Heart bagels for Valentine's Day!!!! Called ahead and they held the last 2 for my sister and I. Fun and clean atmosphere. read more

Bagel Supreme - Bagels Near Me - Rutherford, New Jersey

See all

Of all the bagel spots in North NJ this might be the worst one. The employees' ignore you despite the customer having to question why a simple Breakfast Bagel should take 40+ Min to complete. Then when it's time to pick it up from the register it's cold and they refuse to make a warm one. Between the rude staff, high prices and lack of food safety you could not pay me to eat there again. read more

Bagel was okay. A little chewy. Also, I ordered iced coffee only to go around the corner and find a counter top ice machine. Not nearly enough to provide ice for the amount of customers. Staff was friendly they could have been attentive to wiping down tables between customers. Also- the time it took to wait in line and order and receive our food was quick. That was appreciated. Especially since there was a line out the door. Would not come again. read more

Solid bagel spot. Ordered the sausage egg and cheese bagel, delicious as always. People taking my order were nice. Cute fall decor inside. There is plenty of seating inside. read more

Good spot if you want a bagel, but it's ALWAYS packed, so be prepared for a long wait. Solid bagels, just plan ahead!

Visited a friend in the neighborhood who highly recommended the Lox bagel at this place. We got the lox on sundried tomato bagel, and Philly steak with egg & cheese on a rainbow bagel. The lox was generously portioned, right amount of cream cheese and lox. Just wished we had picked different bagel .... maybe cinnamon to give it a hit of sweetness. Philly steak with cheese & egg on rainbow bagel was soft and warm, but I will probably go with ham, egg & cheese next time !!! read more

Bagel Supreme - Bagels Near Me - Rutherford, New Jersey

Had to come here to get some NJ bagels while I'm in town and I was not disappointed!! Lots of options of bagels - some unique flavors too. Got a Bagel sandwhich and it was stuffed with goodness. Really great flavors and the Bagel was cooked perfectly. I love that outer crunch shell and the soft interior. That's what sets East Coast Bagels apart from West Coast Bagels. So good! Come here early if you want all the bagel choices - they definitely sell out of stuff. read more

See all

Welcoming and beautifully decorated for the Halloween season. Counter staff quick to help. Ordered my go to a bacon egg and cheese on a toasted bagel SPK. I chose a Russian bagel which is basically a pumpernickel with sesame seeds. Good selection of cold drinks, several different coffee and hot beverage stations. Also prepared yogurt parfaits and fruit salad cups. Serving Boars Head cold it's. Varied selection of cream cheeses. The basic chips and candy offering as well as local newspapers. Plenty of seating. Bathrooms for customers. Service was quick. The sandwich was delicious. The bacon was crispy without being greasy. They forgot my ketchup but not a big problem. Still enjoyed my breakfast! Worth the stop! read more

See all

Bagel Supreme is well known and is usually the busiest bagel place in town. We have visited multiple times but will probably not visit again. The prices are more expensive than many of the other places nearby. The bagels, are good but not great. The main reason for the 2 stars is the service. Multiple times we have gone here and witnessed who seems to be the manager either yelling at other customers or the workers. For the price you pay, and the service given, unfortunately it is not worth a visit with so many other options in the area. read more

so good my gf and i loved our bacon egg & cheese !! would come back here everyday easily read more

Bagel Supreme - quality food the bacon egg & cheese was perfection ! - Bagels Near Me - Rutherford, New Jersey

As we were driving by this bagel shop, there was a line out the door. So I said to my wife, we have to give it a shot. She wasn't feeling the vibe of finding parking and waiting, but she took one for the team. There's street parking which we did a few laps around until we found a spot a few blocks away. They were very organized inside and the place was very clean. There system worked well and the wait was very minimal. I got the Supreme Special which was Taylor Ham, Egg, cheese, potatoes and hashbrowns on a round roll. The sandwich was excellent except for the fact that there was almost no cheese on it. With the exception of that, it was very tasty and well put together. My wife and son got a sausage egg and cheese. My wife was not that thrilled about it and my son came in the living room and asked, "What's this?" There was only sausage on one half of his sandwich. Not sure how that happened, but it did. All in all, the line didn't reflect what my expectations were. Decent place if you're local but I wouldn't go out of my way to come back. read more

See all

Food is good. I seriously hate going in there though. The service is always bad unless its this one hispanic lady and a tall man. Theres is this one woman who is ALWAYS RUDE with an attitude for no reason at all. Im always kind to everyone but it is very difficult with her because she always acts like she is disgusted by you. Also, if its not empty, it will have a white person/family (likely racist) who needs to stare at you while you wait for your order. Not the best place, but the food is good so i have mixed feelings. I believe good customer service is essential for running a business. This place definitely does not have that. read more

So I've been here multiple times. Never overly impressed. First off, stay away from the coffee, its absolutely awful! Think of your worst Jersey diner coffee and you know what I mean. The staff is pleasant enough but got my order wrong, again. There's plenty of bagels for your perusal but there's no description of what bagel is what. You probably don't need a Bagel PHD to tell a blueberry from an everything but come on, it's common bagel shop etiquette. The interior is kinda no-frills but the do try their best to decorate for each holiday. As for the bagels. They are good, but nothing to go out of your way for. read more

Bagel Supreme - The bagels with no descriptions - Bagels Near Me - Rutherford, New Jersey

See all

was charged $29 ordered 3 bagels with Taylor ham, egg and cheese - I have no issue paying delivery fee and tip but VERY disappointed in the lack of egg and meat in the sandwich. They legit had 1 egg and 1 slice of taylor ham (I took pics of anyone is interested in seeing them). First and LAST time ordering from here read more

Bagel Supreme - Bagels Near Me - Rutherford, New Jersey

Great bialys! Stopped in one morning because I'm on a mission to try all the bagel shops in the area. This one is definitely popular. There was a line as soon as I walked in. I loved the decor inside, super spring time festive. The staff was really friendly. I ordered a BLT and a Taylor ham egg and cheese. Once I saw the bialys I had to try them. Very similar to a flagel, I liked it. The Taylor ham I got on a bagel and it was good too, not a home run but definitely good. The bagel was crispy outside and chewy on the inside. They have a huge selection of sandwiches too. Lots of lunch time items. Their bagel selection is great too, lots of cream cheese spreads as well. I would definitely come back here, service was very quick and the food is good. What more can you ask for from a breakfast place? Oh they also have a great selection of desserts! read more

See all

For what it's worth, the service is a very fast, and the ambiance is clean. Good bagel and breakfast sandwich place. I'd encourage you to come in and check it out for yourself and not worry about not getting a delicious breakfast. Parking, while unrelated, is always easy to get out front. The sandwich 'slaps' as they say and is what you're looking for. Not enormous and unreasonably large so it's probably as much as a person should have of this in one sitting. I'm pleased. The coffee is good, and you have a few flavors to choose from like hazelnut. And they have flavored syrups you can add. I did find the cookies, which while cute and convenient, to lack the lemon flavor in the cake and fudge flavor in the frosting. Also, the carrot cake was a little dry. Overall, I ate them all with no hesitation. read more

See all

Gave here a try a few days ago. I enjoyed it. I thought the bagels were tasty and the bacon, egg and cheese sandwich they made was very good. Ordering was a bit of an adventure, I saw other comments about the staff getting confused. I did have to repeat my order a few times. But the order was right in the end. Would come back here. 2 bagel sandwiches, 2 bagels as is to go for about 10 bucks. read more

Bagel Supreme - Bacon egg and cheese on an everything bagel - Bagels Near Me - Rutherford, New Jersey

See all

Wow, without the lovely owner truly running things like when it started, it has went down hill fast. The sandwiches are not that at all! It's like eating if you were scrapping together your last deli meats you had until next month because of money issues. The bagels are tough my lord. The guy in the back is awesome! Alway wears a hat. The short Hispanic lady, listen, you don't want to work or do your job don't be there because I have heard many people not going there just because of the attitude. One lady amazing, thinner, heavy accent but she tries to carry everyone's duties/ so does the guy. LOVE THE OWNER, her FAMILY! But love, don't let your workers be the down fall of what you worked for. I just don't go here anymore. :( read more

This place has an amazing assortment of bagels, wraps, and sandwiches. The prices are quite fair and the service is friendly. I would have left five stars had one of our wraps had not contained a huge, hard lettuce core. Other than that , i would return. PS.... good coffee, too! read more

Bagel Supreme - a person eating a sandwich - Bagels Near Me - Rutherford, New Jersey

Food and service is so good, one problem, the customers. Suprised I had to say this but on my way to new York for business I stopped by this small restaurant, i ordered my food and sat down just to see customers constantly yelling at the employees. "You did this wrong" " don't give me that" was I all I hear while trying to eat. The workers were literally running back and forth to help the stampede of impatient customers. Most of them just order then walk out the door, leaving the dying business to lose more money. It disgusted me to experience the inhumane acts of these New Jersey citizens. If you're trying to move to the east coast, just remember you're on your own. read more

Yall BETTER show up to bagel supreme!! on my momma this food delicious as hell and everyone was nice. Plus the smell was good and scenery was like a regular 5 star restaurant so I can't expect less. I love this place read more

very slow impersonal service, nothing special about their bagels except OUTRAGEOUS prices, taylor ham, 1 piece cheese on a small bagel $7.20, $3.50/tax for a small bagel with cream cheese. NEVER AGAIN read more

Is there a bigger crime to humanity than a bagel with absolutely zero crust/crunch?! Just some blob of barely cooked dough that you might find at the counter of some dingy diner that looks more like a life preserver than a delicious breakfast food? Thankfully Bagel Supreme have earned their moniker. Their bagels have that great balance of being soft and chewy, not too fatty and the perfect texture on that outer layer when you're biting in. The variety (Black Russian! Rainbow! Sundried Tomato!) rivals that of the more popular places a town over. And there's ample sitting here as well. Two gripes: the street parking is pretty rough... it's a small popular block with limited spots on either side of the street. And if you go when they've just opened up (5am): nothing is ready. I've waited and gone at 5:30 only to have maybe half of the baskets have bagels. But if you go too late in the morning - the place is packed to the rafters, even with the small army of workers behind the counter. read more

Bagel Supreme - Seriously delicious bagels... - Bagels Near Me - Rutherford, New Jersey

So this place has a very special place in my heart because I lived across the street from this place. I remember when they first opened, it was a hole in the wall. Word got out real quick in town that their bagels were amazing. Kids in town used to go out of their way to get lunch here and grab something before going to school in the am. After some time, the hole in the wall expanded and they completely remodeled. My brother went to school with the son of the people that owned the business and they were also our neighbor in our condo after the business grew. Great people that knew a thing or two about bagels. When my brother asked his classmate what the secret was, he said "the water." The reason why NYC has amazing pizza and bagels is because of the water. They actually import water from NYC for their bagels. Like wow! For NJ, especially the town of Rutherford, that is just amazing! Living in NYC and being a Yelper I guess, I am quite a snob when it comes to my bagels. My all time fave is just down the block from me and I stand by it, but my place does not do sausage, egg and cheese all that well because they microwave that stuff...So sort of killing a perfect bagel with terrible fixings. When I want a sausage, egg, and cheese, I go here. The bagel may not be NYC best, but it is up there. With a griddle cooked sausage, egg, and cheese moment, wow! I want one now! Now, one thing I will have to note is that their baked goods are not that good. I think they are outsourced so can't really dinged them for that. However, their muffins, rolls, bagels, and smears are all delicious. Their lemon poppyseed muffins used to be my favorite growing up, but they didn't have it all the time. My family and I no longer live across the street, but I do make my brother take me for a everything bagel sandwich whenever I am visiting Jersey and am craving a proper sandwich. If you live in Rutherford, you NEED to go. Can't really say you are a Rutherfordian unless you've had one of these. This place has become so iconic that any proper Rutherfordian knows this place. If you know, you know.. read more

the food was great and service was quick and friendly. the inside was very calm and quaint. read more

Bagel Supreme - blueberry bagel with blueberry cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Rutherford, New Jersey

Service is awful. Extremely slow. I went in when nobody was in the bagel shop. They have six workers that sit behind the counter do nothing and you wait 15-20 minutes for bagel. Lacking in the customer service. read more

Great tasty bagels. Clean establishment and courteous service. My onion bagel tasted great! Much better then bagels stores at Bob's in Lyndhurst, worth the drive to neighboring town. Recommend the onion bagel and whole wheat everything! Seating inside. Parking is metered outside, but can always get parking spot. read more

See all

I used to come here all the time, but unfortunately the service isn't what it used to be. They still don't have vegan cream cheese like many of their competitors nearby. The other bagel stores in town have veggie and scallion tofu spread. Many people are vegan or lactose intolerant, so it makes it a pain when you're grabbing bagels for a road-trip and we have to go somewhere else to accommodate everyone. read more

Good food but honestly, can they get an order right for once. I do like the food but I've learned my lesson to ask them to repeat the order back because it seems like they just write what they think they hear. This has happened often. So I take a break, go back and it happens again. I might just give up now anyway. Also if the French toast bagel is the most popular why stop making them after 10am? SMH read more

The food here is good especially the bagels. Customer service is another story. Although having over four people behind the counter, no one acknowledged me or a man standing in back of me in line to place an order. He left first after more than 5 minutes and I stayed for a few more minutes. There was a young man behind the counter, doing nothing in particular. I can appreciate the others were preparing orders but the store was not crowded. Acknowledge who comes in and say we'll be right with you or at least just nod. It was actually comical how they avoided looking in our direction. I then left went down the street to Steve and Andreas for a breakfast order. It's a different story when someone who I presume is the owner and a younger man who appears to be related to him are there. Even if it is busy and crowded, they are very hospitable and things move quickly. Don't mind waiting but to be ignored is insulting to customers. read more

I don't know why they are like this. But I never been anywhere where the employees act as if you don't exist for such along time before they a knowledge you are standing there for a while . Weather they r busy or not it's the same slow walk slow service. At times I feel it's faster if I go behind the counter and get my own food and take few other customers as well while I am at it. They make sure to finish their conversation and jokes before they ask if they can help you . Am at the point to start making my own bagels so I won't have to stop by. I regret going every time I want to get bagels. read more

A great place to grab breakfast or lunch and go. I usually call ahead and it's ready in 10 minutes or less. The line to pay is long sometimes at peak breakfast hours or on holidays, but that can be expected at any deli. I live for bagel sandwiches, my favorite being egg, cheese and potato. The area around my town is heavily populated with stores, so the competition is pretty tough. The bagels here are pretty thick, but they make sure to load up your sandwich contents to make up for it. Despite using it for take out most of the time, I do prefer staying in. The overall ambiance and unique decor in the place makes it feel cozy. I'll have to add more photos of the inside next time I get a bagel to stay. Overall a great local spot with friendly service and good food. read more

Bagel Supreme - Potato egg and cheese on a plain bagel - Bagels Near Me - Rutherford, New Jersey

See all

Excellent customer service, the ladies behind the counter are so friendly and ready to have a laugh with the customers . They will make you feel at home . Bagel are fresh and cream cheese taste home made. The shop also has fresh homemade muffins Salads sandwiches soda etc Shop looks and feels clean and fresh Will come back for their great customer service , And great bagel options .. read more

Bagel Supreme - Egg and cheese on a multigrain , - Bagels Near Me - Rutherford, New Jersey

They are never welcoming when I come in and I have to chase them to put my order. Today, the lady couldn't figure out how to make my wrap even though it's on the menu on their wall. She asked me many questions and studied the menu. Then I came home and found out she forgot the main ingredient, cheese. It was a mozzarella cheese wrap without the cheese ‍ so disappointing. Plus she put so much vinaigrette that it was leaking all over the place. My sandwich was soggy. Garbage. read more

I still don't know why the owner/management haven't fired the entire staff and get new trained one. Those workers are rhetorical rudest people ever. They do not acknowledge you AT ALL! You have to chase them down. They take their sweet time, they show no remorse whatsoever that you've been waiting in life for 25 minutes. I come here often cause I like the food and always order the same thing all the time ... but everytime I come they charge me different prices. read more

This must be the slowest work staff in town. People just walk out due to having to go work. Usually a place has people making the sandwiches while another makes the simple bagel and cream cheese. Not this place. No sense of hurry. They don't seem to care that their customers have jobs. read more

Unfortunately have to give this place one star. Had a really bad experience here where the person who took my order (a larger order for mother's day) completely messed it up. The employee didn't give us the butter we asked for and then proceeded to argue with me that I told him I didn't want it anymore....? Weird but okay... then we opened the bag to find we only had 1/2 lb of cream cheese even though I paid for 1lb. To top it off, the large box of coffee we ordered was filled so high that it spilled all over the place when we opened it. I called to explain what happened, and the manager said he'd take care of us when we came in next time. Well, we went in today, got bagels and a couple OJ's and water. The kicker?? We were charged for the drinks lol. Like really?? $5?? Never going back here. read more

This place has the worst customer service of any bagel store, deli,I have ever been to. Last two times I was there,I stood at the counter for what seemed like 5 minutes, nobody approached to take my order. Both times I left vowing not to come back. This time I'll be sticking to my word,lots of other great bagel shops in the area. read more

Constantly gets order wrong and now when I call and complain they tell me "its not my fuckin problem" . Never do business with them.

This has always been my favorite bagel place in town, but today it fell short. The bagels are great. Soft, doughy with a nice crust and always fresh. Ordered an everything bagels with Taylor ham, egg and cheese. They skimped on the Taylor ham. All the bagels only had one piece of Taylor ham. They used to put 3-4 pieces. The service is pretty fast considering there's always a line on a weekend morning. Great tasting bagels, but a big let down when it came to filling today. I'll give them another chance, hopefully they don't let me down next time. read more

Bagel Supreme - Taylor ham egg and cheese on everything bagel (only one slice of ham) - Bagels Near Me - Rutherford, New Jersey

See all