The food is delicious. I keep coming back for the eggplant parmigiana and the arancini, which are consistently excellent. But for the love of God, please turn up the lights a little bit. It's so dark it feels like the power went out and someone found a single tea candle in a drawer. Half the time I had no idea what I was eating. When you order a Caesar salad, you want to spear a little cheese and a crouton with your fork, but you can't even see them. Half the time I wasn't even sure the person across from me was my husband!:) Turn the lights up just a notch and this place would be perfect, because the food is absolutely worth it. read more

Tavern 227 in Sea Cliff delivered a really solid night out--great food, attentive service, and a warm, polished tavern vibe that feels both comfortable and a little elevated. We started with the Kobe meatballs and they were the perfect opener--rich, flavorful, and absolutely worth ordering. The Caesar salad was fine (not bad, just not as memorable as the rest of the meal), but everything after that turned the corner in a big way. The pasta was outstanding--cooked perfectly and packed with flavor--and the pork chop was the star: huge, beautifully cooked, and the kind of entrée you're still talking about after you leave. Service was friendly and on top of things without hovering, and the decor gives you that cozy, classic tavern feel that works for a date night or a relaxed dinner with friends. I'll definitely be back. read more

Tavern 227 - Sides - Bars Near Me - Sea Cliff, New York

My wife and I have eaten here three or four times and have enjoyed it every time. Delicious food, good service, a nice bar and a cozy, warm almost Brooklyn vibe will encourage us to return again and again. In fact we have been recommending this hidden gem to friends and family since our first encounter. read more

Great drinks and service that simply is perfect in every respect. 227 should be on your LETS TRY IT list.

a local favorite. the staff is amazing (amanda is wonderful) and the food is always consistently 10/10!!! read more

Tavern 227 - brussel sprouts and Arancini - Bars Near Me - Sea Cliff, New York

Food is delicious l especially like the gnocchi. It's not easy to find a light fluffy excellent prepared gnocchi. Tavern 227 knows how to make this dish to perfection. The ambiance is comfortable and friendly. A neighborhood place with great food and nice people The staff are amazing. They are all pleasant, friendly and truly want to help you enjoy your time at Tavern 227 Very strongly recommended this restaurant read more

The food was great! Homemade pasta, grilled octopus appetizer. Particularly tasty and well done. The room is small but well done, with a large bar. The downside- we went on a Friday night and the sound level was crazy loud. We actually stopped speaking because we couldn't hear one another talk. read more

Excellent food- the pesto gnocchi, octopus salad and butchers cut special (rack of lamb) were all 10/10. Would highly recommend. I would also disagree when people say it's over priced- we had 6 drinks, 2 entrees and an appetizer and the bill was under 200. Thought that was fair! read more

Great casual Italian. The cheese platter was great. Limited but fantastic menu. Pappardelle bolognese was very good. Staff is friendly and helpful. Big bar warm decor and lighting. I highly recommend this restaurant. read more

Nice place, nice atmosphere. Good lighting. Service was excellent. Had Wagyu Meatball, pear salad and Halibut over fingerling potatoes. I appreciate that the prices are a little high as they are using high end ingredients. My only advice to them is to come up with one or two "we have to come back here for this" dishes. Sea Cliff is awesome but off the path for some, so it can be a little harder to pull in traffic. That said, it had a good crowd yesterday. For example: * make your own bread, serve it warm with Italian honey butter, make that a signature of the restaurant. * have a spicy pasta. Something heat lovers crave to come back for. * make the music you play a signature of the restaurant. E.g forgione only plays solid 70s/80s classic rock. It's those things you remember. read more

Tavern 227 - Meatball appetizer - Bars Near Me - Sea Cliff, New York

My husband & I discovered this place by accident and we were wowed. Great wines, great food, and great service. We've eaten at the bar and tonight we had 6 for an early dinner. Each meal was better then the last one. Standouts are the rice balls, the crispy brussel sprouts, and the orecchiette. Desserts are limited as is the rest of the menu but all absolutely delicious. read more

Great food and romantic atmosphere. We got the arancini and truffle fries, and shared the eggplant parmigiana, gnocchi and orecchiette. The service was excellent - prompt and attentive. read more

See all

Absolutely love the place! The decor and setting really can't be beat. Very high ceilinged, exposed brick, tiled floor, old style place. Recalls a class and elegance of the day when Seacliff was a summer destination in its own right (if you haven't been to Seacliff, I strongly recommend it). The appetizers were excellent The calamari fritto is as good as you are going to get anywhere, cooked perfectly and served with a deep bodied, slightly peppery marinara. We also got the artichoke alla romana, which is the tougher of the two to make and it was all aces: fried just right with that perfect citric bump just as you bite through it. Seriously, it's the best I've had. A star came off for the entrees though. Wife got the burger, which was good, but the fries were awful. They were hard and oily. Seemed like their oil temp wasn't high enough or they flubbed the first fry. They did make it right by bringing us more delicious bread, so no problemo. My dish was the pesto. Granted, that's a tough dish to make properly, but even given that wide berth, the execution was sub par. We absolutely plan on going back, we just plan on being a bit more careful with the entrees. Oh the service was great too. Attentive, but not overbearing and altogether friendly and welcoming. Btw, super kudos on the tap beer! 60 minute Dogfish IPA! read more

The service was great couldn't complain about that, but the food was mediocre for the price. I was actually very disappointed, a lot of people told me this place was good but when I went I wasn't to impressed. I do have to say the rice balls were probably the only thing I would order from here again, but the cacio de pepi was god awful, It tasted like they opened a box of pasta and just put some parmesan on it, it definitely was not authentic. I was actually very upset about this experience. The ambience is beautiful it feels like your sitting in a restaurant in nyc but the food just doesn't do it justice, I will not be coming back nor will be recommending this place maybe just for drinks but that's about it. They need to step up the food game. read more

First time for us last night. Great place. We are new to the area and looking to expand our list of go to restaurants. Definitely adding this to our list. Good food, attentive service and excellent bar scene. Highly recommend read more

227 is a little Italian with few tables, large bar and old Bar feel. The menu is limited but the entree's are excellent and delicious. The portions are small especially when you consider the entrees don't come with any sides and the one slice of bread is cut very thin. The price's are high to top this considering this is a local pub. However as I said, the Food is great with nice service and I'll continue to frequent 227, and just order some pasta if I am really hungry. When there are people at the Bar you have a high noise level but just nice people having a good time. read more

A family member and I visited for the first time last night and decided to sit outside. There was no hostess to greet us when we arrived and this brought confusion about when and where to sit. It almost seemed we were forgotten after our order was taken. I haven't experienced a wait that long in ages and, by this point, we were getting hangry. The look of annoyance for the wait was apparent on other patrons faces, as well. The maitre d' was abrupt and rather rude taking our order. He even had the nerve to suggest my relative "didn't need bread" for the table ....because her dish had bread in it. This is besides the point that she is one of the fittest, thinnest people I know and that my dish didn't "include bread". My branzino dish was expensive and was supposed to have been, overall, very light on oil or fat, as ordered, but came out drenched in it. My relative's Waygu burger was tremendously over cooked, yet cold when it came out, and the cheese on top looked like Velveeta. The waiter who brought the dish also admitted that half the fries were missing because they'd dropped on the floor on the way out! Although it was promised that more fries would be coming, my relative received overcooked, hard, pieces of fries that were inedible. It seems like they were from 'the bottom of the frozen bag' of fries that had run out! It was almost impossible to get the attention of hostess or maitre d' to try to correct the issue. There was no follow up after the order came out to see if anything was amiss or needed. Instead of being prioritized for a fast, new medium rare burger - it took forever to receive the corrected order and there was no profuse apology or effort to remediate for the excessive time by the waiter. To top it off, the maitre d' was unapologetic and offered very poor customer service when the error in and quality of the dish was brought to their attention. Needless to say, we won't be returning. read more

Tremendous service to start. Went to a private party and the staff's attentiveness stood out. This is to say nothing bad about the food which was spectacular. Would highly recommend for a small group or party! read more

what a great find, super pretty place with good food and fair prices for the quality food. All of the pastas were amazing and the salads were super fresh. Fast and efficient service with a nice attitude. The bar is really nice but the noise level is high. read more

Came here for a quick dinner before a show. The food was outstanding. We had the cactus margarita, Manhattan, truffle fries, pumpkin gnocchi, and sea bass. Everything was outstanding. Not a single bite or sip left!! Highly recommend all of these, especially the gnocchi and fries. Phoebe was our bartender and waitress. She is wonderful. Currently waiting on the chocolate lava cake- expectations are high! read more

Quaint place, Friendly service, good food. Bartender was welcoming and attentive. Sat at the bar for a drink and dinner. Very Limited wine menu ( no Pinot noir, or Chianti, Merlot) but understand they are soon to come. Sampled a few wines, and found a perfect taste. Food was surprising delicious. Grilled octopus was grilled to perfection. It was served over cannelloni beans, but probably would have presented better over something with color. But taste was spot on. Had the lasagna special and wasn't disappointed. Serving size was healthy. Plenty of melted mozzarella, and stuffed with a mix of meat. Delicious choice. Tuesday is 1/2 price burgers, I'll be back to try them next time. Definitely recommend a visit, you won't be disappointed. read more

Food is excellent and pricing is fare. Wine and beer menu could be expanded. I will return and recommend this restaurant to friends.

This was my first time here sat at the bar. No one welcomed us or explained the menu. There was one bartender running the entire restaurant which is not his fault. I specifically asked for my burger medium rare and it was well done with frozen french fries. We were never given bread while we waited so long for the food. Would not come back totally not worth it much better service and quality of food in the surrounding areas. read more

Visited a few weeks ago in a busy Saturday night. While service was a bit slow, it was still attentive and the food delicious. If you are patient you will enjoy! I look forward to going back. read more

i am in the food business all my life cook and pastry chef .Trying different restaurants every weekend and i must say Tavern 227 was on the spot.Very good service and drinks. My compliments to the chef,food was fresh,tasty and portion right.Definitely i will go back read more

Such a cute tiny place! The food was fantastic! Truly it was ! Portion size however was small for the price. I feel like if the prices were a little lower it would be a staple, but we felt that there were comparable places nearby for less money. We may be back again sometime in the future. read more

Expensive and sooo not worth the price. Pretty place but the menu and food leaves alot to be desired. The grilled octopus was a total joke, chicken cacciatore ( recommended by the waiter) was salty and watery, pork shank tasteless and cold. The only decent entree was the burger. Sorry but with so many good restaurants in the area they need to step it up or say goodbye to Sea Cliff. Not impressed read more

Not impressed, place is beautiful, staff great and attentive..but food........ really forgettable. Too many good Italian restaurants within a 5-7 minute drive to serve bland pasta dishes that are already overpriced for the portions. Fries? I was expecting something a little fancier than bowling alley fries. Pasta dish Cacio e peppe 18.00? I was done in 5 average sized bites! 2nd time remembered it better the first, the second time I was thinking of all the other places I should have spent 100.00 read more

Last night my friends and I had an incredible dinner at Tavern 227. It was difficult to choose from the items on the menu and the many specials they offered. Our server, Claudia, was well versed in the menu and helped us craft our meal. We had a slight issue with one of the appetizers, but Phoebe handled it in a prompt and professional manner. And on top of incredible food, the bartender made the best sidecar I have ever had. I predict this will be a tough reservation to get one the word gets out. read more

Tavern 227 - Bars Near Me - Sea Cliff, New York

See all

A year later we enjoyed another amazing dinner here! There were 4 of us this time...apps of meatballs (once again they were terrific!), calamari (so tender & fresh!) & grilled polenta w a mushroom ragu over top (was wonderful!). Our friend had the onion soup, which we all sampled & all agreed it may have been the best we'd all ever had!! Wine list was good & my husband's mixed drinks very good. I had the butternut squash ravioli-delicious (tho be warned, very rich!). My husband had the parpardele bolognese, which he loved! The other couple we were with thoroughly enjoyed their rigatoni & eggplant parm as well. Ended with a yummy tira mi su! Love this little gem of a restaurant!! 3rd time @ this little Sea Cliff gem & it didn't disappoint! It's a small, intimate space, but the very high ceilings give it a spacious feel. Atmosphere & ambiance is wonderful. Exposed brick walls, ceiling tiles, great, soft lighting & jazzy kind of music, that's not too loud. Servers are very pleasant-not super sophisticated as servers go, but very eager to please & very friendly & capable. Small wine list, but decent. The burger is AMAZING (& I'm not a big burger person overall), the fries that came w it were fresh & tasty, the mussels (done bianco style) were simple but absolutely delicious!!! I will go back again just for those!! Also had very tasty beet salad. The small plate meatballs are light & delicious too. It was also great to go to a nice restaurant that wasn't overly crowded & loud, where you could hold a conversation with your meal companions without shouting, but you didn't have to whisper either. Wine by the glass & cocktails are a little pricey but it's the North Shore, so it's on par with local establishments. Arrived early (around 6:45 in a Fri night) & we're seated immediately. Place was about half full plus some bar patrons. By the time we left around 8:30 there may have been a table or 2 available but the bar was full. Definitely will return!! read more

Great place for a date! Nice atmosphere, great food and drink, no distracting TVs. Can't beat it!

Love the atmosphere, great service. Bartender Phebe was awesome. Would take a date here or a friend for a drink. 10/10

Food is very good, but the wait for it to arrive is exceptionally long. We have been several times and enjoy the meal, but sometimes we get bread, sometimes we don't, sometimes the service is good, sometimes it isn't. Wish it were more consistent. read more

Small place with good food. On the pricy side - drinks are $14 and dinner specials are $30. Plates on small side but fine. Really like the look inside, they did a terrific job with the decor. It's an upscale place so they charge a little more. No reservations so come early otherwise can be wait for a table. read more

My friend and I came in for dinner on Thursday evening just wanting a nice and cozy local spot. The atmosphere was so beautiful and warm. The restaurant was so neat and I noticed very clean. The staff was welcoming and very attentive. The waitress was very knowledgeable to answer questions regarding gluten free concerns. I ordered the Orcecchiette Barese and my friend had the salmon special. Both dishes were so delicious! I can't wait to go back and I highly recommend Tavern 227! read more

Have you ever been to a full fare restaurant with specials, a chef, etc that doesn't serve coffee of any kind? Have you ordered an heirloom tomato salad that came with only cherry tomatoes? We sent it back! Sea Cliff has much better restaurants than this. Their days are numbered!! Pathetic. read more

The Tuesday Burger Specials ate amazing! Our waiter- Keith- was top notch, solicitous and inspired to be there made our visit enjoyable. His personal favorites and warm personality enhanced our time. read more

Reminds me of Brooklyn! Great place for dinner with your hubby or even just drink with your girlfriends. Wonderful little addition to Sea Cliff! read more

Wonderful atmosphere with a lovely, retro-style bar and delicious entrees, my one piece of advice (or rather, request) to Tavern 227 would be to lay on more bar food. If you want a small snack with your delicious cocktails, there isn't any to be had apart from starters off the main menu, which are more salad-based, and not great for sharing. But apart from that, a wonderful addition! read more