Cancel

Open app

Search

Bay Ridge Bakery

3.9 (125 reviews)
ModerateBakeries, Desserts
Closed 10:00 am - 8:00 pm

Bay Ridge Bakery Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Bay Ridge Bakery

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Linda E.

I would have preferred a bigger selection of Italian cookies but still the ones that were available were fresh and delicious. The pignoli cookies were my favorite as they were soft & chewy! Equally as good, the rainbow and shortbread cookies were delicious. I was tempted to try the cakes but I had already selected too many cookies! I'll def try those next time around.

Irish soda bread

Irish soda bread yesterday was somehow missing an ingredient because it was flat, dense and dry! For 3 tiny connolis $5. that doesn't make sense, to much for minis! It was tasty but cream seemed like it was slightly low in quality! I don't live around there but was dining in Skinflints and visited the bakery. The young lady was welcoming and the twin tower cake was interesting and a cool story!!

Carrot Cake [$5]
Felisa F.

I stopped by and bought, what I think, was the last piece of carrot cake [$5]. It was actually really light and not overly sweet. There's a perfect amount of cream cheese frosting on top and in the layers. The raisins were juicy and tart. This cake was really amazing. Bay Ridge Bakery is the epitome of an old school Brooklyn bakery. Lots of neon florescent lighting and display cases of butter cookies and cake. There's also a whole section devoted to gluten free goods. I would love to have another slice of carrot cake..not right now but sometime soon.

Fruit Tart
Reema S.

This place has had a chokehold on me since 2018 when I had a bite of their Chocolate Mousse cake. I have been coming here religiously for years. This bakery is an absolute local gem. I will drive out of my way to get a cake from them on a special occasion if I have to. The pastries are to die for. Presentation is beautiful and professional with cute chocolate buttons and glaze. The taste of everything is amazing and the sweets are not too expensive. This is a classic bakery with very high quality cakes. My favorite pastries are the german chocolate cake, chocolate mousse cake and the pineapple coconut. Love this little bakery!!

Cookie Display Case
Mike A.

My favorite bakery in Bay Ridge! I love this place. My belt doesn't but I do. The deserts here are always so good. I never bring these pastries somewhere where I don't hear "Oh that's good!" You really can't go wrong here with a choice, and you have plenty of choice. I've never had a problem with the service. The women at the register are always nice knowledgeable, and help you out. This reminds me of the bakeries I grew up with in the city. Nice local people who know what they're doing, good food, and like the radio set to the oldies station in the background. It's a vibe.

Blessings I.

Everything is tasty and sweet. Every cake that we have tasted so far is awesome. The cookies tastes great too.

Butter cookies

Stumbled upon this cute bakery 2 or 3 years ago and this has been a go-to every time I'm in Bay Ridge. The butter cookies are my absolute favorite. They have a light crunch and chocolate dipped end with sprinkles. This is a nice family owned business and each time I've visited I was always met with a sweet and courteous worker. I'll be back!

$6 Mini Strawberry Cheesecake
Ga Hing C.

Very nice service! Got their mini strawberry cheesecake and it was a bit pricy ($6). The texture was not as creamy as I like it, felt like those no bake cheesecakes (jello-pudding consistency) but still good.

Almond creme fruit cake~Very good
Mei C.

This year's office potluck was kept small and simple. Someone brought in this wonderfully decorated cake from Bay ridge Bakery and it was the highlight of my day. The cake was super moist with a fluff of lite creme and almond filling. I couldn't get enough of this delicious cake.. The fruit toppings were all drenched in sugar glaze; wasn't too thrill with that though. Bakery offers lots of varieties of pastries and cookies as well. Will definitely stop by to purchase their sweets.

Black Forest cake
Reham M.

I'm updating my review, unfortunately from 5 stars to 1 star. I honestly don't know what went wrong with this bakery but something happened and their cakes are not the same anymore. I've always loved their Black Forest cake and I tried several other cakes and they were all really good and moist and just had the right amount of buttercream that made the cake so delicious. A couple of months ago I was nearby so I went in and ordered a black forest as always, when I got back home and tried it, the cake was dry and definitely has been in the fridge for so long and wasn't fresh. The next day, the leftovers of that cake smelled weird, rotten or something, I threw it away and didn't enjoy the whole thing. I thought oh well, maybe cuz of COVID they are not baking daily as the demand is not high. Yesterday was my son's birthday and I went there a day before and pre-ordered a cake, informed the employee who's working there that my last experience was awful and cake was dry , " please make sure that it'll be baked fresh and it's moist" she told me not to worry and took my order. In the birthday party, when we cut the cake and I tried it, I was soooo disappointed of how DRY the cake was! It's for sure not fresh and not baked for this occasion though I pre-ordered a day before! Also their buttercream filling was waaaay buttery (if that's a word) that you can't eat it, I had to throw a lot of the filling as you feel you're eating raw butter (noticed the guests did the same as well) because it's way too much! Not enjoyable at all. Last pic (the darker one) is from yesterday's cake.

Amy N.

It was my turn to bring the sweets. We had a playdate, and this time we were invited to Katie's place. Originally stopped by Monaco's but found out they were closed on Mondays, so immediately went on Yelp to look for another resort and found Bay Ridge Bakery. Didn't see any labels of the cakes and sweets in the counter so I picked with my eyes. The Strawberry Cheesecakes were decadent. There was an orange flavored cake that was very refreshing. The chocolate slice was rich. I also got a round shaped cake, or was it more of a cookie, not too sure but it was sure ex-creamy good. I really didn't get the names of the sweets so you guys would have to reference with the pictures I took.

a strawberry and chocolate cake in a box

See all

Photo of Phil M.
73
468
681

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

16 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

16 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 4 of 4

Ask the Community - Bay Ridge Bakery

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Bakeries 71,296 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Laza Dessert Cafe

Laza Dessert Cafe

4.1
(42 reviews)
0.5 mi

Laza Cafe is the place to be for intricate and elaborate desserts. I haven't been here since the…read morename rebrand, but their location on Steinway is always popping, and I had to see for myself what the fuss is about with this joint right in the heart of Bay Ridge Brooklyn. Firstly the rebrand has been phenomenal, I love the care that has obviously gone in to the packaging, transportation and delivery of my order. It really felt like it was delivered straight from the shop with no problems. The lotusella crepe was every biscoff lover's dream come true. The pairing with chocolate and banana and strawberry is a classic hit and I love that they didn't skimp on the chocolate or biscoff here. The layers of crepe were appropriate thickness and not too dense. I hate when they crepe is too thick and feels like you're getting a mouthful of dough. Not with this bad boy. I like the dusting of lotus crumbs and they actually don't go soggy which is nice. I can't wait to try more things of their menu. A true neighborhood gem!!

This is for delivery. Seriously craving crêpes and read terrific things about this place so I…read morethought I'd give it a go. I believe they also go by the name Laza Dessert Cafe. We ordered one strawberry and one strawberry banana crêpe. They were filled with strawberries and bananas, and the outside was drizzled with glorious Nutella, which is a hazelnut chocolate sauce . The texture of the crêpes were absolutely perfect and that was the part I was most craving. I also loved the Nutella part. The banana and strawberry not so much as to me that didn't really have much of a taste, but maybe that was because the rest of it was super flavorful and over powered the fruit. All good and definitely satisfied my crêpe craving, but next time I would stop by to enjoy their desserts in person. The Kunafa looks particularly wonderful and has definitely peaked my curiosity.

Photos
Laza Dessert Cafe
$13.99-Dubai Crepe 10/10 it was delicious (added Banana {$1})
$13.99-Dubai Crepe 10/10 it was delicious (added Banana {$1})
Laza Dessert Cafe

See all

Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain

Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain

4.0
(861 reviews)
4.1 mi
$$

FARMACY Deli on Henry & Sackett is an absolute gem in Carroll Gardens. If you're looking for that…read moreclassic Brooklyn pharmacy-style soda fountain vibe with a modern touch, this is the place. The ice cream is incredible--rich, flavorful, and tastes homemade. The mango is a standout, and the brownies are honestly next-level--warm, decadent, and just a step away from a perfect lava cake. They've also got amazing cakes (including a fantastic carrot cake) and a great selection of treats that keep you coming back. What really makes this place special, though, is the owner, Peter. He's always welcoming, professional, and genuinely kind. He greets customers with a smile, takes the time to say hello, and creates an atmosphere that feels both personal and inviting. The staff deserves just as much praise--every single one of them is amazing: professional, friendly, funny, and kind. I've known many of them over time, and they consistently go above and beyond. Today, one of the staff members was incredibly sweet--she even brought my order out to me while I was sitting in my car. That kind of service is rare and really shows how much they care. The shop itself is spotless--seriously clean, top to bottom--and there's even a cozy outdoor seating area where you can sit and enjoy your coffee or dessert. Brooklyn FARMACY at its best--fresh, friendly, local, and full of charm. Highly recommend stopping by--you won't regret it.

I have had Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain bookmarked for ages - I can't even remember when it…read morelanded in there. Anyway, I was in Brooklyn with my brother to see a concert and had just finished dinner. We had some time before doors opened so we decided to grab a little ice cream before heading over to the venue. Farmacy was steps away - it all seemed like it was meant to be, so off we went. Farmacy aims to capture the nostalgia of an old fashioned soda shop and ice cream parlor. Immediately upon walking in we were greeted by aesthetics - the tile, fixtures, and decor totally give off that vibe. There are a few tables to sit as well as a large bar area with stools; I also noticed a few tables set up outside as well. The traffic flow is set up so that you order first and then have it served to you after sitting. Browsing the menu, I noticed they have a selection of ice cream scoops, shakes, egg creams, specialty sodas, hot chocolates, and a large variety of sundae creations. Since we were there for ice cream, we decided to split a sundae -specifically the Sir Twix-a-Lot. This was chunks for shortcake tossed in caramel and topped with vanilla ice cream that was coated in a chocolate shell. Overall I thought the sundae was solid - but the combinations of textures weren't my favorite to be honest, mostly with how the shortcake played with the ice cream. It wasn't bad though - the flavors definitely gave the Twix aesthetic. My only other issue with the dish was that because chocolate shell was used, any residue at the bottom was hard so you have to chisel it if you want to savor any last spoonfuls; I guess that comes with the territory. Service was good - everyone was friendly. It wasn't too busy when we were there so we had our selection of seats and our ice cream was ready pretty quickly. Overall, I'm glad I finally tried Brooklyn Farmacy out - they have a large selection so I would definitely return when I'm in the area again.

Photos
Memorabilia
Memorabilia
Broken dreams
Broken dreams
Have a seat.

See all

Have a seat.
Laser Wolf

Laser Wolf

4.4
(521 reviews)
7.3 mi
$$$$

In one word: incredible!…read more We enjoyed the friendly arrival to the elevator, and then up to the top floor for a great view, We have eaten all over the world and everyone in our party found the food just delicious! We enjoyed the unique way the restaurant made the small condiments available--highlights were the Persian cucumbers, fresh hummus and olive oil with I believe was a potato dish. We tried a number of grilled meats which were all tender and absolutely cooked to perfection. I also noticed a few grilled vegetable dishes which would be perfect for my daughter since she is Vegan! Thank you again for a great experience!

I enjoyed Laser Wolf's prix fixe format where your grill choice automatically comes with silky…read morehummus, warm pita and a daily spread of four salatim. Before the main even arrives you're already happy! The pickled vegetables, baba ganoush, cabbage salad and olives kept things exciting from the start. The Steak Shishlik was the real moment though, beautifully charred, tender and served on a metal platter with pickled red onions and sumac tahini. Just really solid, satisfying dish. Drinks were a vibe too. The Pomegranate Cosmo was deep pink, orchid-topped and delicious. The Hot Crush brought a bright kiwi flavor with just enough spice to keep it interesting. And the Brown Sugar Soft Serve with halva oat crumble to finish? Light, a little crunchy and the perfect ending.

Photos
View from the counter
View from the counter
Platter with dips etc
Platter with dips etc
Window view

See all

Window view
The Chocolate Room

The Chocolate Room

4.3
(700 reviews)
4.3 mi
$$

It's never too crowded or empty when I visit. It's 'the chocolate room' but the smell of chocolate…read moredoesn't hit you in the face like a brick when you enter the shop. It's pleasant. The staff are nice, relaxed. It's a nice spot to get something to sip on and catch up with a friend. Get some cupcakes to go if there are any left.

Cute spot for a sweet break. Coffee, sweets of all kinds, chocolates, and baked goods are on the…read moremenu. Seating space (not a lot of it, so I imagine it can get packed on busy times) and bathrooms on premises. Hot chocolate was delicious. We got the spiced dark chocolate and the spices were overwhelming. Get dark chocolate without spices. The extra dollar for marshmallow made the chocolate even sweeter, so it was overwhelming and I wouldn't recommend. But. The extra dollar for whipped cream would be nice because the their homemade whipped cream isn't sweet, so it will just thicken up the drink and give you that extra texture oooomph that you'll appreciate. Torino cafe is basically coffee added to any hot chocolate of your choice. That was tasty with dark chocolate. You definitely tasted the coffee and it was less thick than regular hot chocolate (which was on a thinner, sippier side). You can sample ice cream to make your selection. It's all very sweet, so if you're looking for a less sweet option go with Belgian dark chocolate flavor. For a $18 banana split you get three scoops of ice cream and a caramelized banana. Not a big portion for such hefty price. The tiny addition of toppings didn't make this banana split come together into a cohesive dish. Would get something else next time. Definitely not a good deal. Young lovely girls at the cashier were super friendly and accommodating. The not so young gentleman with a mustache who brought our order to the table was very dismissive and rude when we asked him to please bring us a correct order (he carried multiple orders and was harried to be done delivering them and barked something incoherent at us when we asked for help).

Photos
Dark Chocolate Pecan Square. Outstanding
Dark Chocolate Pecan Square. Outstanding
Dark Chocolate Pecan Square. Outstanding
Dark Chocolate Pecan Square. Outstanding
Inside

See all

Inside

Bay Ridge Bakery - bakeries - Updated July 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...