Matt is awesome and honest. He tells it how it is and he tells it bluntly. I appreciate - am thankful and grateful, for his hard work and time. Matt is very knowledgeable and thorough with his checks. I used his service on a used vehicle- he provided feedback, pictures, checklists, computer docs, and grade of the vehicle. Thanks Matt! Jason read more

I cannot say enough good things about this business & Matt (the owner)! I had a Volvo S60 T5 inspected by Matt on 11/25/2025, he provided me with so much information & pictures of the car, he is the ultimate inspector! Very easy to talk with, and personable! He made me comfortable with the information he provided on the car; we bought it the next day. Not to mention HONEST! Thank you so Matt! Teresa read more

My experience with Auto Critic has been nothing but great. I've been searching for a car for over six months, so having someone I could genuinely trust made a huge difference in the process. I ended up using Auto Critic twice to help me compare and separate different cars, and both times he took excellent care of me. He's extremely detailed, professional, and explains things in a way that actually makes sense instead of just throwing a report at you. One thing that really stood out is that he lifts the car off the ground during the inspection. That alone adds another level of confidence and sophistication to the process you're not just getting a surface-level look, you're getting a truly thorough inspection. As a former educator, I really appreciated that shared mindset of educating yourself before making a big purchase. Getting a second opinion isn't a red flag--it's the smart thing to do. I'd much rather know what's going on upfront than buy something that turns into a costly problem later. His reputation speaks for itself, and after working with him firsthand, I can confidently say he's the best in the DFW area. Honestly, just walk away from the guesswork and give him a call--you won't regret it. We all know cars are extremely expensive from the start, and using Auto Critic is one of the best decisions you can make before buying. read more

I called Matt about a pre purchase inspection on a private sale for a 95 Tacoma. He was great. He got out quick and helped me coordinate with the seller. His report was thorough and accurate. I'd use him again and recommend to anyone. read more

Had Matt go look at an Audi S6 for me. Since it would have been a far drive for me and I am no experct in European cars, I wanted someone who knows what too look for inspect the car. He did a great job finding things that I would have missed and getting under the car to realy look at the guts is probably the most important part. I HIGHLY recomend him to anyone interested in a luxury car. read more

For the first time, I'm considering purchasing a car sight unseen because I don't live in Dallas. I was very apprehensive about it because not test driving and seeing the car myself seemed foolish. I was ready to dismiss the whole thing because I just don't see myself flying there either. Then someone suggested I check out Auto Critic. Seeing all the 5 star reviews, I gave them a call. Matt, the inspector, was very straightforward from the get-go. He quoted a reasonable fee, and despite being very busy, he was able to accommodate my request for an inspection the very next day. His inspection report was detailed and comprehensive. He didn't miss even a hairline scratch on the car. His discerning eye, attention to detail, and years of expertise inspecting cars gave me such a peace of mind that I felt the money was well spent regardless if I decide to purchase the car or not. Prior to getting the inspection, I was very reluctant to even consider this interstate purchase, but now I feel I've at least done my due diligence to consider it as an option. So trust me, if there's a car you're considering buying whether you're local or not, I'd absolutely would have Matt inspect it. I wish there were more honest people like Matt in the car industry. read more

See all

I reached out to Auto Critic about a prepurchase inspection. Unfortunately, the vehicle was a little out of their service area and they didn't have availability, but Matt still reached out, talked to me about the vehicle and what to look for, and was even willing to provide a recommendation for another service in the area (which from everything I've seen, is also very reputable). Super nice dude and very knowledgeable. Honestly. I was sad to not use him. Totally worth checking into if you need a solid pre-purchase inspection! read more

I found Matt when looking for someone who did PPIs in the Dallas area. I was short on time and looking for a flexible appointment time that matched my car buying process yet wouldn't compromise on attention to detail. Matt was super informative, gave me tips on how to take care of the vehicle, performed an exhaustive inspection, and was friendly and flexible with timing. Would not hesitate to go to him if/when I purchase another car, he knows his stuff and his pricing is VERY reasonable for the work he does. read more

Best service in DFW. Use them and you will be well taken care of! Thorough, fast and reliable.

I reached out to Auto Critic after finding a classic car in the Dallas area I wanted to buy. They were super flexible on quick turn around on an inspection and went over and above on the inspection to save me from a car misrepresented by the dealer. Thorough conversations, Dropbox full of videos with thorough explanations of what he's seeing, and photos. I will definitely use them again for my next purchase! read more

Matt is a great guy! Highly recommend working with him. Super honest and reliable. Thanks so much for your help

I contacted Matt by cell phone and he immediately answered. I informed him that I was applying for a used luxury suv and needed it inspected. He contacted the dealer for inspection and once he accessed the vehicle he gave me the stamp of approval and ensured me that the vehicle is in great condition and very reliable. Exceptional service, very knowledgeable and true to customers. Will definitely use again and recommend to others. Thanks Matt for all of your help. You service and assistance with this matter was great appreciated cause you went above and beyond to put my mind at ease with this major purchase. read more

Matt was upfront, quick to return my call and willing to get my mobil PPI scheduled ASAP. Unfortunately the jack asses at Carrick Motors sold the car out from underneath me and turned Matt away when he arrived on the agreed upon day, bit he took it in stride and was professional about it. He was transparent about his scope of work and his process were stated, clear and reasonable. Nothing but good things to say about him. read more

We hired Matt at Auto Critic to help evaluate a car we were buying. It was not a hugely expensive car - just a Civic - but still something we wanted to have peace of mind with. And Matt is the guy for peace of mind. He puts a level of detail and effort into his inspections that the others don't really come close to. On the car we were buying, pretty much everything was in order. There were $200 or so worth of small things that needed to be done, and the seller took care of those, which already will cover Matt's fee. Beyond that, we are glad to have that peace of mind in knowing that we are buying a car that has been looked after and is in the condition that it is claimed to be in. EDIT: Things fell through when the dealership screwed us over and sold our car to someone else, then gave us a different car that looked the same. Ultimately they gave us our money back and reimbursed us for Matt's fee. We hired Matt to inspect a second Civic for us. This one was in even better shape than the first, and Matt got out there super quick to make it happen. I showed Matt's report to my mechanic and he was blown away by the thoroughness. He said "no way I'd be doing all that stuff at the prices he's charging." If you're buying a car in the Dallas area, you cannot afford not to have Auto Critic look at it first. read more

I have used Auto Critic on 2 purchases so far and both times have been impressed with their service. They do a thorough job of inspecting every part of the vehicle they can get to and test driving it like they stole it! When purchasing a used vehicle for my kids I want to make sure we aren't getting into a money pit and that it is safe and sound. In both inspections they found some issues that needed to be addressed and in one case we negotiated a lower price and had the repairs done ourselves and in the most recent case we had the dealer agree to make repairs before finalizing the transaction. Both times the dealers told me how impressed they were with the amount of time spent on the vehicle and how thorough the inspector was. MATT P. was our recent inspector and did a great job. If you are looking at purchasing a used vehicle from a dealer or individual - I highly recommend you use them. If the seller doesn't want an inspection then run away from that vehicle. You can visit Auto Critic at www.AutoCritic.net or call the listed phone #'s. They will get there either the same day or next day (at least that is what I experienced). read more

I had Matt check out a high end used car for me. His inspection was incredibly thorough and detailed. He used a paint gauge to detect where a scratch had been buffed out, but was able to tell me that it wasn't visible to the naked eye and that the quality of work was of such a high standard that it wasn't a significant concern. Matt sent pictures of every single flaw on the car, down to a crack in the plastic under-cladding. He tried to shoot video of where he'd found the paintwork, but as he'd said, it wasn't visible. His deliverable is a detailed checklist of all the items he inspected, their condition, and a Dropbox link of photo / video of the areas where he noticed flaws. I close on the car in a few days and am 100% confident that the vehicle is exactly what it's been represented to be. read more

Matt's service is outstanding. Very professional, knowledgeable, honest and available. He also has a great sense of humor that helps thru with the process. I just bought a used 2002 Porsche 911 C2 from a dealership in Plano, TX - I live in NYC. I would never buy anything remotely such as this - unless I was reassured by several local car enthusiasts (Porsche Club of A.) about the detailed inspections that Matt is capable of. After I called him, he was able to mentioned several potential issues on the car - he was at the dealership the next day - put the car up on a lift - detailed every test and took pics of every part of the car. I felt very confident about buying the car even remotely. The car is now here and in perfect conditions with a few minor things that Matt was able to identify. The full report was extremely detailed and totally a great value. I recommend Auto Critic without any hesitation. Thanks Matt! read more

See all

Matt is very thorough and complete with his assessments. Stands behind his work. Has the right diagnostic tools with the knowledge to use them unlike others. He gets underneath and digs deep to find issues that otherwise get passed over by other fart knockers who show up on their scooters with tools in a backpack. Just sayin' read more

See all

Buying a used 20+year old pickup from 1100 miles away. I was skeptical about the vehicle and the vehicle inspection. Enter Matt of auto critics. Matt put me at ease right from the initial phone call. After the inspection we talked about the vehicle and i was able to purchase with confidence. Auto Critics thorough inspection was well worth every penny spent! I would use them again. Highly recommended. No BS! read more

I was very pleased with the services from them. Matt did a great job. He Inspected the car, spent time explaining what he saw to me, and provided a detailed written report. The car came as he represented. I would not have had the confidence to buy a car online if not for him. read more

Matt was fantastic! He really knows his stuff. I didn't want to spend the money but I'm so glad I did! Worth every penny. I highly recommend his service. read more

Matt saved me tons of time and money! I live in Austin, but found a car I wanted in Dallas. They went and reveiwed it, took pictures, and explained the problems to me. The car was mostly as advertised, but I wouldn't have known about the internal issues, if it hadn't been for them. I would have driven up and either wasted time and gas money looking, or ended up with a lemon. Thanks Auto Critic! read more

Matt is an absolute dream of a mechanic and everything you could hope for in getting a thorough inspection! After trying to find the specific make/model we wanted in our hometown, my husband and I turned to Autotrader to find vehicles within 500 miles. We did manage to find the "perfect car" but needed a good, detail oriented mechanic to confirm that. That's where Matt comes in... We had a great phone conversation and he gave me tips on how to make the out of state buying process easier on me and my husband and gave me warning signs to look out for as well. Matt and I were on the phone as he was doing the inspection so he could tell me exactly what he was seeing with his own two eyes. He took some detailed photos and emailed them along with his report to me promptly. The vehicle got his stamp of approval and my husband will be flying over to pick up our car. :) Thank you Matt for being so thorough, kind, and flexible with your schedule in our time crunch! I would recommend him to ANYONE in the Dallas area in a heartbeat. read more

Matt from Auto Critic is the real deal! A true expect at his craft. If you need someone to look at a vehicle for you, here is your spot in texas. We highley recommend. He was fast and gave us a full report. call him. read more

6 Years after posting my poor review of this guys work, he leaves me an angry voicemail at 9pm on a Saturday night screaming at me. I wish I could post the audio for people to hear! He's upset at me for hos POOR performance! Nice! I see that he has a lot of 5-Star Reviews here so I know he's capable f good work, just be careful he doesn't drop the ball on YOUR job (and then scream at you for it). read more

In May of 2015, we decided to get a cheap convertible for the summer. After looking through many websites we finally found one in Dallas, TX. Long distance buy from New York is usually a gamble. There are many advertised to do car buying inspection but I have found none to be reliable. I found Matt after reading some positive reviews. It was for a 2006 Lexus SC430. He went out inspected the car and took numerous pictures. The best part is the detailed report and pictures he sent me on the same day of inspection. After getting an OK from him, we put down a deposit and drove it home after 2 weeks. The car is almost like new!... very happy. I really wish there are someone like Auto Critic near where I live. Because of his excellent service, I would purposely look for cars in the Dallas Tx area in the future. See his pics. https://dkny.smugmug.com/Cars/SC/n-CJCNxh/ read more

I was referred to Matt, and it was the best decision to let him look over the SL 500 AMG I was planning on buying. He has incredible knowledge of Mercedes and knew exactly what to look for that could be wrong with the car. He even put me in touch with someone other than the dealership to make the repairs and because of their knowledge of Mercedes, I ended up not buying the car. I feel like it was a fair price for the car but the many different things that could break in the future is why I didn't buy the car. Matt is super professional and sent over a detailed report on the car, far more than I expected. Thanks Matt! read more

Because of natural disasters, I had concerns about buying Texas car online (a low-mileage BMW M3). Matt, who is the Auto Critic, resolved these concerns through providing a report of the vehicle that was as detailed as it was comprehensive. Had I taken vacation time from work, flown to Texas, and personally inspected the car there is no way I could have done so well as he did. Why? Matt is a professional. From the moment I called him, he was up-front with me. He was clear in communicating. He not only kept his appointment, but he finished the job three days ahead of his scheduled date. Buying a car is a large purchase for most people. And Matt's attention to detail gives this process the respect it deserves. His reports are in-depth. He takes photos. He calls as a courtesy to follow-up at times. He did in my case and I had a way more relaxed weekend knowing the car I planned to buy was in as good of condition as I believed. Matt's education and experience makes him an expert in his field. He has critiqued well over 11,000 cars. He offers on-site services. Even so, he lifts the car and inspects. There is no one in the Dallas area to my knowledge who does such an inspection in such painstaking detail, certainly not on-site. Matt does all his inspections himself, and this cumulative experience makes him THE auto critic. Matt cares about his customers. He could likely hire less qualified or experienced workers and bank on his reputation and probably double his money. He could likely charge way more and do high-end inspections, and probably triple his profits. But he does not. I suspect this is because he truly cares about his customers more even than he does about the cars, and certainly more than he does the profits. My experience with his services is that Matt wants to see people have a good outcome and he knows that when people know what they're buying they will make a decision themselves instead of having the decision made for them because of something they didn't know or believed they knew but was false. If you have to know what you're buying -- if you have any doubts -- if you have any questions -- if you need an expert mechanic -- heck, if you like talking about cars, call up the Auto Critic. You will not be disappointed. Indeed, even and perhaps especially if the news is bad, you will be glad you found out before you purchased the thing. And if there's anything to notice, it will not escape the Auto Critic. read more

Found Matt doing some online research and was very impressed with his services. Live in Ohio and had him check out BMW X5 in Dallas area. He communicated throughout the whole process and even called during the inspection to tell me what he was finding. Went out the same day I called him! Very informative, knowledgeable and meticulous with his inspection. Once he was done he sent me over 40 pictures of the car-high quality legible pics and 2 report print outs. One was the diagnostics/computer scan done and the other his detailed report about everything he went over and found good or bad. Would definitely recommend using Matt and Auto Critic if you need a car looked at in the Dallas, Tx area! Brian-Ohio read more

I bought a car in 10/2016 and contemplated writing this but just finally had to. So I will start out with this,I live in South Florida and was in the market for a 2007 Porsche 911 Turbo. As for anyone would,I had a certain budget in mind and found a car located at Texas Auto Wholesale in Plano,Texas. The car was priced reasonably and after speaking with the salesman at the dealer I explained I would want a third party inspection performed and Blake (the salesman) happily recommended Auto Critic. After contacting them and speaking with Matt he seemed extremely cool and pleasant to deal with. I was able to schedule with the selling dealer the inspection and all in all it went as well as could be expected I guess since I bought the car given the report I was given. Keep this in mind for anyone reading this, Matt had made a comment to me before the inspection that he wasn't a heavy "picture taker" and was different than the other inspectors in the area since he believes all they do is take pics of the exterior and do not really know nor inspect the cars and I believed him. I am pretty anal when it comes to my cars and since I am buying a car in Texas and not seeing myself I am counting on the inspector to be pretty damm accurate and let me know before hand about prior paint work that has been done and any damages,both cosmetically and mechanically. Common sense right? Especially since I am buying a Porsche? Maybe not,I received a few pictures at most from Matt showing the coolant lines I asked him to check for me and he emailed me a list of some mechanical things needed which was appreciated and minor thank god. Let's just say he said he would measure the paint with a gauge,he obviously didn't do that and I asked specifically to have this done. He did say that the hood and left panels had been repainted and that he found no bondo or bodywork which I thought ok I can live with that since the carfax shows no accidents. When I got the car home let's just say he either missed a lot or was working with the dealer to push the sale through since there were multiple and very fundamental signs of paintwork and really bad paintwork also! Also the interior was not checked properly and explained either which pissed me off. Back panels scraped and worn door handles missing paint so on and so forth. I should have flown in and saw the car but I saw Matts ratings and after speaking with him I felt confident he was thoroughly going to inspect the car.. If you are out of state and going to use Matt do your self a huge favor and demand a lot of pictures of the car of the exterior and interior if you are picky like me or just want to know and have an accurate assessment of what you are potentially buying. Mechanically I believe he is ok,not great but competent. read more

See all

Matt did a great job. Same day service and the inspection more than paid for itself. He found and documented needed repairs and seal leaks. He pointed these out to the dealwr, so I was able to use his report to get them to fix, then I will use in the price negotions. read more

I was involved with Matt as a seller of my previous car. An out-of-state buyer requested Matt come out and perform a detailed inspection of the contemplated car. Matt was very professional with me as the seller of the vehicle and took meticulous notes, photos, etc. Additionally, Matt was very friendly and took time to explain to me items about my car, which I previously didn't know. I would highly recommend any potential buyer use Matt for their car inspection. read more

Matt with Auto Critic knows his business and has been dedicated to the business for a long time. Matt can't guarantee the future of a vehicle's performance but he can definitely tell you what has happened in the past and what will likely happen in the future. I purchased a vehicle sight-unseen putting all of my trust in Matt's expertise when examining the vehicles interior, exterior, mechanical and electrical systems. The best part is he checks the entire diagnostic history of trouble codes via the onboard computer. He also provides a series of pictures indicating any previously repaired or current cosmetic damage which includes potential worn parts or leaking components. I didn't realize how lucky I was to find Matt and would absolutely recommend him whether you are buying the car in person or over the internet. read more

Matt is amazing!!! If you need a third party inspection prior to buying a vehicle....Matt is your guy!! Very Honest and thorough!!

I particularly recommend Matt P. My wife and I feel Matt's service is a good value. The private party sellers of the 2003 Honda Accord we purchased had positive feedback about their experience w/Matt, too. read more

Matt did a through inspection of the vehicle that I wanted to purchase and gave me a phone call to walk through the items he identified followed with a report of what he looked at. Great service. Would definitely use his service again. Thanks Matt read more

I was very impressed with Matt. I felt like I could trust not only his inspection, but his recommendations about the makes and models I was looking at purchasing. He knows his stuff. read more

Matt is the real deal, and if you are buying a used car, you need to have him look at it first. He was so incredibly nice, and he helped me with my car decisions and saved me THOUSANDS! I was incredibly impressed with his knowledge and how detailed he was. I give him my highest recommendation, and I really cant say enough good about him! Stellar guy! Thanks Matt! :) read more

If your looking for an incredible inspector, with an eye for detail, Matt is going to get it done right for you. His report and pictures will save you a lot of heartache and insure you know what you are getting into. read more

I used these guys back in November 2010, the report was spot on and honest. Would definitely recommend these guys.