Fresh egg bagels at 11am? Ok Best Bagels Around. I see you! It's tough to find good bagels in Suffolk. This is one of the rare spots. It really is one of the Best Bagels Around. As someone previously said, the waiting area is tight, but it is worth the wait. There is also a small sit down area so you can chill there if needed. A good selection of cream cheese with olive being my fav. My last order was a turkey club on a roll which was a solid sandwich. Boar's head cold cuts are freshly sliced to your sandwich. The hubs got two egg bagels and they were coming out fresh. They wanted to make sure I was ok with both cream cheese and the butter to be put on the "hot out of the oven" bagels but the hubs didn't mind this at all. Deli iced tea on point...IYKYK read more

Honestly the best tasting bagels I've had in a long time. Recently tried their bacon egg and cheese, and it was perfection. And all of the workers there are very kind and helpful. It's a great bagel spot! read more

Best bagels!! Joy, the most amazing person always smiling always welcoming. I highly recommend you stop in and say hi and have a bagel and coffee. read more

This place has let me down on so many occasions I can't even tell you. What happened the other day it's just more salt in the wound. I called ahead because I was in a rush and one of my order to be ready so I could walk in pay for it and leave. Additionally the food that I ordered was to be prepared hot. Nobody orders hot food to eat it cold. I walk into the bagel store and walk up to the counter and say is there a line for pick ups? Although I was told no she asked me what my name was because I told her I had called in an order over the phone and she went and grabbed it. She then looked at me and said next time you're gonna have to wait online. I looked at her and said what's the point in calling an order in if you're gonna have to stand online and wait for 10 people to get served ahead of you. She looked at me, had absolutely zero to say other than "sorry". I grabbed my order paid for it rolled my eyes and walked out. Since then I've taken a pole on Facebook and with friends etc. and presented the situation to them and ask them what the correct procedure would be in their minds. I think we all know the right move here. How somebody could think otherwise is beyond me. This is a terrible bagel store. Always has been and always will be. read more

Honestly they know exactly how to make a BEC and just overall everything they make is amazing! But they suck at answering the phone. So if you are in a hurry and want to do a pick up maybe don't go here because they are very busy and won't answer the phone. read more

The same girl burns my French toast everytime like literally everytime idk if it's me or the French toast but there some sort of disconnect , other than that there good read more

this place is trash. they don't answer the phone and when they do they forget to make the food they we supposed to. worst bagel place on the island. read more

I live in Ronkonkoma, I called to order a Bacon and egg on an everything roll. No answer! So I called about 10 more times. Rings and rings no answer. So I drove there, but they were out of the everything rolls. I'm not sure how to deal with them? Don't get me wrong, they make a great breakfast sandwich. But when they don't answer the phone for a simple question. This wastes my time and money. I think I have to write them off! read more

Had to run to Stop & Shop on the go one morning but my husband and I were craving a morning bagel and our usual spot is in the opposite direction of where we were headed for the day. We decided to give Best Bagels Around a try and came in right before the rush of people started piling up. We were quickly greeted and our order was prepared and brought out to us in a timely manner. Service was definitely efficient as they navigated through the morning stream of customers walking in and picking up called-in orders. My husband and I both got egg sandwiches (mine with bacon and his with sausage). Bagels were soft and super fresh. Sandwiches were nice and warm. Positive experience overall. read more

See all

Very fresh bagels very clean and always very kind employees and great ice cold coffee better then Starbucks coffee

The bagels here are really good - soft on the inside, fresh, and not chewy. The jalapeño cheddar cream cheese is my favorite! read more

Best Bagels Around - Onion bagel with jalapeño cheddar cream cheese - Delis Near Me - Medford, New York

Thank you to whatever development planner decided to add this to the sunshine plaza (Insert glory hands)! This plaza was lacking just that a deli. I'm so glad to see this place open up. Inside is quaint. They offer bagels, all day breakfast and lunch options. I don't care too much for the small size of the ordering counter. Once you order you have to stand on the wall and there isn't much waiting space. This place gets very crowded in the morning and the line extends back to the seating area. I love that they offer a seating area! That's the problem I have with most delis on Long Island. Sometimes it's nice to just sit inside and enjoy the moment instead of getting your food and rushing home. I feel a lotta shops on LI neglect this unlike NYC patrons who have this convenience. The workers here are all very nice and attentive. I was a bit taken aback when the woman asked how I wanted the sandwich made and the type of roll I wanted. Most delis you order a SEC and they give u whatever the heck they please. And now to the best part the FOOD! Delicious! The quality of their breads are fantastic. I also tried some of my boyfriend's bagel and it was so soft and tasty! I highly recommend giving this place a try! read more

See all

Kind of undecided about this place still. 1st time the bacon egg and cheeses were delicious. We were relieved to had found an alternative to a place we've been going for years where service and quality has declined. 4 stars easily... 2nd time (today) once again the sandwiches were great until a strand of long blonde hair flossed my fiancés teeth on the third bite (she is not a blonde)...obviously this through a wrench into breakfast. Convinced her it was a one off and to shrug it off an keep eating....another bite, another donation from Rapunzel. This obviously was the end of that sandwich which still had a whole other half left. Through my appetite for a loop and I didn't want to finish mine either. I get it. This happens, but it shouldn't. That's why they make hairnets my friends. 1 hair...alright gross but maybe we can look past it. 2 or more?!? That's just disgusting. We'll probably give this place one more chance because the bagels and food are good. But definitely going into the next visit with a different level of confidence in the kitchen. read more

I just ate here for the first time of my life I live 10 minutes away no wonder never heard of it . . The service is slow but not as bad as the food . Ordered a BEC terrible ! Cold no salt pepper cheese not melted .. if you're from LI you know the pull is the best part of a BEC .. only good thing is the everything roll just get butter if you go . I usually don't complain but for the price this place is TRASH ! Last thing how's the wait so long but the food cold and trash ?Breakfast Sandwiches.. shouldn't even get one star but I never tried the bagel . read more

This is the "egg white" sandwich you'll receive on a Sunday morning as your order at Best Bagels Around in Medford. Their bagels are good, best around? No. Only around? Yes. Go for a bagel, skip the squared off eggs and grayish bacon sandwich. read more

Best Bagels Around - Delis Near Me - Medford, New York

These people make one of the best egg sandwiches I've had everytime I can try on them for well cooked eggs, usually making my bacon crispy, sometimes they could do a little better on that. The food is always ready within the time frame they give me when I call in. Always high quality satisfying sandwich, they are masters of breakfast. read more

Best Bagels Around - Delis Near Me - Medford, New York

Awesome !!! Great food & great prices... The omelet with spinach & feta was great along with the hard roll & egg sandwich which my dad loved... We got 2 small potatoes but only needed one bc the small was big which we should of known better being we are on Long Island but talk about flavor awesome... We will definitely go again & again... Great people as well... read more

Best Bagels Around - Delis Near Me - Medford, New York

See all

Best bagels around? Not sure because I didn't get to try them. It's a Saturday. The signs are lit up in the window "breakfast and lunch all day", but the door is locked. No hours on the door. I just had to Google it to see that they closed ten minutes ago at 2:30pm. That's very early- especially for a weekend and they're located in a busy shopping center. Disappointed. read more

Very good. Great variety. Good price. Cute location. Would recommend. I had the everything bagel and it was just what I needed. read more

Best Bagels Around - Delis Near Me - Medford, New York

The bagels are pretty good but the thing that will keep my business is the service. There is a young man that works there that blew me away. He is kind,respectful and helpful. He is like this every time with every customer. I haven't seen that in a young employee in way too long. The owner of the store is blessed to have him. read more

Horrible service. Move a little faster please . Good good, but no one wants to stand there for 20 minutes waiting for 1 egg sandwich and a bagel. read more

The first time I stopped by this place was the day after they opened, and it instantly became my go-to place for breakfast food in the area. I sometimes go there early in the morning after my workouts at Planet Fitness, and I have always been very satisfied with the food and the customer service. While I can't comment on the crowds during their busy hours, there has never been a line when I've gone. There are a good number of clean tables to choose from if you decide to eat in, and they offer a wide range of menu options, including some breakfast specials. I always order bacon and eggs, but the other options behind the glass look delicious as well. Across my visits, I've met a few of the workers (including the owner, I believe), and they have all been very pleasant and personable. One thing I greatly appreciate is the fact that there is no "$10 minimum" requirement for credit card use. That tends to be a very rare thing in the world of bagel places. I always look forward to my visits here, and I highly recommend checking this place out if you're in the area. read more

Best Bagels Around - This is by far the best presentation of bacon and eggs that I've ever gotten from a bagel place. - Delis Near Me - Medford, New York

I've been craving a bagel for a while I'm decided to stop in since I was already in the neighborhood. I was a little skeptical that the place was small on for Saturday morning before 11 I expected a line. I was excited to see the variety of bagels they had put more excited to see how big they were. I ordered a toasted everything with vegetable cream cheese I was not disappointed. The outside was nice and crispy on the inside was soft. read more

Best Bagels Around - Toasted everything bagel with vegetable cream cheese. The other half is already gone since I couldn't wait to eat it! - Delis Near Me - Medford, New York

See all

Ordered a lox bagel, a true error to order from these people. The woman at the register (fairly old, blond, wrinkles), maybe the owner, came with a bite and attitude when I brought up that there must have been a mistake in the order. We placed an order of 2 lox Bagels, we received 1 bagel uncut, untouched, and a second bagel with only salmon. We understand what the definition of "lox" is, but we also know what it means when you ask for a lox sandwich; capers, onion, cream cheese, the whole sandwich. I brought this to her attention, saying there must have been a mistake, which there was. Obviously the order was lost in translation.. That is not the problem, I understand this can happen. Instead of explaining that they don't make Lox Sandwiches and that they literally mean just salmon only, this woman bit down hard and decided explain to me that, I was wrong to assume they would make me a lox sandwich when I ordered a lox sandwich. She continued on saying "This isn't Brighton Beach, or some 'Jewish' town where they serve lox with capers" very condescendingly. She said things here on Long Island are different... I'm from here, I know how "things are like" and I know what a lox order is and what it means in any other bagel shop in the same town. Final product, a slapped together cheap recreation of what a lox sandwich is supposed to look like. There are 12 other bagel shops within 5 minutes of these guys. Do yourself a favor (and everyone else) and drive to one of those instead. read more

Wasn't expecting much as it looks like a small "Hole-in-the-wall" from the parking lot. You get inside and there is a lot of dated Formica. Looks dated but but I betting your not here for ambiance. But hold on cause here comes the good stuff... I ordered a Whole Wheat bagel with light Cream Cheese and bacon. I would saw this was done pretty expertly. Some place when you ask for light cream cheese they literally put a paper thin film on your bagel. Other places think "light" means just under a cup per bagel. This was about 2 tablespoons which is a nice layer and prevents the cheese from being lost and the bagel from being overwhelmed. They topped it with 2-3 strips of bacon (two would suffice, but three is nice). It's not super crispy which I like on a sandwich but it was good 'nuf. The part I was most surprised by is how filling it was. I ate that one bagel and was held over until lunch time, four and half hours later. The bagels are big and fluffy. No so crispy on the outside more pillow-y but still tasty. I'll certainly give them another go and may be try a hot sandwich that I see positively reviewed by others. For now it's A-OK and could get better... read more

I am very disappointed with the way they handle issues. I waited 15-20 minutes for my order and went home with my food. I ordered whole wheat toast with mashed avocado with eggs over medium on top. When i got home, the bread was not toasted, the avocado was brown( not sure why they would give a customer bruised avocado like that), and the eggs were fried and sloppily thrown to the side (not on my sandwich). I called them to let them know that i was dissatisfied and that i cant eat that (as its disgusting and not made correctly) the gentleman asked if i wanted to pick up a new one but i declined as i didnt want to waste more time going back and forth. He said "ok then" so i responded "so i just wasted my money on it then? Because now i have to make my own breakfast when i just bought breakfast from you". His response was "i guess so" with a laugh and hung up. I have previously gone here plenty of time as it was my go to breakfast spot but after this situation i am very turned off. Im not sure that i will be retuning anytime soon. They could have offered me a credit back or something! Not even an apology that he made it wrong.. very dissatisfied and disappointed! read more

This place is good. Makes good sandwiches but has me screaming that they don't take off their gloves when they touch money. Then they take the next customer with the same gloves and make your bagels. This is a basic food saftey requirement, makes me curious what else they aren't doing. Hopefully, this post will make them aware and re train employees about changing gloves. read more

It was a leg day at the gym. I ate light the night before so I was ravenous, I needed food fast. "Best Bagels Around" is in the same shopping center as my gym, so I was about to put there claim to the test (well minus the bagel). When I got there I saw lots of people going in, that's always a good sign. I could smell the bagels and I loved it. The business almost reminds me of a Dunkin Donuts, but with more bagel and deli meats. The staff working behind the counter moved fast and greeted everyone that walked in. When it was my turn the gentleman asked what I wanted I told him and he said he would toss in a extra egg, nice! Again I will emphasize, the smell inside this deli was impressive, If I could bottle up the scent and release it in my house I would. When I got my tray and sat down at the table I saw beauty. Upon eating I was pleased with how crunchy the bacon. I need to also mention, I don't know what American cheese they used, but it was the best tasting cheese I've ever eaten. The only negative is they don't put enough on it. Next time I will definitely ask for extra. I've been going to my gym for years and never went in this place. It's a mistake that won't happen again. Best bagel? I can tell you they make the best eggs and bacon around. read more

See all

Great Bagels...Ran in for a quick bagel on a Saturday afternoon... Was hoping the bagels weren't stale being so late into the day, or even any left... BUT they had a good selection that looked great. AND were VERY fresh! Thank you! ...My son loved his bagel after a tough cold soccer game read more

This place seriously has the best bagels and make an amazing bacon egg and cheese. Always a great selection and the bagels are super fresh. Yes they can get busy, but if you walk into a bagel store on the island and it's empty that's never a good sign, so I'd prefer a small wait for excellent food and service. The staff is always efficient and friendly and have been following Covid guidelines. Highly recommend read more

Best Bagels Around - Bacon egg and cheese, sooooo good. - Delis Near Me - Medford, New York

WOW.. there name really is ironic.... I called in my order and showed up in 20 min as instructed. I had been running late to work and like usually calling in helps me grab my food and go!! But with this place ?? She told me with a nasty attitude to wait on the back of the line... it was a long line of people waiting to order ... I called in so why would I wait on a long line for my food to get cold? Long story short I told her to keep my order and they've lost my business entirely and I will never recommend them to anyone of my friends or family. Rude and unpleasant customer experience. read more

I go here often and it's not the establishment it's this one worker who just chooses to do what she wants and not what you order. First time I gave her the benefit of the doubt. Second time today and I'm done with her helping me. Turkey egg and cheese eggs over easy salt pepper ketchup mayo bread heavily toasted lightly buttered.. i get back something totally different. I mean write it down for gods sake if your not gonna remember and are to shy or afraid to ask me again. Jesus. read more

Delicious bagels but I went today and most of the staff members and patrons were not wearing masks. (The NY Mask mandate resumed on Monday) I take safety seriously so I will take my business elsewhere. read more

I got the chicken salad with walnuts and cranberries OMG it was real chicken breast not the canned crap! Yummy, very fresh and the roll was perfect. The next time i went i got a bagel and yep, terrific! The people that work there are friendly. The place is small but clean. A seating area is a great idea and it is clean as well. read more

Definitely the best bagels around! Egg sandwiches are awesome! Everything is cooked perfectly and the bagels with lox have lots of lox on it!! I go every Sunday and will continue. Call ahead to avoid the line. I posted a pic of the card with the phone number because it wasn't listed. read more

Best Bagels Around - Great bagels and breakfast! Here's the card with the phone # since there isn't one listed. Call your order in to avoid the line! - Delis Near Me - Medford, New York

Passing through on our way back to the city and we found a place that rivals NYC bagels!! Delicious!! The chicken and tuna salad was incredible as well. Highly recommend! read more

Best Bagels Around - Now that's what I call a large coffee! - Delis Near Me - Medford, New York

Yummy bagels and egg sandwiches. Staff mildly grumpy but in an expected NY way. Definitely recommend.

Great food an service I suggest calling I. Because there could be a line out the door most weekends !

Love their tuna salad!! Best I've had in a very long time. Bagels are good. Egg sandwiches are good as well. Service is pretty quick.

Came in yesterday for a bagel, was in and out, very quick service, and the cashier was friendly. Bagel was very soft and satisfying. Would definitely come again read more