Before my boyfriend and I visited this place, I read the reviews and wasn't sure if we should go. I'm a big fan of bagels, especially fresh ones. For my first time here, I ordered something very simple: an everything bagel with butter. I loved it! It was really good, and you could taste how fresh the bagel was. read more

I asked for onion bialys bagel she gave me an onion bagel when I told her she said NO & said I asked for an onion bagel even if I did why not fix the situation and KEEP A CUSTOMER but im just a small guy here never again read more

-Two Sausage egg and Cheese on a plain bagel. -One large Iced coffee. -One small hot coffee. $27 Dollars?! Don't get me wrong. The food is okay. Their coffee is okay... but $27?! Never again. read more

Bagel Club - Sausage Egg and Cheese ON a plain bagel. - Bagels Near Me - Bayside, New York

I stopped by this bagel spot without checking reviews first, and luckily, I had a pretty standard experience. I ordered half a dozen bagels, which were warm and decent--nothing extraordinary, but definitely solid. The service was also standard, nothing to write home about. It's not my first choice when it comes to bagel spots, but it got the job done. read more

Could they spare the butter? Or did they run out? Must have been low on cream cheese too. I have lived 2 minutes from this spot for 15 years and it has been, eh, decent enough but last few trips had me wishing I took the time to go to Utopia Bagels instead. Like NO butter on a bagel with butter and barely enough any cream cheese on my kid's bagel either - $6.00 (!) for 2 bagels (didn't ask for "light" and they didn't even have toast them) & I had to put stuff on at home myself. It takes A LOT to make me write a review for anything but at these prices, the slow and cruddy service and horrible product had to speak up - DO BETTER! read more

Bagel Club - Bagel with.....? - Bagels Near Me - Bayside, New York

I have to say, I loved this place until I walked out paying $14 for a large iced coffee and a bagel with vegitable tofu..... excuse me ????????? $14?????? Which i ended uo throwing out because the bagel had some type of greasy substance on the top of it. I think that price was absurd read more

Best bagels in the 5 Boros service is amazing and plenty of parking since it's in a shopping center excellent for bagels

Wow this place has gone downhill. At 930am my bagel and cream cheese was hard. Not only that, it wasn't tasty and very little cream cheese. I struggled to eat half, I would have assumed it was a leftover bagel if I hadn't bought it myself. This will be our last time here. read more

I stopped in to get some NY bagels before hopping on the road back to FL. I have not had bagels from here for close to 20 years! I used to hang out in Bayside all the time but as I became older, I was nit in the area so much. There is a better place in the area, that is closer to my parents', that I have been going to all this time instead. This lag time I visited, I was in the plaza to ship something and was headed back to FL right after. I was home for almost 2 months and did not have the chance to order bagels to bring back to FL so Bagel Club was the stop this time. I went on a weekday afternoon and it was dead. Upon walking in, I noticed the refrigerators filled with drinks and bagel toppings. Some which made me smile because I realized they were only sold in NYC and made more sad I had to go back to FL. I was greeted and offered help but not right away or without distractions. There were three kids behind the counter. I ordered a dozen bagels to go, which were a mix of everything, cinnamon raisin, and sesame. I also ordered an everything bagel toasted with lite cream cheese to eat with my slice of pizza before we hopped on the road. It took longer than I expected but not horrible. Holy crap the prices were high here! The bagel was good, but not as good as my usual spot. Still way better than any shit they call NY bagels in FL of course! read more

Bagel Club - a variety of donuts in a display case - Bagels Near Me - Bayside, New York

Past couple times that we have been ordering at this establishment we have been disappointed. I believe the staff has a had a huge turnover; the staff could be friendlier and more tentative. However they got our orders wrong again. Plain bagel vs Flat everything bagel but this time I went back and they corrected it (which they were adamant that they gave me the correct order until I showed them the paid receipt, and still no apologies) For the regular size bagels they have literally shrunk?! However, the flat bagels were good. The bagels seems much flatter than usual. We ordered: toasted vegetable, scallion and pimento/olive toasted bagels and all the ordered we hardly were able to taste or bits of the flavorful cream cheeses, it felt more like regular cream cheese (not so fresh), which happened more than once! The iced coffee completely milked down and felt like milk and water vs ice coffee. This was extremely disappointing. read more

The young man taking the order got everything I ordered correct on the first try, the food is great and the service is fast. Great place to order out or sit down for breakfast, gives me an old school feel, where all client are familiar with the employees. Great service. read more

Bagel Club - the inside of a store - Bagels Near Me - Bayside, New York

I came into this business just to pick up some bagels and the staff was extremely rude. Not only that the service is PAINFULLY SLOW. You're wasting your time and money going to this place. You're better off just going to utopia bagels. read more

bagels are the worse ever . i don't mind spending for good food , but quality is horrible . stop here a few times before I head to highway . I have no idea how they stay in business bagel ends are hard . ordered egg sandwich ,the ham in it was hard and dry . I tossed both out . the fat heavy guy with the voice is rude and when you ask a question he seems like he is on another planet . next time i go back to bagels in 35 ave and clear view . hands down the best . also. another good place is in Whitestone on 14 Ave and 150. don't waste your time . and his prices are through the roof for the quality . read more

Ordered bagels to take home since our neighborhood bagel shop was closed (I think it's closed forever). It was so bad. It just tasted like bread. Didn't have the chewy exterior nor the soft inside. Used to live on bagels as a child/teen from our local bagel shop on 108th Street in Forest Hills. Now none of the bagels taste like that anymore!!! read more

Customer service is the worst, portions are small, very over priced, hit or miss if you actually get what you ordered. Don't waste your money. read more

Cashier always have an attitude, paid $5 for a cream cheese and jelly, waited 20mins and got cream cheese only on an old raisin bagel Never gonna order from here again read more

After coming here for the past six months, I went to Yelp just expecting to see confirmation of my view that this is a first-rate bagel shop. Seeing that there were so many negative reviews I decided to leave my own review. These are some of the best bagels that I've had in NYC, particularly the flats. Also, I've found the service to be extremely efficient and friendly. I really don't recognize the place from what some others are writing. read more

This was probably my WORST breakfast experience in my entire life as a New Yorker. I asked how much a bacon egg n cheese was n they told me $8.70, which I think is ridiculous because standout places like Pardon My Sub charge $6.50 or Dom's Deli in New Hyde Park charge $5.95 (and both places give a packed sandwich that is very filling and can even be shared by 2 people). I ordered simply bacon and cheese on a roll. They not only still charged an absurd price of $8.70 but it was simply 2 small pieces of bacon, 2 very cold, unmelted slices of American cheese on a stale roll. HORRIBLE FOOD. HORRIBLE PRICES. HORRIBLE SERVICE. I wish I would have checked before I left because I NEVER would have paid nearly $9 for the garbage they served. On top of it the man that packed it does not know how to wrap a sandwich in the paper because when I reached to take it out of the bag it unraveled and half the "sandwich" fell out. read more

Bagel Club - This is a horrible $8.70 overpriced 2 pieces of bacon with 2 cold slices of American cheese on a stale roll. - Bagels Near Me - Bayside, New York

hmmm i REALLY want to LOVE this place, it's convenient. it has parking. It's got great bagel spread. but it's just not quite there, especially given Utopia Bagels is only a mile away. If I am in a rush, i would go here over utopia bagels. Other than that, nah. My go to here? Sausage egg and cheese or jalapeno cream cheese on a sesame bagel. read more

This place sucks for such a premium area!!! Standing outside with 4 other customers at 6:10am when they are supposed to open at 6am, the employees just stand around telling jokes to each other. Even if the bagels aren't ready, I would take a wrap or a roll instead of leaving with nothing to be on time for work!!! STEP YOUR GAME UP!!! read more

This place is close to my house, but every time I come here I regret it. Their system for helping customers is the most inefficient I've ever seen. You have to line up twice: once to place the order and then again to receive the order and pay. (There is no reason they could not take payment at the time the order is placed -- the person taking the order is directly behind the cash register.) So instead of being able to grab your order when it's ready and leave, you have to continue to stand around to give them your money. It's even worse when you order and pay ahead of time because there is no separate pickup area to get helped quickly. Instead, you have to stand in the normal line or float around hoping someone will help you out (no one ever offers to). They are also totally disorganized and will leave pickup bags at various spots behind the counter, and sometimes do not even bring them out from the kitchen, so when you arrive and ask for your order they have to go hunt for it. Completely defeats the purpose of ordering in advance. Can't stand it. Food quality is mediocre, and unsurprisingly, they are slow to complete orders despite having a bunch of staff behind the counter. read more

The bagels and bialys could improve. They were closed today with a padlock no explanation

Bagel Club is located right next to the Cross Island Parkway in Baybridge Commons. There's a large parking lot which makes it very convenient to stop and quickly grab a bite to eat. The bagels are okay but nothing mind blowing. I've been here a few times and I find that the bagels are very inconsistent: sometimes they're yummy and fresh, while other times they're dense and hard. I once got a bagel that was so thin I thought I had accidentally ordered the flat bread. The workers are friendly but service is on the slower side. If you're ordering anything else besides a bagel with cream cheese, you'll have to wait a bit. Also, note that if you use a credit card, 3.95% is added to your purchase. read more

Bagel Club - Everything Bagel with Cream Cheese - Bagels Near Me - Bayside, New York

Not the worst bagel I've ever had but pretty darn close. Very dry. The thing about bagels is, not all bagels are good. There's a certain taste, texture, and airiness that makes a bagel amazing. This place has none of that. On top of the bad bagel the service is atrocious!!!! I worked in a bagel place in HS so I know a thing or two. There are 4 people behind the counter and many times they all would disappear. They each take a customer's order THEN make that order! Wtf?! There really should be two people designated on the grill, one person designated to making coffees and grabbing the bagels for the grill, and one person taking orders and ringing customers up. It's was so bad! 30 mins waiting in line then another 5 minutes to get my sandwich. This is New York for goodness sake. The line was long too. Especially after me. It was out the door and down the side walk. Doesn't matter, I won't be back. If you decide to go maybe call ahead for pickup. read more

Had my first bialy here and it was excellent. I ordered a plain lox with scallion cream cheese. They are located in a small shopping strip and there is a dining area outside with a shared free parking lot. Lobby area is spacious but with the current set up there is little room for a line which led to confusion for customers that was trying to find where the line began for placing orders. Store is clean, and everyone wore their mask properly. Highly recommend, looking forward to my next bialy. read more

Ridiculously priced for the portion I received. I Won't be back here and won't be telling people to come here. Brutal. read more

Bagel Club - $9 omelette - Bagels Near Me - Bayside, New York

I like the "Flat Bagels" - A bit disappointed; They could do quite a bit better. Service - especially during the busy morning hours is slow. I suppose the owners don't want to pay to have sufficient staffing. Bagels are OK; They sort of have a limited selection of "Extra Stuff" like Fresh Fruits Etc. Etc. Parking is great! - Awesome, if you are working over @ Ft. Totten. I was afraid to Order Eggs Sandwiches, because they were just too darn slow and the place was to busy. I think I would have overwhelmed everyone. read more

Bagel Club - Breakfast - Bagel Flat & Coffee - Bagels Near Me - Bayside, New York

See all

Not sure why this bagel shop has such low stars?? Their bagels are great and their Bacon Egg and Cheese Sandwiches are awesome. I think their BEC Sandwiches are the best in Bayside!! Friendly service and easy parking. Great coffee too!! read more

You ever go in a place 3 times to get the order right? I did and the person made me wait to get my bagel with cream cheese toasted. Some person with M hat needs an attitude adjustment. I made is loud and clear about my order. It's a toasted bagel with cream cheese not a complex sandwich. read more

While they open later than their competitor 1/2 mile away, I do appreciate the quality of their offerings. Once they do open, you still have to wait extra time for their variety. read more

I love how fresh the bagels are. Toppings are always fresh too. Nova on poppy w scallion cream ...10/10.

On August 14 my wife and I went into the Bagel Club to get a couple of bagels with cream cheese. There were several people working behind the counter. We waited for a few minutes until a young girl with glasses asked us if we were being served. We said no and gave her our order. And then we waited...and waited...and waited while other customers were being served...everyone except for my wife and me. So we left angry and hungry...never to return. The place is very inefficiently run read more

The egg sandwich was blah and coffee was tasteless. Come to think of it, even the bagel itself was tasteless.

Stopped in today for some egg bagel sandwiches which were pretty good. The bagels themselves were good (not the greatest I've had in NY but still good). Also picked up a dozen to bring back to Massachusetts. My family will be very happy. read more

Sat. 5-27-23: VERY DISAPPOINTING! 1, S-L-O-W service! (I mean like, VERY slow!) 2. Half the time, one of the (hispanic) counter people (who also prepares the sandwiches) does not understand instructions given to them in simple English AND therefor somehow/someway . . . manages to screw up the order. Good intent, VERY poor execution! 3. The "eat-in" area is a (DUMPY) mess. Boxes pilled everywhere, tables with recent customers leftovers - still on the table tops, UCH! 4. The customer bathroom is . . . borderline "filthy!". Ok, so today, I placed an order for a simple (egg) sandwich with a Capichino coffee. The sandwich was "OK", but the Capichino took 12 minutes (yup, you read correctly, 12 minutes) to make. So, by the time I received it, my egg sandwich was COLD! Who wants to eat a cold egg sandwich? NOT me! So, please note, I am OK with how long it took to make the Capichino (the machine had not been used recently, so he had to "set up" the machine. BUT, why didn't he tell me (in advance), that it was going to take 12 minutes - in which case, I would have ordered some other type of beverage. Just plain ole' "common sense", or . . . . . . lack thereof! So, all-in-ll my "dinning experience" here today - was VERRY DISAPPOINTING! I didn't bother asking for the manager, because if I had spoken to him, he would have "blown off" my complaint, and acted like he was going to do something about. But in real life, he wouldn't have given a (S - - T) about what the customer thinks! YOU KNOW IM RIGHT! Ever wonder why "small businesses" stay small? It's because they don't have the BRAIN capacity to (EVER) see the "big picture", or . . . even think five minutes ahead of themselves to avoid problems . . . thats why! read more

3 people in front of me were complaining that their breakfast orders were wrong. The obviously stoned young guy who took my order took his time with my order as he watched the other staff dealing with the wrong orders. I got my bag and went out to my vehicle and the order was wrong. Not even close to what I asked for. I won't be back , there are other bagel places in the vicinity. Maybe they can get the order right. read more

Love coming by to pick up my coffee and bagel. I can always try something new and tasty and I'm always satisfied.

I get anxiety going into this store. It's crowded only because of its location, not its quality. One time, I waited almost 30 mins for 4 bagels and a pound of creme cheese. There is no "line starts here" so everyone is standing around randomly and you don't know who's been served or not so you have to ask customers. And the friendly staff: They shout NEXT! with pusses on their faces. Once I placed my order, and they gave me blueberry muffins instead of bagels. I go back to the store, and I get an angry face and then I'm handed my bagels without a sorry for your inconvenience. Another time, I'm placing my order and the server interrupts me with a curt WHAT? Like I'm a mumbling idiot. And passing on the credit card merchant fee is laughable. What legitimate business does that? I hate this place and I'm done. read more

Bagels are good. Staff could be friendlier. Convenient in a pinch. They have a good assortment of bagels.

So I get there on Friday March 25th at 2:55pm and guess what? Doors locked already! It wasn't like there was customers already in there and that's why they locked the doors early. Is the owner aware of this??? I guess they don't care about customer service! read more