I've been a loyal Bagel Chalet customer for YEARS! Nick and his team did a great job in upscaling after purchasing from the previous owners. Freshly made food! Bagels are delicious. And..... they make low carb multi-grain bagels......which I order with light veggie tuna! A BIG THUMBS UP! read more

Little on the expensive side but never disappoints. Excellent bagels and pre made sandwiches , strong coffee. There are a ton of workers who are pleasant which is nice . The line moves fast don't get discouraged . They are always nice to my kids , we come here often. The chicken salad on a toasted egg everything is my go too besides egg sandwiches . read more

This place is really good. But for some reason they keep burning the bread on breakfast sandwiches. I called multiple times about this. If the bread is burnt black it should never leave the kitchen. read more

Bagel Chalet - Burnt bread should never be served to a customer. - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

Lots of options to choose from, and the service nice and fast and friendly! They have a bunch of different sandwiches premade and a salad bar, fresh fruit cups and yogurts, bakery items. I love delis with variety read more

I had to satisfy my bagel craving during a quick visit to Long Island and this was it. Great atmosphere and plenty to choose from. I had a bacon, egg and cheese on an everything egg bagel. Wow! Every aspect was perfect. Plenty of bacon and loads of flavor. Wish I had this place back home. read more

Bagel Chalet - Bacon, egg and cheese on an everything egg bagel. - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

I'm actually gonna save you on my food critique because it's always delicious. But why is that I find myself keep coming back for over 20yrs? It's the atmosphere or what they call in the retail business "The Experience". It's impossible to feel lonely here as the people keep pouring in. Owner Nick might as well just install a revolving door. Rarely won't there be a line, but I do admit they got it down to a science and Disney could take a few lessons from them as the line always moves quick. I use Bagel Chalet for multiple reasons. It's a great meeting place to discuss business and/or catch up with old friends. I understand Nick's wife is the interior decorator here. Agreed a a bit ornate or even gaudy but ironically it adds to the character and charm. Don't be surprised if the decor changes once again as they are always freshening up the place with new surprises. Come once and you too will become a customer for life. read more

Bagel Chalet - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

Love the bagels...lines out the door sometimes,but the staff moves so quickly with orders, wait isn't as long as you think. Staff is friendly and when you stay they bring your food right to your table. read more

Bagel Chalet - Sausage,egg over medium w/cheese,spk on an egg bagel. Yum - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

Most bagel places on Long Island are chaotic and unfriendly, especially as the quality of the bagels go up. This place the staff are surprisingly friendly and organized. The make-your-own salads are really good, you fill out a form while on line of what you want to save time and avoid confusion or incorrect orders, and they will bring it to you if you're seating. $11 for a large, it was quite filling. The bagels are good (not the best, for me that award still goes to Brendel's), there is also a variety of healthy and not-healthy snacks. There is also seating for maybe 20-25 people. The location is uninspiring (strip mall). read more

I'm becoming a Bagel Chalet addict. I order from this place almost every day since I started working near them. I literally cannot day enough positive things about the food I get from here. Their menu options are really broad and everything is always very fresh. I usually order a wrap, with a small side of chicken or tuna salad and a pickle with unsweetened raspberry tea. Bagel Chalet has definitely become my go to when I'm hungry at work. Love this place. read more

I'll fight anyone who gives this place less than 4 stars. This is the best place in the Commack/Hauppauge area. Not only do they deliver in a timely manner but you can cater food too. I've ordered almost everything on the menu. If you balk at their prices, then you don't like to eat quality food, because that's what you are getting here. Try the express cobb salad or the bbq chicken wrap. Bagel Chalet rules. read more

Food was edible. Quite expensive for just a flat bread and a few slices of deli meat. I got the commack supreme - containing slices of turkey, cappicola, and two cheeses. It wasn't very supreme. It was overly cheesy and somehow the texture of the two cheeses clashed with each other. Our table was very dirty (so we cleaned it) and the music was very loud, making it difficult to hear the staff. read more

Bagel Chalet - Commack supre-meh - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

You won't be able to find a better bagel. A great place to stop no matter what time of day. The chalet pasta salad is great and they always seem to make the perfect cup of hot tea. The cashiers are always friendly despite how busy the store can be. They also have great salads! read more

Not sure how to describe this place other than an upscale deli. Great food, ranging from a simple bacon egg and cheese for a go to breakfast sandwich, to gourmet sandwiches for lunch. Bagel Chalet also offers delicious pastries, or if you're looking for something more on the healthier side, there is a make your own salad bar that's a perfect choice. Great for quick afternoon meet up, and even better for your bagel fix! read more

This was my first stop after arriving in New York. I got an onion bagel with lox cream cheese and an iced coffee. The bagel was very tasty and had the perfect amount of onion. But the lox cream cheese was absolutely exceptional. They are definitely not skimpy on the cream cheese either - see my photo! I also enjoyed my iced coffee very much. It was nothing special but it was adequately strong. I was very impressed with my breakfast here and it was also just around $6. So good!!! read more

See all

Words cannot express how disappointed my fiancé and I are with Bagel Chalet. Not only did they forget items in the delivery, but our Chalet Chicken Club had the most burnt bacon we have ever seen. Unless somebody requests burnt bacon, there is NO REASON it should look like this. The pictures don't even do it justice on how pulverized it was. I had to wait for a long delivery time for a sandwich that was thrown out. read more

See all

By far the best bagels I have EVER had! I am a carb junkie, and I would eat everything bagels with cream cheese for breakfast, lunch, and dinner if I could- they really are my meal of choice, especially from Bagel Chalet. I grew up in Commack, so I constantly find myself holding all bagels to the "Bagel Chalet" standard. Few have ever met the bar. I have taken these bagels to friends who live in Manhattan, even brought them as my carry on to a friend in Texas (i kid you not), because I really feel they are just that good. You may notice a huge line, but I have noticed that Bagel Chalet also comes equipped with a huge staff that is great at moving people along so the wait is never all that bad. I've never had to wait longer than 5 minutes to get my food even if the line is all the way at the door. Salads are amazing, and made to order, if you want to opt for a healthier choice. They also have some great sandwiches and Panini's that put Panera and Cosi to shame, as well as some baked goods that could put your Grandma's infamous pound cake to shame (the Oreo pie is to die for and only $9.99). It's like a one stop shop when you're on your way to a party. You grab breakfast and your polite "look i'm not showing up empty handed" bakery item. The only bad thing I would say about this place is that it can get crowded, especially during lunch. So while there is ample seating, you may be next to a ton of soccer moms or high school students on a lunch break... FYI- they carry sugar free and low-carb bagels for anyone with dietary restrictions, as well as the most amazing whole wheat and regular flagels on the planet (that cost the SAME AMOUNT as a regular bagel). read more

If you can excuse the inefficiency of ordering and paying, you'll love everything about Bagel Chalet. Let's talk bagels.... some of the best I ever had, and that's a bold statement for Long Island. Their homemade cream cheese is to die for (my personal favorite is the vegetable cc which includes scallions so it's a home run for everybody). Don't overlook their salads either, especially the cucumber salad which is crazy good. So good that I visited 2 days in a row (I'm not from the area) for it. And if you want a side of nostalgia with your bagel, grab a sweet iced tea, which I am 99% positive is just the dry Lipton's mix.... but what's not to like about a great throwback? read more

Being new to the area I've heard about this place since we moved in. I'm not sure the hype? The line was extremely long which had my hopes up, I ordered a selection of bagels and kids didn't want to finish them. The Greek salad I got was good but nothing I'm craving to go back. The bagels went bad cause kids and my husband and I didn't like. He also tried the chicken salad was good but again not spectacular as I've heard. Moved on from here and was disappointed. I really wanted to love this place but after 2 times and the price tag, they're expensive, I'm not going back. read more

I went there today got a bagel with butter, they had a line which moved quickly so that was very promising I was excited about how many locals went there and recognized by the shop owner, however my bagel was handed to the cashier and placed in the bag handed to me as I drove out and started to eat it it was black not toasted but burnt from the inside. I almost wanted to drive back and give it to them. While asking for lightly buttered, it was given a bagel dripping grease. I would never go there again not I would recommend them to anyone. read more

Bagel Chalet - $2.50 for a toasted butter bagel is double what we pay in NYC for same! This store is over priced - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

Food and salads always outstanding. Staff always gloved and masked. The place is small and with the crowds (especially on a weekend) and Uber and DoorDash business they do, makes me second guess to go there in this day and age of coronavirus. Customers usually don't social distance as well as the drivers. Everyone piled on top of each other. It's an accident waiting to happen. read more

I'm not typically someone that writes reviews but when it's something positive why not spread the word. I have only ordered through Grub Hub so I can't speak to in house service. Let it be known that the food is always delicious. The Mesa and Smokehouse paninis are my favorite. It may be a silly detail but I love how neatly and impeccably wrapped the paninis are every time which as a personal peeve messy food drives me up a wall so I greatly appreciate this. I would love to try their other paninis but I can't get off the ones I get because they're so good ! read more

Love this place but wish it was less pricy. Always crowded which makes it annoying to go to because the structure of the store is very narrow. The food is amazing and the salads are to die for but these other aspects as mentioned bring it down. Breakfast sandwiches and bagels are greAt! read more

Slowest bagel place I've ever been to. Waited 30 minutes for one sandwich & it was cold when I finally got it. Avoiding at all costs.

Absolutely terrible customer service. Placed an order for a 9:30 delivery which came on time but noticed they forget 4 plain bagels took them over an hours & a half to deliver them. Ridiculous read more

This place is expensive for what it is. But it's so nice inside, it's a great place to meet up with somebody and chat. I thought their salad portion was huge (picture included) but I also needed a separate plate because there is no way you could eat out of the dish that it's provided in. It's way too packed to not spill anything out of the bowl. I do like this place a lot, but if I came here all the time, it would break my bank. read more

See all

Always fresh! Salads, Sandwiches, Bagels Fruits ..Name it..LOVE This Place. ..fast friendly service :) read more

Bagel Chalet - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

Love bagels and this place has some of the best. I recently went on a low carb diet but after a few weeks had a craving for a bagel from there that wouldn't go away so I gave in. They do have a low carb option but when I asked what makes it low carb I was told whole wheat flour and a smaller size. Not really sure if that constitutes as low carb but still love this place. Still curious if that is really why they call it low carb. read more

Long line to place the order. After you order, the wait while they prep the food is also long. Good bagels but the star deduction is for the lack of organization. Everyone's running around like headless chickens here. May be because rush hour in the morning, but as a bagel shop, you should know how to tackle busy mornings a little better than that. read more

Perhaps one of the "better" bagels available on Long Island. Depending on when you arrive, the line could very well be out the door. However, it moves quickly as they always seem to be appropriately staffed for the time of day (how refreshing). In perhaps the most quintessential of oxymorons, I've made an annual Christmas morning stop to the Bagel Chalet to get a nice Jewish feast for my family's Christmas Day breakfast. I'm not the only one - the line is huge early on Christmas day. Hey, who else is open on Christmas Day really? The bagels are always fresh and they have every variety you could want. Order a dozen and get either some more bagels or some cream cheese thrown in. They have a huge deli case for everything you could possible want to spread - whitefish salad, nova lox, liver, pickled herring, chicken salad, you name it... read more

Best bagels in the area. I have tried a few different varieties of bagels and they were all great. The Asiago bagel is delicious and loaded with cheese. The staff are extremely helpful and pleasant. The Bagel Chalet is a must try. read more

Ok...first the disclaimer. I have not been here in about fifteen years when I was living and working on the Island. My mother came to visit me recently and was nice enough to bring me some bagels from here. This review is strictly about the bagels. The bagels were nothing to rave about.. They tasted OK but not great and were on the small side. Thank goodness she brought me some bagels from my beloved Bagel Boss. There are other bagel stores in the area that are much better and that I will continue to visit when I am in the area. read more

Bagel Chalet...where do I even begin to rave about this place. I'll start by saying that I'm a bagel snob, not sure its something to be proud of but just saying. Bagel Chalet has some of the best bagels on Long Island. No, really it does. Fresh big bagels every day. My go to is an everything bagel with scallion cream cheese. Today I decided I'd live on the edge and I ordered a whole wheat with jalapeño cream cheese...Mind blown! The BEST jalapeño cream cheese I've had and I've tasted many. That cream cheese was just amazing and actually HOT. It gets packed but there are lots of people behind the counter and they're friendly and nice. The decor...a bit gaudy but hey don't judge it IS Long Island. Go there! Eat the bagels and Love it! read more

Came in the morning to get bagel and coffee. Zero safety measures as regards to your customers for the Coronavirus. Way to many people in the store waiting in line or at the register. read more

I love me some bagels, I love plain ones, flat ones, pumpernickel and cinnamon raisin and yum. Bagel Chalet has some deeeelicious, round and chewy bagels. Their coffee is great, and their other sandwich items were hugee. I'm sucha fan! Early in the morning, this spot is the only place in the plaza with their lights on and doors open, and with a few scattered cars parked outside - it's pointing you in their direction.. go try it. Yum! read more

just letting people know that I went there yesterday, 2 small chopped salads with grilled chicken, coffee and a water $35.86.Pretty costly don't you think. Didn't taste or see the chicken in either salad. Don't mind spending money for a salad in a sit down restaurant , being served but when you have to wait on line for 10 minutes and another 10 before the salad comes and overpay ... not worth it to me! read more

Went there around 2pm today to pick up bagels to take home to Florida, 9 dollars a half dozen and they were hard as a rock, they could be used as a weapon, totallly sucked and can't believe they have the balls to sell these bagels in this condition read more

had gone to my daughters place for mother's we had ordered from there hands down best egg sandwich i ever had 1000% recommend live in huntington ill be back soon for another -*-*chrissy*-*- read more

Easily one of the top 20 bagel joints in Commack. You pay a lot and get something. Food not bad but also not great. Solid.

I can't emphasize enough how amazing this place is. They have almost everything you can imagine from a bagel place and more. They have every kind of bagel, wraps, snacks, sandwiches, specials, salads, etc. My absolute favorite is the create your own salad option. You can have the salad customized exactly how you want it down to the smallest detail. I'm totally hooked on this place. read more

Was just passing through and popped in. What an amazing place, the manager/owner(?) was outstandingly friendly and helpful. You could tell he appreciates the customers. They have these amazing flat bagels (why don't we have these in NYC?!) that are amazing, just think of a bagel but with crispness. The French toast muffin was insane!! This place is five stars for food, flavors, efficiency and friendliness. read more

Bagel Chalet - Plenty of seating despite being busy! - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York