The best pizza in Bennington! Mostly take out with small in house dining area. Family owned and loved by locals. Crust and sauce are to die for, toppings are fresh and the portions are large. My favorite is the 12" tomato, mushroom, and spinach. My go to place for cast parties at Bennington Theater. read more

Great food in the old-school pizza joint! This Jersey girl found it familiar and delicious- There are only three booths in the front dining area, but we got the first one for an early lunch. Shared a calzone and one had a beef gyro- everyone was satisfied! read more

Bennington Pizza House - almost forgot to take a photo 'cause the Calzone was so good! - Pizza Near Me - Bennington, Vermont

Definitely the best pizza house in town. I'm not sure where the bad reviews are coming from. Competitors? I'm from the Western Mass, and there are exceptionally good restaurants there . Needless to say, Bennington has been overall very disappointing when it comes to restaurants. Bennington Pizza House was a very pleasant surprise when we moved here, and our go-to for pizza! read more

TAKE IT FROM A LOCAL, NOT A WANNA B CRITIC. HANDS DOWN BEST PIZZA IN TOWN AND HAS BEEN FOR 15 plus years. The pizza is bombing good with high quality produce. every bite melts in the mouth with the incredible high end food quality used. this place will take every other pizza joint in town and roll it up and serve them as a appetizer compared to there pizza. PROMISE YOU WONT BE DISAPPOINTED. Always been rated best in town for many many years sense I was a kid. Even award winning pizza. read more

Bennington looks like a very small town with very little food options , we decided to order some delivery from this place to our hotel and I must say the food was absolutely excellent. Even better than I expected, we had the chicken parm and also chicken in olive and oil with grilled chicken and broccoli , everything was so fresh and delivered hot . Very good idea if you're looking for some real food instead of fast food . read more

Bennington Pizza House - Chicken in olive oil and garlic with Brit over pasta - Pizza Near Me - Bennington, Vermont

A mainstay for pizza , heros, salads. The food is solid, for Bennington. I came during covid, some employees had masks below their noses - I get it, it's hot in a narrow kitchen. Still, my Italian salami/cheese hero was ample (though it could have used more meat). Prices and choices abound at this rinky-dink pizza shop! At night all the young crowd the outside. Inexpensive, easily accessible Italian joint that also delivers out. Beware though, the shop changed owners a few years back: the old newspaper articles in black and white on wall, are the original proprietors. Rebel review: 4 read more

Bennington Pizza House - salami, Swiss, vinegar, onion subs - Pizza Near Me - Bennington, Vermont

See all

The pizza is very good. We had a sausage, onion and mushroom and a pepperoni. We tried the wings as well. The wings were good, but not great. Being in the take out containers always ruins wings. We might have to try them at the restaurant. read more

We had a great pizza last Wednesday, which was a special for that day only, but we hope they have it again! It was a #WildcardWednesday pizza. Prime Rib, Caramelized Onions, Creamy Horseradish Sauce with shredded Cheddar Cheese. The crust was baked evenly and all of it was delicious! Highly recommend checking them out, especially on a Wednesday! read more

Rest in peace Bennington Pizza House. Another great business where I once had fond memories is going down the drain and wondering why people prefer going anywhere else. I went in there today thinking I'd wait out the rain with some nice hot food. The employee was chewing on something and then he gave me a hard time when I placed my order. Then when I walked away from the counter, he and another employee started laughing. They found losing a customer hilarious. Well, Bennington Pizza House just became the new comedy scene because they're going to be laughing a whole lot more now. read more

We've ordered Delivery twice now from Bennington Pizza house, getting their calzones. They were delicious. The crust was really nice. We got the House Special Calzone. Combination of meat and veggies was such a nice mix and not greasy...which can be at some places. We got the 16" size which was plenty for the two of us. Delivery was on time by friendly driver. read more

This pizza was better than some I had just out of Manhattan the day before. So good. My husband with gluten and lactose intolerance caved and it didn't give him as much problems as I was expecting. Crust not too chewy or hard (but thoroughly cooked) so I was able to give it to my infant son for our lunch break. Also got paper plates and napkins. Convenient location, will pop by again next time through. read more

Bennington Pizza House - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bennington, Vermont

The only place we can get good pizza! They make it just the way we like it and the the daily specials really are good!

We loved it. The Wednesday special: $3 off an 18-inch. Spinach, artichoke, garlic and sausage. So Damn Delicious. The crust was a tiny bit thick but everything was so fresh. The service was also excellent. $25 with beer, soft drink, and tip. read more

Yes, its a traditional pizza joint, but there is SOMETHING about the crust - Its the prefect combination of crusty tasty (and I rarely eat the crust on pizza - dont care for other pizzerias fired oven variety, always tastes like some sooty carbon card-bored to me) Yum. Comfort food - keep it simple and you wont regret it! read more

I was in Bennington for a bit and ordered pizza from this place. The guy on the phone called me "dear" and then the delivery guy also called me "dear." Coming from LA, the idea the guy taking the order is also the guy delivering is madness, but that's what I think happened! The pizza was worlds better than big chain pizza, arrived quickly, and satisfied my pizza dreams. read more

I ordered a pizza today, the pizza came uncooked in the center. I called and told them about the problem so they could fix it for other customers, and they had nothing but attitude. I do not suggest purchasing ANYTHING from this place. The kitchen is also very dirty. Very dissatisfied. read more

Pizza is pretty bad. Like worse than gas station pizza. I'd rather have a box of Ellios... or god forbid, Dominos. I'm of the persuasion that there's no such thing as bad pizza, but this has to be close. Didn't try anything else, but don't really want to with Ramuntos up the street. Sorry Bennington Pizza House, I wanted to like you. Also, cash only... which is ok by me, just a heads up to anyone else dying for a slice of disappointment. Bring a lot of cash because it cost me $7+ for two tiny slices and a bottle of water. Staff seemed nice enough. read more

Randomly found myself here when I was looking for lunch after driving a family member to buy a car from Bennington Subaru. I'd say this is the best Pizza I've ever had. I ordered Garlic Bread as well and it was like they rolled out a Pizza Crust, and just smothered it with Butter and spices picked right from Heaven. It wasn't want I expected to see, but it proved to be so much better that what I'm used to. It ruined me, because I live over an hour a way and can't make that drive just for Pizza. But the next time I find myself in Bennington, I'm making a special trip here for lunch. And maybe Dinner too. And a snack for the ride home. read more

Ugh. Do NOT stop here. Food is all processed out of frozen or ziplock bags - saw nothing being "cooked" just heated up. Owners - if this is your pizza house - get real. Cook the food from Skratch and do NOT just heat up processed food. Never EVER again eating here - do not waste your $ read more

Didn't even have a chance to try the food due to the horrible customer service. I was with a group of four and we walked in at 8:30pm on a Saturday night. The hours posted on the door and online stated they were open until 10pm. When we walked in the woman behind the counter had a horrible stank face and didn't even greet us. I said hello to her and she didn't respond. She then turned to someone else working behind the counter and angrily and loudly said "since when have we started being open past 9?" to which he responded "it's Saturday, we're open until 10." Her response was to role her eyes and stare blankly at us when we were trying to order. We then ditched that place and grabbed dinner instead at the brewery next door which was great! read more

Have been coming here for 4 years now on our way to a ski weekend. Friendly service and beet on tap makes for a good time. Meatball sub is meh, they're sliced meatballs, not whole like I prefer. Overall this is a nice service with good quality pizza. read more

Bennington Pizza House - the menu for the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Bennington, Vermont

Excellent service. Located next to a brewery on main street in Bennington Vermont this pizza has a nice light crust and tasty sausage and mushrooms. Me and the wife were pleasantly surprised. read more

Bennington Pizza House - Excellent service and Excellent sausage and mushroom pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bennington, Vermont

We stop now and then, and never had a bad experience. I have tried the pizza & gyro. My partner likes the spanokopita and greek salad, and the eggplant parmesan was rated good by two others. Lots more on the menu than the downloadable one. The staff has always been attentive and serves our table after ordering at the kitchen. Ohhh.. the baklava on the counter is quite large, and good. Nothing excellent, but just good, and that is good enough! Prices are reasonable, just check the menu. read more

This pizza spot used to be great but horrible customer service these days, better off going to ramuntos , matter of fact any other pizza place in town. read more

I hate to only give 2 stars to a place with the best pizza around, but the rest of the food is embarrassing. Excellent Greek style pizza, perfect crust and enough cheese for a 70s Travolta movie. But the rest. A total waste. Last visit I ordered a Greek salad and Buffalo chicken tenders. I actually thought before I ordered that this may have been the place with the bad other foods but talked myself out of it. The salad was a salad. It had weak romaine lettuce which does not scream Greek to me, the olives and other veggies were fine. The feta was sparce and lacking flavor, in fact it may have been mozzarella. The dressing was disgraceful. I am mostly sure it was olive oil with Italian seasoning in it. In the end I ate it to get my serving of greens but was very disappointed. The tenders? These are the debacle choice I recall from bringing my family here. I'm certain these were dropped in the fryer frozen for 5 minutes. They were soggy, rubbery, and bland. Also served half tossed in Buffalo sauce with no dipping sauce.. just horrible. Without a doubt if I had bought frozen tenders at Walmart and microwaved them they would have been far better. Bottom line? Order your pizza here and go literally anywhere else for the rest. read more

Looks like a basic pizza place, but also has quite good grinders and pasta. We had spaghetti and meatballs and ravioli and the sauce was really quite good, the portions large, and the prices reasonable. read more

We came here for dinner our first night in Vermont. We tried the pizza and the pasta, and everything was delicious, and the service was quick. They do not accept credit cards, so be sure you have cash before you order! read more

There's nothing quite like deliciously greasy pizza, and the Pizza House is a good place to go for it. A large pizza feeds two people and starts at about $11. The crust is thin and crusty and delicious. This is not, however, a good place to go if you're on a tight schedule. The staff is very small, and orders take especially long when they're busy. I've had to wait for an hour before to get my pizza. If you've got the time (and it's not a weekend, when they're super busy), it's a good idea to stop in. read more

Good pizza and grinders slightly pricey.

This place was awful...the reviews can't be the same place. Came here for lunch and the after 10 times repeating a simple order to the counter girl, the food still came out wrong. Chicken parm is just a large frozen chicken mcnugget with sauce from a jar and processed cheese. Meatball parm same thing..,frozen and processed. Total waste of money...if you want decent pizza/subs don't come here. read more

Just passing through Bennington, VT and wanted pizza. Had their island specialty pizza and it was fantastic!

It's clean, newly updated looking, friendly staff, pizza is delicious haven't tried any other food but I would recommend this place to others and I will definitely be back when I'm in town again read more

Guy behind the counter was a passive aggressive prick. Chicken Parm ordered to go took over 45 min to make with no time updates on when it would be ready. Place was filled with stinky hikers and hippies. Chicken Parm tasted like dish water mixed with sugar- worst I have ever tasted in my life. read more

We have been getting this pizza for take out for awhile now, but last Saturday we decided to eat in. Yes the pizza was outstanding, but after bussing our own table and telling to kids behind the counter how good the pizza was. We heard them laughing and making fun of us. Saying in a mocking tone 'ya thanks for the pizza'. WE WILL NEVER EAT THERE AGAIN, how completely rude. read more

This is phenomenal pizza! First time we ordered it we got pepperoni pizza and garlic cheesy bread. The bread was covered in gooey delicious cheese. The pizza was greasy with a crunchy crust that was so perfect. The marinara was something to write home about. Definitely our new pizza spot! read more

Starving on 4th of July and this was one of the only places open and we were so happy to try it. The chicken wings had a great sauce that was crispy as if they baked them. Delicious! Their pizza was also really great- crispy crust that made me break my no carbs diet. Would definitely come back here the next time we are in town. read more

Stopped in while sightseeing, wasn't sure what to expect. Great food for a great value!

We discovered this little gem driving through Bennington, on way to Manchester (have to get off the new by-pass highway). The pizza is great - classic Greek-style, which is hard to come by these days! Owners are very friendly. Highly recommend. read more

After three tries, we're done. Each time, they have screwed up our take-out order. The other night, it cost us 17.44. We ordered a gyro and a Greek salad with grilled chicken. I received a tossed salad with TWO ounces of chicken (there was so little that I had to know how much it was). The gyro was $6.75, so I paid about ten bucks for a terrible salad (reheated chicken, horrible lettuce). They obviously had no difficulty figuring the order out so they could charge us for it, they just couldn't manage to actually give it to us. NEVER going back, and will make a point of telling people not to go there. A big waste of money. The good reviews must have confused this place with somewhere else, or they are plants by owners' friends. read more

We had a delicious meal. The Greek salad was fresh and very good. We loved the vegetarian pizza! The crust tasted cheesy and had just the right amount of crunchiness. The flavors in the sauce and toppings blended smoothly. The friendly staff and good service, along with the excellent food, rounded off a positive meal. read more