Husband and I ordered to go a week ago. The ordering process was easy. I also liked that I did nit have to go in to get my order, I called the number on the sign and they bring it to your car. Mozzarella sticks were house made and the pizza had great flavor. read more

Great spot to grab lunch! Clean, efficient staff. Ordered a Meateor pizza! Yum! You would be disappointed! read more

Blue Moon Pizza - Meateor pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

First time here and we will be back! Service was great. Everyone was super friendly. Had the mozzarella moon appetizer and it was so good! Very crunchy and the cheese pulls were fab. We also got a margarita and bacon cheeseburger pizza. Both were delish. Crust is chewy and yummy. Great atmosphere as well. Wasn't busy when we got there but was packed when we left but not too noisy. read more

Blue Moon Pizza - Margherita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

See all

Ordered a custom pizza delivered and it was perfect! I will highly recommend this place. read more

Blue Moon Pizza - Custom Pizza * - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

Great pizza and service! We had the Greek and BBQ Chicken pizzas. It's a fairly typical pizza parlor and the ambiance is lively and upbeat. I would definitely recommend this place if you're in Fort Myers! read more

The food, the service the pizza and the salad were wonderful. The new owners are doing a great job!!! The outside patio is beautiful and tropical! I think we will be back weekly and they have great lunch specials! read more

Blue Moon Pizza - Nice bar with big screens for you sports fans! My love and I enjoying his favorite food pizza and my favorite food salad - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

See all

Pizza is good, thin crust, outside crust was a bit burnt, however flavor was still there, tiny salty as well Service is really good, waiter was always looking for us Ambience is nice, not specially clean, but clean enough. It's a nice place to come with your family as long as you know what to expect read more

See all

I am not sure how the food tastes I decided not to eat here after the experience i had ordering over the phone. I was ordering a calzone and they wanted to charge me a dollar for marinara sauce. Who sells a calzone and doesn't include marinara sauce? The website has a side of marinara sauce with the BYO calzone which is 11.50. In the picture when you order online there is a side of sauce. The classic calzone was $15 and I would have had to pay a dollar extra for marinara on the side. How does this make sense? Due to these issues I won't be going to this place because I feel like they are ripping customers off or maybe they just don't know their own menu. Either way I will go to a different pizza place that gives me marinara with my calzone. read more

Blue Moon Pizza - The classic calzone for $15 and no side of marinara sauce. - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

See all

Forgot to snap a photo of our salads and pizza, but the food here was decent overall. It's a fairly typical pizza joint with menu options that include a number of premade pizza combinations, along with build your own options, wings, salads, sandwiches etc. Parking was easy and the place was super clean (not greasy as pizza places can be sometimes). Everyone working here was friendly, although a big group next to us seemed to slow things down in the kitchen today. Our white pizza was 7/10 for me. I really enjoyed the thin, crispy crust. The red onions threw me off a little. Salads were competent. Solid place for lunch in this area in my opinion. read more

Had a wonderful experience, staff was great. Food was wonderful will definitely be back!

We ordered the white pizza to be delivered. It took longer than they told me plus was barely warm when it got here. Because we were so hungry, reheated in microwave - big mistake! Was really good next day reheated properly. Most expensive pizza I have ever bought! read more

Everything was delicious!! Our server was super friendly and all smiles. Plenty of indoor and outdoor seating, as well as a bar. We'll definitely return! read more

See all

Upon entering, I immediately realized why I never choose this place. It was a random Tuesday night, and this place was a zoo. I waited at the door a few moments to be seated, and waited almost 30 minutes for a drink. No one came to my table - I repeatedly tried and no one would make eye contact with me. I finally got up and stopped someone, and no one was sure who was supposed to be my server. My friend and I waited for over an hour for our food - we ordered salads. Nothing was comped, the bill had a mistake, a small apology was given. The food was fine once we finally got it, but no food was worth waiting that long in a chaotic environment where you feel like you're being ignored. If you're looking for a place where you'll wait indefinitely for your food and you'll need to shout across the table because there are feral children screaming and running around all over, then this sounds like the place for you. There are SO many better options in this town, in my opinion. I sadly remembered why I never eat here, and I definitely won't be back. read more

Ordered the BLT! It was so beyond yummy. Was on a warm flatbread with cheese too. A definite must. Husbands ordered the Italian. He LOVED it. Got a Greek salad so fresh and crunchy. We'll be back! read more

loved the cobb salad and white pizza service was excellent. yummmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmy

I actually can't believe that this place has good reviews on here. What a horrendous experience ‍. The waitress had absolutely no clue about what celiac was or the need for no cross contamination for gluten free (they advertise this). The menu under "100% gluten free" it lists crispy chicken for the buffalo salad so when I asked her about it she didn't know. She went back to the cook who confirmed that it wasn't safe and it should say grilled. The entire menu is wrong and that is really unsafe for celiac customers and even gluten free considering the crispy chicken has gluten. They were also unsure about the dressings for salads listed on the GF menu. I ordered the GF pizza against better judgement and it came with a random piece of chicken on it and no basil (margarita pizza). Then the manager came over with a terrible snarky attitude and said he'd personally remake it and rolled his eyes!!! We left without eating. No way would I trust this place. On top of these issues, the waitress stuck her finger inside my cup to refill. Totally gross. Addition: my husband's food that wasn't GF was also terrible. Never returning. read more

Best pizza I've had in years. Service team is superb. Ambience is very good/you can visit in normal tone of voice. Two-fer on standard beers, and house wines, tasty - 3 Pm to 6 pm daily. Try it out. I've been in there four times since the new owners took over three months ago. The father and his son former owner of TRADERS. read more

The pizza was delicious, unfortunately the outside crust was a little bit burnt, but still good. The service is what you would expect nothing special. The outside logo looks cool and the inside is with booths and chairs. read more

Blue Moon Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

See all

Whenever we are down in Ft. Myers, we visit Blue Moon Pizza. It's a short walk from our place and the food is always good. They have a cute patio with string lights and the restaurant has a lot of seating and a bar. It feels cozy in the evenings and you can watch a game and have a drink. My husband always orders the Meateor and loves it! It's too much meat for me (hello meat sweats!). This is my first time trying the meatball sub and it was really good. The meatballs were large in size and had a good spicy kick. There was a bunch of melted mozzarella toasted on top. The bread itself was crunchy from toasting but still soft enough that it doesn't flake everywhere. If you are in the area, check them out! read more

See all

We used to go there every Friday night, but since the new owners took over, the food is not good. I wish they would've left it the way it was because it was great. read more

Great overall experience. Very comfortable atmosphere. Service was great and the thin crust pizza was exceptional. Perfectly done. The crust stood on its own. No folding required. read more

Had a great Pizza (Classic-asked for it a little crispy), and the fire wings. Both were delicious. Service was also very good. But, the most surprising and unexpected delight was they made the best Vesper Martini I've had in Lee County. Perfect blend of Gin and Vodka with a hint of Lillet, and the perfect lemon twist, all shaken hard so that I had the little ice chips floating like snowflakes on your windshield. Somebody knows their martini business! Well done Blue Moon. read more

Stood there and waited to be seated. No one came. Server came from outside, no greeting, just said no where to sit but the bar when there were open tables. He was younger and wasn't feeling it and you know you can just tell it isn't going to go well. Too bad, we always have have a stellar experience.This time , not so much. I guess no Blue Moon tonight. read more

See all

I found my new hang out on Friday nights. Great bar. Something must have changed recently. Great service!

Fort Myers: This place used to have great pizza however it has become the source of the worst pizza I've ever eaten. They skimp on toppings hardly any sauce and the pie I had tonight was under cooked and stuck to the box. Tried three times, no more. read more

I worked near Blue Moon many years ago. Whenever we have social gathering or pizza party, we would order several "Take-n-Bake" pizzas and bake in our oven to ensure freshness, crisp and hot steaming pies. I don't believe this; it is been more than 3 years since our last visit. We stop by to have a pizza and beer for lunch! I ordered my favorite, "Classic" pizza with pepperoni, sausage, red and green peppers, mushroom, and red onions. You can smell the fragrance as the staff put the pie on the table! Needless to say, "Delicious!" My friend ordered her Margherita pizza with roasted tomato, mozzarella and basil with a light sauce. Both pies were spot on! You can see how pandemic affected their tables arrangement. They are spread farther apart both for inside and outside seating! The ambiance is casual and relax. Staff is always friendly and professional. Need to come back more often! read more

See all

I got a great pizza tonight - my favorite, Bacon Cheeseburger, is excellent!! Big thanks for the great service, too, from Brenna and Ana! read more

Blue Moon Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

Today I was in a mood for a quick snack and was passing i front of " Blue Moon pizza " so I decided to stop and try. It's rare when I leave a review only when the place,food and service make my day. Even for simple chicken wing I had a great expérience. Alisa the bartender was very nice and very attentive. And that where I just realized you don't need to be in a Michelin stars restaurant to enjoy the moment at any table. Thanks again Aliza and all the staff at Blue Moon to make a great start for my day PS and the wings where excellent read more

Blue Moon Pizza - Chicken 10 Wings* - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

Food was really good. Service was great. Place wasn't busy, must've came at a good time. Wife and I met some friends here and had a double date. Place was very clean. Set up was nice. We enjoyed the food and atmosphere here. Cool pizza spot. They have tasty food, apps where great here too. read more

See all

Stopped here for lunch today, randomly based on yelp. I ordered a buffalo chicken pizza and my wife got a veggie flat bread. The food and service weee top notch. Highly recommend this place!!!! read more

Calzone was only have full of stuffing. Paid extra for garlic which was not in the pitiful portion of filling. Calzone looked like a deflated tire. Delivery but still only warm while my husband's mozzarella sticks were hot. read more

Blue Moon Pizza - 3 inch of nothing - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

See all

we went to Blue Moon Pizza for their bruschetta and pizza. Was amazing ! The new owner was working and suggested an appetizer that had mozzarella on top of a spring mix , and tomatoes had balsamic glaze on it. Was excellent! They have great daily drink specials as well. He suggested putting hot honey on our pizza. Turns out that tastes better than it sounds. My husband and I consider our selves as Pizza connoisseurs and always looking for the best pizza. We definitely found one of the best pizza's in Southwest Florida. Owner was extremely attentive as well as the bartender. Had a very good experience all the way around! read more

Brought friends with us to dinner here tonight, we all had a great time. Waitress was super fun and the food was wonderful. Love that they deliver and have curbside available as well! read more

First and last time here..... got a salad, comes on top of undercooked bread? (Why?) with grocery store salad and cut up chicken tenders and tastes like nothing. My friend got the cheesy bread and the sauce was definitely store bought and it seems that is what most of the cuisine is here. Was underwhelmed and even though I didn't eat my food they still charged me. Avoid this place and go somewhere else. Plenty of better options in the area. read more

Blue Moon Pizza - Buffalo chicken greens - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

Good food and friendly staff. we seated quickly and the service was fast and friendly. About all you can ask for The pizza was very very good. I will definitely come back here and try other variations. Drinks were very good as well. read more

Great food & customer service, I will most definitely be coming back. The meat-eater pizza was perfect & so were our drinks. 10/10

This was not the worst and not the best pizza I've had. Hunger makes you do what you have to do. It really looked good and the ingredients were fresh but the crust was not to my liking. read more

Blue Moon Pizza - a pizza box on a table - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

See all

I'm a pizza is pizza person so for me it's good pizza-their drinks are good and the place was clean Staff was good too

The food was amazing, the server helping was so nice and willing to help explain all the sizes of pizza, toppings, let us split toppings half and half, etc. The price is extremely fair, i would go beyond to say it's super cheap for a family. Amazing chicago style thin crust, not too much sauce or dough. They had a bar too with sports and light music. Overall would 100% recommend to stop by and try. Wish I took pics of the pizza but I did take of the dessert. read more

Blue Moon Pizza - Dessert - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

Food is great, the atmosphere is old and hasn't been updated in years. Same decor for the last 15 years. I do like their Greek salad.