Fion was an amazing server! He was very friendly, attentive, and took great care of us throughout our visit. He made sure everything was taken care of and provided excellent service. read more

Bagatelle Montauk - AMAZIN FRENCH TOAST!! - French Near Me - Montauk, New York

An Absolute Must in Montauk! What an incredible evening at Bagatelle Montauk! We are a family of five--all adults--and from the moment we arrived, Luke and the entire staff made us feel like a million bucks. Attentive without hovering, incredibly knowledgeable about the menu, and genuinely welcoming. The service was every bit as impressive as the food. We started with the pizza, grilled octopus, and burrata with peaches--an absolutely perfect way to kick off the meal. I had the prettiest tuna tartare I've ever seen, and somehow it tasted even better than it looked. Then came the mains. The lobster linguine was fantastic and large enough for the whole table to share. The steak arrived sliced and ready to eat and literally melted in your mouth like butter. The ravioli were perfect. And then there were the ribs! You don't see ribs on a menu like this very often, but boy are we glad we gave them a shot. They were outstanding. As good as the food was, what really made the night special was the hospitality. After dinner, our kids headed home while my wife and I wanted to stay for a nightcap. Luke went out of his way to set us up in a beautiful, romantic spot where we could relax, have a drink, and simply enjoy each other's company. It was such a thoughtful touch and the perfect ending to an already wonderful evening. Bagatelle is an absolute must when you're in Montauk. Beautiful setting, fantastic food, exceptional service, and a staff that understands how to make dinner feel like an experience. Thank you, Luke and the entire crew. We will absolutely be back! Cheers! read more

The old Gosmans Restaurant was taken over and rebranded to the french Mediterranean restaurant called bagatelle. As someone who enjoys seafood and fine dining this was a great choice. Octopus was slightly undercooked in my opinion but the halibut was fantastic. Most of the waiters/waitresses were from europe which added to the cool vibes. Would highly recommend. read more

The manager, David, made sure we had an excellent experience. The sunset view was beautiful, and all the dishes we tried were perfectly prepared. read more

Bagatelle Montauk - View from outside table - French Near Me - Montauk, New York

Great location and fun night out. Nice menu and good food. Pricey. Usual attitude with all Bagatelle locations - which isnt needed in laid back Montauk. read more

It was a great experience and fun dinner party vibes. The staff was really nice and welcoming. Would definitely go back again!!!

First off I am happy to say that it is time to CHANGE Montauk and let it finally realize that it can be a world class vacation destination. I am sick and tired of the old farts complaining about how things aren't "family friendly" anymore. I'm sick of family friendly! I'm sick of tired old boring tourist trap restaurants with a menu from the 1970's in dated decor with screaming unruly kids next to their clueless parents ruining my vibe. Its time for Montauk to go global, therefore I am extremely happy that a place like Bagatelle is bringing this ambiance to the area. HOWEVER, this is not the Bagatelle that I know of in Miami and St Tropez. This is a shell of itself. The menu is not good and very limited. The service was pedestrian at best. Where were the dancing girls on the tables, where were the themed nights? This needs to be improved! If you build it they will come and come they will and chase out all the annoying families! read more

Such a fun atmosphere. All staff seemed eager to accommodate needs. David was great. DJ was a nice touch for the end of our dinner. Dinner turns into an after-party just FYI. We ordered a ton of food (two-three of a few dishes) which was all very satisfying, but the Branzino stood apart. The striped bass carpaccio was flavorful, but it would have complemented better if it were chopped thinner. The lobster was tender and soft. French fries were nice and crispy thin. I loved the tomatoes (tomates olivettes confites). Cauliflower could have done without as both servings weren't to temperature -- more on the warm side. However, I would recommend just about everything we ordered (see proper French dish names below). Drinks were all good; we just ordered classic drinks/wine/cocktails. Let's talk dessert! We tried everything except the fruit. My absolute favorite was the crepes dentelles! Second favorite, the chocolate ice cream. Beignets were ok, a little too dense inside instead of airy/puffy. And the brioche cake (or tropezienne a la vanille) was sweet - a couple of bites are plenty. French names: Carpaccio De Bar Rayé x2, Gosman's Live Lobster x2, Tomates Olivettes Confites x2, Pommes Frites À L'origan x3, Choux-Fleurs Marinés Et Dorés Au Four x2. read more

I was at Bagatelle Montauk with my husband and son last week The food was fabulous, the service was impeccable and the atmosphere was fun and great music. I love Bagatelle and it's a great addition to Montauk. Can't wait to go back! read more

Bagatelle Montauk - Patio - French Near Me - Montauk, New York

First time for us, we had a great experience, food was awesome. Definitely we will be visiting again.

Our server was the highlight of our night, she was extremely friendly and attentive and was the highlight of our experience. Unfortunately, the food looks a lot better than it tastes. No one at our table had any flavor in their entrees and everyone was disappointed with their drinks. For the price that we paid, we were expecting much better food. read more

Bagatelle Montauk was an amazing experience. The ambiance was incredibly relaxing while still having that festive energy that makes Bagatelle so special. It immediately reminded me of Saint-Tropez, with its beautiful waterfront setting, elegant décor, great music, and lively atmosphere. The service was impeccable from start to finish. The staff was attentive, friendly, and made us feel genuinely welcomed throughout the evening. Every detail was handled perfectly. The food and cocktails were excellent, beautifully presented and full of flavor. What I loved most was how the restaurant manages to combine a sophisticated dining experience with a fun and vibrant vibe. If you're looking for a place that brings the spirit of the French Riviera to Montauk, Bagatelle is the place to be. I highly recommend it and can't wait to come back. read more

My parents celebrated their anniversary here last night, and they asked me to leave a review because they had such an amazing experience! They absolutely loved the food, the atmosphere, and the exceptional service. And loved the chocolate pizza!! A special shoutout to Lucas, Fionn, and Yelita for being so friendly and making their evening even more memorable. I can't wait to come here myself at the end of August with my friends after hearing such wonderful things! read more

Worst experience ever, waiter was rude, lobster fettuccini took over an hour. Multiple tables served prior and a nice $537 bill Lobster was dry, the pasta flavorless read more

Bagatelle Montauk - French Near Me - Montauk, New York

best time with my girlfriends at bagatelle Montauk ! Jade was awesome - she made our experience so fun. She helped with the menu, made sure we were happy and got us dancing! Excellent service! Can't wait to go back' read more

Jade was the best server I've ever had. The food, service, and ambiance were phenomenal. Great options for dietary restrictions.

We just had our 3rd fabulous dinner at Bagatelle. Our server, Ela did a terrific job throughout. Matt the Chef visited. He's great. The scallops and raviolli were amazing. Don't pass up the chocolate pizza for dessert. It's tremendous. Bagatelle is pricey but clearly worth it. read more

Start to finish an excellent experience. The management team (David and Mathias) were so welcoming and warm, making sure to check in with the table. Our server Christopher gave us exceptional service along with the other staff like Ella who did a wonderful job as well. Highly recommend brunch for the fun atmosphere. We loved the burrata. read more

Loved it. Been going since the start of the Summer and each time was better than the last. Keep up the amazing atmosphere and experiences!!!

Food was great and and an amazing ambiance! The whole staff, especially Kenji, was amazing, really made the experience perfect!

Restaurant is grossly overpriced, filled with staff who were forgetful and unfocused, portions were small. Definitely not worth it!

If you want a brunch that turns into a party, Bagatelle Montauk is unmatched! From the moment you sit down, the energy is electric. The French Mediterranean dishes are out of this world (the truffle pizza is a must!). The staff made us feel like VIPs, and before we knew it, we were dancing on our chairs! read more

Disappointed at the New "Gosman's" in Montauk I've been going to Gosman's Dock in Montauk with my family for decades. It was always a casual, family-friendly place where you could enjoy fresh seafood, a salty breeze, and a sunset without breaking the bank or needing a dictionary to decode the menu. That's why last night's experience at the newly rebranded Bagatelle Montauk was such a letdown. We walked in hoping for the same welcoming vibe, but instead were met with a French fine-dining concept--menus in French with English subtitles, an overly curated atmosphere, and prices that made us feel like we were in Manhattan, not the Montauk waterfront. I ordered a simple martini with two olives and was served a small, precious glass with a lemon twist--and a $28 price tag. Honestly, it was the most expensive martini I've ever had, and certainly not the most memorable (for the right reasons). After that round of drinks, we decided to leave. It just wasn't the place for us anymore. I understand change happens, but it's disappointing when it comes at the cost of charm, accessibility, and local spirit. For longtime fans of the original Gosman's, be warned: this is not the same place. read more

Beautiful.place and waitress was a sweetheart...but...the food was horrible. Not even average but just horrible....and $480 for 2 Stay away read more

We did not know what to expect but overall the experience was good. We got the ribeye with the mash potatoes and it was delicious! The oysters were tiny but the ceviche was good. The ambiance was nice as we were sat right on the water. Our server barely checked on us and but we did have a bus boy named BYRON who was amazing and made sure we were happy with the food and asked if we needed anything. read more

Amazing food, service, & ambience. They went out of their way to make our meal special and I would absolutely come back here. Sinclair was the best! Great addition to MTK! read more

Let me start with the setting, and why I gave 2 stars. It's absolutely beautiful, blue and white umbrellas, crisp white linens, outside seating looking over water. Stunning. Now on to a disappointing over priced meal.... We ordered truffle pizza ($55) that was the highlight of the eve. The server seemed sweet as she rattled off specials, highlighting her faves and raving about their steak selections. We ordered. As we were finishing our appetizers .... The servers were hovering ..... and 2 servers on either side of me waiting anxiously for me to fiinsh. I finally chirped up and said.. 'I am still eating ' and they apologized but remained vigilant ... and stated they need to set for the next course At the same time. Mind u with such attentive service ....Our water glasses was never re -filled ... unless one of us flagged someone down to ask. Dinner ... I ordered the halibut that came raw inside. Sent it back and made me a new one. My sister ordered a steak.... charred to death. Her hubby ordered wagyu steak ($230) also dry & fatty. I was extremely surprise & disappointed they didn't send it back. But as I was treating they were being polite. We also ordered the lobster pasta... for 2 ($135) It came, they never split it, lobster was tough and it had a drop of sauce. I don't mind paying for great food and experience. But this was neither. Go for a drink, enjoy the view. Maybe even the pizza. Then head elsewhere for dinner. read more

In retrospect - Everything especially the food, is awful, with just the view being good - and to wit, astronomical prices (really astronomical.) This is a place for suckers.... it's posturing as chic. You can spend $300 -$400 for bad food for 2 persons here, in the blink of an eye. read more

Love sincalare and the food and vibes. So so so good and service so good LOVE U BAHAKDAHAHEME

Okay when my husband said he wanted to go to bagatelle I originally shut it down. I did not want to go. I saw horrible stuff on TikTok and in the previous yelp reviews, and I was convinced I would be disappointed. I have to admit I was wrong. Everything was phenomenal. The interior space was beautiful with amazing views of the water. The service was excellent and the food was delicious. We started with the truffle pizza and they gave us a good amount of truffles so I think it was worth the $55 price. It was actually spectacular. for my entrée I had the scallops they were quite good. They came with a zucchini risotto, which was super fresh and decadent. I would say the scallops themselves were small, but that's okay. My husband had the octopus as his entrée because he ate before. He said it was very good. For sides we had the mashed potatoes and the tomatoes and they were pretty good. Gordon Ramsay would approve. For dessert we had the sorbet because we were honestly so full. The coconut sorbet was the best I've had and the basil strawberry was also superb. I also think the sorbet and gelato was the cheapest I've seen in Montauk. It was four dollars a scoop and everywhere else in the Hamptons. they're selling a scoop of ice cream for nine dollars so I actually think it's a good deal. Everyone on here complains about the prices, but just be smart about what to get. They definitely have some ripoff items on the menu, but you should know to avoid those. read more

See all

if I could give this a negative rating I would. this place is the opposite of anything nice - it's tacky and repulsive and doesn't belong in montauk. The servers were horrifically rude to us and basically insinuated that we couldn't afford their menu. gossmans was once a staple in Montauk and now it's the worst part of Miami Beach. read more

We had lunch yesterday at Bagatelle. As we were seated on a busy Saturday, we wondered why we were only the second table in the restaurant. The menu has very limited choices, and it is super expensive! We ordered the grilled salad and a pizza to share. Both were disappointing. The pizza was loaded with truffle and was not good. The salad was like a Caesar salad but served as a whole section of romaine lettuce. This also was not good. We were so disappointed in what this restaurant has become. The whole area has closed shops, and we wondered if this whole section, now under private equity ownership was going to be turned into something completely not "Montauk friendly". What a shame! read more

How could anyone one who claims to be a successful restaurant/business operator think that this was going to work in Montauk? If you don't understand the community & demographic you're catering to after years of Gosman's deep, decades long connection to locals & tourists alike, you are sorely mistaken. Big mistake. Huge. read more

Ambiance beautiful! Can't be beat. Service awful. We sat down asked for bread 6 times until a busboy brought us some 1/2 hour after asking our waitress and several times. We ordered dinner and our dinner was served 2 HOURS later! It was a Sunday not even crowded. Food was ok. They need to get their act together, never going back not worth the high price for terrible service. Oh and captains chairs at the tables became very uncomfortable after 2 hours. read more

we had a 3:15 reservation on a Sunday for lunch. we sat down at 3:05 (early) they told us the kitchen was closing on ten min and we needed to order now or we can't eat. we hurried and ordered. The food came wrong. The waiter kept trying to clear our food while we were eating. since we were hurried and finished in 30 min we thought we would have a drink at the bar however the bar was closed until 5:30. I was recently at Bagatelle in St Barths had a great meal and so much fun. This was not that experience at all. read more

I've been going to Gosman's for 25 years and always found it was great food at a reasonable price in a stunningly picturesque environment. And while we usually eat at Gosman's Topside, the formal restaurant was a nice alternative if a member of our party couldn't find anything at Topside. The new Bagatelle, unfortunately, is pretentious (I mean, really, a French-language-first menu?) and priced only for those who rolled in on a yacht. Not surprising that the place was completely empty last Saturday while Topside and the Clam Bar were packed. Nice job bringing the snobby Hamptons experience to Montauk! read more

Bagatelle in montauk takes the cake for one of the worse dining experiences in out east. Where to start with what went wrong? We had made the reservation weeks in advance for a birthday with a request to sit inside. When we had got there promptly at our reservation time we were asked to wait ten minutes. 20 minutes later we come to find out the table was given to other customers deemed "more important" than those who made reservations.... we were finally offered a fake table cramped where we could barely fit around the table. We attempted talking to the manager who is probably the most disorganized and rudest people ever. Instead of being apologetic, we received threats from the manager saying we can take our makeshift table or leave. As it was my friends birthday, we decided to try and stick it out now 45 minutes past our reservation. When we sat, we continued to wait for water for another 50 minutes. I have never had to get up and leave a restaurant. This restaurant should be ashamed of their behavior to decent customers and should re evaluate management and clueless staff. Save your money and time and go anywhere else. read more