Cute small town cafe with lots of creative options for food and drink. I had the special avocado…read moreplatter (salad with feta, pickled onion and balsamic, large sourdough toast with avocado spread and sliced covered with an egg and more feta). You pay at the counter and they bring the food to you. I had a iced coffee with almond milk. Everything was fresh, tasty and well made. Definite stop for breakfast/snack if you are in the area.

Love the artsy feel to this place. The decor is so colorful and bright. I love that they feature…read morelocal art. Many food choices to choose from on the chalkboard menus. They support local vendors and incorporate them into their menu items. The staff were very friendly. It was a two-person show on a Thursday around lunch time. He placed our orders at the counter. We sat down and waited. We were able to see the kitchen from where we were seated and he was also helping to make the food. He brought our lunches to us. After a few minutes he came back around to make sure everything was tasting good. There is a cart to place your dirty dishes on after eating. Service was very good! Can't wait to come back and try this place again, when I am in the area. I will definitely tell others about this cafe.

Limited menu but everything was a 10/10…read more Mom and pop restaurant in an old single room school house. Everyone was super friendly and you could feel the passion and care that went into everything created. Coming by the morning of July 4th will be our new yearly tradition.

We saw this passing through to our Airbnb in Cohocton and added it to the top of our list to visit…read more We came here on Sunday, Father's Day and the weather was perfect. We sat outside with our dog in the grassy area with picnic tables. We went in to order and the line moved quickly. The entire staff was so friendly and organized. I ordered a breakfast sandwich with an iced mocha, and my daughter had the cinnamon roll with a coffee as well. (Hazelnut and Caramel). There was also a solo musician singing and playing guitar on the lawn, which made for a perfect ambiance. I highly recommend stopping in if you're ever in the area.

Never disappointed at Wagner. Great fish dinner on Friday from 4-7, but hard to choose between some…read moreof the other specials like stuffed pork chops or stuffed peppers; my favorites. The waitresses are delightful and serve promptly.

The Wagner is an institution in Penn Yan. We have been coming here since 1992 and the food and the…read moreexperience has not changed. Not one little bit, except our favorite server back then seems to be in management now. The food is good, it is not in the Michelin guide but I don't want it to be. It is reliable and quality diner food. They have lunch and now fish fries on certain days but I've only had breakfast. lots of omlette choices pancakes (buttermilk or a Penn Yan special, buckwheat) and breakfast sandwiches. If you go you won't be disappointed. I think it may have been a bar in its previous life ... it's a little dark inside but you can get all the sun you need at the lake. Servers generally last years there and are top notch and friendly.

Consistently good food & service. Atmosphere is very laid back. We've eaten there many times &…read morerecommend it often.

Stopped by here for lunch while doing some shopping in the area. The restaurant is clean and has…read moreplenty of seating. There's also a bar area. Our waitress was friendly and attentive throughout our time there. I ordered the switz burger and it was huge! I definitely left with a full belly.

Had lunch here today. Ordered the burger and fries. The fries were really good. Like really good…read more The burger was average. It was good, but the bun was soaking wet from the burger juices. I didn't love that part. It was a really nice restaurant. Easy parking. The menu was a little pricey. I know the cost of everything is way up. I'm just informing it would be hard to stay under $25 for lunch here. I recommend it if you are looking for food in the area. Didn't seem many options. So that probably helps them with setting prices.

Food was delicious and huge portions! We went for lunch and had good service. Would love to try…read morethe dessert next time!

Awesome atmosphere and good service. Breakfast food is made to order. Owners are unfortunately…read moreclosing on the 31st of August 2022. Let's go Brandon.

Stopped here for Breakfast on the way home after Niagara Falls visit. Picked this place because…read morethere weren't really any other options in the area. After this experience, I wish I chose to give my business to some other place even if it meant going hungry for a little longer. The menu prices here are reasonable - that is their only positive. Service is extremely slow and they are way understaffed. There was the lone unpleasant old man who was very slow in taking the orders. Probably hard of hearing too. I asked for Onion Rings which was on their menu and he retorted that they don't serve Onion Drinks. When I pointed the item on the menu he yelled out "You want Onion REEEEEEEENGS!" Water was never offered. I have never seen that happen in the USA in any sit-down restaurant before. We just had to wait to finish eating and leave and drink water from the bottles in our car. Omelettes and eggs tasted very ordinary. Belgian waffle was expected to be crunchy but it came soft and soggy. Seriously how difficult is it to make a waffle? The batter comes out of a box and you just throw it in the waffle maker. How can they make a mess out of that? There were only a total of 4 other people in the restaurant and our (simple) order took about 45 minutes to arrive. We felt very unwelcome with the whole experience.

Delicious with a beautiful presentation. Unfortunately I did not get a chance to take a picture. I…read moreate it right away.

Excellent food at reasonable prices for the quality and portion sizes. The stand outs are:…read more Stuffed salmon - it's wrapped in cabbage and leaks with toasted walnuts. The veggies keep the salmon soft and also soak up some flavorful juices. The walnuts provide great textural contrast. Zwiebelkuchen - had never had this before but we're fans now. Zwiebelkuchen is a savory German onion cake made of steamed onions, diced bacon, cream, and caraway seeds on leavened dough. Absolute flavor bomb! Service was excellent. Ambiance - nothing to write home about on the inside. Outside you have great views of the lake. Logistics: parking in the back. Reservations via Open Table.

Just left the Stone House Cafe and the food and service was horrible. We got two burgers and a…read moreTurkey BLT. The burgers tasted like the meat was rotting and smelled the same. When we asked for the check with full plates of food, the waitress didn't ask how our food was. We paid almost $40 for three plates that we only took two bites of. The building was the only charming part of the whole experience. Spent a total of 25 minutes in there and it was the worst restaurant experience I've ever had.

Great food and even better service. We have enjoyed many flavorful meals here. I've always loved…read morethe building. The lighting is always warm and soft.