Didn't know they opened this location on the far north side. Pleasant surprise! Because I love their Ruebens. Not the biggest place, but service was great and quick, and my Rueben was excellent, like always! read more

Benji's Delicatessen & Restaurant - Just a great Rueben! - Delis Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

ZERO STARS AND TWO THUMBS DOWN!!! SERVICE WAS ABSOLUTELY TERRIBLE. I was on the phone with my friend while he was ordering his food. He ordered steak and eggs. When his order came out, he received bacon which he DOES NOT EAT and have not in over 30 years. The man at the register who claimed to be the manager argued my friend down about what he heard. He continued to say I heard you say bacon. This frustrated me so badly because he was adamantly WRONG! I CLEARLY HEARD MY FRIEND SAY THAT HE WILL TAKE STEAK AND EGGS. AND I KNOW THAT HE DOES NOT EAT BACON SO WHY WOULD HE SAY THAT HE WANTED BACON??? THE MAN WAS INITIALLY TRYING TO MAKE HIM PAY FOR A WHOLE NEW MEAL. I WAS STILL ON THE PHONE AND I TOLD MY FRIEND NO! THAT IS NOT RIGHT. I TOLD HIM TO REQUEST A REFUND! THE MAN SAID HE IS NOT ALLOWED TO GIVE A REFUND BECAUSE HE HEARD HIM SAY BACON. HE DID NOT ORDER BACON. IN A JEWISH DELI...WHY ARE YOU EVEN SERVING PORK?????? HE WENT THERE WITH CONFIDENCE THAT IT WOULD BE KOSHER. My friend asked for the manager and the owner. The man told him he was the manager and to call the owner on Monday. Totally unacceptable! Totally unnecessary. Learn how to apologize when you have clearly made a mistake and correct the mistake that YOU made. My friend was so calm and kind to this rude and unaccountability taking man that it truly frustrated me to witness such bad customer service prompting this review. He even left an undeserving tip. To the owner, if you have cameras... Saturday 9/12/2026 between 10:30 and 11am. My friend did not deserve to be treated so poorly, and I feel something should still be done to correct this horrible service. He has *Dietary restrictions* with pig juice all on his eggs. For shame!!! read more

My cousin brought me here for lunch after I flew into town. She loves this place, and I can see why. She got the Hoppel Poppel and I had a tuna melt. It was delicious. Our server, Linda, was great too! Definitely a must try! read more

Benji's Delicatessen & Restaurant - Delis Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

Been to Benji's a number of times over the years. It's one of those iconic places you have to visit when you're in Milwaukee. It's not the best food I've ever had, but where else can you go to get a matzah ball like this? Food: The food is good, but I wouldn't call it spectacular. I usually order the chicken soup with matzah balls. For me, the soup itself has always been a bit blah, more like a very thin chicken broth. The matzah ball is really the star of the show. I also noticed what other people were eating, and the corned beef sandwich and potato pancakes looked very good. Most people cleaned their plates, which is always a good sign. Service: Service has always been very good. Quick and efficient is the name of the game here. I got a spot at the counter, seated between two other people. Menus, ordering, and the check all happened without much waiting. The servers are friendly, but always on the move. There's not much idle chatter. Atmosphere: The place feels worn, but clean. The large windows bring in lots of natural light. There is booth, table, and counter seating. They fit a lot of people into the space, but it doesn't feel overcrowded. With that many people, the noise level can get loud. Pro tip: The parking lot is small and shared with several other businesses. It's usually best to find a spot on the street. read more

See all

Benji's has long been my preferred establishment for matzo ball soup. However, on this occasion, I opted for a pastrami on rye sandwich accompanied by a side of French fries. The sandwich was delectable, with freshly bread combined with a flavorful brown mustard. The French fries were equally impressive, achieving a perfect balance of crispiness and flavor. Overall, Benji's was an exceptional lunch experience. read more

See all

Fantastic! Really impressed. I haven't been in a while as I moved out of the area. I recently moved back and thought let's try it. It is even better than I remembered. The food was fantastic. The sandwiches are so tasty. The soup was also great. We did order delivery and everything was packaged very well. I will definitely order again. read more

Nobody was friendly here, but I'm still giving it 4 stars cause the food was good. I got the Hear o Israel, it wasn't quite what I saw on the food network but still very good. I've had this place on my radar for awhile, I just felt like they didn't want me there, most employees don't talk to you or look at you unless you directly address them. Weird, but I still need to come back to try the matzo ball soup because that's supposedly a staple menu item read more

Benji's Delicatessen & Restaurant - Hear-O Israel - Delis Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

I wanted to go here my whole life and I finally got here! Looking at pictures from past patrons it didn't quite match the amount of meat in their sandwiches. It was like going back in time to a diner, but everyone was very serious and not sure what the vibe is supposed to be. I opted for the not Italian beef, which was pretty good but very thin on a baguette bun, my dining companion had me try her Benji sandwich and that was much more flavorful. It had a small amount of coleslaw and cheese and battered fries. Now I can take this off my list as having tried it. Potato salad was my favorite of all as it tasted just like homemade and fresh. There are many cameras in the smallest establishment read more

See all

Everything I've had was top shelf if I want guaranteed satisfaction this is the spot!

Great variety of foods and seasonings are just right !! Staff are great and eager to please and check often to ensure all is going well with each guest !!' If you haven't read more

The pizza was great and hot . The restaurant was very quiet but it was cold in there.

Had breakfast / brunch at Benji's and I thought the food was great- and that's really what you're there for. Service was good, and the ambiance was Ok - nothing fancy here. Sit-down and have a feast. read more

See all

The service here is amazing. Their eggs and meats are fantastic. My favorites include: bagel & lox, omelette, and Benji's breakfast. They have the best Reuben I've ever had. We stop in as often as we can! read more

See all

2nd visit. Reuben eggs benedict. Eggs poached perfectly, corned beef tasty and lean. Main issue at this location is food is never hot enough. Cheese not melted, kraut and beef only lukewarm. The hollandaise is made specially for this sandwich and has a hint of thousand island in it which is a nice touch, but it is very sparing. Definitely needs more. read more

Benji's Delicatessen & Restaurant - Reuben eggs benedict - Delis Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Best turkey pastrami I've ever had! Was just passing through but will ensure we stop on way up north again.

Great corned beef sandwich. I'm not sure you could get a better version in the Midwest! However the price is ridiculous. I think they forgot they are not in NYC? Paying approximately $25 for a sandwich and a side of fries? Won't be hustling back. read more

Service and food both fantastic. So yummy! Will go back next time we are visiting the area.

The Ruben Sandwich is awesome! Perfect homemade corn beef, rye bread and delicious sauerkraut. I don't care for the side salads and won't rate them. Anyway, just buy one to eat and one to eat later. http://www.benjisdeliandrestaurant.com Benjis is an old school deli. The restaurant could use a renovation. Mostly because they are competing with so many upscaled places in the same area. read more

Having worked near Benji's for several years now I am happy to say that I've found a new go-to for sandwiches or similar fare. I am a big reuben fan, and having tried many of the options in the Milwaukee area I have to say I think Benji's reuben is the new winner. I was shocked with how loaded this baby was with (hand carved) corned beef, even with it being on the higher side of the price range. The sandwich was paired with a nice amount of Swiss cheese, sauerkraut and thousand island dressing, buttered and then grilled just as it should be. I was happy to also see that a pickle and chips were included. A hefty lunch for sure! If you are in the area, drive straight past the neighboring subway or other chain options and come right to this local spot. You'll be happy you did. read more

Benji's Delicatessen & Restaurant - Enjoying a delicious Reuben from Benji's! - Delis Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

This sandwich truly lives up to its name. It was so unbelievably SALTY but I was so so hungry that I ate as much as I could. I may try Benji's delicatessen again but I will not be ordering this sandwich. The pickle wasn't good either. I expected better. read more

Benji's Delicatessen & Restaurant - The "Not So Italian" Italian Beef Sandwich - Delis Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Great food I've been going to this restaurant since I was a child and it never disappointed me I love this restaurant

Really great classic deli sandwiches! Have gotten soups a couple times and they seem a bit overpriced for the sustenance. Price overall is high but great quality. read more

Had a taste for a pastrami sandwich. Drove up to Benji's with my wife. Huge disappointment. The meat was very, very tough and looked as though it came from a grocery store package. Pastrami and corned beef are supposed to be cut across the grain to make it more tender. Mine was cut with the grain and was like eating rope. The meat was also served at room temperature which didn't help for tenderness. The quantity was nothing like their picture but in this case that was good. Their rye bread was tremendous. The server (she's been there for years) was also good. My wife had pea soup which she felt was "OK." I should have had hoppel poppel. read more

We come here often, and while I have reviewed this place before, I thought I would give an update. Benji's is still the best. This throwback, Brooklyn like diner is nothing fancy. Great food, great vibe and an awesomely old diner decor. We came here on Mother's Day and were seating pretty quick. I have the matzo ball soup and then the hot Italian beef. My wife had a veggie omelet with some sausage and home fries. One of my kids had a burger and the other French toast. All was delish! My personal favs here are the home fries and the corned beef sand. This place is the best. Go. Here. Now read more

Portions are small and the price is high. The only delicatessen in the area. The quality has gone down with the new ownerships.

2 stars for nostalgia and matzo ball soup. But shouldn't a deli offer real pastrami? This place is supposed to be the best deli in MKE (since Jake's is taking a standing eight count, if not actually knocked out), yet they don't offer legit pastrami. And pastrami is the foundation of a real deli. But Benji offers thin yet weirdly hard to chew slices of past-its-sell-by-date pastrami. No flavor, bad texture, not fresh, expensive. The rye and brown mustard are the highlights of the sandwich. You don't have to be Katz's or Canter's, but cmon. Waterfront Deli serves much better pastrami, and their pastrami is precooked/prepackaged/shipped in from food service. Have a little pride. The best thing Benji offers is their beef hot dog. Which I can make at home. It's a shame that they treat their customers with such disregard. read more

Food is a bit pricey, but everything tasted really fresh, so it's totally worth it. Lots of flavor and a really nice, cozy atmosphere. There was really only one waitress checking on everybody, but she was great on making sure we were good and taken care of. "Not So Italian" was great! Can't wait to go back and try more! read more

Benji's is good and probably the closest thing to a "NY deli" that Milwaukee has. This location is in a strip mall and thus has plenty of parking which is nice. The interior is basic and fairly small - maybe seating for 30 and 1/2 dozen counter seats. You can get breakfast any time, burgers and salads but you're here for the classics - corned beef, pastrami and soup. Every day there is mushroom barley & chicken soup plus some specials - today was cabbage borscht. I opted for the "mish mosh" variety of chicken soup ($5) and it proved to be full of rice, noodles, a meat filled dumpling and a matzo ball. A hearty bowl to say the least! I appreciated that their matzo is nice and fluffy - not gummy at all. I would have loved to see some veggies in there but I guess that's not how they do it. I also had 2 potato pancakes ($2.50/ea - they are homemade and served with applesauce and sour cream. They're also boring - I mean, they're fine but devoid of any kind of seasoning. I'd skip them next time. The Mister had a Rueben and liked it - Benji's has very good corned beef - what we had was very lean (I prefer that). Definitely some of the best corned beef in the city but quite pricey ($14-ish) for something that wasn't piled especially high. They do serve it with a good spot deli pickle. Our service was good - food cane out quickly and we were regularly checked on. Overall, Benji's is good when you get the craving but not necessarily a place I'd seek out. read more

See all

Reliable favorite in the neighborhood. Don't expect any atmosphere but the food is solid. Recommend the tunafish sandwich. Burgers are great and hopple popple. Just ask for the salami to be well done. Perfection. read more

There is great food and desserts for anyone. You can get from the counter or get table service. It has the ambience of a deli and would suggest. read more

Great food and deli atmosphere. The staff was friendly and welcoming. My girlfriend just moved in across the street and I have a feeling they will be seeing a lot of me1 read more

Recommend the beef Borsch and matzoh ball soup. Corn beef is also very good. We get it delivered.

Food has gone downhill for years while prices have gone up exponentially. Lox bagel and a quart of soup is $26. Brueggers or Einsteins unfortunately blows their bagels out of the water these days. Not what it used to be. read more

Benji's is a gem. It's unfortunate that it took me all this time to discover it. But now..., now that I have I am never getting another pastrami sandwich anywhere else. The break is freshly toasted with caraway seeds. The cucumber is perfectly picked; ideal balance of crunchiness and acidity. There is just enough hint of coleslaw and thousand island dressing to moisten the sandwich. Swiss cheese used is wholesome. It's locally sourced Wisconsin cheese. And the meats. It's something else. Everything from corned beef, pastrami, salami, and pepper beef is in it. I always get my meats grilled. At Benji's, there are no compromises, no corners cut, no stone left unturned. The sandwich is made with love and affection, and you can taste it. Please try the Hear-O-Israel, ask the meats be grilled, replace fried for home fries, and you will not be disappointed. read more

Benji's Delicatessen & Restaurant - Hear-o Israel - Delis Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Bengies is better than I expect and a good, solid place for breakfast or lunch. The menu is so expensive that there's gotta be something for everyone. The only complaint is that it's small. read more

This is where I do my first morning meal whenever I'm back in Wisconsin. Everything on the menu is worth trying. Try the epiphany: Rueben sandwich with potato latkes instead of bread read more

Benji's Delicatessen & Restaurant - Mish Mosh - Delis Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

I used to rave about this place because their food was so good, but I had an issue today that makes me never want to give this place money ever again. I had been ordering their caesar salad with grilled chicken for a while and it was always so tasty. The best dressing I've found in the city so far, in fact. But this past week when I ordered, they changed their dressing from what it was to a caesar vinaigrette. It does not work at all for the salad, the acidity is gross with the smoked bits of chicken and the consistency soaks into their amazing croutons and turns them into sour mush instantly. I called to ask if there had been a mistake, if the dressing that used to work so well would be coming back, and the man working (who didn't give me his name) that answered the phone was so incredibly rude and disrespectful that I will never be eating there again. read more

I have been eating good corned beef since I was a child. I have been to the Shorewood location but had a craving today and went to the Brown Deer location. I paid $26/lb for the worst corned beef I ever had. I asked for it for "not lean". I wanted the fat. It was lean, dry, tough. I was so so so disappointed. I also saw them put some in a micro for a sandwich. What happened to the nice, juicy, thick corned beef? read more

Great matzo ball and split pea soups. They're nice and hot when you get them- even on carry out. Sandwiches are great, too.

Everything we ever had at Benjy's was terrific. Jewish delicatessens in the Midwest are far superior to any and every deli outside of that section of the country. Quantity, New York's M.O. does not beat quality. The corned beef is more flavorful, the bread, unseeded rye, is outstanding with soft body and a crunchy crust, and the rest of the fare is equally outstanding. While Chicago is but 90 miles away, it's unnecessary to leave Milwaukee for deli food. read more