Blue 11

Great food, great service, nice setting. Ceviche was delicious--great limey tang with such fresh…read morefish. Fish dip was great, and the veggies were so fresh. Lobster Mac and cheese was terrific with lots of lobster. Tuna crudo Japanese style was just okay compared to everything else. Citrus tart was great to finish things off. Love the casual atmosphere and super fresh food. I wish they would start serving Sunday brunch again!

Was just ok for me...unless you like raw seafood you don't have a lot of options. The fish of the…read moreday was Wahoo and Tuna and I don't like those. I wound up getting the Lobster Mac which was tasty but too rich to eat as a main course. The prices are high and the service was just ok, service needs to match the prices you're asking for your food. My drink was delicious some green goddess type cocktail. My husband liked his tuna and our friend had the fish Sammy

Porch sitting- get there somewhat early to be seated "outside"

Caribbean fish dinner with Tuna

See all

Muddy Water

The Easterly

4.4(447 reviews)

7.5 km

We had such a great dinner at The Easterly, definitely more of an upscale dining experience but…read morestill felt really relaxed and welcoming. We made a reservation, but honestly it didn't seem totally necessary when we went. From the moment we sat down, the staff was on top of everything and so friendly. You could tell they really care about the experience, and everything flowed perfectly without feeling rushed. For drinks, we ordered the Vessup and the Carib and both were so good. The Vessup especially stood out, the cream on top was so smooth and delicious and just made the whole drink. They brought out fresh bread to start and it was so good (always a win in my book). For dinner, we went with the lobster with potato and broccolini and it was incredible. Everything was cooked perfectly and the flavors were just on point. Between the food, drinks, atmosphere, and service, this was easily one of our favorite dinners on the trip. Definitely a spot I'd recommend if you're looking for something a little nicer but still with that island feel.

Great ambiance Great friendly servers…read more Beautiful place for bday dinner Pricey per portions Seating area requested was given to another couple Hard to park depending on time Event: Vacation for birthday

See all

Cravin' Crabs

4.1(158 reviews)

0.5 km

The seafood boil taste just delicious!…read more Fantastic flavor, lots of spice, you really feel that caribbean love. Come get the seafood boil when you are in st thomas

Whew! This put me into a coma! I usually get the seafood mash, but this season I wanted to mix it…read moreup and decided to try the Island Style Lobster & Shrimp Curry. You get half of a whole lobster, split straight down the middle, served with seasoned rice, fried plantains, and summer squash. I loved the curry sauce served on top, and wished I got a little more to put on my rice. I was heartbroken to hear that I had missed the last shipment of Red Horse beer, which if available, I highly recommend ordering it with your meal. It's brewed in the Philippines, and is absolutely delightful. As usual, staff was attentive and polite. Our waitress even cracked a few jokes that made my table laugh. Indoor seating is scarce, but I honestly would prefer to sit outside and eat here cause the AC is blasting.

Buffet style to get the food

Seafood boil for 2

See all

Caribbean Fish Market

3.8(325 reviews)

8.4 km

I love when I get excited to write a review for a new restaurant I tried on vacation. This trip…read moretook me to St. Thomas, and being an island community, it also meant seafood, which I love and is hard to come by in Phoenix, AZ. The Fish Market sits on the beach at the bottom of the Elysian Hotel. While you can walk there, it's a long, winding road through the hotel grounds. While I want to say we were met with a warm island welcome, instead, we were met by a grouchy young lady who seemed less than happy to be working or enjoying her day. On a positive note, our waitress, Kieke, was delightful and sweet and a complete opposite from the hostess. As for the food, let me be honest when I say it was one of the top two seafood meals I've had in my life. I got the crab-stuffed grouper with broccolini and couscous. It was cooked perfectly and had a sauce that was delicious! At the end of the day, this was a great experience, and if you can get down to the restaurant (which is a hike), you will absolutely enjoy the meal and ask for Kieke and ignore the rude hostess.

We came to Caribbean Fish Market on a Sunday for brunch and it was such a great vibe overall. They…read moreoffer bottomless Bloody Marys and mimosas, which is always a fun bonus for a relaxing brunch by the water. We ordered the ahi tuna nachos and the veggie egg white scramble. Both were really good; the nachos were super fresh and flavorful with a nice mix of textures, and the scramble was light but still filling with plenty of veggies. Definitely felt like a good, balanced brunch option. The service was great, friendly, attentive, and everything came out at a good pace. The only thing that wasn't my favorite was the Bloody Mary. It had a pretty strong horseradish kick, which just isn't my thing, but if you like that extra spice you'd probably enjoy it. Overall, great food, beautiful setting, and a solid brunch spot. I'd absolutely come back (and probably stick to mimosas next time!).

Prawns

See all

Calamari

Surf N' Turf Bistro

4.8(23 reviews)

1.4 km

Surf N' Turf Bistro is an absolute gem! They fit us in…read morewithout a reservation on a Sunday when EVERYTHING is closed. The ladies were the sweetest but also the most professional, kudos to them. We had the jerk Cornish hen, the vegan pizza(but they added cheese because we aren't vegan) and an absolutely divine lobster mac & cheese that came with a side Caesar salad. So delicious. When in St Thomas definitely go to this restaurant (you'll thank me.) It is beautiful and quaint and perfect for a date or a friends' gathering.

Dinner was outstanding! Best meal we've had on the island since we've been here. The ribeye was…read morefantastic and my wife's lobster Mac was exceptional!

Inside bar area

See all

Dining room

Catch Of The Day

4.4(14 reviews)

5.9 km

Ambiance , location and food was absolutely delicious!!!!! So happy I ordered the fish it seems…read morethat it was the fish of the day!!! It was soo meaty and seasoned to perfection. It was a long wait to come but it's because it was literally freshly made. If you like fish come and try it here. Our server was good as well. She appeared to be the only server working. She was busting her butt. She did well!!

Racist staff here do not eat. Everything we wanted on the menu was conveniently sold out. So we…read morepivoted a few times and settled on grilled octopus and conch chowder. People dining here had finished their meals and new people dining had gotten their food yet ours hadn't arrived in 50 mins. Asked the cook where our food was and he said he was never given our ticket and go complain to the bartender. The bartender gave us a very snarky "sorry" without being empathetic at all. Other places at Coki beach were much friendlier.

Racist bartender here. "Took" our food order yet never delivered to cook and was snarky 50 mins later.

Stuffed fish

See all

Beach

Hook'd USVI

4.2(230 reviews)

7.4 km

While touring the USVI I had the pleasure of trying several different types of places and Hook'd is…read morean was an absolute pleasure of mine. I ended up showing up early so I was only able to see and try the breakfast menu and drinks, so those are the only items I can rate Ambiance: 5 stars. It's an open floor plan right on the dock. We were able to sit right next to the water and get some fresh air. The place isn't too loud, but very inviting. They have a bottomless mimosa option and this place feels like it would be a great brunch vibe Service: 4 stars. Staff was super nice and waitress was helpful in regards of what to order. There was an issue with steak being overcooked and they were able to replace it, but it did take taking to 3 different people, which I thought was weird Drinks: 3.5 stars. The Rum away with me was absolutely wonderful, but the White Russian was not good at all Food : 4.5 stars Steak and eggs was fantastic. We had to get the steak recooked, but when it was made well, it was a top shelf steak. Crab cakes: also would recommend! No notes here Breakfast burger:,really loved the fact that the patty was smashed. I was worried that there was too much going on but everything combined quite nicely. I got the breakfast potatoes and they weren't really anything special. Overall this place was a 4.5 stars, but I'm rounding up to 5 because the vibe and views were immaculate

Good spot for casual dining and a drink…read more Staff were friendly and attentive. I ordered the Fish And Chips ($29), a large portion of Fish and a generous amount of fries with a very tasty coleslaw. Free parking located on site. (parking garage). Be aware, and check your receipt as gratuity may have been added.

Plain cake

See all

Beyond Benny

Tarpon's Table

4.3(103 reviews)

7.5 km

The food was amazing!! The staff We're welcoming and the…read moreatmosphere is the best we have had yet!! We had a 4lb lobster (the best I have ever eaten) and I even forgot my purse & our amazing server ran us down with it! 15/10.. Do not miss this place!

So great, we came here two times during our week here. The drinks are soo good. The owner both…read moretimes came out to check on us and make sure we are ok, his grandma's recipes are also used in some plates, which is soo sweet. The food is fresh, full of flavor, just soo delicious! Also the huge Tarpons' swimming in front of the restaurant are insane too, they are really cool to look at.

Interior

Andoullie stuffed caribbean lobster & asparagus

See all

Feeding the Tarpon

G&D Seafood

4.7(54 reviews)

3.3 km

After hearing from locals that G&D Seafood was a must-try, we decided to stop by after picking up…read moreour carnival costumes--and we're glad we did! At G&D, you can either order fresh seafood to take home or dine in. We chose to sit down and enjoy a meal. We started with two drinks: Passion Fruit and Tamarind Passion Fruit. Both were refreshing, but I personally preferred the Tamarind blend. For our meal, we ordered the Stuffed Lobster and Shrimp--beautifully plated, as you can see below. I had the shrimp, and it definitely hit the spot. My cousin enjoyed the lobster and said it was just as flavorful. The pricing was fair for the portion and quality. The atmosphere was welcoming, and our waitress was friendly and attentive. You can also get a feel for the vibe from the photo of the restaurant's interior below. Will I return? Yes, I would--but next time, I'll try something different on the menu!

Worth the wait!! Food was delicious and cooked to perfection. The grilled snapper and fried shrimp…read morecombo is a must try with seasoned rice and salad as your sides. Oh, and don't forget to order Sorrell as your drink. Thank me later!!

Passion Fruit and Tamarind Passion Fruit

Stuffed lobster & Shrimp

See all

Shrimp Plate

Oceana Restaurant & Bistro

4.1(241 reviews)

2.1 km

We chose Oceana to celebrate our 30th wedding anniversary this evening. They went out of their way…read moreto make it very special for us which was very much appreciated. We seated right next to the ocean and enjoyed a beautiful view while we were eating this evening. Our servers name was Adan and he did an absolutely amazing job. The entire facility is very romantic and definitely a place to go for a special occasion or even just to have a very nice meal. We both decided to start our meal tonight with salads and bread. Adan highly recommended the red & golden beet escabeche and I am very glad that I took his recommendation. It was the absolute perfect balance of the tartness of the whipped brie cheese, sweetness of the beets, and brought together with spring greens and pickled ginger. AMAZING flavor. For our main courses, I ordered the Caribbean lobster because they told me it was still alive in the ocean a couple hours before we sat down to eat and my wife ordered the filet. Both meals were exquisite. Her filet was cooked to perfection and the lobster was not overcooked. We finished the meal with French pressed coffee, flourless, chocolate, torte, and a trio of sorbet that is made in house. We had a wonderful experience and I highly recommend this restaurant if you decide to come to St. Thomas. This is one you should move to the top of your list.

This place was bombbbb. We went with a large party and the staff took such phenomenal care of our…read moreparty. The restaurant is right on the water so you have a gorgeous view if you're sitting outside. For starters we ordered the tuna tartare and the ceviche. So good and so fresh. My entree, the ahi tuna, was so perfect I can't even handle it. I don't have the words to tell you how good it was. My boyfriend ordered the lobster which they were doing a special where they added mac n cheese. The mac had cavatappi pasta which is my favorite noodle but his was just good compared to the stellar entree I ordered. For dessert, again, absolute bangers. We ordered the crème brûlée which was great and the bananas foster bread pudding which was spectacular. Awesome amazing and fantastic, go here!

View of kitchen from our table

Dutch mussels - fantastic

Oceana Restaurant & Bistro - Cocktails the next night. Hightop perch only - which is awkward for some statures. wind was too high for the Oceanside chair seating.

See all

Cocktails the next night. Hightop perch only - which is awkward for some statures. wind was too high for the Oceanside chair seating.

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

3 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Jamie D.

383

2 years ago

Blue11 was nothing short of extraordinary! We did the nine-course tasting menu, and somehow, each course managed to outdo the last. Every dish was beautifully presented and bursting with flavor, making it a true journey for the palate. My absolute favorite? A next-level lobster mac and cheese with coconut brea! As someone who doesn't eat meat, I really appreciated how accommodating they were in crafting a pescetarian-friendly menu. The wine selection was fantastic, perfectly complementing each dish, and the service was impeccable--attentive, knowledgeable, and genuinely passionate about the experience they were creating. If you're looking for a top-tier dining experience in St. Thomas, Blue11 is an absolute mu read more

Melanie S.

1 year ago

Unforgettable Dining at Blue 11 Our taxi driver recommended Blue 11, and it exceeded all expectations. The 7-course meal was a culinary masterpiece, with each dish surpassing the last in creativity, flavor, and presentation, I've never experienced anything like it. Watching the chefs craft each plate was mesmerizing, and the service was impeccable. The elegant atmosphere, with the dishes that were incredible. If you're visiting, Blue 11 is an absolute must-try. This was the best dining experience we have ever had! read more

Nicole P.

5 years ago

We can't say enough about this place. It was absolutely amazing! Every dish was delicious. Excellent service! Thank you, from the Pizzo's.

Blue 11 - seafood - Updated September 2026

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Blue 11 also viewed

Old Stone Farmhouse

3.8

(104 reviews)

•$$$$

Ugh! We had the worst night here.It has gone downhill fast since we were here three years ago…read more Six of our 17 meals had to be returned as the grouper was rubbery with a congealed sauce. They took those meals off the bill, but then charged us for the replacement meals which hit the table 1.5 hours after the first meals were served. Server was happy to auto-grat our bill despite us having to get our own drinks at the bar multiple times. Too many more issues to list, but the coup d'état was the trashy manger accosting us at the valet stand when we were leaving as we were joking about how bad the experience was. Keep it classy Old Stone!

What a beautiful setting. You drive up and there is valet parking. The stone building are full of…read morehistory and architecturally stunning. We had reservations and were seated immediately. The menu had many enticing options but we both had a craving for fish and mahi mahi is one of our favs so we ordered the same meal. Usually I don't allow that because it's so fun to try other's meals but I made an exception in thiscase. The meal was great. It had a nice island flavor. I also loved the jasmine rice served with it. We split a garden salad which had fresh veggies and a nice homemade dressing. We finished with affogato which was nice and light. Service was great. We really enjoyed the experience.

1864 The Restaurant

4.2

(110 reviews)

Here's something a bit different at 1864 . Try the amazing grits as a side order . They are quite…read moreunique and made from scratch every day . They are Caribbean style , with a little coconut flavoring . I'm from the South and I know my grits . These are exceptional!! Try them once and you'll order them every time . And their version of " oysters Rockefeller " are also incredible . For me , this is the best restaurant on St John !

We had reservations for 6:30 and showed up half hour early and were seated immediately. With it…read moreopening at 5:30, not all tables were full so we were lucky. We had a nice intimate table in the back of the restaurant, surrounded by the beautiful stone architecture. The openness of the restaurant allowed for cool breezes to flow through. So nice. We started with the garlic focaccia bread and the shrimp cocktail. All good. I chose the fish of the day (mahi mahi) as my entree. It came on top of greens with green beans and a tropical mango salsa. Perfect island flavors. Our server, Jeremiah, was outstanding. He walked us through the menu. He suggested a honeycomb side to Husband's chicken and Mac-n-cheese which he loved. He was so friendly. Just made the meal even better. So enjoyed this experience.

Morgan's Mango

4.2

(422 reviews)

So many people told us to come here is it was very hard to secure a last minute reservation so we…read morewere excited to try. We ended up absolutely loving the food here. Everything is so fresh and packed with flavor, that you really can't go wrong with anything in the menu. The vegetable paella was delicious, the two tridatos we tried were fresh and bright with the different sauces on top, and the key lime pie was absolutely amazing. It is definitely the vacationers favorite spot, but I wouldn't say it's too touristy or anything. It gets a lot of attention because it's good and a nice place to eat dinner with your family on vacation. We sat at the bar and the bartender was super friendly. The host was kind enough to try to squeeze us in anywhere he could so for that we are very grateful. The food took awhile to come out, but that's probably just island time stuff, and besides the place was PACKED. But our appetizers and desserts came out really quickly. We loved our time here and would definitely recommend giving it a try if possible! There is a good mix of seafood and "land breezes" on the menu, plus a couple vegetarian plates if needed. Perfect for cocktail and mocktails as well!

We were fortunate to get a same day reservation by calling between 9-4 and were looking forward to…read moreour experience as first time diners. After getting an amazing cocktail at the bar while waiting for our table, and then receiving a great spot on the front corner of the patio things started going downhill as others have mentioned. After taking our order, we never saw our server again (other than watching him help other tables) until after our entrees were delivered and we asked someone to find him to help us get a glass of wine. We had originally planned to order a bottle but just opted for a glass at that point. Our appetizers dishes and empty cocktail glasses also sat for quite awhile on the table while we waited. Food was a mixed bag. Enjoyed the special soup and tango salad but our grouper and wahoo entrees were disappointing and overcooked. Skipped dessert as we were both a bit bummed at the overall experience. Not sure if we would try again with other spots on the island we would like to try, but if we did, would opt for the bar in hopes of better service.

Mafolie Restaurant

4.1

(115 reviews)

Fantastic restaurant! Chef Ronaldo is truly one in a million, a Michelin-star quality chef with…read moreexcellent instincts and high flavor intuition. Food was fresh, everything hand crafted with such simple ingredients, yet incredible complex and delightful flavors. If I could eat here every day, I would! Alas, we live 4000+ miles away. But when we come back to St Thomas (and we will), Mafolie Restaurant will be our first stop! Excellent service with Toovin (top notch), what a delightful staff! Thank you Simone! A++++++. 100 of 10 stars, if that were possible. We'll be back!

If you're looking for one of the best views on the island, this is it. The overlook is absolutely…read moreunreal especially around sunset. Shout out to the manager, Robin. She was incredibly kind and welcoming, and the service overall was exceptional. We started with the Virgin Islands crab cakes. Two flat crab cakes, packed with real lump crab meat. Moist, flavorful, and not stuffed with filler. They came with a sauce that had this cinnamon apple ketchup vibe to it which sounds odd but somehow worked. I was skeptical at first, but I ended up loving it. For the main course, we had the Filet Mignon ($68). The menu mentioned that it was served with honey spiced asparagus but instead came with carrots. It also came with mashed potatoes and a coconut green peppercorn sauce. I asked for the steak to be cooked medium rare and they delivered on that. We also tried the Whole Snapper for $55. It was deep fried and served with peas and rice and carrots. Packed with flavor and very crispy. For drinks, I got the Golden Hour Martini $16. Slightly sweet, citrusy, and refreshing. Easy to sip while watching the sun set over the island. Mafolie is on the pricier side and I do recommend making a reservation prior. But between the view, the quality of the food, and the service, you are paying for the full experience. If you're in St. Thomas and want a memorable dinner with a view that actually lives up to the hype, Mafolie delivers.

Pangea Terra Table

4.5

(142 reviews)

Excellent food and ambience! My wife is GF and there were…read moreplenty of options Highly recommend

Beautiful restaurant! Food was just ok. Very small portions and high prices. I have never had such…read morea small serving of fajitas; no pico de gallo. Three tortillas and six shrimp. Very mediocre.

STJ Speakeasy

4.4

(16 reviews)

What a find! We were getting a roti at Roti King in the Lumberyard parking lot when we spied this…read morerestaurant. It's so cool! We scored a reservation for later that night and made plans to come back. Everything we ate was amazing. The grouper ceviche with the tostones - wow. The charred octopus. Also wow. We went with the fish of the day. It was perfect. Since we shared an entree, we had room for dessert. Dark chocolate cremieux. Insanely good. Make a reservation and check them out.

I'm not sure why they call it a speakeasy, maybe half of the staff is hiding…read more Good drinks. Service is polite but slow.

The Banana Deck

3.8

(103 reviews)

They should call this restaurant "Cream Sauce Deck" because they seem to smother everything with…read moresome version of the same sauce. That said, everything is pretty pricey in St. John and this is a little less pricey and a little more casual. We went for dinner. It was fine. I wouldn't repeat it on a trip but may be a good hang for drinks and they are apparently known for the rib eye which I didn't try. It's not bad. If you're on the fence go there.

First .... Let me say my rating dropped 1 star for ONE REASON - A reason the establishment had no…read morecontrol over. We had an early dinner / ahead of the typical crowd. I asked for and was provided seating in the shade. Our meals were outstanding. They're known for their rib eye steak. It was cooked perfectly, very tender and seasoned well. The accompaniment (baked potato & green vegetable) were good. My wife opted for an appetizer (crab and shrimp roll) which she said was delicious. Drinks were on spot and our server did a great job. Our only issue was the young buck knuckle heads seated by us. Drunk / high, loud obnoxious language that an old guy like me just didn't appreciate while having dinner with my wife who was dressed to kill. I know - not the restaurant's fault but it did diminish our experience. Outstanding meal & service but don't be surprised if you get dive bar patrons next to you

Ocean 362

3.8

(141 reviews)

Most expensive dinner we had all week. Best view we had for dinner all week. Service was…read morewelcoming, easy going. If you're walking it's an uphill walk on a narrow street. Taxi is easier. Drinks were good and uniquely crafted cocktails. Food.. salad was fresh and delicious. Caribbean Clam chowder good, crab cakes good. Healthy portion sizes, which may explain why it was more expensive than the other restaurants.

surprisingly happier than I expected. i've been here in the past, but it's much better now.read more

The Easterly

4.4

(447 reviews)

Brooks Restaurant And Bar

4.4

(149 reviews)