Don't be fooled by the outside of the building. They have great burgers. Tater tots were good, but the fries came out a little overcooked, as did the mini corndogs my daughter ordered in her kids meal. Service was great and prices were reasonable. Be warned, this is about 10 minutes off the freeway to the outskirts of Rexburg. read more

Solid burger. I honestly can't complain about anything there besides maybe about the cleanliness. But it really didn't distract from the experience too much. The food is very fresh. The ingredients they use are pretty good. Good buns, fresh veggies and flavorful beef. It was decent Best part was the fried pickles. By far the best fried pickles I have ever had in my life. Like unbelievable good. I would come here just for the fried pickles. WOW. Can't say enough about them Service was friendly but slow but they are busy and they did good enough considering the circumstances. Overall it's a fun and tastey burger joint and the best fried pickles you'll ever have anywhre in world. read more

All the burgers here are amazing, I did the 2lb burger challenge and i'll never do it again but i got the picture ont he wall which is what matters most ;) get the Blue Cheese Burger read more

Big Jud's - 2lb Challenge - Burgers Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

This is an interesting place in the middle of nowhere in Idaho. Very odd but they have made it work. To make up for the location, they provide fun food that attracts people from all over. If you want the best burger you will ever eat, then this is the place. I got the green chili burger and was the most amazing combination of flavors you can get on a burger. All the other burgers look great though and you can't go wrong. We also shared an order of fries, fried pickles, onion rings and sweet potato fries. All were great and good additions to the burger. Very reasonable prices also. I wish I lived in the area because I would eat here all the time. There is usually a line so be prepared to wait. read more

Awesome burger, huge portion of tots. Ordered the double avocado bacon burger with jalapenos, and a large potato tot, normally I'd order the burger medium, but forgot. It came out a tasty med rare though, I was happy they don't cook all the moisture out of their patties like so many other places. One of the better burgers I've ordered, couldn't finish the tots. The server was attentive and pleasant. Only reason it gets 4 instead of 5 stars was the dishes were chipped, and anytime anyone in the party of 3 raised or lowered their arms, it would almost launch the drinks and plates because of the table legs being so uneven. Overall I'd eat here weekly if it wasn't so far away. All three of us walked away stuffed with delicious food for under half a bill. Highly recommend. read more

We always visit this location when we are in town the guys working tonight we're awesome very friendly the food was great.

Great food and service. The shakes are super. We live in Washington State, but every time we go to rexburg we make a visit here.

Ohhhhh, yeah! Jud's is doin' it, and doin' it, and doing it well! If you luv your burgers, fries n milkshake, THIS is the place. Mmm, mmmm, mmm. My friend lives in Rexburg and told me I had to eat at Big Jud's and boy was she right. We drove along a lil country road on the outskirts of Rexburg. When you see the house that's buried underground (only their roof is visible), then you know you're almost there. Adorable view of green farmlands, baby colts and tiny furry baby cows along the way too (I'm from San Diego so these are things I noticed as a tourist to your town). Anyhow, Jud's is a small n cozy diner with big eats. Adam from the Man vs Food tv show ate here. They have a "1 Pound" challenge with plenty of photos of the winners, and then a "2 Pound Challenge"--- not so many photos, and I cannot believe anyone can conquer this one! My burger was probably a third pound, and filled me up, so major kudos to those wild ones who take either challenge! The menu has their popular burgers highlighted. They have beef and chicken burgers. I ordered the Bacon Cheeseburger with small fries and a lemonade. The place was packed and our food was ready in record time-- I couldn't believe it. My cold pink lemonade was enormous, in fact I could only drink half. My burger was picture perfect! The bun was excellent, toasted to perfection and baked to handle all the goodness in between. The patty had a nice outer BBQ char, grilled onions, slightly soft thick cut bacon, crisp lettuce, ripe deep red tomatoes, pickles, and gooey cheese. Oh. Heaven. Help. Me. I ate it all. Stuffed myself even more with Jud's fresh cut fries. Thick and believe it or not, there was a creaminess to them. Is that how Idaho potatoes are?? They weren't crumbly and dry like a russet. I loved those fries! Had a fantastic time dipping them in their famous "Fry Sauce" (that's a Utah and Idaho thing--- in SoCal we have ketchup). Now mind you, the fries were a 'small' and I shared the basket with my friend. I managed to shove a couple spoonfuls of my friend's thick, rich chocolate shake and then called myself done! Wow. If you couldn't tell by now, I give good ole Big Jud's a big thumbs up and five glorious stars. If you are ever near Rexburg, take the time to drive on over and eat top notch, all-American, huge portioned, fresh-made, mouthwatering food over at BIG JUD's where the staff is friendly, smiley, and ready to serve! Dang delish and a lot of bang for your buck read more

What can I say... fabulous! Burger greatly juicy and tasty. Bun one of the best. Fries worth the drive. Stop by -- worth the drive.

Hit up Big Judd's again tonight while in the area. The burger was great. Burgers here are consistently well seasoned & well dressed. We went for a round of tots tonight and they were hot and crispy. A little light on the salt but IMHO better than the fries. The fries are fresh cut so they won't ever be able to meet my standard of crispy. read more

See all

We were looking for a good burger place & found it here. Food was superb. Husband and the Hawaiian burger & I can bbq chicken. Both were delicious. We ordered a large fries to share & the amount served was massive. We couldn't eat everything. The restaurant is clean, cute & fabulous service. Well worth the drive - off the main roads by a bit. read more

See all

Great burgers, milkshakes. Cool small burger joint will be back next time I'm in the area

This place is insane, hamburgers the size of your plate! Fresh cut fries from Idaho potatoes are amazing and the fry sauce is great! The ice cream is good and the place is always packed. You can feed four people for $25 which is hard to beat, and the burgers can be customized. read more

See all

Awesome sit down local gem. Great burgers and fries. Always busy though so expect to make an evening out of it!

Looooove this place. They have a GF bun!! . Service is great. The milkshakes are something ELSE. so thick and creamy. If you're in town. Bug Jud's is a must!! read more

Big Jud's - Fried pickles and a jalapeño burger. - Burgers Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

See all

Stopped in here with my Sister and Brother-in-law. I will say this is out in the middle of nowhere. We shared one of their 1lb burgers as wells a tots and fries. Overall very tasty. The wait staff was friendly. Everyone enjoyed their food and it was cooked just the way we wanted. read more

I was thoroughly disappointed. The food tasted like oil and the restaurant was very rundown. I also had a shake that was bland and strangely grainy. Although the food wasn't good, the service was great. Food came out piping hot which is a big plus in my book, and the server was very attentive. read more

If you've ever craved a burger before, this is the burger you were craving. It's a great burger. Delicious patty, good all around. Not the best I've ever eaten, but the classic burger experience. The milkshakes are RIDICULOUSLY good. Do not miss those shakes. The huckleberry milkshake was so so delicious, and so was the moose tracks. Since you're in Idaho, you have to get the fries. The fries, in my opinion, are the best fries I've ever had. However, they're really close to in n out fries but better, so if you like them you'll love these. If you don't love in n out fries you'll think the fries are pretty mediocre, but the fry sauce is delicious so you'll enjoy it as well. The portions are doable for the normal burgers. One large fry was enough for five people (this is not an exaggeration. Get one large/five people, maybe one large one small). Overall highly recommend for a solid American burger, delicious Idaho fries, and the best milkshake you've ever had. Worth getting off the highway for, and we got there at 11 so we're seated early, but other reviews say it's crowded. read more

Don't be daunted by crowds. Awesome staff that knows how to handle large herds of farm polk. We checked into what looked like an overflowing family reunion hot spot on a saturday during 4th of July weekend. Ventured out to a local farm to kill the time, ended up on a tandem bike ride and tailgate ride down to the snake river. Returned just in time for delicious greasy spoon goodness. They have something for everyone. We had a vegetarian in our midst in small town Idaho, no problem...veggie burger sub. Fresh idaho French fries, they'll convert any sandwich into an awesome salad, and good gooey cheese bacon concoction of a burger on a nice soft bun. Going all in now with a chocolate malt. This is a dive to take on with an empty belly full force. read more

See all

Yum! We always order the big jud and split it in 4ths. The fries are the bomb! Just wish they had a bigger place, it's always so packed that you feel like your sitting on top of everyone. Otherwise super yummy. Love their hawaiian burger and chicken burger too. Also the onion rings. So dang good! They're huckleberry ice cream is the best too! read more

Big Jud's - Burgers Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

Stopped here while traveling from Yellowstone. Definitely worth driving a few miles off the main road. Delicious onion rings and fries. Fried pickles were good, too. (I prefer the pickle chips style.). Hamburgers were awesome - in size and flavor. Our group had six different kinds and everyone loved theirs. Super nice service. read more

Awesome food. Amazing portions. Amazing service. Great price. A must for anyone within 50 miles. You will enjoy yourself. Make sure you get dessert too! read more

Big Jud's - Menu!! - Burgers Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

See all

If you aren't paying attention you are going to drive by this little gem. The burgers are second to none. Simple, yet delicious ingredients make for a classic burger. Even noteworthy is the bread used for the buns...making for a top to bottom delicious burger. Gotta get the 1lb burger if no other reason the novelty of seeing a 1lb burger, but don't worry it too is delicious. Fresh Idaho potatoes make for some near perfect Fries!! Ambiance is what you would expect for a tiny hole in the wall out in the countryside of what is already a small town. You are going just for the food!! read more

This place never disappoints! Food is always so good and the customer service is fantastic. We love going there as it's almost right around the corner from our house. read more

Burgers and fries are the greatest, service is with a smile and hard working young people.

One burger could feed an entire family lol. I like the old fashioned feel and their food is really good.

Delicious! The fries and burgers were great. Onion rings are not made in house so we will not order them again. Will definitely go back!

Great portion sizes, great food! Great service, they make their own buns, they are so friendly, they make gluten green food. you have to go!

Something people don't talk about at burger joints is the bun. The buns at Jud's are some of the best I've ever had. Especially on one of the eponymous Big Jud burgers with the 1lb patty. Kind of a pain to get to, but worth it. I like the ice cream available and its general atmosphere. Only been there AFTER going to college in Rexburg. Weird. I wish I had been here while I was still a teen. I coulda easily been on the double- or triple-patty wall of fame. Every time I'm in rexburg, I have to go there. I'll be back. read more

See all

Yep. Good burgers! Good family atmosphere. Ortega burger was my favorite. 4 adults we each ordered one burger and cut them up into quarters to share. Ortega Jalapeño Pastrami And mushroom Bacon All were great. read more

Come with an appettite for sure! Being a California, I have tried all kinds of burgers but never had I seen one this large! It was huge and I just ordered the single so I can only image the monster burgers the folks at Big Jud's can create. The meat is flavorful and I do agree there is a little too much bread but how else could I expect it to be held together. I really enjoy their fry sauce. I really wish I would have saved room for the ice cream, sure looked yummy. read more

Big Jud's - Big Jud's Single - Burgers Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

A lot has been said about Big Jud's. The reviewers are correct. Great burgers and fantastic fries. (BTW, the small fries are enough for 2 people.) I wanted to mostly comment on the veggie burger. I had the veggie burger patty on the mushroom burger. It was great! Thank you for having a non-meat option. If you are not paying attention you may miss it on the menu, it is in small print at the top of the menu. Note that it is $1 more to substitute the vegi patty for a meat patty. I'm not sure why that is. It doesn't make any sense to me, but I'm just glad they offer it. Thanks! read more

Lives up to the hype. Good quality beef not incinerated and generous portions. The facilities are slightly off-putting.

Free cat with our meal. We love big Judds. Our family goes here about once every six weeks and the freshly made food never disappoints. We split the special for four or five of us and always leave full. We also like them because we found a beautiful stray cat there nearly two years ago. The staff liked her so much they took care of her up to that point. Very kind people. read more

This place is excellent for what it is, a great burger joint with a small hometown feel. Service was friendly and consistent and the burgers are delicious. The chicken sandwiches are good too but not as good as the burgers. The onion rings are amazing! read more

Big Jud's - Burgers Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

See all

So damn GOOD! We didn't know this was a restaurant off of Man vs Food & I've totally watched that episode so that was cool surprise. I have zero complaints, the food was great & so was the service. Definitely coming back! read more

See all

solid place for burgers when you're in Rexburg. If you're brave try the giant burger featured on Man Vs. Food! Also the onion rings are top notch! read more

The food was fantastic and the service was exceptional. It's in the middle of nowhere but a diamond in the rough. Had the Big Jud's one pound burger. Delicious! read more

Big Jud's - The Jud's one pound burger. The burger on the left is a normal size burger. - Burgers Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

Great food staff is wonderful and prices are reasonable however the diner is filthy tables are sticky and there is trash everywhere. If you can get past the filth it is a great stop for any trip read more

Great service. Delicious food!!! The tots are amazing! They are not skimpy on toppings, and the buns are fluffy and light.