Food is not bad, pizza is fine. I ordered a large pie with 2 toppings which added about $10 to the price, they were so stingy with the toppings that it really felt like a rip off. Additionally, the workers are not friendly at all. Not sure if I will return... read more

My first time ordering pizza from Pasquale's. Ordered two plain cheese pies. The sauce tasted good but I couldn't quite tell about the sauce and cheese ratio. My fault because I had a few errands to run while on my way home so it was a little cold. Would love to try again and bring the food right home. I do like my pizza is more well done and that's one thing I really appreciated. Nice crisp and undercarriage. But something to keep in mind if you prefer yours less done. read more

Pasquale Pizzeria & Restaurant - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Suffern, New York

We ordered a large pizza, half pepperoni and sausage. This pizza was large NY style pizza. The thickness was not thin but not thick. The pizza was very good. It could use a little more tomato sauce. The mozzarella cheese was plenty and the sausages and pepperonis were not salty. The thickness of the slice was perfect, it came out extremely hot and the slice held the cheese! The pizza was done in less than 15 minutes. I would definitely come back here. They have a small dining area and clean. So you hear everything when someone is talking a little loud. read more

See all

The pizza and mozzarella sticks were really good. I would definitely recommend ordering from here.

Born and brought up in the Tri-State area, but moved to the west coast for the last 21 years, so I've missed the NY pizza bad. Recently made a trip back to the east coast, and visited Pasquale for a quick bite. The pizza was outstanding. Prices were great. Over the course of my trip throughout the tri-state area, Pasquale's pizza was most memorable. We ordered a large cheese pie. Garlic knots were also yum. read more

The food here is consistently good. Pizza is cooked to perfection. They know have several varieties of Rice and Beans on the menu.

Best pizza by far in the area. If you like an old school pizza pie, this is your place. Their large pie is an 18" pie as opposed to the usual 16" pie most places sell. The dough, sauce and cheese ratio is perfect, and it is always cooked on the well side, which is how it is supposed to be cooked in my opinion. They are very reasonably priced, it seems like everywhere I order from is a ripoff, but I always feel I got good value from Pasquale's. Family run business, father son and daughter working together, they are all very nice and treat the customer the right way. I feel good giving them my money as opposed to some other places that don't seem to care. I highly recommend ordering a pizza from Pasquale's. read more

Omg I got a salad slice from there the other day - it was amazing!! The crust was thin and crispy the salad fresh and they give this white vinegar dressing that blew my socks off!!! A hidden gem!! I was totally impressed and my sister got a regular slice that she loved also! Customer service was fantastic there was no salad pizza but the guy didn't hesitate to make it immediately. I can't wait to go back!! read more

My daughter and I were traveling from Ohio and staying in Mahwah. We read great reviews about this place and wanted to try it out. We loved it! The pizza is scrumptious and the salad is so fresh. Kind man working and took good care of us. The food came out quick and was exactly what we ordered. We had to come back the next night for dinner again before we left town! We will see you again next time we are in town! read more

An absolute staple in downtown suffern. Great pizza, fresh ingredients. Would highly recommend all food. I order from here all the time. Hands down the best! read more

Best pizza in Rockland County and, in my opinion, rivals New York City pixza with a lot less grease!

Ralph makes the best everything !! Convenient location , friendly service, always fresh.

Best pizza I've had since moving here from Brooklyn!!! Absolutely fantastic pie!!

This pizza spot is the absolute best in the area, great chicken parm slices and regular slices, knots are outstanding and the price can't be beat. Everyone is super friendly and the restaurant is clean and welcoming! Awesome spot! read more

Yet again a great experience! Ordered a pepperoni pie, chicken fingers, mussels and a salad. I love this place and their prices are great too! read more

This place has been around for over 30 years and the pizza is good. The owner has changed but the new owners have worked for the former owner for 32 years. Since we live near Massachusetts now, the pizza is not the same. When we come to visit family, we make sure we stop by for a slice. The mushroom pizza is delicious and to die for. I am not a vegetarian, I just love mushrooms. They put lots of mushrooms on the pizza. I think next time I will ask for Pepperoni and Mushrooms. My husband just stills to a classic cheese slice. The owners are very nice too. read more

Ive been going to this pizza place since I was a kid.. And they never disappoint. I moved out the state many years ago.. But the second I cross the state line I detour right to Pasquales... Ive heard the original owner no longer is here, but the pizza recipe still seem to be in tact.. I just love it.. We ate in the restaurant.. I enjoyed every single bite.. Of the three pizza pies we had last week while visiting ;) By far the best pizza in Rickland! read more

Very good pizza for Suffern. They have a great crust, however the pizza is always a little greasy. Maybe from the type of cheese they are using ? Service is always friendly and quick. This place is great for a sports team outing or just for a quick dinner. I have only tried the pizza, so I cannot comment on their other food. The only real downfall to this place is trying to find parking downtown. Definitely try this place, of is worth it! read more

Love the pie here. Large pizza pie - genuinely good NY pizza. Good price , guys inside are nice

Really good italian and latin food, you should try the rice and beans with beef and the spaghetti with sausage. read more

Pasquale Pizzeria & Restaurant - Sausage and peperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Suffern, New York

Pizza and garlic knots are great, but a little in the salty side. Tomato sauce was fine, but also on the salty side and was too thin. Other than that, great place. Service was efficient and friendly and pricing was decent. Best pizza I've had in Suffern. read more

Pizza little too salty. But first time. Maybe I'll give another chance and review again. Price good. Pizza ok though. But that's it

We feel the best way to judge how good a pizza is is a classic Cheese pizza. Pasquale's was great! We feel it is the best we've had yet in the area. read more

Pasquale Pizzeria & Restaurant - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Suffern, New York

See all

I get it...High School kids work at pizza places. But good management and happy kids make sure the customer experience is excellent. I don't know who answered the phone but in a million years I wouldn't order from this place. The kid sounded half asleep and genuinely annoyed I was calling. This place lost a potential customer. read more

For quality pizza this is the choice in Suffern. Although I prefer nickys for subs, wings and sandwiches this is the place for a great tasting pie. Extra sauce and fresh ingredients make this our goto pizza place for pizza that is. read more

I have been a customer here for decades. Excellent pizza. Spaghetti, baked ziti, heroes, garlic knots and bread all very good. Prices are all very reasonable and a slice is still $2.00! read more

A little hole in the wall on Lafayette. Nothing fancy. A second room on the side. Very inexpensive. Very tasty. A bit out of date, but the food is well above average. I get pizza from them at least 2-3 times a month, even though it is 45 minutes from my home and when I'm passing through Suffern, I rarely have the time to stop in. read more