Their deep dish pies via GoldBelly nationwide delivery are some of the best we've had, dare I say even better than Lou Malnati's? Price is a bit steep at $120 (including shipping) for three 12"pies, but they're super dense and packed with toppings. Great sauce, lots of cheese, and decent crust. Recommend! read more

Bartolini's - Deep Dish via GoldBelly nationwide delivery - Pizza Near Me - Midlothian, Illinois

Their gnocchi with diablo sauce is very good! The diablo sauce was excellent, I have a high tolerance for spicy foods and this diablo sauce is seriously spicy! Their dessert nuggets was the bomb!!!! You definitely need to try it! It will not disappoint. Their bar has decent beer selection from Lagunitas, Founders, local breweries like Blue Island Brewery and Hailstorm Brewery just to mention a few. read more

There food is terrific. I've tried almost every thing on the menu. Liked just about everything. Greg read more

My Job ordered takeout and my food(Chicken Cesar Salad) was amazing. My co workers ordered the Calzones and they smelled and looked great. Everyone enjoyed the food and no l w had any complaints. Would definitely try again! read more

Nice place. Nice service. Nice people. Ambiance is a little dark. Food nice. Service is fast. Dining room is crowded tables tight. But nice time was had. read more

We are out of towers and found this place through Yelp. What an amazing experience. Casual ambience but the service was top notch. Melissa took such great care our party if 5. Mini Meatballs were incredible. PIA pizza was out of this world. Tiramisu was one for best we ever had with love from Dominic, the owner who came out to say hello and made us feel very special. This is our go-to place. We absolutely loved it. read more

Unfortunately I've never had a good meal here. I'm local and this is a town favorite but I've tried more than a handful of times and I just don't get the hype. From the pizza to sandwiches and pasta read more

I've tried most of the deep dish pizza in the area and this is by far the worst. As the crust was as hard as a piece of coal. The pizza was half cut making it super hard to cut even with a regular knife. Very flavorless even with the fresh garlic on it. read more

Food, service, everything is top notch! Have been eating here for years and would recommend this place to anyone wanting good pasta dishes!

Such a local fav. Gotta love this place. Amazing pizza and so many other great menu items. They don't have their wraps anymore so i branched out and discovered an amazing chicken sandwich, a meatball pizza that is out of this world, fried chicken, salads, everything is so good. You really can't go wrong. The beer nuggets are a family favorite. My whole family loves this place. read more

Great neighborhood casual place, portions are huge and food tastes amazing! Service by Brittany was 12/10. Will be back!!! read more

See all

The absolute BEST pizza! Perfectly thin and crispy crust with generous toppings and REAL cheese. All orders are made fresh to customer specifications. Salads and sandwiches are phenomenal and you'll NEVER leave hungry. Service is impeccable every single time. Bartolini's is,by far, our favorite,#1, go to spot for good fresh food and family atmosphere! read more

Great food and friendly atmosphere! Have eaten there many times and have used their catering, My husband's funeral lunch was there and everyone loved the food and service. Have been eating there since they first opened. read more

We live in New York and love pizza. Last month, Goldbelly, ran a promotion for Bartolini's Restaurant that included two deep dish and two thin crust pies. We decided to try it. The pizzas were delivered sooner than promised and were in good condition when they arrived. We have eaten two of the four and were genuinely pleased with the quality. Please look at the attached photos. Don't be frightened by the messiness of the thin crust pizza. You are looking at something that came out of a pizzeria, not a factory. The abundant meatballs were made from good quality meat and the crust was delicious. These pizzas were much bigger than others we ordered online. (Not naming names.) The sauce on this larger pie was a bit on the sweet side. I was less crazy about this than my partner. Red pepper flakes from our pantry balanced it out, however. We are fans. read more

See all

Always love coming to this restaurant! The staff is amazing and the food is even better! Highly recommended! Their cajun chicken alfredo with breaded chicken and sweet peppers is out of this world! read more

If i could give this more than 5 stars I would. The meatballs are RIDICULOUSLY good and have never changed, the quality never goes down even with the stress of these covid times. We got way more food than we needed but Dominc /owner when taking my phone order described everything in such a way that we had to try it! He should teach a class on describing food not to mention cooking it! Thank you for never disappointing. read more

Bartolini's - Pizza Near Me - Midlothian, Illinois

Everything is always delicious. My favorite is angel hair pasta with tomatoes and big shrimp but there isn't anything on the menu we don't like. We've catered several times but this was the first time we had ordered the Mac and cheese. Let me tell you it was delicious! read more

Stopped in after securing our real ID next door. This was about 3:30 Outdoor patio was locked up. They never had a chance to open it up that day. (Believe they open at 11am) There were a few patrons indoors. However, NOT ONE of the staff was wearing a mask. Not the hostess, cook, servers. Although, we had carry out, won't even be doing that. read more

Delicious pizza and great selection of craft beers. Nice place to grab a bite as the meatball sandwich and calzones are tasty.

Bad experience with one of the owners, the big rude one. Really too bad because we liked their food. I can't believe that he would be so pompous with a customer. Honestly, your meatballs suck and there are many many other pizza joints in town. Bye bye. read more

Friendly staff and great service! LOVED the beer nuggets!! Plus they have Hailstorm beer on tap!

I absolutely love it here. Every time I come here they make feel like a KING! Owners and staff are friendly with great food to match. Always served up fresh and hot. I never wait long at all. read more

The Italian food is really REALLY good if your looking for a place you need to go here great service,great food you must come!

Best customer service and the food has never disappointed! The ambiance is perfect for a local Chicago Italian restaurant!

I've lived in the area for over 20 years and have heard nothing but good things about Bartolinis. This was possibly some of the worst food I've ever wasted $50 on. Hubby got the breaded steak, expecting something similar to the breaded steak from Ricobenes or Rubinos. This was like 4 well done steak "nuggets". Hubby said it was like eating shoe leather. I ordered the spaghetti carbonara. This was NOT carbonara. It was an alfredo sauce with bacon thrown in it. Carbonara is not made with cream sauce. It was downright inedible. That went directly in the trash. No one wanted it. We also ordered a pizza that was met with little enthusiasm from my son and his friends. Not sure I've ever seen them leave pizza on the table. But there was plenty left. We'll stick to Blarney, Beggars, or even Kenootz for pizza. And just about ANYWHERE else for Italian food! read more

You want an authentic Italian restaurant where the food is served in heaven, then stop in at Bartolini's!!! I've had many items from Chris and Dom's menu and have always been 100% satisfied. If you don't like what you ordered then there's something wrong with your tongue. These guys know how to cook!!! Mongia!!! read more

Wow. Great meataball sandwich. Garlic parm pub fries were excellent. I only did take out, but fast service and excellent counter staff. Nice bar in there as well with Stella on tap. Open Sundays which is nice. Tried the eggplant parm sandwich. Not bad but could use a bit more of a heavy pour on sauce. Loved the hot giardinara. Mine had lots of olives. Cole slaw was good too. Overall an excellent experience. Will be back shortly. read more

Bartolini's - Meataball on garlic bread with sweet pepper and garlic parm pub fries. - Pizza Near Me - Midlothian, Illinois

What do you order when you go to a place known for their meatballs and even has a meatball challenge on their menu? Pizza!! ....WRONG! Meatballs, DUH! (Yeah.... I went there) took the recommendations from my server tonight and she did not steer me wrong. The pub fries (Parmesan & Garlic) and Meatball sub on toasted garlic bread was lit. Homemade tiramisu to go. . Also... they ship nationwide. Interested in their famous meatballs? You can order em online! Monday night dinner is served. read more

See all

chicken wrap is excellent. my daughters father and i ate our meal at the bar. the woman bartender was cool and fun. the atmosphere was relaxing. read more

So since my first visit here i beg my brother every wkend that we must go OR order take out! Soooooooo good! Very quick service, my drink was always full..which is a huge thing for my brother if his drink is empty for sheesh more than ??? a min! So big thumbs up for that! So first visit went on sunday (((Sunday half off pizza for dine-in))) Ordered medium Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Brushetta, Salad and side of spaghetti plus 3 drinks THE WHOLE MEAL WAS $29!!!! Which blew my mind for how delicious & FRESH everything was! read more

Bartolini's - Apple Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Midlothian, Illinois

While leaving O'Hare we had a hungry group and found this place near our location on the interstate. With the previously earned star ranking, I suggested we check this spot out. The environment was very hospitable and the food was good. Honestly the food was pretty regular for an Italian spot and the award winning coleslaw received some new fans. I am intrigued to tryout some pizza here next time I'm around town. I suggest any new comers checking this place out come hungry, the meal portion sizes were filling! read more

We have been coming to this restaurant for probably around 8 years. It is at least 45 minutes away, but we will travel for good food. I have brought numerous family members here and talk it up at work quite a bit. It has been the go-to any time we are near. First sign was when we ordered our beers on tap they tasted nothing like Three Floyd's Gumballhead. I've had this beer hundreds of times but was off. My guess is dirty beer tap lines. The second sign was our appetizer was pub fries and came out barely warm. They used to be fresh hand cut, but were now frozen crinkle cut fries. Third and most disappointing was the meatballs, my favorite, tasted like someone lost the salt container in the mixer when making them. Almost every time we have dined in one of the owners would approach the party and ask how everything was. Ghost town today. Our waitress Jill performed her job well. I think she could tell we didn't enjoy our meal. The food wasn't awful, but NOTHING like it was close to a year ago. And the food took forever to come out and the restaurant wasn't busy at 8pm on Sunday night. $110 I'll never get back. read more

Love the southwest salad with Buffalo chicken added and a side of garlic bread! It's all we ever order.

Went here while traveling based on the Yelp reviews. It did not disappoint. The deep dish is incredible! The owners were so nice and came over to our table to meet us. read more

Holy Mother of God! I'm so friggin happy! I saw the dumplings and immediately wanted them.This Schnitzel is amazing. I'm kind of a dork and had to ask Jordan what schnitzel was. Tender, succulent pork beaten and rubbed in mustard and fried in bread crumbs with capers. I love capers and I hate veggies but I'm eating these green beans cause they're in butter and I'm pulling them thru the munchy thingys on my plate that are making me so happy. Chris and Jordan tell me it'll be here all month. Hurrah for October and Schnitzel! read more

Bartolini's - Pizza Near Me - Midlothian, Illinois

This place is just amazing! The meatballs are sooo delicious. I called to see if I could order their meat lasagna "last minute" and the manager was very accommodating. Nonetheless, everyone loved it! I def recommend this place. You get amazing food and amazing service! read more

Pizza Pia was delicious. My only regret was I couldn't stop eating it and was wishing for more leftovers the next day. The wait staff was more than accommodating and did not mind that we sat and talked well after our meals were done. A top-notch family owned business. We will be back! read more

This is my favorite Italian place. Every single person that I've brought here has also said the same thing. You honestly won't find a better, more friendly place than here. They really treat you like family... and like a family that can REALLY cook. I need a wheel barrel to help roll me outta the restaurant lol. But seriously folks, it's the bees knees. read more

Bartolini's - Pizza Near Me - Midlothian, Illinois

See all

I had your pizza delivered to California and it was definitely the best I've had delivered this way. My only issue was I found the deep dish pizza crust was really difficult to cut through. Is that typical? I cooked it for 40 min. Would 30 min have helped at all? read more

Great food, excellent friendly HAPPY service! Cannot choose a favorite BUT those meatballs!!!!! Visit as often as I can!