The bagels are really good. I have tried a variety of bagels and both times they've been great. I prefer this location over downtown just due to the parking situation. It's much easier here to get in and out and park. read more

Tried a new bagel spot and glad we did. This place is what it says and I appreciate that! It does bagels and it does it really well. Fast, sandwiches made to order! This isn't your coffee spot! Come in, grab a bagel to go or eat in. The service is great and the staff is super helpful! Easily could become a part of our weekend routine! I'd suggest stopping in and giving it a try! read more

Barry Bagels St. Matthews - Sausage, egg, and provolone cheese on a vanilla cinnamon bagel. - Bakeries Near Me - Saint Matthews, Kentucky

So glad we tried the newest bagel shop and Barry's will be welcomed into our rotation. We loved the bright orange of their branding and it helped us spot their building right away. My husband and I both ordered the egg, cheese and meat. Yum! You get your pick of bagel and meat. Loved my bacon and the size of the sandwich. We ordered a plain bagel with cream cheese to split. So soft! They add the cream cheese. My husband also got a small cup of chicken salad. I appreciated it. Subtle flavors but good and I appreciated it wasn't overrun with onion. Check out their menu ... they offer a lot of options. Out of the breakfast mindset? No issue - lunch options, chips and sodas are available. Service was friendly, which helped us overlook the hiccups of it being slow and the coffee being completely empty. If you're staying in, a small coffee is more than enough and you can refill it. I wasn't wild about either roast and wished I'd kept my dollars for another shop. Seating is scarce. There's one counter with about 8 high top chairs and three tables for 2ppl. A family of 4 might struggle to find seating so be prepared to an alternative. Parking is shared with other businesses. No issue to get a spot in their lot. read more

See all

So glad to have another bagel spot in Louisville. The prices are great & Service was friendly & happy to help. It was new & clean with a few places to sit. They have plenty to choose from. I went with the BLT on a jalapeño cheddar bagel with scallion cream cheese. I also got their potato salad to try. It's mustard based & the potatoes could stand to be cooked a little longer but it was still good! They were cleaning up from a late lunch rush so next time I will have to get a variety 1/2 dozen to take home for my husband & I to try for the week. Can't wait to go back & try other things. read more

See all

Lousiville has been lacking in the bagel department until Barry's came around. Solid bagels, fairly priced, fast, delicious. Can't ask for anything more. read more

Barry Bagels St. Matthews - Eggle sandwich with egg, sausage, and veggie cream cheese on everything bagel - Bakeries Near Me - Saint Matthews, Kentucky

Barry Bagels are some of the better bagels in town. They're made fresh on site, and they offer a range of traditional spreads and breakfast sandwiches alongside a rather large list of deli sandwiches and salads. I haven't tried any of the latter. The regular bagels with cream cheese are fresh. They're not as generous with cream cheese as you'd find in NYC nor are they as good, but these are about as close as I've encountered here in Louisville. The waits can get pretty long when they're busy, as the staff haven't quite managed handling a bunch of orders and cycling them through quickly. But, they're upbeat and engaging even when busy. The ambiance is pretty much like any quick service spot and seating is limited, so I recommend just grabbing your food and dining elsewhere. Had high hopes during my first visit and will be back. read more

See all

Get here early! We came on a Sunday at 11 and the line was out the door. The bagel or the eggel (bagel with egg and cheese) was really good. Toasted to perfection with hasbrown, egg, bacon, and cheese. Another friend got the lox bagel and cream cheese which looked heavenly. I even paired it with the tiramisu coffee which was in a dispenser which was delicious. It is a small place though so we got shushed for being loud... read more

See all

The employees were a little overwhelmed when I came in for a takeout order. However, they were very friendly and did their best during a difficult day. Definitely empathized with them and felt they worked hard to full orders quickly. The food was...fine. Decent turkey sandwich on a honey wheat bagel. But this was the smallest bagel I've ever seen. It doesn't need to be Costco sized, but this was on the other end if the spectrum. I think there are much better tasting and more filling bagel sandwiches for the price point, including Born 2 Bagel. read more

I tried yall. I really did. I've tried both locations in Louisville and I'll say this: They are consistent. Consistently underbaked, flavorless bagels. I even asked for it toasted this time. It was barely warm and that toasting seemed more like a little trip for the bagel than anything that actually TOASTED the bagel. I get it that this location (Norton commons) is new. However. This isn't because of that. It's just NOT A GOOD BAGEL SHOP. IF ANYTHING IS WORTH IT, take bagels home and actually toast them. Might finally get some caramelization in the crust. They still have no flavor in the actual bagels. Stick with Payne Street. Literally handcrafted from a local bagel specialist with YEARS of proven product. This is a franchise (Barry's) and it shows. read more

I was so happy when I heard a new bagel spot was opening in town. What a disappointment. I ordered 2 bec sandwiches on everything's bagels. First, I noticed the gentleman helping me pulled out these oddly shaped bacon wheels. They look very processed and not fresh. Next I see him scoop liquid eggs into a plastic container with cheese and place it into the microwave. The cheese looked extremely processed and so was turned off by the fact that they chose to use fake eggs. The container he refilled with said egg product on the side. As confirmed when I took the first bite in the car, the bagels were below average and the bacon egg and cheese all tasted like processed plastic. There is no way they will be successful long term with this type of food quality. read more

Barry Bagels St. Matthews - Egg Product? - Bakeries Near Me - Saint Matthews, Kentucky

There was not a long line and I was able to order quickly. The person taking my order was helpful in assisting me pick my food selections. They serve breakfast sandwiches all day and I knew I wanted a breakfast sandwich. They do not have turkey or vegan bacon or sausage so I went with turkey slices with eggs mixed with onions, tomatoes and peppers. I also added a slice of cheese. The bagel was super soft and yummy! I want to go back just for the bagel and cream cheese. The restaurant also has room for seating and you can even see the workers make the bagels near the front entrance. read more

See all

Absolutely delicious breakfast breads. Simple, tasty, fresh and fast. I was hangry, now I'm happy. read more

Barry Bagels St. Matthews - Asiago Bagel with jalapeño cream cheese - Bakeries Near Me - Saint Matthews, Kentucky

Terribly understaffed or just downright slow. My call ahead order wasn't even started when I got there and I had to wait in the long line for something I had ordered 30 minutes before. The bagels were fine, but there are a lot of better local bagel places in town. read more

Absolutely delicious and pleasantly surprised! Great selection of items whether it is for breakfast or lunch! If you have not tried Barry's bagels, you should! read more

The turkey on Asiago bagel sandwich I ate was perfect. They make it just how you want it. The server was nice and helpful. The seating is sparse, so plan to take it to go. I would've loved to eat in an outside dining area, that would've made the whole visit perfect. read more

Loved my first time here! My bagel sandwich was super tasty. I'll definitely be back!

Got a dozen of bagels through them last week using an app called "too good to go" that is supposed to be for companies to sell their soon to expire food and save from having to toss otherwise good food. Well, out of the dozen, quite a few were burnt pretty severely on the bottom side and many others were misshapen and much thinner on one side. I feel as if these weren't simply soon to expire, but rated not good enough to be on the rack for sale hence the lower rating for this business. If it isnt good enough for the business, you wont save face by selling them in another market base, it still reflects on the business. read more

They have a large variety of bagels. I had the poppies seed with Lox. The bagel was so good and with the added toppings was the best I've taste. Service was excellent and friendly. They are seats if you want to eat your bagel there. I will differently be back for more Barry Bagels. read more

They consistently don't have what is on the menu. I was told "we don't have rye bread". (Then why have it on the menu?!) "My boss wants me to get rid of the two bread options that we have". Was told the same on two visits during the last two weeks. Both times I left and I won't be back. read more

Fast, friendly, with a decent selection of bagels. Not too many cream cheese choices; they need to add lox spread. They do have lox, and the bagels are fresh. read more

Got there early--only one in the shop. Made to wait for 10 minutes--not even acknowledging my presence! Bagels were good though... read more

Was so mesmerized by the beautiful stack of meat and veggies against the contrast of delectable cream cheese smear that I forgot to take a picture of my bagel before devouring it!! What a unique concept and amazing addition to the Louisville food scene, definitely worth a visit! read more

Greasy food. Bland stale tasting bagels. Awful sides. Was missing items in my door dash order. Never again.

Best bagel place in Louisville! Everything is so fresh and the prices cannot be beat. My favorite is the sausage egg and cheese, and the cookies are delicious. It's rare to find a place the full family can enjoy, but Barry Bagels does it all! read more

It's pretty good. It was best the first weekend I tried it the next time it was not as good. They cut the bagels inconsistently I had to ask them to redo it because mine didn't have a bottom that wasn't broken. The bacon is microwaved and not worth getting. I think the bagels and cream cheeses are good wouldn't recommend a sandwich. read more

We order two breakfast bagels with egg, cheese, and sausage. I was shocked to see them microwave the egg and sausage. Needless to say we took one bite of the breakfast sandwiches and were done. Yuck! We also got a bagel with cream cheese. It was around what I would expect from a grocery store bagel. The chocolate peanut butter cookie was the shining star of the order and the only thing worth eating. read more

The bagels are amazing and that keeps us coming back because the service is a cluster! Love the many menu options and textures/flavors of the bagels. Both visits we've had slow service from lackluster employees. I hope management gets ahead of the sloooooow service (with 5 employees working we stood for almost 10 minutes without being acknowledged or asked for our order, no one in front of us in line as they changed out cream cheeses, did other things) and disorganization so this place can survive. read more

Major disappointment . Meal was made to order using microwaves. Service was not good. Worker needed to pull up pants.

Great bagels. I enjoy the turkey club on everything! Made fresh daily. Plethora of options....

The bagels are yummy and fresh and the cream cheeses are yummy as well. I would definitely come back when in the area.

Good price and super fresh bagels!! It was a great first time there and will definitely be back.

The bagels are fresh with a great selection of toppings, the staff is friendly and the app is easy to use for to go orders!

I never leave reviews but this was so bad I have to. I ordered two garlic bagels toasted, one with jalapeño CC and the other with turkey, cheese, lettuce and mayo. I couldn't tell but the first bagel looked like sesame so I confirmed with the employee who said it was garlic. I couldn't tell because the bagel was so barely toasted that I wouldn't even call it toasted. I thought maybe the garlic just didn't brown as much as it would normally. This first bagel was cut ridiculously in half horizontally, but I then asked to cut vertically to share with my husband to which I told them that we were sharing both. they then cut it ridiculously vertically so it was one giant piece and three tiny pieces. Ok I can deal. Then when doing the turkey bagel, the same cutting issue except the knife wasn't cleaned so if smeared the jalapeño cream cheese all over this one. Also watched as there was literally no mayo left in the bottle so they put a single dot of mayo on then cut it. Ordered the bagels to go so figured I could put more mayo on at home. Only to get home and find both bagels were in fact sesame bagels and not garlic. My husband and I think the mistakes were so egregious that it was done purposefully. we were pleasant the entire time and the only customers in the entire place so they weren't overwhelmed In fact, I should have spoken up. 30 bucks later, we ate what we could. Threw the rest in the trash. 0 out of 5 stars. Save your money read more

Makes the best bagels, fresh daily! Friendly staff & beautiful place, love the salt and vanilla cinnamon bagel! Plus scallion cream cheese