Stopped in there for a quick lunch and was shocked by how good their pizza was for being a local…read moreplace. Had a individual mushroom and margherita slices and what makes them special the crust. It was perfectly balanced between thickness and crunchiness without being floppy.

Not sure what planet the owner is living on after my last order here…read more Grew up in New York, with unquestionably better pizza options all around me. Aside from that, I've had some of the best in NYC and NJ, and usually if I go back to a pizza shop, one of my more favorite tests of quality is either a Sicilian pie, or more specifically a grandma pie. Never, in my entire 41 years on this planet, I have never seen a grandma pie made any other way than a thin Sicilian crust with tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil, and olive oil drizzle to finish. I got some thicker crusted, upside down Sicilian pie that didn't have fresh mozzarella or proper sauce. Again - not sure what the chef or owner think that was, but it was not a grandma pie. Was matter-of-factly told with a lot of pompous arrogance that I had no idea what I was talking about and that this was a grandma pie. Didn't even ask for a refund. Threw this monstrosity out and just took a $20 lesson to know to never order from this place again.

Joe's Pizzeria is tucked away in a shopping plaza right off where the Route 206 bypass and business…read moreportions meet in Hillsborough, NJ. I hadn't stopped by in over 10 years, so figured I'd order a pizza as I was passing through the area and you generally get a decent pie with Italian-owned pizzerias in New Jersey. We went with a standard large cheese pizza, which came in just north of $21 when paying with a credit card, which I consider on the steep side for central NJ. The pizza was the standard uninspired average Jersey pie without anything memorable about the sauce, cheese, or crust. There was nothing particularly bad about it, but the pizza just didn't tantalize the tastebuds enough to warrant a repeat visit or recommendation to others from me, as there's other pizzerias in the area that make a better pie. The inside of the restaurant was pretty nice, so perhaps their wheelhouse for food is pasta dishes/sandwiches, or maybe I just caught them on an off day in the kitchen for pizza.

Has been a favorite of mine for YEARS. I love the variety of pizzas, with the Sicilian,…read morecheesesteak, and bruschetta pizzas being my favorites. Service is always good and the food is always fresh. Can't recommend this place enough!

Great place for some pizza right behind the farmers market complex. We got a large plain and…read morepepperoni to go with the Tuesday special. We ate a slice fresh when we got out of the restaurant and it was amazing. The cheese was goopy and melted off the slice, and the crust was nice. We will be back!

Great pizza! I ordered this for a kids party and the parents were blown away. The cheese pizza is…read morevery tasty and their specialty pies are amazing. This was a 10 out of 10.

Amazing pizza, truly an institution. Call ahead to reserve your time otherwise you're SOL. Honestly…read moresimple is better here, the pizza is just a masterpiece based on the oven they have. They should never renovate this place. Also bring your own wine, it's BYOB!

We bought a large pie this past Friday. With the pizza reviewer hype, we had to try out one of the…read moretop reviews given to a Nj pizza restaurant. When I picked up my pie, we ate our first slices outside. The pizza was warm, and I wish it was scolding hot. This was phone order that we picked up in 25 minutes. So I don't know if this pie was one that was already made. The pie was well done. I like my pie with some white mozzarella cheese still on the pie. The pie was kinda orange when you look at the pictures I posted. Some of the crust and slice underneath was burnt. Plus when you look at the pie, it was not a perfect circle. One slice was out of place. As for the pizza slice, it was a bit on the salty side. The pizza base crust was a little on the heavy side. It was not thinner or on the lighter side. This reminded me of the way Vermont pizza is made, well done. The pizza was ok, and people's opinion is very subjective. What one person thinks is a 9.4 out of 10, could be an 8.4 by another. I couldn't test if the crust held up the cheese and sauce since I picked it up warm. From what I gathered with the underside crust, I would not flop since the crust was on the heavy side. Overall, I would try it out again and eat in so I get the great experience of the pizza pie coming right out of the oven!

If you don't come here for Italian food in Hillsborough, NJ, you're doing it wrong. I used to live…read morein this area in my teens. This place pretty good back then. As of this writing, this place was taken over a year ago. I've spoken to the owner and I can tell she cares about how the food is made. The hot subs are massive, and so are the Italian hotdogs! (See pic). The veggies in the hotdog are all prepped in house, the way it's supposed to be. Cheers

I stopped in for lunch and got the pesto chicken panini with a side salad. I enjoyed the Panini and…read moreit was a good choice for a light lunch. There wasn't much to the side salad but the balsamic dressing was tasty. It is moderately priced for the portion size so if I ordered another panini here, I would maybe try it with the french fries. I ate in and the seating area was very hot so I would probably take out next time. I did find the service was friendly though.

I'm not sure I reviewed Alfonso's yet. My bad. Alfonso's reminds me of going home to my grandma…read morehouse. Always welcome and always good food! Amazing service. Here you are part of the family. Perfect ambience for the entire family.

Update (Feb 2026)…read more Stopped in to Alfonso's after visiting Princeton NJ, for a late lunch/ early Dinner. Decided to get the Stromboli (Med) ($15). A packed pocket of delicious goodness. Pro tip: get the Medium, it will feed you for Days !!! It's huge ! Service has always been great, and today was no exception. The dinning room was quiet, casual and chill. Which made it easy to just hang out and relax. Follow me on IG, yelp, and YouTube, as I travel the world in search of the best dining entertainment IG: @Noodlesoupr

Tried the panini and fries and I loved it! Called for pick-up, it was quick-easy-and delicious…read more Will definitely be back to try other menu items.

I'm not too big on pizza unless it's really really good. This place had one of the best slices of…read morepizza that I've ever tried. I think it's highly priced but it was a good slice a pizza!! The service was quick and straight to the point! You can sit down and eat inside and there's a table or two outside as well. It was a little hot inside. Either way it's a decent place to get pizza!

Fantastic to work with. Pizza and dessert are perfect every time. Just booked them for our 4th…read morefamily event (birthdays, graduations, just because). Courteous and efficient. Highly recommend for your next event!

Va Fa Napoli Pizza not only serves delicious food but also provides a unique experience. The…read morehomemade crust was cooked beautifully, the toppings were very fresh and the service was exceptional. There was a constant stream of fresh pizza varieties available for enjoying. Overall, a wonderful experience and we loved seeing the oven in action!