All. You. Hipsters. Shut. The eff. Up. You had enough nerve infiltrating my hood but you're gonna talk smack about the pizzeria while you're at it? Listen, this is my neighborhood pizzeria. Been eating here for over 25 years. I've moved across the country and still, not a single slice has compared. Every time I come back home, the first thing I eat is pizza from this spot. And it's what I eat before I head back. Luckily, you can still get a slice for a decent price. Unlike the apartments around here (thanks to you 1 star review leaving jerks). So consider yourself blessed that the effects of gentrification haven't screwed this hidden jewel of a pizzeria over as badly as the rest of the area. Because I couldn't imagine my neighborhood without this place. Order a fresh pie and get some of the fruit punch. Support local. read more

My favorite neighborhood spot. Customer service is great. I always get a slice of pepperoni. They always put it in the oven until nice and crispy. A slice and a soda after work hits the spot. read more

Best pizza in BK! Huge fan of their slice! They throw it in the oven for you and have it out last. This is a great local spot!

Don't judge a book by its cover works for this place. Old fashioned pizza parlor style decor from the 80s growing up. Pizza did not look that good cold on the pan but after they heated it up it had nice and crispy crust. Even after the pizza sat in the box. The cheese had a nice strong flavor to it also. I would rate this a solid 8.1 definitely would recommend a slice if your in the area. read more

Hella buttery Alfredo that came with a side of bread! The workers were hella nice too :) read more

Bedstuy Mike's Pizza - Alfredo pasta - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I love this place. Local joint been over here for 40(?) years. Ask for a slice and they'll heat it up. I usually get pepperoni and add some chili flakes, parm cheese, and garlic powder. New York pizza can't be beat! CASH ONLY read more

Bedstuy Mike's Pizza - Pepperoni slice - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

The food is good, service is fast and efficient. Bilingual customer service. The establishment is kept clean and wide open so you can get an aroma of their freshly baked goods. read more

Best pizza spot I've had in Brooklyn so far . Garlic knots are delicious and it's not over priced ! The employees are very nice and service was fast for how busy it's stays read more

The pizza is good. I just wish they made the pizza stayed in the over a little bit longer. Their service was good, I think the girl was training, but she did good. I think that's the reason the pizza didn't stay longer. I did in-fact re-heat it when I got home. Besides that there's no complain. Price: 1 slice - $2.50, pepperoni- $3.25 read more

Bedstuy Mike's Pizza - Plain cheese pizza slice - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Pizza here is good! Tried many. Cheese pizza is soooo good too! I love a good slice of cheese pizza. Also the philly cheesesteak with lettuce, tomato, and mayo is perfect! Def a great spot. Cash only. read more

Bedstuy Mike's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I literally just left this place fuming! I've been a loyal customer forever and I will never return. The entire staff is wonderful - but, Salvatore is a complete ass hole! (Apologies to yelp for cursing) Very rude and doesn't handle his position under pressure. I watched him talk about other customers as they were leaving and he gave attitude and was rude to me! I assumed professionalism would be taken serious in the business of customer service. The idea is flipped here on his behalf. read more

I had a grandma and really enjoyed it. The staff is kind and polite and I did not have a very long wait. I cannot complain. I did not get a slice on the strength of the other reviews. read more

I love Mike's pizza the food is always fresh the restaurant is always clean in the workers are very friendly and nice your greeted with smiles as soon as you come in . You never have to wait a long time for your food they have a tv overall it's a good restaurant read more

Not a fan of the pizza here, but the Philly cheesesteak is great!!! It's a must! The bread is soft and lightly toasted the steak is amazing and the cheese omgg. My mouth is watering just thinking about it. The corner store sells cheesesteak sandwiches but they add all types of seasoning to it and it doesn't need all of that. I'm so glad I found this place, it's also super cheap, $6! read more

The crust is whatever, the options are whatever, the price is...whatever ! It's just your neighborhood cheap slice, should be cheaper to match the quality. I know dollar slices that taste better. I can't say I will avoid this place because it's too close to my house, without competition it will keep going. read more

I just ate the worst pizza I've ever had. And I've had Domino's, Pizza Hut, Papa Johns. I once ate a whole $5 gas station pizza on a dare. I know pizza. I fear no pizza. But this... This is not pizza. The crust was somehow burnt, yet still soft and floppy. The sauce tasted like the can it came out of. And the cheese was something else entirely. Some foul, rubbery thing that seemed like it was scraped from the subway tracks. I'm normally very in-depth, but this place blew me away in all the wrong ways. I don't even have the words. This is a strange and terrible place. I will be returning only in my nightmares. read more

It's a pizza shop. It's right next to the Tompkins Houses Projects. It's not good. They have french fries for cheap if you're in the mood and live within the block. But I don't recommend eating the pizza unless you're in a hurry... Since I found Rocco Pizza 8 months ago I haven't been back to this place. And when I used to go here I'd have to add some of my own cheese at home, because they only use some weird greasy thing that's kind of like cheese. They don't have parmesan cheese and the hot sauce is literally watered down. It's next to a chinese place that I'd choose over this place any day of the week. And I really don't even like that Chinese place... read more

Bedstuy Mike's Pizza - Avoid @ All Costs! - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I've been coming here all my life as I'm from the neighborhood, born and raised. My mom knows the owners and the people who work there have seen me grown up. Nicest people ever and really great with the community. With that being said, I've never got food poisoning from here (nor have anyone I've grown up with who also always go to Mike's) or have had soggy pizza or a slice with a pathetic amount of cheese. I've always gotten a fresh slice or a fresh pie.The one star reviews and stupid comments are only from people who are not from the neighborhood from what I see. Anyway, if you come here around Valentine's Day they make heart shaped pizzas! So good!! You will not be disappointed! read more

Bedstuy Mike's Pizza - The heart shaped pizza that they made fresh for me on Valentine's Day!! - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I've been going here since childhood, only pizza ship that has mustard at the counter to try with your Slice everyone I've recommended fell in love with this place read more

This place has been here for 40 years and Still making some great pizza. Fresh ingredients. Can't go wrong. They now offer Grubhub and Uber eats. read more

I've been eating at this pizza spot for over 30 years. Born and raised in Brooklyn (MARCY PROJECTS). I've had pizza all over the U.S and this is and always has been the best. Everytime I'm back home I always stop in at least 4 times when I'm there. Greatest pizza....salute. read more

I don't recommend. Service was good but the food wasn't. Currently I ate there about a dozen times and about half the time I got sick from the food. I tried giving them a chance to redeem themselves but I ended up getting sick with the flip of a coin read more

I'm biased. I've been eating Mike's pizza for 25 years. Yup, they have longevity like that. It's around the way Brooklyn pizza. It's perfectly greasy with a good amount of cheese and no extra doughy taste. Yum! It's not gourmet and definitely not fine dining. It's also not overpriced or pretentious. Whenever I am closeby I try to grab a slice. They also have an extended menu of pastas and burgers, but I stick with the pizza. read more

This is no frills but amazing pizza. I've been coming here since I was four years old way before yuppies starting coming to Bed Stuy. Order a freshly made personal pizza to go and you won't be disappointed! read more

This place is not bad. It's your typical, run-of-the-mill pizza spot. The sicilian needs improvement.

Been going here for a few years. Always get the same thing- baked ziti w chicken. It comes w a warm hero as the bread. Get it w extra butter. It's ghetto food = cheap ($7), super fast, and huge enough to equal 2-3 meals. It's not little Italy good, but gets the job done. Pizza is ehh- its good if you're in a pinch and need caloric intake pronto- but you're better off walking 2 blocks over ... read more

I got the meat lovers pizza and got food poisoning!!!! I would not recommend this place ever unless you want to be throwing up all night long. read more

Not terrible pizza, although nothing fancy about it. 8.99$ for a large pie on Sundays & VERY quick delivery - it was here in less than 20 minutes!! Good to feed drunk friends at the end of a long night/mornin :) read more

Mike's is my fave pizza spot on the north side of bed-stuy. They are very fast, efficient and no frills. Very inexpensive. They serve NY-style pizza with a thinner crust, but it's not neapolitan style. I consider it better than Rocco's which is a few blocks away, but that's my personal preference. In particular I like their basic cheese slice and their mozzarella basil slice. Good bang for your buck here. read more

Their pizza is good. But the dough in their chicken Rolls are usually under done. I actually have to ask them to make mine well done so that my dough isn't under cooked. Other than that the food is pretty good. read more

Great pizza! I've been getting pizza from here for 2 1/2 years and I love it. It's the best in the neighborhood. read more

This pizza is disgusting. The sauce taste plain and the dough is soggy.

Their services is very good and I liked that they had my order on time(I ordered a beef patty.) It was pretty good I would definitely recommend this restaurant to one of my friends. The only downside it their not open when it is time for me to get breakfast and be early for school. read more

This food looks old even when it comes straight out the oven. I would not eat there even if it was free. Stay away, jump on a train to go eat, walk a few blocks. Not worth it at all. read more