Bagels Your Way Cafe

Maggie's would fit right in on the beach in Brighton as a seaside eatery. It is bright, airy,…read morecheery, and colorful. It is a very welcoming environment. The epoxy counter is a comic book lover's delight from which to order. My wife and I entered for an early dinner. We walked up to the counter and ordered our entrees. I had the fish and chips, my wife ordered a burger. Not being beer conoscenti, we left the choice to the waiter/chef. Within fifteen minutes our orders were ready. The cod and French fries I ordered were delicious! My wife also found her entree excellent. The beer was cold, dark gold, and tasty. The portion to price aspect was a bit lacking: the entree could have contained a fourth piece of cod instead of three. The Takeaway: 1. Excellent food 2. Pricy 3. Great beach vibes for ambiance 4. Good beer 5. Excellent parking 6. No reservations needed I would have given four and a half stars if the program permitted.

We decided last minute to do lunch and I remembered someone talking about this place. It was our…read morefirst time here. It's adorable. Small but spacious and bright and cheerful vibe. We were greeted upon arrival. I had the chopped cheese with fries and it was SO GOOD. My husband had the double cheeseburger with bacon and he's a burger snob and loved it! We will definitely be back!

See all

Joey Z's

4.3(493 reviews)

2.4 mi

Decided to order takeout on this day and another reason why I love Port Jefferson, NY, is because…read moreof close proximity available from the Danfords Hotel. Last year, I was in Port Jefferson and had dinner at Joey Z's. Classic and traditional style Italian food. The pizza had a thin, crispy crust and texture

Stopped into Joey Z's for nice Italian meal while in Long Island and Port Jefferson seemed like a…read moregood lively spot. The place is tight but I prefer to call it intimate. Staff was nice and helpful. Ordered the calamari rings to start and they were nice and fresh as well as a good portion size. Glass of wine was more like a goblet. They really fill you up so be prepared. For entree, I ordered the Branzini which was perfectly cooked and the crust was just right. The veggies and sweet potato were also very nice. Overall the service and food were great. Definitely a recommended spot for an Italian meal.

Outside

See all

Chocolate Brownie

Prohibition Port Jefferson

4.2(340 reviews)

2.4 mi

Food was absolutely delicious and amazing!! People are super friendly!! Highly recommendread more

Food is just alright, heavy on the grease and on the expensive side. Everything was just okay…read more Onion rings were crunchy but more over fryer than needed. Burgers are alright but lacked differential elements and expensive for add ons AND sides($2-$4 such as bacon, cheese, onion rings, garlic fries, etc). Pretzel was decent for size but greasy. Is filling on the bright side for the sheer volume of food. Service has dine in and ambiance is dark but quant. 7.6/10

BBQ Grilled Cheese

See all

Old Fashioned

Better On A Bagel - Miller Place

4.0(64 reviews)

1.8 mi

Absolutely the best bagels -- soft, fresh, and perfectly chewy! You can really taste the quality…read more Easily my new go-to spot for breakfast!

Always fresh and soft bagels! Reasonable pricing. Friendly staff that's always on the move to get…read moreyour order and keeps the line moving. Great egg sandwiches too! The only bagel shop I'll go to

Everything bagel with cream cheese

Business closed

See all

Local's Cafe

4.2(274 reviews)

2.4 mi

placed a doordash order online and didn't receive my drink. i went in to see if i could get a new…read moreone, and the girl behind the counter was more then accommodating. the service here has always been great, and their banana foster latte is so good! i really recommend this place. also wanted to edit and say that it was not their fault it was doordashes.

This place saved our coffee. After a coffee fiasco in…read moreanother place we stopped here. And the shop has a basement scent type of vibe but the coffee was good. The lady at front nice and We were surprised to see the traffic of people ordering food and beverages. Other than the visual everything was nice.

Chocolate Chip Walnut Cookie ($3)

See all

Blueberry Lavender Fresh brewed ice tea

PJ Sushi Teriyaki

4.1(198 reviews)

1.9 mi

The food was very good and prices were reasonable. I'll definitely come back.Highly recommend !read more

Love their food and quick service. We always call ahead to pick up. The restaurant is perfect for…read moreour needs. They also have some decent takoyaki which I love.

Alligator Roll ~ 3.24.26

See all

Spicy Tuna Roll spicy salmon with avocado chicken tempura roll

Ruvo

4.1(572 reviews)

2.3 mi

•$$$

Food always consistently great and staff is always friendly…read more Love the live music. Would recommend to friends and family

Great place with vibe and food. They have enormous portion…read moresize. Food was great. We got $60. 3 courses meal. Ordered flatbread, fresh salad, chicken Tuscany, meatball pasta, cheesecake. The size of the flatbread and meatballs were great. Very satisfying. Of course we had to pack leftover home Just server was too slow and keep missing what we asked. But everything else was great. Def coming back for Thursday lobster nights

Bar area

Flourless peanut butter, chocolate cake

See all

Pinot Noir

Colosseo

4.1(399 reviews)

1.2 mi

New to the area and we've been looking for a new pizza spot...WE FOUND IT!! Pizza was AMAZINGread more

Stopped by Colosseo Pizza recently and it felt like stepping right back into my childhood. I used…read moreto come here all the time as a kid, and even though it's been years, that same no-frills, neighborhood pizza place energy is still very much alive. We started by sharing a salad and WOW. Do not skip it. It's one of those simple Italian salads that somehow just hits perfectly, and adding the mozzarella is an absolute must. Fresh, generous portions, and way better than you'd expect from a classic pizza joint. I could've eaten the whole thing myself and been happy. We each grabbed a slice and shared some garlic knots, which were warm, soft, and loaded with garlic flavor (aka exactly what you want). The slices were classic New York-style, nothing overdone, just solid, comforting pizza that reminds you why these spots never go out of style. The menu keeps things simple in the best way. Pizza, slices, and, salads. All the staples you expect, no unnecessary extras. It makes ordering easy and keeps the focus on what they do well. You're not here for trendy toppings or experimental flavors, you're here for reliable, satisfying food. The vibe inside is super casual and welcoming. It feels like a true local spot where regulars come in, families stop by, and no one's trying too hard. The staff were friendly and easygoing, which just adds to the comfort factor. I'm already looking forward to coming back, and next time, I might just order that salad for myself.

The pizza options

Extra cheeses and mushroom...soo good!

See all

Town & Country Market

4.0(54 reviews)

2.0 mi

The school where I work always has a welcome back lunch for staff. In Covid, couldn't have…read moretraditional grab and go buffet. Town & Countey made us all individually wrapped brown bag lunches. The sandwiches were fresh, delicious and loaded. I had the chicken salad and it was awesome. Tomatoes you could tell were so fresh. This deli is not that close to me, but next time I need sandwiches, heroes etc I'm taking the trip to here.

Service is friendly, but they are understaffed and you will be waiting forever for your food. First…read moretime I ordered, items were missing (no hash browns, no drink). French toast was raw in the middle. Decided to try again, preordered and went to pick up. As I waited, I saw about 4-5 flies buzzing behind the counter and sitting on the individually wrapped pastries, so I decided to cancel and never return.

BLT...with a a very small b for the bacon...for the price i expect way more

Established 2009

See all

Great deli

Toast Coffeehouse

3.9(882 reviews)

1.4 mi

Toast Coffeehouse has a great rustic barn-style look while still feeling warm and comfortable,…read moreespecially with the cozy booths. The space itself is large, open and spacious, making it a nice spot to sit down and relax. I tried the Original Breakfast Burrito and it was a really good grab-and-go option scrambled eggs, potatoes, peppers, onions and Vermont white cheddar all came together nicely. The staff was friendly and welcoming, and lastly, the caramel latte with an extra shot definitely hit the spot. Great atmosphere, good food, and solid coffee. I'd definitely come back.

July 2926 - 2 for brunch…read more New place is big, bold and awesome!! Service fantastic, food and selection vast and appealing. Coffee service was very slow, and kitchen food delivery also slow. We did enjoy it all though.

Inside the front dividable room

The Krispy Nutella French Toast with side of home fries and vanilla latte

See all

Iced Irish coffee

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

2 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Diana S.

10 years ago

Bagels your way has the best bagels in the area hands down. I don't get why they don't have a 5 star rating ?! Been coming here since they opened when I was a kid. Anytime we have out of town company they always request their bagels! I've also used them to send thank you platters they never disappoint :) read more

Jen R.

7 days ago

Such a great local spot! The staff is always so warm, friendly, and welcoming the second you walk through the door. Everything they offer is very fresh, top-notch and clearly made with care. A wonderful neighborhood gem that never disappoints! read more

Bagels Your Way Cafe - bagels - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Bagels Your Way Cafe also viewed

Bagel Express

3.3

(143 reviews)

I was in New York for a weekend and stopped by Bagel Express on my way to visit a family member at…read moreSt. Charles. From the moment I walked in, I was hit with that New York deli feel. The kind of place you just don't find anywhere else, especially not back home in Virginia Beach. The inviting feel when you walk in, the regulars chatting up the staff, the air filled with the wonderful smells of fresh bacon, baked bagels, and savory spices. For my order, I went with a classic sesame bagel with cream cheese. It was absolutely fantastic. Soft on the inside, perfectly chewy, and the cream cheese was delicious. My dad was craving something a little different, so he got a BLT with chipotle mayo and avocado on toast. He raved about it the entire meal, saying it was one of the best BLTs he's ever had. It came with macaroni salad and a pickle (which I obviously stole from him). Even though this was my first time at Bagel Express, since I'm not local to Setauket, the whole experience was great. The quality, service, and authentic deli experience are definitely worth a stop. I'm already looking forward to coming back the next time I'm in town. If you're anywhere near East Setauket or just passing through, don't miss out on this spot!

Can only speak to the bagels and egg sandwiches but they are great! Bagels are big, fresh and chewy…read more- even later in the day. They have an easy to use online system which I highly recommend because the inside of the store is a little chaotic. Even when you order online, you have to push your way to the front and get someone's attention for your order, because the pickup window for online and phone orders is the same as pickup for in store orders. Don't love the slightly high stress pickup process, but the sandwiches are totally worth it. Service is friendly enough, and they have a ton of lunch options in addition to bagels. GREAT bagels!

Bagels Your Way Cafe

3.4

(28 reviews)

My online order was completely messed up. They gave the nerve to charge so much for each extra…read moretopping on the bagel, but not add it to the bagel! Not even toasted like was requested...can't believe they ruined my special breakfast with my family for me and my husband. Never ordering from them again

Stopped by and had an excellent ham cheese and egg bagel! The service was excellent! Warm,…read morefriendly, and very helpful. The Bagel had just come out of the oven when I arrived and was delicious! I also had some of their lemonade which was good. I would love to return!

Hot Bagels Plus

3.6

(10 reviews)

Bad bagels, bad prices, creepy service. The place looks dirty and old, and the food has a similar…read morevibe, so if that is what they are going for they nailed it!

These bagels don't even look remotely fresh, I got an everything with cream cheese... meh; I don't…read moresee a point in returning, the place needed help to say the least. Very few bagels, very limited options, dirty tables, small and dingy place. People rave about their kindness but uhhhh... nope. They weren't rude but they didn't really say a word to me; even when I ordered they sorta just did it without their vocal chords at all... Nothing special. Goldbergs is slow but at least they have options. I'd drive out of town a bit to get a decent bagel breakfast.

St James Bagels

4.2

(60 reviews)

The classic LI bagel shop. Their everything egg bagels are so good. I usually buy a half dozen and…read moretake them back to the city they last a long time in the freezer.

I have been a regular customer of St.James bagels for the past several years and have been going…read morethere for their great service and great food products, however the past two months have been very disappointing for me as they are not providing the service they are supposed to do, first of all now we cannot order over the phone anymore like we used to, the reason being that their phone is always off the hook and when you enter the deli you will witness yourself that the phone is constantly ringing and no one in bothering to pick up, I asked them why aren't you picking up the phone and they say that we are short of help and we can't fulfill all the orders , then two times they literally gave me burnt croissant sandwiches instead of toasted , I took the sandwich to show them and again the reason they gave was shortness of help. I have special attachment to this place but don't want them to lose their standard and also lose valuable customers, hopefully the owner is able to attend to this with seriousness and make necessary changes

Bagels Delox

3.1

(98 reviews)

Yelp ratings should be higher for this place…read more These are my favorite bagels in Suffolk. Their bagels are smaller, with a delicious crusty exterior, but they are light and tender on the inside. There is a reason why there is a line out the door in the morning. The freshly made/baked croissants are also delicious but they usually run out by 1:00. Why not make more? I usually crave their chicken salad on a croissant or egg everything at some point in the day...so damn good. The baker who makes everything is in an open kitchen in the back so you can watch the preparation. The guy is always making something, but not extra croissants. Breakfast sandwiches are only $7-8 which is affordable considering the recent spike in BEC's. 5 Solid Stars.

Was looking forward to a nice bagel with cream cheese but there's barely a schmear of cream cheese…read more Cheap.

Hilltop Bagel Cafe

4.1

(121 reviews)

Was in the area for work and popped in for a quick bite for breakfast. Easily one of the best…read morebagels I've had in a long time. When you think about the quintessential long island bagel this place hits the spot. Will be back for sure!

Ok Hilltop!!!! If you were here 25 years ago, you would have given Strathmore a run for their…read moremoney. IYKYK. This place has a killer menu and a killer Tuna hero. It did take a while to get my sandwiches, but they seemed to reshoot staff and had a fairly large order ahead of me, so I waited patiently. If I'm in the area, I'm going to check out one of their more novelty menu items. See my pics for what I'm referring to.

H&E Bagel Cafe

3.8

(13 reviews)

We order from H&E at my job at least once a week, I always feel bad calling in such a big order but…read morethey are always so patient and accommodating. Yesterday I got the Spanish omelette with spinach and it was probably the best thing I have eaten in a long time. Always 5 stars & and I recommend to friends and family all the time. thanks guys!

Let me start off by saying the customer service at H&E Bagel Cafe is fantastic, such friendly staff…read moremaking sure your bellies are well fed! I made my journey out east to Center Moriches where i came across this fantastic bagel place. I was craving a nice lox bagel because I missed out on breakfast this morning so I made my way. I highly recommend trying out their bagels, even after going a little late, their bagels were still fresh and amazing. I was amazed with their selections of bagles even getting there in the afternoon, the quality of the bagel was great. I got their plain bagel with Lox. Perfectly creamy cream cheese with chunks of lox. It's better than it sounds folks because I knew I should've gotten 2 of them because the bagel was beyond amazing. Some people don't find the liking in lox, but it's absolutely amazing how the team at H&R bagel make them. Such friendly staff and even better quality of food. Amazing.

The Everything Bagel of Commack

3.7

(83 reviews)

Friendly Welcoming…read moreClean Brightly lit Ample parking Selections galore! Only feedback was to girl forever to give change Couldn't even process the change I gave lol A good selection on way to highways

$16.98 for a western omelette with cheese, ham, peppers, and onions because I asked for a roll…read moreinstead of a bagel is ridiculous. And they didn't even give me the bagel. I don't mind paying fair prices, but this felt like getting overcharged for a basic bagel shop order. Bad value, bad experience, and definitely not something I'd recommend.

Bagels and More

3.7

(22 reviews)