The most delicious, creamy scrambled eggs I have ever eaten (and I am 70 years young). lovely atmosphere. French toast was also good but portion was small and not filling for my hubby. Will return next time we are on the Island. read more

Ok, this place is perfection. The decor, the food, the service is amazing. If I lived there, i would forever be there. So i went for breakfast and as soon as you walk in you see a casual outdoor tent setting with a raw bar outside. Walk to the back and you order your breakfast. Everyone was super friendly. I ordered their avocado toast with soft boiled eggs. I didnt even know anyone can achieve those flavors. It was perfect. I washed it down with an iced lavender latte... yup... it felt so zen! Definitely a repeat spot for future trips! read more

Behind The Bookstore - Avocado toast with soft boiled eggs - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

Such a bizarre experience, I don't get the hype. Drinks were wildly overpriced and the food was horrible. My burger was complete dried out, the fries were clearly frozen fries and my wife's salad had only 2 pieces of shrimp on it. read more

Behind The Bookstore - Burger - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

A general note of appreciation to "BTB" for staying open well past peak season this year. I also appreciated their branching out their coffee service into Vineyard Haven for part of the summer, though that secondary location closed immediately after Labor Day - hope it may return next year. Food items in general are on the high end price-wise, though I have found the quality to be correspondingly high of those entrees that I have tried. The "porridge" (interesting to see that dish name on an American menu) was particularly memorable. I have come to rely on a semi-regular dosage of their coffees this year, finding that they often offer the highest flavor quality to be found across the island. Pastries are also worth considering, though can also be priced on the high side. read more

Beautiful environment but the customer service is ok. We got 2 salads and there was almost no flavor at all. We could tell there was some type of dressing on it but it had truly no flavor. We are really easy customers , so we just went up and asked for some extra dressing of some kind so we could make the best of it. They told us the kitchen was closed and there was nothing they could do. The meal was 60$ for two salads and a appetizer of lobster spring rolls. The spring rolls were pretty good but definitely unhappy with paying 60$ and getting 2 salads with no flavor or a willingness to refund our money. read more

Cute setup (def check out the book store in front) great for breakfast. Unfortunately there is no wait service. You have to wait online to order and then hope for a table to open up for seating outside. The outdoor area is very cute but restricted due to covid. The line was long but my shakshuka was delicious along w the lavender latte read more

Behind The Bookstore - Shakshuka - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

Strong drinks, good ambiance, nice staff but the cocktail menu that's based on famous author names is sorely missing any female authors. Wharton? Austen? Eliot? Chopin? We ask that they diversify. Thank you for your time. Peace and love. read more

Emma was awesome. Be careful when you go inside the girl at the register, Sarah, is horrible. She definitely has no people skills. She should probably find another job behind a computer where she doesn't have to talk to people. 1.) she expects you to know the menu when you question something she gives you an attitude. 2.) she doesn't welcome you when you come in. 3.) she doesn't thank you when you leave. When you get a croissant and a 30-45ml coffee that's way overpriced for what you get the least you should get is great customer service. read more

Two words: avocado toast. Mmmmm. My husband and I came here after finding just about every other Edgartown breakfast joint closed for the season. This place was open, but with a limited menu and outdoor seating only. No matter - the selections they had were sufficient and the food and beverage delightful! We sat outside (seemed to be dog friendly) in a lovely little area tucked away from the street. We ordered the chai latte (yum) and the mocha latte (my husband said the best he's ever had). For food, I ordered the avocado toast, piled high with fresh avocado and sprinkled with some lovely specialty salt and pepper. My husband had the fried egg BLT and he said it delivered! This place was just adorable and exactly what we needed for a lovely Saturday breakfast. Thanks for being open, Behind the Bookstore! read more

See all

This restaurant was really cute! Service was fast and very safe especially with new covid restrictions. Avocado Toast was phenomenal with ricotta on top and the Chopped Salad with grilled shrimp was a refreshing lunch on a hot day. The only complaint we had was that we wish there were more menu options, but they may have been limited due to covid 19. Would definitely recommend!! read more

Behind The Bookstore - ambiance - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

I ordered a chopped salad. The lettuce was cold almost frozen. The lettuce was brown as well. It was drenched in salad dressing. It was a $20 salad which I returned. The owner/manager was extremely rude however he did give me a refund. He didnt look at me or apologize. What a disappointment read more

As others are noting, the burger is bad. Really, really bad. Billed as a "smash" burger, it is not smashed. It's just a frozen burger patty that is massively over-cooked. The salad was also sub-par. I don't know what they were going for with their dressing and grilled under-ripe peaches, but it didn't work. Giving the place 3 stars (instead of fewer) because the cocktails at Hennessy Bar are legit excellent. read more

Agreeing with others - the service here is truly terrible. I came in at noon on a weekend for lunch. I ordered an iced latte, and the woman taking the order missed the "iced" part when putting the order in. I gently corrected them when I got the hot drink, and the woman who took my order told me, in a sarcastic tone, "If you wanted it iced, you should have asked for iced." That's it, no indication as to whether they would remake the drink. Just condescension, even though she was the one who got the order wrong. She also gave my friend an attitude and rolled her eyes when he asked her about a specialty drink. You're not obligated to educate anyone who can't google what a latte is, but when the menu doesn't explain any of the specialty drinks, people will have questions. I talked to a manager about this, but the manager responded "Oh, I'm sorry, he's just always like that." Turns out the manager thought I meant the barista. Yikes. (Edit: the barista Mikhail is now personally harassing me) But the manager did seem apologetic and asked if there was anything she could do, and took the rude person off the register. The iced latte was good, and the seating area was nice, but we waited a long time for our food. It took around 40 minutes to get our orders, even though the place wasn't crowded, and we ordered sandwiches off the menu without substitutions. Another friend split off from our group, went to go get a meal at a different place, ate it, and came back before we even got our first sandwich. Sandwiches were ~$13 and bad. The brisket was dry and my other friend couldn't even get halfway through her turkey sandwich. I also got a biscuit, which was stale and greasy. Tl;dr: we overpaid so that someone could be mean to us while we waited a long time for our bad food to arrive. ----- EDIT: After this review, Mikhail, a barista at BTB, started harassing me on Yelp. Mikhail the barista left three 5-star reviews of BTB, using different accounts and different names (H D.; Mikhail S.; & California D.) Two of these accounts (H D. & California D.) private messaged me via Yelp to send me a copy of Mikhail S.'s review. All three left separate 5-star reviews for BTB, two of which mentioned me by name (WTF?). See attached screenshots. It's really shady that BTB had their employee leave fake 5-star reviews. Let's be clear. I did not engage in any of the behavior Mikhail's ranting about. I did, however, notice that they had gotten my drink order wrong, and asked them to correct it. It wasn't busy, and this happens all the time. The costs of remade (or spilled) drinks are built into the profit margins of any stable business (especially at BTB prices). Mikhail did not actually hear me order. I saw him making drinks a couple of feet away while I was ordering. Basically, an employee who wasn't even there during the transaction is harassing a customer via Yelp using multiple fake accounts. Mikhail went out of his way to make a bad experience worse even days later, and personally messaging me multiple copies of his same incoherent ramblings is beyond creepy and inappropriate. No customer should expect to be treated like this by an employee, ever. EDIT 2: I spoke with BTB manager Elana about Mikhail's messages to me. She said that he had removed his reviews addressing me and would not be harassing me further. As of 11AM on 7/8, his review is still up, and Mikhail is still working at BTB, and was not disciplined. BTB apparently prefers to create fake social media accounts to harass customers who leave bad reviews, rather than being polite to customers or serving food that tastes good. read more

See all

Located in the main/downtown area in Edgartown, Martha's Vineyard, Massachusetts- Behind the Bookstore is an adorable café/restaurant with both indoor and outdoor seating. I actually discovered this place because I needed to use the restroom and I stopped here. While I was waiting in line (for about 10 minutes-there's is only one restroom for everyone), I got a great chance to look around and see how charming this place was. Also, while waiting in line - I got to peek into the kitchen because the door was open. I could tell that one of the chefs was eating. I found this to be a little bit alarming and it sort of grossed me out. Eating, over food that is being made to feed to restaurant patrons didn't really sit well with me.The menu had some very healthy items on it as well as delicious coffee drinks. The outdoor seating is really cute and there was not a table available. You could tell it was a good mix of the summer locals and tourists. I ended up standing in line to get a coffee. I got a medium, dark roast iced coffee and it was delicious. I wish we had more time to sit down and enjoy the outdoor area and pick off of the menu, but I suggest going here for its Edgartown charm. I will be returning to eat some food, next summer! read more

Behind The Bookstore - Halfway through my delicious BTB iced coffee in Edgartown. - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

I happened upon this little place while meandering around on my own before all of my friends woke up on Labor Day weekend. Any place with baked goods is automatically going to earn my patronage -- especially when the baked goods look as delectable as the ones here! I had a fennel ricotta muffin, which is a combo I've never seen before. It didn't taste much like fennel (a good thing, in my book) and was just very moist. I wish I would've picked up some of the other carb-filled goodies. Also had fresh pressed juice (watermelon, cucumber, lemon). So fresh! Great to have first thing in the morning. I probably would've given this place 4 stars except I found it to be rather expensive. Now, yes, I know this is on Martha's Vineyard...so I should expect that, but c'mon...it was around $10 for juice and a muffin. read more

Behind The Bookstore - Mmmmmmm baked goods - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

See all

Soooo beautiful, great cocktails, thoughtful service, innovative cuisine. Reservations a must!

One of the quaintest and coolest restaurants in Edgartown.Arrived for cocktails and could not have been more pleased with the atmosphere,the service,the decor,the amazing cocktails.Certainly worth returning. read more

See all

Visiting Martha's Vineyard for the week. Came here due to a recommendation from a friend. The management is extremely rude and the servers are as well. I went back inside to get a packet of sugar for my coffee since they didn't make it very good and two of the servers gave me a nasty look and the manager proceeded to scream at me to get out. When we finally got a table outside we kindly asked after 5 minutes of standing if it could be cleaned off because it was dirty from the last customer that sat there. The server proceeded to snap at us and told us that we were very impatient. After this, they proceeded to get our order wrong and told us we were wrong and not them, only to take back their statement after seeing our receipt. We will never come back here. the very nice setting is not worth the amount of disrespect you will receive upon your visit. Sincerely, A pissed off customer read more

Absolutely delicious selection of specialty lattes. I had the Orange Thyme iced with almond milk and it was probably one of the best coffee beverages I've ever had. The atmosphere was beautiful and they were playing a mix of Celine Dion, Whitney Houston, etc and it just fit the vibe so perfectly. read more

We had breakfast here on a weekday. The coffee is excellent, the best I had in Martha's Vineyard and comparable to my favorite coffee in NY. For breakfast we ordered at the counter (1 cappuccino, 1 latte, 1 shakshouka and 1 slice of almond strawberry cake). You have to carry your coffee over but they will bring your food out when it is ready. Everything was excellent, the cake was so fresh it was still a little warm. They told us that a baker comes in at 5 am every morning and bakes everything from scratch. The shakshouka was great and we wanted some extra bread which they provided us with at no cost. read more

Behind The Bookstore - Shakshouka - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

See all

Really disappointing. Ordered a cappuccino, paid and gave a tip. When barista put the cup on the counter for me, I saw a small 8oz cup that was 3/4's full. I asked about the cup size and why it wasn't in the 12oz cup. "Oh we put lattes in those, cappuccinos in the smaller." Hmmm. So I got 3ozs of coffee, 1oz of foam, and 2ozs of empty space for $5, and waited 5:30 to get it. Not even close to being worth it. Too many other choices in town, so I'll leave this cafe Behind. read more

I always stop here, when I am on the Vineyard, for cappuccino...scones....snacks type things. One of these visits, we will try dinner..... Conveniently located behind the Edgartown Books, you are able to eat outside, under shelter (no rain worries), and listen to pleasant tunes....highly recommend! read more

There are no truly gluten free options here, but modifications were not too difficult and the staff were helpful. My coffee is delicious (I tend to the hypercritical with coffee) the outdoor space is calming and open/fresh like a little oasis. We ordered the Shakshuka-Baked Eggs and the Fried Egg BLT (which they can do in a bowl) and both were superb. Note- the coffee is SO good that I ordered too many and am getting cracked out. Oops. read more

Behind The Bookstore - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

This cafe is in a very cute location but has pretty limited seating so have a backup plan if they are full. We went here for breakfast, I got the avocado and egg sandwich which a matcha latte and my friend for the Shakshuka with a lavender latte. My Egg sandwich was good but would of liked a fried eggs over scrambled but they didn't seem open to substitutions. I tried a bite of the shakshuka and that was delicious, will be my top choice next time I go back. Both the lavender and Matcha lattes were delicious as well! The menu is more limited but I think that is to be expected for a smaller cafe. Definitely would recommended to anyone visiting the area, between the food and atmosphere it was a great breakfast! read more

Incredibly overpriced and meh food. Cashiers & workers aren't friendly & don't provide good customer service. Getting a table is a difficult feat. It is located in a cute area but I wouldn't go back. read more

Very cute place, but VERY average food and VERY expensive. If you have another option, take it.

BTB has a great ambiance. I've been here for breakfast and coffee and heard great things about the dinner as well. Avocado toast was delicious as well as the breakfast sandwich. The outdoor seating under the tent/trees is magical !! Would recommend this place for all times of day. read more

Behind The Bookstore - Avocado toast, breakfast sandwich, matcha - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

Oh hi to my favorite coffee shop ever! BTB is hidden place in Edgartown, found out about it in July probably. So cozy, the staff is super cool. Uhhh the best coffee I have ever tried in my entire life! Can't wait to have Lavender latte! read more

Behind The Bookstore - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

The food, location, ambiance, and servers were terrific. The place was nicely crowded for Saturday brunch and the only problem was the limited availability of tables. I couldn't believe that the owner was sitting and chatting with only one person at a table for 5 at the height of the morning rush, while the poor hostess was struggling to find people tables. The whole time I was there, someone else sat alone waiting at a table for 5 for more than 40 minutes before any of his companions arrived. Both showed a lack of consideration for other guests. But I have to say the food was lovely and the coffee was great. If you get a table easily you will really enjoy yourself. read more

Behind The Bookstore - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

This charming little spot is tucked back quite literally behind the bookstore. We stopped here off the bike trail for a quick drink and the rose lemonade hit the spot on a hot summer day. We were pretty confused from the time we got there. Do we snag a table? Is there some sort of host? Do we order at our table? What if we want water? It was a bit of a cluster, but we figured it out and once we got settled really ended up enjoying the relaxed vibe of this spot! read more

Would like to give zero. Food looked amazing but ours never came. Rude owners did t care That people around us ordered an eight and left and we were still waiting for food 45 minutes later. I would not recommend. Waited for food and had he nerve to charge us for our two coffees even after they forgot our order. read more

VERY pricey - but you're in Edgartown so I mean, expect it. That being said, venue space is as unique as they come. A must stop for any foodie or visitor to the island. read more

The food here is about as overpriced as the rest of the Island, so don't be surprised. I think that the workers are tired of serving all of the rich people so they're a bit rude. For example my husband asked nicely "could I trouble you for a glass of ice?" and the woman said "no but you can trouble him!" and pointed at her coworker. Overall with the amount of people who need jobs right now you think that they could hire some nicer people. I probably would recommend going elsewhere unless you don't mind waiting in a long line for your food only to be greeted by rude staff. Also the seating situation is a lot. I'm not ready for this amount of competition before my morning coffee. read more

Dinner review: mediocre and over priced food and drink paired with laughable service! ...it's cute though...

Cute outdoor space! Short order place with an excellent vibe. We had breakfast sandwiches and coffee. Would definitely go back.

You need to check out this hidden gem. Hidden off the road we stopped by just for an ice coffee. The pastry was too tempting to pass up and the cold brew was great! Tented tables it was just great! read more

Behind The Bookstore - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

Cute place that was hidden. Originally I was just looking for a restroom but I ended up ordering the Mint latte. It had a pretty unique taste and I've never had it before. It was a hot day that day so the drink was pretty refreshing. There was also like a patio/ outside area that's shaded that you could sit down. I thought it was pretty cool and the ambiance was nice. The workers were helpful and very knowledgeable as well. This place is literally behind the bookstore. What a cute name. read more

I went to Behind the Bookstore on 9/9/2020. The line to order was long but we patiently waited our turn for 40 minutes. By the time we were able to place our order it was 11:35 AM. The clerk informed us that they stopped serving breakfast at 11:30 and lunch was not being served until 12:00. She offered coffee or pastries instead. Why would we have stood in line for 40 minutes for a pastry? We left without placing an order and will never return. For future reference I would suggest that someone from the establishment let the customers standing in line know that they will not be able to order food when it is getting close to the time that you can't order. Very poor customer service! read more

Cool spot and ambiance, but food is just average and overpriced. Worth checking out but don't need to go back.

Outdoor seating only. Excellent food. Handmade linguine delicious and different. Lamb burger was great. Expensive. read more