One of our favorite pizza places! The staff is always friendly, the food is consistently delicious, and the atmosphere is warm and inviting. Great cocktails, too. Highly recommend stopping in. You won't be disappointed! read more

This is our go to Friday night spot! Feels like our Cheers! Where everyone knows your name!

This place is so great! Perfect for a late night pizza and beer. The servers were so nice and everything about the space is very chill.

Absolutely amazing experience! The food was excellent and the owner spent time talking with us. Highly recommended!

Got there at 5:30 Food was good BUT service was slow. Sat at the bar figuring drinks would be faster but tables were served first. Still go back though read more

Updated to add photos of the food! This is seriously the best pizza I've had in the neighborhood, maybe in all of Brooklyn! Can't speak highly enough about the service, they're all so sweet and attentive. Great cocktails too! read more

Battle Hill Tavern - Burrata pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

One of my low key favorites in the neighborhood. Love their garlic knots, meatballs, and lamb ragu. The Moscow Mule is great too.

Super low key place with great pizza and pasta! We got the Di Parma pizza and it was so thin, and loaded with toppings. The lamb ragu pasta was also so filling and rich, a really delicious sauce. Service is really great, and it's really casual with football playing in the background and beer on tap read more

Battle Hill Tavern - Di Parma - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Really great lowkey spot a few blocks away from a friend that we were visiting. We sat outside for a few beers, and our server was sweet & very fast. To start we shared the really tasty Pear & Goat Cheese salad. Pears were sweet and balanced so nicely with the slightly bitter arugula, goat cheese and tangy lemony dressing. Then we ordered two pizzas, the White Canvas & the Funghi, which were tasty & fresh out of the brick oven. I enjoyed both but think I'd try others in the future. The real star of the meal for me were the Ricotta meatballs-- so fluffy and most and well flavored. If I was in the area I'd come back just for them! read more

See all

I use to come here when it was called Toby's Public House and loved the pizza here. Super glad that the pizza is still solid after new ownership and name change. This is a great local neighborhood spot where you see the same families or people dining here. It's not a noisy sports bar like all those 5th ave bars which I love. They have a good variety of food and beer on their menu. We are big fans of their pizza and salads. I would skip the pasta dishes here since it's not their strong suit. The staff is also super friendly. If you want a nice chill place to sit and eat, then definitely give Battle Hill a try. read more

Battle Hill Tavern - Caesar salad with Shrimp. FYI: skip the shrimp as it's frozen and tasted weird. The salad itself was great. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Living outside of Chicago, where deep dish pizza is king, we tried a Brooklyn thin crust brick oven pizza. We were amazed at the freshness, and taste of their pizza. As a bonus, we even parked our car right out front. We highly recommend Battle Hill Tavern. read more

Last Saturday we had an amazing pizza and shared a small Caesar salad. We loved the ambiance and vibe. The food was great and so was the service. We will be dining there again tonight. Can't wait! read more

Battle Hill Tavern - Wood-fire oven pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Great food and vibes, the food was very filling and portion wise was great. Definitely going back again. read more

See all

This place has delicious food, cool beer selection and the vibe is chill and casual. The service is excellent, everyone is pretty friendly.

Perfect neighborhood spot. Quality pizza, super friendly service, friendly vibe. Never been disappointed.

Love this place! We have talked about moving out of the park slope neighborhood but have been apprehensive about doing so because it would mean being further away from our beloved gem that is Battle Hill Tavern. Our favorites include but are not limited to the Fig and Fungi pizzas, as well as the lamb ragu. If we do end up moving out of the neighborhood we will likely return just for Battle Hill. But if we are being honest with ourselves, we will probably try and move even closer than we currently are. Ps: the Mac n' cheese gets an honorable mention! read more

Battle Hill Tavern - Mac n cheese on the patio! - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Okay, obsessed might be an understatement! The pizza is addicting but a tad pricey. The fig pie is my absolute favorite and I haven't found a place that rivals it. Highly recommend!! read more

Battle Hill Tavern - Fig Pie & Burrata Pie - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Came here just for drinks but was a lovely experience. Great ambiance, fabulous staff and wonderful seating. Definitely will revisit to try the menu. read more

We live around the corner and have been eating here since pandemic and honestly the service has changed. When we eat here once a week the server has attitude towards us to order,they leave the phone off the hook on purpose to drive business. Great food just need better servers who don't bring attitude to the dinner table.You ignored our question by asking the bartender about the phone issue. Have a better attitude and more local families will return. Try and learn from these tough times that customer service is a must during tough times. read more

The foods delicious but the service sucks. The Girl that works there is not very bright. Unfortunately she's there all the time. Maybe she's the manager. Great place to take your kids and they are allowed to run around like it's a playground. Not for me. read more

Delicious Neapolitan pizza in many flavorways with excellent outdoor seating in the summer and plenty of indoor seating for the not summer. TVs inside if you love sports. Very family friendly, so if you've got kids, well, so does everyone else eating here. The pizza is delicious, floppy, juicy, full of flavor. I was feeling like I needed vitamins after a night of shenanigan however so I ordered the salmon with broccoli rabe for a health boost - I've been spoiled with good salmon in the past month and I would say as my tastes go this was by far not my favorite - the filet was ostensibly deep fried and served well-done which is the opposite of what I like (black and pink) and is served atop a generous mountain of broccoli rabe and cauliflower. I was grateful for all the veg, but it to me was also overcooked and had the freshness zapped out of it. Here's me still ignoring the delicious pizza, hoping I can get them to menu-ify salmon served grilled and rare and atop the show-stopping looking Cesar salad they have by the time I return (because I'm the queen of south slope lol). Waiter was very nice, pizza was quite memorable in a city (and street) full of pizza, seating was fun for the good weather, great beer list, proud to have it in the neighborhood! read more

Battle Hill Tavern - Tartufo Nero - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

We tried the artichoke and spinach dip, and also got a pizza half margherita and half hot soppresata. The artichoke and spinach dip was fine, it had a little too much mozzarella for my taste making it very stringy but the taste was good. It was served with plain toasted bread which we weren't too thrilled about. Pizza was also fine, good but nothing out of the ordinary. It was a little soggy, i did wish for a better textured crust. Staff was very friendly, the place definitely has more of a sports bar vibe rather than a restaurant. read more

See all

The fungi pizza is absolutely delicious here, the others are A-okay. I also ordered the garlic knots. They were very well-made: baked to perfection with generous amount of fresh garlic but were on the bland side. A little salt or parmesan could go a long way. read more

We love Battle Hill! My partner truly asks to go here about once a week. It's just a great menu with great drinks, great outdoor space, and great service - what more could you ask for? It's a perfect mix of neighborhood spot mixed with elevated cocktails (if you so desire) and wonderful food. Highly recommend (although I don't need to tell folks in the neighborhood to go, they already know) read more

I'm a big fan of this place. We've lived in the neighborhood for 22 years and have seen the place change hands for sure but we recently have been coming pretty consistently. The food is so great and the main girl behind the bar always takes the best care of us. Highly recommend!!!! read more

Nice atmosphere -- cozy with the open oven. Friendly service, easy street parking, at least on a Sunday, and very good pizzas and salads.

Great food. Fantastic atmosphere. A menu that's accommodating and adaptable for anyone. (My wife, a vegan, was able to easily find a few options and we keep coming back.) The staff is incredibly friendly and welcoming, and part of the reason we keep returning as well. In the end, a great neighborhood spot to meet a friend (or five), get a great meal, some drinks, and ultimately have a lovely evening. read more

Regular customer here. The staff is super helpful and friendly. I will be honest that service can be slow during the peak hours. Be patient. It can take awhile for your pizza depending on how busy it is. Overall, the food is always good. The portions are quite generous. The mussels are my favorite. I just want to drink all the soup left on the pot. I love their salads. My favorite pizza is the margarita. I looked red sauce. Overall, i think they're all good. read more

We came in Saturday night and it was the perfect vibe for what I needed. It was a really great, cozy spot with a lot of TVs, a decent size bar, and a number of tables. Bartender was attentive and friendly - the beer list was really great (lots of local beers and a variety of flavors). The size of the large salad was HUGE - we had the antipasta type one, which is my favorite type and did not disappoint. The sliders juicy and got rave reviews from my burger-loving boyfriend, and the pizza was yummy. Overall, it was a great, casual spot where I felt comfortable kicking back and hanging out in. We will totally go back. read more

Great place , with great food and environment. I would definitely recommend anyone that is around the area to try this place out !! Customer service is also very good ! read more

We used to come to this place when it was under different management and different name. When we decided to stop by for a pizza last Sunday night, we discovered that things have been updated and everything had a nice facelift. The pizza is still great: thin crust and baked in a real fire oven with very delicious toppings. We got a mushroom pie and a classic margarita, and they did not disappoint. Good selection of beer and wine on the menu. Definitely worth a visit! read more

Battle Hill Tavern - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Big fan of Battle Hill. Great draft selections that rotate. The simple menu of thin crust pizzas, appetizers, and of course mussels! The food is great, the atmosphere is quintessential "at home by the fire" (it's the huge oven that does it) and friendly staff. Outdoor seating when the weather is nice that is dog friendly. Make sure you stop here if you're in the neighborhood. read more

Nice addition to the neighborhood! Laid back and chill vibe. Have both outdoor and indoor seating. Full bar and good selection of beers. Friendly bartenders and staff. Pizza was delicious! We got the sopressata - such great flavor. Had a kick and loved the spicy honey on top. Would definitely come here for some more again and to try out something new. Would recommend! read more

Battle Hill has a good beer selection, a legit pizza oven, and shakshouka for brunch. I couldn't ask for more...well, maybe that it were a little easier to get to from Prospect Park (or Jackson Heights), but we can't always get what we want. I'm excited to return and try their other offerings. read more

Battle Hill Tavern - Brunch shakshouka, served with foccacia bread. Delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

First time here since Toby's closed. Good brick oven pizza, good beer, friendly staff. Recommend checking it out. Large variety of beer on tap. read more

Battle Hill Tavern - Andouille Slice - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This place is great! Went here after dinner for a drink and ended up ordering a salad and dessert. The burrata in the salad was so creamy but the real hit was the cookie! Made in a cast iron pan and baked in the wood oven - best cookie in the neighborhood!! Amazing service as well! We brought our dog for outdoor dining and they were very dog friendly. Will definitely be back. read more

Don't go here. The food is terrible. The drinks are worse. I really wanted to like it because it's so close to our house. If you just want to have a beer at the bar, their beer selection is decent. Just don't order a cocktail. Update: in response to the owner, I actually left about half of my salad. I drank the second martini because I felt bad to send back another drink but it was really awful-still just way too dirty. And I'm not sure how I would have told a server or a manager that the pizza and calzone were pretty tasteless. (My kids finished them because they were hungry.) Maybe I could have pointed out that the prosciutto in the Brussels sprouts was just thrown In and undercooked. In any case, if I want to write a bad review, that's my prerogative. It's not the first one you've received. But thanks for the opportunity to be more specific. I hope this feedback is helpful. (Oh and I do want to point out that my waitress was very nice.) read more

This place is great if you want a low key, casual meal out. The food isn't anything to write home about, but the prices are fair and the portions are HUGE. I had the appetizer mussels for an entree most recently, and was literally stuffed afterwards. The staff has always been kind and welcoming, and I appreciate having such a solid spot in the neighborhood. read more

We came here to eat with our daughters. The food was undercooked and poorly prepared (for example the Mac and cheese was cold and swimming in milk(?) and the sliders we ordered for them were raw on the inside) when it arrived. Not to mention we waited over thirty minutes for it. We live in the neighborhood but will never be back for food... read more

Battle Hill Tavern - Raw burger - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Good solid place with great service and great responsive owners. Cozy and casual interior with a nice bar that you can sit and have a drink, grab a bite and relax. Food is high quality and not overly priced. The pizza varieties give you some nice options and they also have surprisingly good salads. One of the better places that I'd recommend checking out. read more