Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Bay Ridge Bakery

    3.9 (125 reviews)
    ModerateBakeries, Desserts
    Closed • 10:00 am - 8:00 pm

    Bay Ridge Bakery Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Bay Ridge Bakery

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Carrot Cake [$5]
    Felisa F.

    I stopped by and bought, what I think, was the last piece of carrot cake [$5]. It was actually really light and not overly sweet. There's a perfect amount of cream cheese frosting on top and in the layers. The raisins were juicy and tart. This cake was really amazing. Bay Ridge Bakery is the epitome of an old school Brooklyn bakery. Lots of neon florescent lighting and display cases of butter cookies and cake. There's also a whole section devoted to gluten free goods. I would love to have another slice of carrot cake..not right now but sometime soon.

    Irish soda bread

    Irish soda bread yesterday was somehow missing an ingredient because it was flat, dense and dry! For 3 tiny connolis $5. that doesn't make sense, to much for minis! It was tasty but cream seemed like it was slightly low in quality! I don't live around there but was dining in Skinflints and visited the bakery. The young lady was welcoming and the twin tower cake was interesting and a cool story!!

    Fruit Tart
    Reema S.

    This place has had a chokehold on me since 2018 when I had a bite of their Chocolate Mousse cake. I have been coming here religiously for years. This bakery is an absolute local gem. I will drive out of my way to get a cake from them on a special occasion if I have to. The pastries are to die for. Presentation is beautiful and professional with cute chocolate buttons and glaze. The taste of everything is amazing and the sweets are not too expensive. This is a classic bakery with very high quality cakes. My favorite pastries are the german chocolate cake, chocolate mousse cake and the pineapple coconut. Love this little bakery!!

    Cookie Display Case
    Mike A.

    My favorite bakery in Bay Ridge! I love this place. My belt doesn't but I do. The deserts here are always so good. I never bring these pastries somewhere where I don't hear "Oh that's good!" You really can't go wrong here with a choice, and you have plenty of choice. I've never had a problem with the service. The women at the register are always nice knowledgeable, and help you out. This reminds me of the bakeries I grew up with in the city. Nice local people who know what they're doing, good food, and like the radio set to the oldies station in the background. It's a vibe.

    Blessings I.

    Everything is tasty and sweet. Every cake that we have tasted so far is awesome. The cookies tastes great too.

    Butter cookies

    Stumbled upon this cute bakery 2 or 3 years ago and this has been a go-to every time I'm in Bay Ridge. The butter cookies are my absolute favorite. They have a light crunch and chocolate dipped end with sprinkles. This is a nice family owned business and each time I've visited I was always met with a sweet and courteous worker. I'll be back!

    $6 Mini Strawberry Cheesecake
    Ga Hing C.

    Very nice service! Got their mini strawberry cheesecake and it was a bit pricy ($6). The texture was not as creamy as I like it, felt like those no bake cheesecakes (jello-pudding consistency) but still good.

    Almond creme fruit cake~Very good
    Mei C.

    This year's office potluck was kept small and simple. Someone brought in this wonderfully decorated cake from Bay ridge Bakery and it was the highlight of my day. The cake was super moist with a fluff of lite creme and almond filling. I couldn't get enough of this delicious cake.. The fruit toppings were all drenched in sugar glaze; wasn't too thrill with that though. Bakery offers lots of varieties of pastries and cookies as well. Will definitely stop by to purchase their sweets.

    Black Forest cake
    Reham M.

    I'm updating my review, unfortunately from 5 stars to 1 star. I honestly don't know what went wrong with this bakery but something happened and their cakes are not the same anymore. I've always loved their Black Forest cake and I tried several other cakes and they were all really good and moist and just had the right amount of buttercream that made the cake so delicious. A couple of months ago I was nearby so I went in and ordered a black forest as always, when I got back home and tried it, the cake was dry and definitely has been in the fridge for so long and wasn't fresh. The next day, the leftovers of that cake smelled weird, rotten or something, I threw it away and didn't enjoy the whole thing. I thought oh well, maybe cuz of COVID they are not baking daily as the demand is not high. Yesterday was my son's birthday and I went there a day before and pre-ordered a cake, informed the employee who's working there that my last experience was awful and cake was dry , " please make sure that it'll be baked fresh and it's moist" she told me not to worry and took my order. In the birthday party, when we cut the cake and I tried it, I was soooo disappointed of how DRY the cake was! It's for sure not fresh and not baked for this occasion though I pre-ordered a day before! Also their buttercream filling was waaaay buttery (if that's a word) that you can't eat it, I had to throw a lot of the filling as you feel you're eating raw butter (noticed the guests did the same as well) because it's way too much! Not enjoyable at all. Last pic (the darker one) is from yesterday's cake.

    Amy N.

    It was my turn to bring the sweets. We had a playdate, and this time we were invited to Katie's place. Originally stopped by Monaco's but found out they were closed on Mondays, so immediately went on Yelp to look for another resort and found Bay Ridge Bakery. Didn't see any labels of the cakes and sweets in the counter so I picked with my eyes. The Strawberry Cheesecakes were decadent. There was an orange flavored cake that was very refreshing. The chocolate slice was rich. I also got a round shaped cake, or was it more of a cookie, not too sure but it was sure ex-creamy good. I really didn't get the names of the sweets so you guys would have to reference with the pictures I took.

    a strawberry and chocolate cake in a box

    See all

    Photo of Phil M.
    73
    468
    681

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    16 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    16 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 4 of 4

    Ask the Community - Bay Ridge Bakery

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Bakeries 74,154 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Mia's Bakery - Oreo cheesecake

    Mia's Bakery

    4.3(1.3k reviews)
    4.5 mi•Cobble Hill, Boerum Hill
    •$$

    Mia's has become my go-to for when I'm looking for a sweet treat or looking to gift someone some…read moresweet treats. Every item I've tried has been delicious. I keep on returning back for their flan. This time, I tried their fruit napoleon and it definitely hit the spot. Their cookies are also super fresh for gifting to folks or hosting. The spot itself is spacious and the service is wonderful. I like that they have outdoor seating as well for summer nights. It's become a regular spot for us when we're craving a sweet treat!

    There are some places that become part of your family's story, and Mia's Bakery is one of ours…read more We've been coming since the day it opened on Smith Street, and everything we've tried, the rainbow cookies, the tres leches, the cheesecake, has been wonderful. But this review is about something bigger than dessert. The strawberry cheesecake here reminds me of my mom. It was her favorite, and it was one of the last desserts I got to share with her. Anytime she wanted a sweet treat, that's what she asked for. Ordering it now keeps me connected to her. This past July, on her 3rd birthday in heaven, I placed an order to celebrate her. The menu only had cherry cheesecake that day, so I wrote a note explaining what the strawberry meant to me. The staff didn't just make it happen, they sent an extra slice of strawberry cheesecake on top of it. That kind of thoughtfulness is rare. The people here have always been this kind. We love everyone who works there, and we're grateful for the small moments of care they've shown our family. Thank you for everything.

    Photos
    Mia's Bakery - Tiramisu

    Tiramisu

    Mia's Bakery
    Mia's Bakery - Baby Shark cake

    See all

    Baby Shark cake

    Bay Ridge Bakery - bakeries - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...