.6(20 reviews)
    1.4 mi

    That might have been the best fish taco I've ever had. I ordered a cubano sandwich and one fish…read moretaco. I wish I would have ordered ordered three fish tacos. That's not to say the cubano was bad by any means, it was also delicious, but the fish taco was delightful. Not sure if it was a supply/demand issue, but I can't stop thinking about it. I sat at the bar. The service was okay. I ran out of beer in my glass before the bartender/server asked if I wanted another. Not a biggie, but would have been extra points for attentiveness. Music was relaxed and the place churns people out pretty quick it seems. Good on them, well deserved. This place was a nice break from some of the restaurants I've been to lately that were found lacking.

    ParkD is an "eclectic eatery" that opened in Rye, New Hampshire in June 2022. It was founded by…read moreculinary couple Ben Solomon and Sarah Blanchette. From a young age, Ben took an interest in cooking and often helped his mother around the kitchen. He graduated from the culinary program at Lakes Region Community College in 2010. He relocated to Portsmouth, known for its bustling restaurant scene, and began working under chef Julie Cutting Kelly at Brazo Restaurant. Once Kelly left to open Cure Restaurant, Ben took over as head chef. He would continue to work at various Portsmouth restaurants over the years. In 2018, Ben and Sarah purchased and opened their own food truck on Islington Street which they dubbed "Wrap Shack". After finding success with the truck, the couple decided to open their own brick & mortar eatery in nearby Rye. The menu at ParkD features a variety of chef plates, sandwiches, tacos, salads, soups and various appetizers. The drink menu also features an eclectic selection of craft beer, cider, wine, cocktails and mocktails. My family and I stopped for lunch at ParkD this past summer while we were on our way to Maine for a summer getaway. We were looking for a good lunch spot in Rye, and ParkD came highly recommended on Yelp. We really liked the vibe at the cozy eatery. The staff were super friendly and accommodating. After looking over the menu, I had the "Pork Belly Grilled Cheese" (fontina, gouda, gruyere cheese blend, fried pork belly, arugula, tuscan white, wine/ chips), my wife had the "Fried Cheese" (Mexican fried cheese, arugula, tomato, pickled onion & cilantro, chipotle aioli, ciabatta, w/ sweet potato fries), our older son had the "Tay's Tenders" (w/ fries), and our younger son had the "Kids Mac & Cheese" (w/ chips). I loved how my sandwich was an excellent balance between the crispiness from the bread and pork belly and the gooeyness from the delicious cheese blend. My wife and I both thought that our sandwiches packed a lot of flavor from the ingredients. I washed my sandwich down with a draft pour of the locally-produced Great Rhythm Brewing's "Squeeze" (IPA). We barely heard a peep from our sons, so they must have really liked their food. We're happy that we discovered ParkD and we highly recommend them to anyone visiting the area!

    Photos
    Parkd - Interior

    Interior

    Parkd - Shaved salad.  Ice tea.

    Shaved salad. Ice tea.

    Parkd - Newspaper article

    See all

    Newspaper article

    Great Island Eatery - seafood - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...