Ugh! We had the worst night here.It has gone downhill fast since we were here three years ago. Six of our 17 meals had to be returned as the grouper was rubbery with a congealed sauce. They took those meals off the bill, but then charged us for the replacement meals which hit the table 1.5 hours after the first meals were served. Server was happy to auto-grat our bill despite us having to get our own drinks at the bar multiple times. Too many more issues to list, but the coup d'état was the trashy manger accosting us at the valet stand when we were leaving as we were joking about how bad the experience was. Keep it classy Old Stone! read more

What a beautiful setting. You drive up and there is valet parking. The stone building are full of history and architecturally stunning. We had reservations and were seated immediately. The menu had many enticing options but we both had a craving for fish and mahi mahi is one of our favs so we ordered the same meal. Usually I don't allow that because it's so fun to try other's meals but I made an exception in thiscase. The meal was great. It had a nice island flavor. I also loved the jasmine rice served with it. We split a garden salad which had fresh veggies and a nice homemade dressing. We finished with affogato which was nice and light. Service was great. We really enjoyed the experience. read more

See all

Our experience here as a family of 6 went very well. Everyone likes their meal and they accommodated us with some kid menu. We ate many options off the menu. I'm giving is 4 stars because food was good but not delicious. The service was 5 stars though. read more

See all

Dinner and service were very good. The ambience is top notch. I would recommend giving the Old Stone Farmhouse a try if you are in St Thomas and are looking for an elegant night out. read more

The ambiance is amazing with thick stone walls and arched windows. The food was delicious. My husband said it was the best tuna he had ever had in his life and melted in his mouth. My friend and I had the two pound local lobster with asparagus. It was delicious and the presentation was awesome. Definitely a special event place. read more

I was invited here for brunch and was blown away from the venue. Clearly a lot of effort was placed into restoring the farm house, and I really appreciated the flower garden and pond in the reception area. We arrived on time for our reservation, and were seated quickly. Our host was especially kind, but we found ourselves waiting a while for our waiter to take our order. We were the only customers in the entire restaurant, and learned from our host that our waiter no-called no-showed. Despite that our host took good care of us, ensuring that our orders made it to the kitchen. The eggs Benedict with lobster was delicious, and was a generous portion. After eating our meal, the head chef came over to ask us for our input. She recently took over the menu and wanted to make sure that we enjoyed our meals which made the whole interaction that much more genuine. I am sure that if they were properly staffed that day I would've given five stars. read more

Old Stone Farmhouse - Inside - Caribbean Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

Considered one of the two best meals you can have when visiting St Thomas. I'd agree already without having yet tried the other establishment. All food service and ambience parameters were met within 30 minutes of being here. Our servers were very knowledgeable and friendly, offering their favorites off the menu and always in tune to our needs. The specials and the entrees were fantastic and could write a review on their own. A must try for fine dining when visiting St Thomas. read more

See all

This was my first time coming to Old Stone Farmhouse, and I chose it because the reviews were so good. However, we had a reservation for 8:15 and didn't get sat until closer to 8:30 because they were so understaffed. We didn't get greeted until about 20 minutes into sitting down and it just felt like we were constantly waiting for service. The food was good but the overall service ruined the experience. read more

Old Stone Farmhouse - Crab cake - Caribbean Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

Ive gone twice and highly recommend . I had the pepper steak and fish tacos. The second time steak tacos and a regular cheese burger. The painkiller drink is really good , as was the strawberry cheesecake drink and the margaritas. The waitress was very informative, nice and attentive. I would highly recommend because everything was fresh and good. read more

I know it says it is a good romantic place, but I went with my 19 year old and still enjoyed the experience. She had the filet and ate everything on her plate. I rarely eat fish, but had the scallops that evening and they were great. Very accommodating too, as I don't eat bacon and they were able to make it without. The place is beautiful. Not sure about the grounds because it was at night, but would love to see it during the day. The server was phenomenal. Aaron, I believe was his name. He even helped me choose the best route back to the condo we were at because the drive was a little scary. Valet was a nice feature and the valet was super friendly. It was just a little confusing to find it when we arrived. Overall, highly recommend for good food. read more

Yeah, ambience is top-notch having been renovated sugarcane farmhouse, and the service was quite good. There was someone in training which I don't mind in the food was absolutely outstanding. I ordered the local pink snapper and I was very very happy and my husband loved his too. read more

The location is absolutely amazing. Stunning location. The food was good. Everyone was happy with their dishes. Food took a while but that seemed to be normal on the island. The service was friendly and had personality. Overall a good spot to go with solid food. read more

See all

We happened upon this restaurant from our driver. It was the most amazing experience. I loved the history behind the building. The food was absolutely fantastic & the service was great! A must place to eat! read more

UNBELIEVABLE!! My wife and I chose this restaurant for the celebration of our 20th Anniversary. They delivered AND SOME! To begin with, the restaurant setting is beautifully unique. We loved the ambiance and the old world feel of the stone walls and the hard wood floors throughout. Next, the service was friendly, professional and attentive from the moment we entered the restaurant. Our server paced the meal perfectly with drinks and the next course always seeming to arrive at the perfect time. Last, the food was spectacular! The entrees were inventive and unique with an island flavor to them. My wife's filet was paired with a tomato purée and an orzo salad that was a lighter starch compliment to the usual steak and potatoes that one finds in every restaurant. My scallops and couscous were also a nice, light alternative that was still flavorful and filling. We finished the evening with the chef's special orange flan which was PERFECT! We learned that they are still in the midst of a "soft opening" as they re-open with a new chef and many new staff members. If they can continue with the dining experience that we enjoyed, this will be a tough reservation to get in the future. Thoroughly enjoyed our dining experience and highly recommend. read more

Old Stone Farmhouse - Scallops and Couscous - Caribbean Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

Indulge in exquisite flavors amidst the charm of a historic 200 year old farmhouse, with country side Caribbean breezes dancing around and nocturnal melodies serenading the night - a dining experience that etches itself into an unforgettable moment! read more

See all

Made a brunch reservation and ordered bottomless mimosas, lobster bisque, eggs Benedict and Caesar with salmon. They did a great job keeping the mimosas full, service was good, Benedict and bisque were both great. The Caesar, on the other hand, was all lettuce spines and virtually no leaves, dressing lacked flavor and salmon was overcooked. read more

See all

We just left and I have never had a worse dining experience. Six of our group of 17 order the special grouper which arrived rubbery and congealed. The fish was gray and covered in way too much sauce apparently covered to hide the issues of the fish. They removed the grouper but then charged us for everything that we ordered to replace. Our second table was completely done with their food before we even received our first meals. We received the replacement meals well after everyone else had finished their meals. They charged us not only for our replacement meals but also $120 for water. We were asked if we wanted still or sparkling but they opened 10 bottles before we noticed we were being charged. We all heard tap or still but were never offered tap or informed of the ridiculous charge for the bottles of water that they just kept opening.bottles without checking in. On an over $1500 tab, with 1/3 of the dishes returned the only thing they offered was three free desserts for 17 people! We would have probably let everything go but then the manager followed us out and we were joking with our kids about the $120 of water and she started yelling at us that she asked us if we wanted bottled still or sparkling. No one at the table heard her say the bottled, we were only offered those two, should have been informed of the cost! Very disappointing as we brought a large group of friends back after an amazing experience a few years ago. The nice little auto gratuity at the end was convenient since several of us had to go to the bar to get drinks while waiting for the second round of meals to come out. Management and bartender were awful! read more

HIGHLY RECOMMEND!! This was absolutely one of our favorite meals while we were in St Thomas. The food was incredible, the service was wonderful and the ambiance was lovely. The chef had delicious specials including a crab cake appetizer and freshly caught lobster entree. Additionally the restaurant is a historic building with an incredible charm to it that made for the perfect backdrop to dinner. We will absolutely be back as everyone was so incredibly welcoming as well read more

See all

Had dinner last night with my wife son and daughter. Great staff, great service, great food and great environment. Best dinner dinner I've ever had. read more

The food, service, and ambiance were top notch. It was far superior to Oceans, which was simply overpriced and overhyped. The Old Stone Farmhouse had excellent food including steaks and seafood. It's expensive m, but well worth it for the experience. Easily the best restaurant we went to during our ten day stay there read more

Pricey but worth it. Delicious food with wide variety. Great setting in a superb location. Most enjoyable.

One of the most beautiful restaurants I've ever been to, and I've been to quite a few. It's in a historic old farmhouse built with stone and brick. Dimly lit adding to the charm. Everyone was professional and friendly. Oysters were great shipped from Massachusetts patriot oysters. Amazing. My grilled Caesar salad was amazing. Not too much dressing plenty of parmigiana cheese. My swordfish special was delicious. Light and blackened perfectly. The grilled tuna was great outside of a few fatty slices but still excellent. Definitely best fine dining restaurant on the island . read more

I had a nice experience at Old Stone Farmhouse; overall setting was cool (the name is fitting). Mostly European/French style cuisine and your standard steak+ sides type of deal. Service was great. Shared a steak+lobster tail combo that also had potatoes and asparagus for $130. Steak was cooked well; lobster was flavorful but seemed a little overcooked (texture seemed harder for sure). I still enjoyed my food a lot though and would go back. read more

Amazing service, our server was attentive,friendly and very knowledgeable! The food was fantastic! My caviar martini was very smooth. The rib short ribs fell right off the bone. The oysters were nice by and fresh. Very delicious and briny, from the New England area where I am from! Made me feel right at home. They had beautiful hanging lights which made it have a romantic vibe. Met a couple who said they had their rehearsal dinner there because it was that beautiful! read more

Old Stone Farmhouse - Caribbean Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

My most favorite place in st Thomas! So beautiful and romantic! Staff was very nice too. Dinner was above expectations. Everything was delicious. read more

See all

Went to VI for spring break for a week and we went here twice! The specials.... Hold on while I wipe my drool from my face... The surf and turf is amazing. If it's an option you need to order it. Sell your left leg or your first born but it's a must. Idk what they put in the Brussels, or how they prepare them but omg I could eat my weight in them. Same with the potaters. There was not a single crumb of food left on anyone's plate. It has the cutest atmosphere with pretty string lights. So romantic or family friendly. Really good for all occasions. Also ask for Jimmy. 10/10 he will take great care of every head in your party! *only parking is valet. read more

Made reservations here over the phone same day. Very kind staff. Food was delicious : seafood chowder very flavorful. Bread and butter was ok. The risotto is delicious. Pay for the scallops. read more

Been here several times NO LONGER the restaurant it used to be. First, unless you want to sweat while eating a $400 dinner for two don't come here. Food was mediocre and charged $115 for surf and turf where the rib eye was not worth it. Too many other good options on the Island. read more

Old Stone Farmhouse knocked it out of the park. Started with an incredible appetizer, the Scallops St Jacques, but the star of the show were the two fish entrées we got: sole meunière, served in a sea of butter, with the sole cooked to complete perfection, and then interrupted with the brightness of capers and the crunchy hericot verts, and then the locally caught yellowfin steak. Oh what a dish. A perfectly seared rare to medium rare, it came stop a bed of mashed potatoes and a delightful velout sauce, but the standout was the roasted cloves of garlic and the mushrooms. Wow. Inventive, surprising, and just worked on all fronts. A true delight. Add to that a fantastic server named Nick, who balanced us alongside a 12 top flawlessly, and just, wow. Pitch perfect, and one of the better meals we've had, here or anywhere. Couldn't be happier. Oh, and the bread and butter was ridiculously good and came in handy for sopping up the various sauces! Highly recommend! read more

Old Stone Farmhouse - Sole meunière, done beautifully - Caribbean Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

Syd was an incredible waitress. Her food recommendations were spot on. The food was incredible & drinks were strong!

Stopped for brunch. Haven't been to Old Stone Farmhouse since before the hurricane. Still is an amazing place. Started with bloody mary's with a marinared shrimp followed by mussels...outstanding. Service at the bar was top notch. Highly recommend a visit. You won't disappointed and the prices are reasonable. read more

See all

Excellent Food,Service,and personnel ! I ate the lobster appetizer,and the Filet For an entree. Both were Awesome ! Beautiful Women named Barb greeted us,and Byron waited on us. Great crew great food!! read more

Food was INCREDIBLE!!! Deducting a few stars because we didn't have good service (our waiter came over to take our drink orders and we waited over 30 minutes to put in apps- the manager had to come take our order bc it took so long and we only saw the waiter again when he handed us our check!). I'll chalk this up to a little mishap though and would absolutely come again- the manager made our time wonderful and the food speaks for itself. Definitely a hike to get there but I'd say worth it! Sea bass and lamb were unreal but I'd say the lamb took first place! read more

Old Stone Farmhouse - Sea bass- the risotto and mushrooms were amazing with this! - Caribbean Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

Very secluded. Valet is great. Upon entering there is a courtyard w a small fountain. Gorgeous stone arches greet you as you enter the bar area. There are four separate rooms but they look into each other. The whole feel is open air. The food was amazing. So flavorful. The three of us got the same fish dish. Good cocktails and wine. Desert was also superb. Best restaurant in the island. read more

My girlfriend and I both had the Lobster Eggs Benedict , one of mine was delicious and sufficient the second one was tiny and a bit dry. Our server and her assistant did a fine job, we were upset that the dessert we wanted was not available. Our cocktails were great! I had the old fashioned and she had a Tom Collin's. I've had double knee replacement surgery so I appreciated that the Valet would bring the car down so I didn't have to climb up all the steps. A reservation must be made for the Brunch and prices are very steep. I do look forward to returning again and trying other popular dishes. It's also nice that they provide free Valet parking. read more

Unfortunately, my attention to detail has yet again lead me to finding hair in my food. Luckily I had not yet taken a bite. This is what $30 can get you for your sunday brunch at Old Stone Farmhouse. My server replaced the plate suspiciously quick, the potatoes were cold and unseasoned. Definitely not going back. I wanted to spread awareness so you save your time and money. read more

Old Stone Farmhouse - Lobster Benedict seasoned with hair - Caribbean Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

We spent $300 here and were not satisfied with a single thing.. the only thing that was great was the service and dessert. Otherwise the lobster was too cooked/chewy. The steak ever bite was pure fat. The mashed potatoes 1/5 nasty! Citrus carrots were alright but we got 6 of them for $14.. that's fine I guess. And again the drinks were terrible! They probably should get one or two star but the place looked nice decent service good place for a date. Just don't come to hungry. Picture looks good not the food isn't read more

We went here for a birthday celebration. The restaurant is situated in a farmhouse that is centuries old. It was absolutely gorgeous! The service, drinks, and food were all fantastic!! I would definitely recommend dining here! read more

To sum up our experience here, this restaurant is like a hot lady you take out on a date but when you actually get into the night you realize there isn't much depth there. This restaurant is romantical, has a unique ambiance for the island (see my pics), and has set itself up to be in the classification of upscale dining but only if the food gets better. Maybe the hubby and I ordered all of the wrong things, but after getting great feedback from others on St. Thomas we thought how could anything be average here especially with the prices? The amuse bouche was probably the tastiest part of the meal ( chilled watermelon sesame soup) and really made me believe everything else after it would be just as exciting. We ordered the salted blue cod cakes with smoked Spanish aioli and avocados ($14) and Lobster Bisque with sweet ginger foam ($13). Both have a very pretty presentation but the lobster bisque tasted like the Trader Joe's box Squash soup with a chunk on lobster in the middle. It's like a bowel of thanksgiving ( not lobster) and the cod cake was cooked very well but didn't have any umpf in flavor. My hubby had the Mahi Mahi with mango Caribbean lobster ($35) and I took the Red Snapper with pumpkin and coconut curry ($32). I will never have my dish again, the "pumpkin coconut curry" is more for color than taste and the couscous was cold in parts like it wasn't microwaved well. The snapper skin was cooked well, and I liked the crispy texture but that's about it. My hubbys Mahi Mahi was tastier than my fish, and the "Caribbean mango lobster salad" on top was a very meager serving. Portions are small here, you can not split entrees and leave satisfied. We thought dessert would be the winner and ordered a bread pudding with rum flavored ice cream ($12). I don't think what was served was bread pudding. It came out in a 4 oz soufflé bowl that's more for a creme brûlée and that's what the "bread pudding" tasted like. There was a centimeter of solid, perhaps still defrosting sugar on it. Did not enjoy this at all, only the very small scoop of ice cream on top was yummy. My verdict is that the menu is jazzed up a bit more than what is actually made. Food is cooked well, but is very safe with flavors which translated into not very exciting for the hubby and I. $143 for all of this wasn't my idea of value. The wine selections are excellent though! The host and sever were amazing , there is nothing lacking with customer service here and the valet guy is 5 stars all the way. Valet it's complimentary and upon leaving the valet came into the restaurant saw us, took a super secret passage to get back outside, across the building and upstairs before we did so our car was at the front and ready for us to go. Rock on valet dude, you really earn your tips! We would go back again to try different dishes, perhaps seafood isn't their thing here or the kitchen had an off night but we'll stick to the beef next time! #St.Thomas #USVI read more

Old Stone Farmhouse - Mahi Mahi w/ mango & Lobster, Lobster Bisque, bread pudding w/ Rum ice cream, red snapper, blue cod cake, watermelon soup #St. Thomas #USVI - Caribbean Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

This message is for the owner and the owner only. Your female gate guard working at 3:30pm on 6/8 just lost a party of 6, solely because of her. Sounds funny but it's true We had dinner reservations there tonight - went to Megan's bay and stopped by old stone on our way back to red hook to get changed for dinner. Literally just drove up to the gate to check the place out (and confirm we wanted to make the 25min drive back for dinner tonight). But nope. But nope. Business is personal and kind employees are important read more