These meatballs are awesome! I was referred to this establishment by a friend and they heaped so much praise on it that I was naturally skeptical. In an attempt to determine whether their opinions have an merit, I decided to check it out. I was not disappointed! Quality ingredients and they are quite friendly. I would definitely recommend it! read more

This place is awesome, great people and a diverse way to get some good Italian food. Only improvement I can think of is I wish it was open later! Closes at 730 on weekdays. Other than that go eat here, you won't regret it; and they deliver. Really a great place, they brought a unique idea into the restaurant industry and executed it perfectly. Deserves more than 5 stars. On a side note, they deliver boars head deli meat by the pound for great prices; only place I've ever seen that does that. It definitely beats standing in line at the food store. Thumbs up to that. read more

This restaurant is a prime example of a reason why to travel off the beaten path! The menu has character and enough choices to make you think about your selection. I had the #20 "Really Shweaty Cheesy Balls" in a bread bowl. The meatballs were flavorful and there was a perfect balance of sauce and cheese; this choice added creamy ricotta cheese to the dish which was an awesome touch. The staff was super-friendly. You should stop in! read more

B-Balls Meatballs - Pizza Near Me - Suffern, New York

located amongst private homes. ordered the reuben with mustard. quite dry, barely any cheese or saurkraut. small meatballs, invisible pastrami that I had to pull out to find. I know they usually give ample portions but mine was tiny. the inside is nice and the hero does taste good. need to work on their consistency of filling up the insides of the bread with product. read more

B-Balls Meatballs - located in a suburb street full of houses. - Pizza Near Me - Suffern, New York

See all

Yum, on a street corner, not much seating, but good variety of meatball subs. It's a family run business and they were really nice and welcoming when we took a road trip out of the city and came by for some quick food. read more

Great spot! A party of 7 of us went around 2pm on a Tuesday and we all enjoyed our sandwiches. I think one sandwich is big enough to share with another person. I definitely will be going back when we visit Warwick again. read more

Awesome spot with yummy meatballs! This is one of the first places in a while that I have been to that actually deserves their high rating- good job!! Will def be back soon! read more

I don't think I've ever had better a pizza or meatball parm sandwich in my life. Having ordered from here a handful of times I was compelled to let the world know. The prices are very fair and the staff are extremely friendly. I live a bit of a drive away but it is beyond worth it! Love this place, will be back there soon. read more

This place a hidden gem in Suffern! My mom and I first tried them last year and have been hooked ever since! I feel as though a lot of people in the county don't know about B-Balls because it is kind of off the beaten track in a residential neighborhood which is such a shame because EVERYONE needs to know about this place! The bread bowls are to die for, they are so filling and most of the time I'm only able to eat half, but they really are one of a kind. The blue balls and buffalo balls are my fave! Sometimes we'll get a margarita pizza which is really good too. I love supporting family businesses, and this place really is a family business. They are ALWAYS so friendly when I go in to pick up my food and one guy (who I think is the owner) always makes conversation when I go in and is super personable. I make sure I tell everyone about this place, love the food, love supporting local business. 5 stars all the way, keep up the great work B-Balls! read more

Fast, hot delivery. Friendly customer service. The pizza is just okay. Kind of bland, fully limp, and a few slices with WAY too much oregano. But it's still better than the national chains. If you're stuck in a hotel in a snowstorm, you could do a lot worse. read more

Very good sandwiches. I really loved my Gyro sandwich while my lunchmate very much enjoyed her Shweaty Balls.

Wow. I'm at a truck stop and they delivered right to me. The guy that drives the Mercedes is very friendly. Lady on the phone was very nice to. The portions are big and the food is amazing! I ordered the fishy balls sandwich and garlic bread which comes with spaghetti sauce. Also my root beer was NOT shaken up from the drive. Fast delivery. Unique recipes. I definitely recommend this place. If you want to try something different which is also really good eat here. read more

Holy moly, what a fantastic buffalo meatball bread bowl! I grabbed take out based on reviews and was NOT disappointed. I will definitely be ordering from here again. read more

First time and we really enjoyed it. Service was great. Food: AWESOME! Recommend it!!! read more

In traveling to Mahwah NJ over the past two years for work, this place has become a go to for good food. I usually get the schweaty balls hero, but I've mixed it trying a few others, all were excellent...even the one with ghost peppers. Nice staff and easy to get to, highly recommend. read more

Meatballs are great! Try the Bocci Balls! Also, in the morning they have amazing egg sandwiches.

Amazing sandwiches and Italian ices. Try the Hernia or Chiplote Balls. Kelly and Lance are fantastic people too. Great idea for a restaurant. read more

Please try this place! Food was delicious and the owners were so caring. Wish I lived in NJ - I'd be a constant customer when in the area.

Tried the baci balls and they were delish! My b/f had the schweaty balls with cheese and enjoyed them as well. This was my first visit and I'll definitely be back. Reasonable prices and friendly owners. read more

I just loved to the neighborhood and I live right around the corner from BBalls Meatballs . They are the nicest people and are always sweet when you go to their store . I order chicken franchise like three times a week from them and there chicken franchise kicks ASS!!!! I sometimes have my food delivered to me ( yes I know I sound lazy because I live just around the corner ) and the delivery boy is always on time and he even asked me if he could help me take my garbage out one day because he saw me taking my garbage down my stairs . If you want great Italian food, fast service and quality service ..... Check out BBalls Meatballs . By the way if you like deviled eggs they make them fresh everyday . I lovvvvvveeeee them . read more

Great sandwiches. Different than other places. The best selection and always tasty. Have eaten here several times, fast service and always fresh. read more

This place has the most creative way to make a meatball sandwich. The menu is extensive and always tastes great.

I knew the great ball on fire would be SUPER spicy even you forgot to put a pepper sign after it on the menu. Everyone be aware. Don't try it unless you are very serious. read more

Pretty good meatball place, only been twice still have to try a few more. Had the mac-daddy balls last time and it was ok. Started to repeat on me the rest of the night but willing to go back again to try something different. Def a place to give a shot. read more

Awesome subs epic pizza really kind folks. Will come back!

This is one of the best hidden gems in the area. The attentions are the best , explaining with details what you are gonna eat. Instead of just saying that I will come back to this place I will say this will be one of my favorite places to lunch. I hope someone else have the same luck of passing and stop as I did. read more

Super friendly staff and delicious food! The bread bowls with cheese was an unexpected and yummy twist on a classic meatball sub. We will most definitely be back. read more

The most fabulous meatball sub you will ever eat. The choices are cleverly named and delicious to boot, the owner extremely friendly and always up for a chat if not otherwise engaged, and the location charming - just outside the heart of Suffern. Haven't had a chance to try their pizza, but it's next on my list! read more

I have been a customer of this deli( and I use that term loosely because they are so much more!) from pancakes in the morning to the perfect hamburger and their infamous meatballs!! Kelly and Lance treat all customers like family !! I urge you to go in!!! You will keep coming back like I do!!!! read more

Very good meatball subs but it gets boring real fast. Some of the sandwiches are just too much. I've only had a couple different types but they're all pretty good. The pizza is a waste of time. It's not bad but there's other places to get good pizza. read more

Stopped at this shop on my way through driving to Pennsylvania. Was a wonderful decision! The owner was very friendly and the food was great. Wish I was a local so I could stop by more. This place rocks! Would recommend in a heart beat. read more

On a road trip from Boston to PA, looking for something authentic for lunch, we found this hidden gem off the main drag. Super meatball parm and Italian ices, not to mention very friendly. This place is the goods. read more

Ordered from here for the first time tonight after reading all the reviews I figured it was worth the try. Ordered 2 different meatball sangwhichs and a Sicilian pie and a plain pie. The meatballs subs were pretty good (baci balls and blue balls) good flavor in the meatballs, all of their meatballs are handmade which is something I really liked about the place. The Sicilian could have been in the oven a little longer, I like my Sicilian crispy on the bottom, a little to doughy for my liking, and a little touch oregano in the sauce. The plain pie was pretty good, but nothing spectacular. The place is really nice, but I don't think I would make the drive all the way down to suffern again for pizza that's just decent. I love the idea and think b-balls is great. A few minor tweaks and this place would be much better. 3 out of 5 stars for me read more

Great Mom and Pap place located in a residential area but don't let that turn u off. If you want a great sandwich made with really good bread stop place has excellent food and it's fun. read more

Great food and great prices....stumbled across this and found the great reviews. Way exceeded what we hoped for! Definitely a great place to go! read more

This place was so good! The food was great and the staff was extremely friendly. Great spot for lunch and the menu was extensive. Sandwiches were filling& we got alfredo balls and blue balls and both were really good. I would def recommend! read more

Awesome sandwiches. Quick and easy. I never thought I'd say I want blue balls again.

Good sandwich, decent price, good portion size. Just takes forever if you don't call ahead.

Good food. I ate a regular meatball so maybe if i try something else one day different it can boost it up to 5.

This restaurant is a treasure for the local community. I recently had the BUTCHERS BALLS sandwich which was absolutely delicious. The meatballs were juicy and tasty and the meat on top was lean and tender. I urge anyone in the area to go in and try any one of their sandwiches on the menu. I look forward to trying them all. read more