I went here quite by accident - but it was a great mistake...! The staff was extremely friendly and helpful. And the bagels are terrific! Nicely sized yet soft and easy to eat. Too many places have smaller, tough bagels - If you hate that kind, you'll love Bagelicious bagels! read more

There is no butter on this bagel & it tastes like margarine, not real butter. Yikes:( read more

Bagelicious Cafe - Bagel with butter (? Tastes like margarine) - Bagels Near Me - Port Jefferson Sta, New York

Im just going to leave this here you well out of my 21 years living I've never felt the urge to leave a review I went in the other day all the ladies behind the counter we're talking about cheating on their boyfriends followed by a whole bunch of high school nonsense. I patiently waited there for three of my bagels and one egg sandwich. I waited there for 20 minutes, looked at my Life360 to double check then upon receiving my items, I was very rudely treated I Only got one egg sandwich and two cream cheese, and my bagels are sitting behind the counter the whole time while the owner and a couple other ladies were making jokes and being very unprofessional, then when I asked about it, they gave me an attitude the blonde dude started speaking Turkish to some girl then they took my cream cheese bagel and threw it inside of the microwave for 10 seconds.. I couldn't even process what I just witnessed and the service i received‍ and on top of that the prices made me lol read more

I was extremely disappointed with my bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich from Bagelicious. For the prices being charged, customers should expect quality and reasonable portions, but that was not my experience at all. The sandwich appeared to have only a single strip of bacon broken into several tiny pieces. There was so little bacon that it was barely noticeable. The cheese was even more disappointing, it looked like only a small corner of a slice had been added. I'm not exaggerating when I say it was difficult to find. The eggs were bland and lacked any real flavor, making the entire sandwich underwhelming from start to finish. What makes this even more frustrating is the cost. If you're going to charge premium prices, then the product should reflect that. Customers should not feel shortchanged when they open their food. There is a difference between managing costs and skimping on ingredients. When people pay hard-earned money for a breakfast sandwich, they expect a fair amount of bacon, a full slice of cheese, and ingredients that are prepared with care. The overall impression was that corners were being cut while prices remained high. A bacon, egg, and cheese is a simple classic, but it still requires quality ingredients and reasonable portions to be worth the money. Unfortunately, this sandwich missed the mark on both flavor and value. I hope management takes customer feedback seriously because no one should leave feeling like they paid top dollar for the bare minimum. read more

Very distasteful bagel store. Paid $38 for 3 egg sandwiches with ONE slice of bacon on top of everything being cooked incorrectly read more

Bagelicious Cafe - Bagels Near Me - Port Jefferson Sta, New York

See all

OMMFG...what a dumpster fire this place is. Stopped in at 7am this morning, 11/7, for breakfast. Ordered one fried egg on a roll SPK, and two Italian Jelly Cookies. I even pointed directly to which cookies I was asking for. They made me TWO SCRAMBLED EGGS on a roll that had half a gallon of ketchup on it, and put two giant wrapped sprinkle cookies in the bag. These cookies were on top of the counter, and nowhere near the Italian Jelly Cookies I specifically requested and pointed to - the jelly cookies were in the pastry case underneath the counter. I kept having to repeat myself that I wanted the jelly cookies. They had no clue what I was talking about. How the f do you sell something, and not even know the name of it? In addition, there was a man standing next to me who was obviously going through a difficult time, so as I was paying for my incorrect order, I told the cashier I wanted to pay for the man's breakfast. SHE HAD ABSOLUTELY NO IDEA WHAT IT WAS I WAS SAYING TO HER! She kept looking at me like I had three heads. I had to repeat myself THREE TIMES, and finally said forget it. Not one person behind the counter had proper command of the English language. One more clueless than the next. read more

Bagel sandwiches are horrible here. Charge insane prices and the sausage on my sandwich would've been too small for a slider...Trust the reviews. Bagel deli gourmet off Jayne is where it's at read more

DONT WASTE YOUR TIME, GO TO BAGEL DELI GOURMET. This is the worst deli I've ever experienced. And outrageously overpriced for the quality of food they produce. Not only is that horrible the customer service is so bad and I tried to give them the benefit of the doubt by going a second time only to get more of an attitude by unhappy workers. Very disappointing. Also I rarely ever review places. So this speaks volumes that I felt the need to read more

I never write reviews. This is the fourth time I've come into this store. Everytime I've come in there's been issues with my orders. It's one thing to make a mistake and apologize for it during a busy hours of the morning. I can understand that. However, if you're going to charge $40 for two egg sandwiches and a corn muffin it better be correct the first time. Not only was my order incorrect, but by the time they fixed it, and I was waiting there by the counter the deli clerk that took my order didn't even have the audacity to let the clerk running the register know my order was fixed! So I stood there for an additional to 10 minutes to be handed my simple order of a corn muffin....toasted with butter. Communication poor. Service poor. Prices are horrible. read more

I was actually heading for a store next to this Bagel Shop. Maybe an egg sandwich, and the store is empty with at least four women and a man behind the counter. So I order an egg sandwich and then decide to get a sandwich for lunch. While waiting, all four women took turns asking if we had been helped. I guess then for good measure the man asked. So waiting waiting waiting. About 29 minutes for an egg sandwich and a panini. Still no one else in the store. The one of the women lifts the plate on the panini maker to take phone calls. Unbelievable. Next, breakfast sandwich comes with juice, but if you don't ask you don't get it. Also panini comes with a choice of potato salad, macaroni salad, or coleslaw. Again, don't ask you don't get. Two stars? Well one of the TV's playing was Turkish TV broadcasting about the very recent earthquake there. Unfortunately not in English, but I guess a public service. Do I plan on ever returning? You already know the answer to that question. read more

This is the second time I have come to this place and disappointed both times. Bagel is below average and they are really a little crazy with their prices. Overpriced for below average. Doesn't sit well with me. read more

Screw this place went there too plain poppy bagels was $3.51, and they weren't even fresh. Taking advantage of the consumer.

Stopped into [bagelious cafe] hoping to start my day with a decent bagel and a smile. Got neither. Let's begin with the food: the bagel was tragically dry, like it had been left out during a sandstorm. I asked for it toasted--they warmed it just enough to disappoint me. The cream cheese? A sad smear that looked like it lost the will to live halfway through being spread. But the real highlight was the associate behind the counter. I'm not sure if I walked into a café or interrupted someone's personal existential crisis. I said, "Good morning," and was met with a sigh so deep I felt like I owed them therapy. I asked for an iced coffee and got a cup of bitter regret--both in taste and tone. When I politely mentioned that my order was wrong, the associate blinked slowly, said "whatever," and wandered off like a ghost of customer service past. I watched them argue with the espresso machine for five minutes, and I'm still not sure who won. In short: The bagel was bad. The coffee was worse. The associate clearly hated their job--and after visiting, I kind of did too. read more

I have worked next-door to this place for three years. I tried time after time to give them the benefit of the doubt because they seem to always have an excuse but at this point after three years, you can't get a simple order right this is unacceptable. This place charges way too much For anything that you order just for them to get it wrong. read more

Waited about 20 minutes for 3 bagels. 2 with crème cheese and 1 without anything. About 7 customers were helped before me, including someone who ordered a dozen bagels. Then when I finally got my bagels, they put crème cheese on the one I asked for nothing on. So frustrating! They always do this too! Never coming back read more

Terrible service! After waiting 30 minutes for our order they shorted us 1 sandwich. Will never go back! 30 minutes for BEC?? Crazy!

I will never embody this place again. After ordering 2 bagels with cream cheese and one without they took 20 minutes to get all three bagels and check out while there were people just walking in ordering bigger orders and getting rung up faster. Then they finally finished our order but waited to ring us up till they made a few more order then rang us up. Then we got to the car and 2 bagels were correct but one had cream cheese when we specifically told them no cream cheese. read more

The service was absolutely amazing! The nicest ladies work here. Soo patient and it was spotless in here

Got a plain egg bagel with creamcheese and it was amazing! the workers were so kind and it was $4.01 which is good. I see reviews about the staff but they showed me nothing but respect and let me pay only $4 in singles instead of the 4.01 since i didnt have one cent laying around. Nice vibe and looked well inside. Had a wide variety of drinks and I would come back! read more

Bagelicious Cafe - a half eaten bagel - Bagels Near Me - Port Jefferson Sta, New York

First off, the two young girls working were so rude from the second I walked in and were clearly talking about me- my eyelashes to be exact (I'm good at reading lips) and staring at me while doing so, before I even got a hello or how can I help you...? So weird and bratty lol. I always walk in with a smile and am polite soo I'm not sure what that was about. Then I get my bagel- I asked for an egg everything bagel with veggie cream cheese- not a pound of veggie cream cheese with a bagel... honestly, who the hell wants this much cream cheese on their bagel?!?! Holy crap. I know they have to put a certain amount but damnnnn. Do less. read more

Bagelicious Cafe - a person holding a bagel with cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Port Jefferson Sta, New York

See all

Good management and ownership, little expensive but bagels are top tier and would recommend to get a straight bagel here not a sandwich of any sorts!! read more

what a rip off. no excuses. a bagel with lox for 13.00 is ridiculous. it's more than what i pay in the city. and they don't even offer capers so screw your rip off bagel. Never ever ever coming back this place. for that price you could at least afford a renovation and better quality bagel. this bagel is so dense and not at all what i would be expecting for $13.00. you may as well be eating a sugarless pound cake. bye no thank you ever again. read more

Bagelicious Cafe - a sandwich with cheese and salmon - Bagels Near Me - Port Jefferson Sta, New York

Many people "working" behind the counter ignoring several people on line, when I did get to order the person seemed to hardly speak English or understand what I was saying. When the two sandwiches came out and they rung me up it was $17 for, 1. two eggs bacon cheese on a bagel and 2. two eggs scrambled turkey and swiss. Nothing special to write about. I will be continuing to go to Better on a Bagel Express, which has far superior breakfast sandwiches for a considerable $$ less. read more

Been around for years with delicious bagels, great sandwiches, and my favorite whole wheat rolls. Staff is always helpful and happy.

Terrible cook doesn't know how to cook Eggs bacon was Cold Choc milk was warm and for 2 eggs bacon plater no potatoes no toast and a choc milk All for $13.95 Don't go read more

if you order delivery your food will not be good. Your bread will be burnt even if you say lightly toasted and they flip it on the lightest side knowing the other side is burnt to a black complexion.. Everytime I order they do the same thing with my toast or bagel instead of just making it over. Then when you call to complain they don't want you to speak to the manager they say they will refund you next time and then next time they act like they have a loss of memory.. It's only right you prepare customers food order properly because the prices are not cheap!! The manger needs to supervisor the food that is being prepared or else he will lose loyal customers. read more

Not even one star!!! My husband ordered a bacon egg and cheese on a bagel and I ordered sausage egg and cheese on a bagel, two 14oz orange juices, and medium iced coffee. The total was 32.15 I was beyond in complete shock. I questioned why it was expensive and the people who worked there became nasty and said it's what I ordered. I ordered a black iced coffee and the lady gave me a iced coffee with milk and gave me the nastiest look. Workers are not nice here don't go here. read more

Disorganized. Ignore people standing in line. Finally after serving probably the 5th a customer who came in after me I asked the customer if they could see me. The poor customer apologized but not the staff, even after I spoke up. Mistakes happen but no excuse for a customer facing staff who don't appear to want to help people. read more

Absolutely delicious bagels, staff is quick and ready to assist. Great prices. Thank you!

This is one of my favorite bagel places! I love getting a fresh egg everything bagel with strawberry cream cheese! They are also great for egg sandwiches, and if you go in before 9 (maybe 10?) you get a free coffee, tea, or orange juice! The staff is very nice and friendly as well. Also, if you buy 12 bagels you get two free and if you order six you get on free! The only reason that I am giving it four and not five stars is because they often have a long line and run out of some types of bagels due to high volume of customers. read more

Bagelicious Cafe - Egg everything with strawberry cream cheese and bacon egg and cheese - Bagels Near Me - Port Jefferson Sta, New York

See all

9.50 for a sausage egg and cheese after waiting 10 minutes in an empty store. Nothing special though. Same exact sandwich 2 towns over cost 5.50 and tastes better. I almost just turned around and left but my son was very hungry. Why would I ever come back to this place to spend 9.50 on a plain old breakfast sandwich that I could make at home for 2$? There is a difference between convenience and just getting plain ripped off. read more

Everything here is good. The people here are very nice & it gives an overall friendly atmosphere.

8.19 cash price for BECSPK when I can get one for at least $2 less at my normal spot. Nothing extra added to it. It was dry and not that great. read more

This place is a waste of money. We order two egg bagels one with cream cheese and one with lox and cream cheese. We get home and open our wrapped bagels and find two disgusting bagels that were like cardboard and tough, not edible plus we paid for lox AND cream cheese and got some gross lox spread. We will never go back here again! We should have learned when we went there a few months ago but said well maybe it was an off day so we tried it again. It definitely wasn't an off day and the food we received today after giving this place a second chance proved it. read more

I don't know if this place changed owners?.but normally Bagelicious was always so so,.the food was decent , I mean as far as breakfast sandwiches go.Now, I won't order a breakfast sandwich anywhere else,Excellent delicious egg sandwiches,Great job to new Management.! read more

I went there with an advice and now i am addicted to their bagels. The stuff is very friendly the food is so delicious. It is the best bagel store in the town. read more

I've been trying several bagel stores for a few months and I can clearly say that this place is the best you can ever find On Long Island. The store is always very clean and neat. They've large selection of food. Their staff is very fast and friendly even when they're busy. The owners are extremely nice people and the most important thing is all the food they have is VERY FRESH. I highly recommend this place. read more

wish i could give zero stars. if you want the most expensive bacon egg and cheese you've ever payed for on the island while also having it taste like it came out of a microwave come here! service is terrible and they tried to charge me 3.00$ for a arizona. read more

I have been coming to bagelicious for years as I used to live just up the block, and finally stopped in for a bagel when I was craving a good one! The store is always packed and they have a pretty massive selection of bagels and cream cheeses. I went with my standard everything bagel with jalapeno cream cheese and it was very good. Not spicy enough for me, but still had good flavor. I also had an order of home fries which could have also used more spice (they used to be quite hot!) but very good nonetheless. Will be back when I'm in the area! read more

If you write down an order you would almost expect to it be correct when you get home. 6 bagels read right off a list and of course it's not right. They have signs all over the place about how pricing has gone up on everything well if that's the case you should get things right read more