Incredibly disappointed with the experience we had at Atria. No mention of our 20th Anniversary despite noting this several times during booking the reservation. Room was hot, stuffy, and very loud making conversation difficult. Service was subpar for price point with a distracted waitress who added nothing to the experience. $90 wok fired lobster was overcooked, sloppily presented over watery potatoes and not pre cracked to make eating easier. Nobody wants to wrestle with an overcooked lobster in a fine dining experience... Overpriced, pretentious and not worth the time or money. Cannot recommend, there are far better dining options at this price point like Bettini's. read more

Fantastic experience, just can't rave enough about the food, waitstaff & atmosphere. Will certainly plan on going again.

Food, service, and ambiance were superb. Indoor and outdoor dining both pleasant. Halibut was perfectly cooked.

Great burger, fries, service, and atmosphere. 10/10 at the cellar. Wine paired with burger was amazing. Would highly recommend

Service was good. Food was okay; desserts were subpar. Nicely decorated, but a very funky smell permeated the dining area (like a diaper genie); extremely off-putting. Bathrooms ran out of paper towels early on. read more

Best burger I have ever had. Phenomenal service, waiter was very nice. Great cocktails too. The outside looks really nice, the speakeasy burger basement cool too. Worth every penny read more

We had such a great dinner here! The food is fresh and so so good. We all loved what we had. The fried lobster was great! We sat at the fire table and it was great! Our waiter was such a nice guy who was on top of everything. Highly recommend. read more

Atria - New American Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

Brick Cellar Bar: Atria's casual downstairs burger and cocktail lounge. This review is for you. I love the atmosphere, the tongue-in-cheek humor on the menu (which bleeds into most signage around the walls), and the outrageously compelling rundown of burgers and burgeresque sandwiches you can only get on this level. Devastated that my red meat hiatus had me perusing on the chicken, turkey and veg options, but the Southern Mother Clucker - a buttermilk fried chicken breast on brioche with cole slaw, pickled onions and cukes, and a dope pimento cheese spread. All plates sided with fries; add $3 to truffle them up. The breast was tender, and the salty coating gave great crunch even though it couldn't hold on to the meat. It also wasn't drained enough from the fryer, and the bottom of the brioche disintegrated in to a useless mush soon after it was served. Aaaaaand it was missing the spicy From Hell baste, which when we finally flagged down our largely MIA server, was brought in a ramekin and simply didn't jibe when drizzled over the meat. It's unfortunate that our most anticipated meal of our overnighter in the Vineyard was a sloppy, incomplete $20 fried chicken sandwich, and nobody checking in to ask about fixing the errors. I'd likely return for a burger, but this visit left a bitter taste in my mouth. read more

Atria - New American Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

Still have lots of love for Atria but have NO LOVE for The Cellar. I am not taking any stars off my review because upstairs Atria is still terrific with fabulous service. This go around we had: - 3lb Lobster stuffed with another 2lbs of lobster and scallops - delectable! - Spring Rolls - very good - Truffle Fries - delicious - Broccolini - delicious - Berry Cobbler with Vanilla Ice Cream - delicious The service was terrific and the restaurant is beautiful. The Cellar: If I could give write a separate review for The Cellar, I would give it 2 stars. The Cellar is downstairs from Atria and it is staffed by children. Atria is a restaurant for adults, run by adults. Our concierge made an error and told us our reservation was for 6 pm when he made it for 6:45 pm. The upstairs staff told us to speak with the hostess downstairs to see if they could accommodate us. The Cellar Hostess acted like there was a line going out the door for this restaurant when in fact it was a Thursday and the dining room was 2/3 empty. She had us wait at the bar for 10 minutes before seating us at a table that was just as empty when we arrived. We initially gave her a pass, thinking that the tables would gradually fill up. 90 minutes later - NOPE, still 2/3 empty. Our waiter acted like this was his first night on the job (perhaps it was.....) We had: - Caesar Salad: very good but after it was served he told us there was a $2 fee for sharing (which were totally fine with) then said it all works out the same. Uh, no it doesn't, the bill is $2 more. Also proper etiquette would be for him to tell us that there was a sharing charge when we placed the order. - Frenchy Burger - so so. They overcooked the prosciutto so it was as hard as a rock. It should have been added after the burger was cooked. - The Fast Eddie - very good but I asked the waiter if the fried egg could be runny. He said that they don't take the temperature of the eggs when they prepare it. Huh?!?! I didn't make a temperature request, I just asked for the egg to be a bit undercooked. Clearly I was speaking Latin to him because he was clueless. - Coffee - I would normally not mention a cup of coffee, but it was served to me black, with no milk or spoon. I had to wait almost 10 minutes before I could flag down the waiter and get milk - and a spoon - which actually was for my dessert! It wasn't a spoon for coffee. - Berry Cobbler with Vanilla Ice Cream - delicious It took at least 15 minutes for us to flag down the waiter to get our check. Luckily we weren't in a rush. Oh and by the way, a party of 6 came in for a table while we were waiting for the check and the hostess turned them away. The restaurant was 2/3 empty with at least 2 empty tables to accommodate 6 people. Clearly The Cellar has no intention of making any money because they let children who don't want to work run the show. read more

See all

The RESY review we left after eating at Atria last night: My boyfriend and I had been really looking forward to eating at Atria, since we'd heard good things from friends of ours who are MV-based chefs. We treat ourselves to one nice date night each summer, and being restaurant workers ourselves, we relish the opportunity to dine in such a nice restaurant - we were expecting a top notch experience all around. We were seated for our reservation promptly, but right next to the entryway which was unfortunate. The property was gorgeous and the restaurant had a lovely ambiance. We started off strong with two appetizers, the tomato carpaccio and the crab cakes. Both phenomenal. We were eyeing several entrees, but went with the halibut with summer succotash. It was bad. The fish was dry, overcooked, and tasted pretty bland. The veggies had varrying levels of done-ness, some being raw and some being completely overcooked. If they were fresh or from the island, we couldn't tell. Similar to the fish, they were underseasoned and I truly felt like this was a dish I could have made better at home for less than $56. Super disappointing. Our side of truffle fries came out half hot half cold, which made us wonder if all of our food had been sitting under a heat lamp before we got it, which would explain why the fish was dry. When our server brought us new hot fries, they were excellent. We tried the cheesecake for dessert, it was okay. Another issue was the table next to us, who received special treatment all night. We couldn't tell if they were friends of the staff or just being picky, but (unlike us) they were constantly being attended to. This type of thing doesn't go unnoticed by other patrons. If they were former workers, we absolutely believe they are entitled to some special treatment. But it seemed to us that the staff went completely overboard, which compounded the feeling that we were getting a lesser experience. We left pretty disappointed, since Atria is so highly esteemed on the island, and of course... incredibly expensive. Maybe we caught you on a bad night, nevertheless we won't be recommending this place to our friends. We'll send them to Alchemy instead where we ate better food with better service last summer. Huuuuuuge bummer. read more

Awesome service, food and wine despite being short staffed during covid. Had the swordfish, orecchiette with short rib, and NY strip. All were unbelievable. The only hiccup was an incredibly rude couple next to us who berated the wait staff and manager for what they perceived as less than ideal food (they were extremely loud and obnoxious and spoke extensively about ruining the managers career as they were "also in the restaurant business" according to them). Extremely rude and disgusting behavior, but I guess that's to be expected of out of town tourists during LDW. Regardless, our waitress was lovely, attentive and had great wine recs. Amazing experience at Atria despite the less than desirable table gues read more

Atria - NY strip - New American Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

There's a reason this restaurant wasn't on the list I compiled from many friends for our first visit to the Vineyard. The upstairs wasn't open for another week, so we sat down in the cellar. Cozy seats at the bar. So far so good. Very nice & sweet bartender (Asia from Brooklyn). We ordered 2 burgers. My husband's came out correct, I got an entirely wrong entree. Asia went over in details what I wanted when I ordered mine, so I'm going to assume it was the kitchen's fault. I simply subbed the Portobello mushroom for the Impossible burger. I got the Frenchy burger with Brie. Ok, no biggie. Asia quickly whisked it away so I could get my right order. Well.....30 mins later I still sat there with zero food. It wasn't busy (again, I'm assuming kitchen issues). My husband was running the marathon in the morning, so I told him to eat Vs waiting for me and I didn't want him eating cold food. When the correct burger came out 35 mins later, I ate by myself. We were annoyed at this point. I heard & saw Asia speak with the hostess to see if something could be done for us, and the hostess said "what do you want ME to do about it? You made the mistake!". I don't think she was the one who screwed, but who speaks to an employee like that, and in public in front of guests?!? VERY POOR MANAGEMENT SKILLS! I did get a free glass of wine after I pointed out all of the sediment in the glass, but waiting 35+ mins for a corrected burger at 9pm when the restaurant was almost empty, and not at least getting an apology from the manager/hostess (and seeing her blow up on a sweet employee) shows poor management skills. Oh, and did I mention the almost $40 for this burger??? Absurd! This restaurant will not only not be on my list of recommeneded places to tell friends, we'll make sure they DON'T go! State Road & Harbor Views were fabulous dinners the night before and the evening after. I highly recommend those! read more

We've been going to Atria since they opened and can't rave about Christian & Greer & their staff enough!! Professional, timely delivery of good, amazingly fresh food. Greer manages the front of the house with such grace and ease - a true class act! Christian rocks in the kitchen with consistent 5 star meals. Also love the extra effort they went to for my birthday by printing my own, personalized menu!! Keep up the good work guys! read more

Atria - My own personalized menu!! Thnx guys xx - New American Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

See all

This place was absolutely fantastic from start to finish! I came here with my best friend and two other girls for her bachelorette party, it was by far one of the prettiest outdoor spaces I've ever eaten in. The back is set up with a tent, among a garden with lights hanging through the trees. The service was wonderful, they really allowed us to take our time and enjoy our special meal. On to the food, it was outrageously good, I got the filet and my friends got the seafood and short rib. Everything was delicious, the meat was cooked perfectly, we also started with the truffle Parmesan fries which were delectable. The only thing we weren't insane about was the creme brulee, it had too strong of a floral taste (even though it was a rose brulee). I highly recommend going to this place, and eating outside, it truly was a night to remember! read more

Atria - The beautiful outdoor patio, picture doesn't do it justice - New American Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

Great outdoor eating experience. They have good mocktails and cocktails. We started with the ribs and calamari, very delicious. Good sauce. We split the burger for our main and that was also so good. Highly recommend, we would eat here again. read more

See all

Would like to diito Antonio V's review about the current rating being far too low - came here with a party of 7 and ate under the tent outside. Yelena was our server and she was really sweet and knowlegable. The food was fresh, flavorful and delicious - my husband and I shared lobster salad, crab cakes and scallops. Yes the prices are high so I wouldn't come here every day, but for a fun group outing this was great. read more

Ended another week vacation with a great meal from Atria! The menu was amazing! I had the lobster salad with friend heirloom tomato and crab cakes for an appetizer. Although small, those crab cakes packed quite the flavor punch! For dinner I had the braised pork shoulder with cheesy grits which was so delicious and I just kept finding new layers of flavor. I'll be back next year, third Saturday of August! read more

spent an hour looking for a dinner spot last night and was happy to find a restaurant with such a diverse menu. tomatoes? they got 'em. bobo's special? refer to paragraph 3. my glass was never empty and my heart was always full. if you're thinking about where to grab a slice of swordfish with dill whipped potatoes this is THE place. great job guys read more

See all

Atria is absolutely amazing. Manager Sam was very welcoming & Natalia the server was one of the best servers we ever have had anywhere. The speciality drinks were amazing & incredibly creative. Food was excellent. The downstairs ambiance was fantastic. A must to check-out when visiting Martha's Vineyard. read more

After a great weekend in MV and having great meals, our last night at Atria was a massive let-down. Our orders of the pork chop and the halibut came out far too quickly and after one bite we could tell why. The food was not only dried out, but it was barely warm. Clearly it had been prepped previously and had been sitting. It was difficult to cut into either entree. The sides had a patina on them also which was further evidence of them sitting. The manager, though very pleasant, made the excuse that their pork chops and halibut get prepared like that and that a replacement would be the same. That, of course, is nonsense. This is the case of a chef who cannot cook the entrees properly or a restaurant looking to churn out expensive meals at a too rapid rate. I politely refused the managers request for replacement entrees as the night was already spoiled and because the replacements would supposedly be no different. I paid for the wine that we ordered and we left. Having eaten in a number of great establishments in Edgartown, I'd recommend that you avoid Atria. There are far better options for a nice dinner. read more

Atria is a gorgeous restaurant with gorgeous food!!! While waiting for our meal my friend and I walked around the porch and courtyard while imagining our weddings taking place there Everything was delicious and the staff was super friendly! The manager even came over to have a nice conversation with us while we waited. The only reason I'm giving 4/5 is because I ordered a pasta plate (an expensive one too) and I feel as though I had a couple bites of pasta with a ton of tomatoes. Good thing I love tomatoes!!! Also the dessert here is read more

Atria - Homemade pappardelle pasta with summer heirloom tomatoes & fresh burrata cheese - New American Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

See all

Have been back many times since my first review of Atria, but for whatever reason haven't reviewed again. Tonight deserved a new review since everything from start to finish on as spot on. Knowing the challenges hospitality is facing post Covid, Atria is operating at a top notch level. Service, food & ambiance was great. Drinks were cold. Food was beautifully presented & enjoyed by everyone. read more

Always 5 star! Beautiful establishment, food and service is always impeccable. Greer and Christian are always gracious and extremely accommodating. we keep a weekly standing reservation. A must when your dining on the Vineyard read more

We have eaten the several times over the summer and the food, service and the upbeat atmosphere always makes for a great evening!

ambiance was nice , except choice of loud music wasnt exactly what we had in mind for dinner. service was a little slow , it wasn't very busy. We had to ask our hostess to find our drinks , food was good , but I chose something that was salty to begin with but the chef added more salt and I couldnt eat it. when I told our waitress , she didn't acknowledge and took my plate away with 90% of my meal still on it. No compensation . I asked for a box so maybe my kids would eat it. She never came back with it. Portions were good , but sides mentioned in menu are puréed . prices were moderate. Appetizers pricey. read more

If I could give this place 0 stars, I would. We came multiple times and would sit there waiting for our food for 2 hours at least. We ordered to-go food for dinner one night and they made us wait an hour after they said it would be ready and got our order COMPLETELY wrong. HIGHLY DISAPPOINTED and NEVER returning. read more

Fantstic food, awesome atmosphere, nice people. Deserves a 4.5 tbh as it is pricy but, currently rated far too low

I made a reservation for two for a Saturday night at 7:30 in June on resy.com as suggested by Atria's website. I specified the "porch" (i.e., outside, not inside) for my dining request due to the age and co-mobidiites of my 83-year-old husband and my own age, which is 71. I made the request and my reason for it explicit in my comments. I arrived at the restaurant at 7:20 that Saturday only to be told there is no outdoor dining available until the following week. No one from the restaurant called to tell me this before the day of my reservation or even on the day of the reservation, which according to the hostess is when my comment was read. Any restaurant that doesn't take into consideration the explicit requests of guests concerning matters of their health and fails to inform them in advance when their requests cannot be met is not worth the price of admission, which in Atria's case is quite a steep one. We ate at Atria last year and it was just okay. Now we will never eat there again. And as for the response of the hostess, although she conceded that we should have been told there was no outdoor dining before we arrived there, she used our method of reserving the restaurant, as recommended on the restaurant's own website, as an excuse for not having notified us. She was not at all apologetic and made no good-will gestures to make up for our being left stranded without a reservation for dinner on a busy in-season Saturday night. In sum, this is a classless operation and not worth a visit. read more

I would avoid this place. I went tonight for a dinner by myself in the bar. Upon arrival, the hostess told me there were no seats. When I asked the bartender about whether high-top tables were reserved, she pointed to reserved signs at her bar seats and didn't suggest I ask about the open high-top seats. When I finally had a different host seat me, no one asked me if I wanted a drink or took my order for over twenty minutes. I ended up walking out. In addition to very poor service that isn't focused on the diner's experience, all of the sandwiches on the bar menu are $32, which isn't standard even on the Vineyard. Terrible experience and I won't be back. read more

I will start by saying we had a wonderful birthday dinner here about 5 years ago. We came for another birthday dinner and although some things were good, many went south. It started by the restaurant completely messing up the reservation. (Please see later in the review for explanation). It was a very poor experience for the prices. Good things: Leafy greens and Gorgonzola salad Ambiance- yes and No (see further) Not so great things: Poor wait staff- many of the wait staff including our server belonged in a lower-priced restaurant. Inattentive sums it ups. We had to ask for many refills and for additional things. Wrong order- Someone got something completely different from what they ordered and were charged for the more expensive than what they ordered. The $74 lobster- Not worth it. I had this as my birthday meal 5 years ago and it was delicious. 3 out of the 6 of us got it this round and were all equally disappointed. All of ours were overdone. The cod- The prosciutto was very over cooked and chewy. The flavor of the meat overwhelmed the fish to the point you couldn't taste it at all. The wrong check- We received someone else's (less expensive) check. We chose to do the right thing and let our waiter know, then were charged for the wrong entree. The reservation- I couldn't tell you exactly what went wrong other than it was their fault. I called to confirm with my credit card info. They had that info but when we showed up for our reservation it was "we called you many times to confirm" and turns out the phone number was completely different than mine. Turns out they were able to "accommodate" us even though that problem was very much their fault. I went back towards the end of our stay to assure my credit card information that I know I gave over the phone to confirm my credit card info was not compromised. I stood by the front desk for 5-10 minutes only to be assumed as part of the staff and asked where the restroom was. Eventually, they figured out they had the right credit card under my name but the complete wrong phone number. So when they called to confirm of course no one answered. Ambiance- the setting was great but we had a couple next to us that we saw aggressively making out multiple times. Overall, just a poor experience all around. It left us feeling like we made a really poor decision to celebrate a special occasion here. I hope they get back to what they were. I was hoping the 3 1/2 star rating wasn't true. I do not think we will return unless we hear that changes have been made. read more

Excellent burger and fries. The drinks were also delicious, my friends and I thoroughly enjoyed ourselves. Only thing we all agreed could have been better were the pickles. read more

Atria - BBQ Brisket Burger - New American Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

The food here is AMAZING, and the service is equally terrific. At our most recent visit Rick took care of us. After selecting our dinners -- Turf and Turf for my daughter and her husband, Lobster Mac and Cheese for my wife, and Swordfish for me -- Sam the Sommelier helped us pick out a great wine from their extensive list. Everything was excellent and we left with no complaints, except it will likely be until next year before we get to enjoy this place again. This is about the best the Vineyard has to offer. Don't miss it, but be prepared for a pricey dinner. As the bottom of their menu says, "Please inform your server if you need a few extra moments to recover from the prices". But trust me, it's well worth it. read more

Food is always prepared to perfection and service, even during these difficult times with staff shortages, never disappoints. Wonderful outdoor dining. read more

We were downstairs in the burger bar and everything was fantastic. We got a bottle of Pinot Noir, an order of calamari, summer corn soup with lobster fritters and summer corn salad for starters - all were exceptional! We finished off with the Frenchy Burger and truffle fries O-M-G!!! Highly recommend Atria - the eats are amazing! read more

See all

We dined Memorial Day weekend 2023 . Burgers are great but the halibut was dry and average. Also, the chicken in the chicken dinner was overcooked. The ribs were not tasty, Our party left unimpressed. For the prices charged, we were expecting very good entrees. read more

Atria is a gem. Probably one of my top 10 restaurants. Everything we had [save for the dessert which didn't impress us much] was absolutely amazing. I'm not a big fan of lobster and my husband had the wok fried lobster... it was so delicious, I wanted to trade my plate for his. It was just SOO sooo good. I don't remember what dish I had but I know the lobster was just so amazing that I wanted to go back the next day and have that myself. Unfortunately we didn't get to go again but I would have definitely gone a second time. Our waiter was more than attentive, he was very friendly, funny, and we absolutely loved him. The atmosphere is very cozy and warm but sophisticated. The food is just fantastic here. Hopefully when I return to MV, this place is still around. read more

Atria - On the swing in Atria's backyard. - New American Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

Excellent from start to finish. Order the Cesar, chicken, short rib and molten cake and you will not be disappointed.

Last week we made our third trip (in 20 years) to Atria. We were rather excited to come seeing we were so pleased with the previous two times we dined there. The appetizers we ordered (soup and greens with gorgonzola and blueberries) were very, very good. The entrees were well-conceived but most of the food was barely warm, with the exception of my fish. This was sort of off-putting. I tend to not believe that this was intentional; it seems that part of the dinner was sitting around waiting for the fish (which was overdone) and cooling off. My wife's dinner was totally lukewarm. The food was good, and we did not say anything because I did not want them to feel they needed to re-do, or worse , nuke it. The wine selection and desert were fantastic. So overall there was that one (very) disappointing aspect, but for the price they are so proud of getting, the food should be perfect. I will more than likely consider spending my money at other places in Edgartown in the future. NB. They also need to learn to answer their phone; I tried to call to confirm my reservation time three times, only to get the recording - during business hours. read more

It was our first trip to MV, and a final evening out in Edgartown. We decided to cap our wonderful week off with a dinner at a local restaurant, Atria. From the moment we were seated at our table, we were disappointed with the overall experience. The menu adequately met our expectations of capturing the island's bounty, but the service left much to be desired. What can we say, the moment you are served a glass of $16 flat sparkling wine (and a botched Manhattan), you understand why the place is barely filled during peak season. (We sent the wine back, but tolerated the Manhattan.) To top our evening off, after ordering $500 worth of food and drinks between two people, a waitress from the next section walked over to our table and harassed us. OMG! We did not expect such poor treatment, never mind the amount of money we spent at the place. What a dump! read more

Atria is a great restaurant that offers two different settings and menus. On The main floor the restaurant is formal. On the Tavern you have a selection of the most amazing and exquisite burgers on the Island. The good thing about sitting at the Tavern is that you can choose from both menus but the same does not happen if you sit on the main floor. Service is great and so is the atmosphere food is very good. I highly recommend the swordfish with mashed potatoes and the steak. read more

See all