Stopped by to pick up a few bagels and an iced coffee. Didn't expect anything special. But what…read morehappened next was not only a total surprise but an indication that this is a place that has pride in the service they provide... As I was putting my iced coffee together, I was asked if I would like my coffee wrapped with suran wrap so it will stay together and not spill during the travel. I was not expecting it and was touched that the worker cared enough to help me out so that I can enjoy my drink with minimal spillage. What a nice way to make someone's day! For that I give them 5 stars and a big ! Don't see this type of care much anymore and am glad it still exists. Definitely will stop by again when in the neighborhood. Thanks for your service!

Mustachio's is simply the best! From the staff to the food, it's a must-have for us every single…read moreweekend that we're in Merrick. We travel from the city for Mustachio's and for the off-menu Sledgehammer (aka the Justin). Don't skip this deli!

great people, they make a number 1 Italian hero amazingly. very kind people! 5 Starsread more

Went to get a bologna sandwich from here. Deli on Jerusalem Ave in Levittown by 711. They never…read moresaid they didnt have Boars Head, which is clearly displayed on their windows. They gave me a $10 german bologna sandwich which i cant stand. I found this out because i started eating it and realized it tasted funny after thinking they just sliced the bologna rly thin. When we brought the sandwich back and asked to swap for a different sandwich since it wasn't what i wanted, they refused to do it and wouldn't refund. Never going there again, complete jerks.

This place is absolutely incredible I come here to this deli every weekend for my breakfast…read moresandwich and a drink and the quality is spectacular here. I have tried so many other bagel places/delis and this one beats all of them to first place. As soon as you walk in you feel a very bright and clean vibe from the deli itself. The service here is also top tier and the workers here are always helping and kind-hearted to their customers.

Great local deli! Plenty of parking in the shared lot with Lidl and CVS. It's a grab and go place…read morewith no seating. I usually go for breakfast and love their breakfast sandwiches. They also have great cold and hot lunch sandwiches as well. Friendly staff. If you are in a hurry, I'd recommend calling your order ahead.

Ordered the $10 any kind of hero. Was delicious and made to…read moreorder Large portion and fresh Will be back

My 5 year old son could of made a better bacon egg and cheese. Asked for salt pepper ketchup got…read morenone of those. Asked for the bread toasted, wasn't toasted. Half a slice of cheese. Legit worst BEC I've gotten in New York. Lazy!

Visit Date: February 22, 2026…read more I have lived in Baldwin most of my life, except for some years I spent in Merrick, Hewlett and in Babylon with my ex-husband. I've been back in my childhood home trying to get back on my feet after divorce which has been hard and I don't remember ever visiting this deli, it's possible I went as a child and don't remember. On Sunday I was doing a 7 mile run before the blizzard hit because my job was closed. I was almost done with my run and realized I lost my second energy waffle for fuel. So I popped into the deli to see if they had bagels. I didn't see any bagels but I got a BEC. They accept google pay which was good because I didn't have my wallet with me just my phone. They didn't even know they accepted google pay until they asked and I tried it. I got my BEC and sat down in a nice little sitting area the deli provides to eat it before finishing the last of my run. It was great. Better than another BEC I got that I wasn't too pleased with and felt I didn't want to review. It was also a pretty good amount of Bacon, egg and cheese a lot of places give you practically nothing now and charge you a lot for it. I ate my awesome sandwich and continued to finish the last mile of my run after. If you haven't been to this little deli you should go!

Keeping it simple:…read more Old school deli feel. Tasty food, wide selection, fast friendly service. Only down fall is parking is tough.

This is my favorite local deli especially for breakfast. I first discovered it when I was…read moresearching on the slice app for breakfast options. I ordered the breakfast quesadilla and let me say it did not disappoint, I've ordered the French toast, French toast with eggs and also their greek omelette. I usually call into order before I head into work and the food is made quickly and fresh! They are also open for lunch and dinner and have a wide variety of salad, sandwiches and paninis! They have plenty of standard seating indoors if you wanted to dine in or grab and go. The staff there are always so wonderful. Definitely highly recommend!

Ordered a bacon cheese burger medium rare and 3 chicken sandwiches. Ended up waiting 35 minutes for…read morean overcooked cheese burger without bacon but at least they wrapped it up in paper so the bun was soggy and wet. The fries were also soggy and wet. Inedible. Everyone else said the sandwiches were decent enough. Just real bummed to have waited so long for disgusting food. Embarrassing burger.

I love this place. The breakfast sandwiches and deli sandwiches are always good and fresh! The…read moreowner is also very nice and lovely.

Ordered a turkey wrap for lunch and the wrap came in with very little turkey. (See pic below)…read moreThe wrap is close to $7 after tax and this is not acceptable. Will not order from this deli again.

Utterly discussed foremost by the food, then followed up by the irate and uncontrollable type of…read moreperson that seems to be running the deli when I pointed out the mold on my sandwich, which is about 10% of what I used to get from there years ago, and that they also charge me $2.80 extra just for using a debit card on top of all that and would not refund my sandwich even though I left it there I am calling the board of health for sure.

Order chicken cordon bleu. It was made fast. Made fresh and tasted good. What else can you really…read moreask for?? Price was reasonable. Not the cheapest but ok for me.