Nick & Stella Pizza Perfecto 7-5-25 Stopped by on Saturday afternoon about 4:55pm. Place was not full, as we were the only people sitting at a table. This place was neat and clean with over 20 TV's throughout the entire place. Our waitress Lisa took our drink ordered fast and got our food ordered right after. I ordered the Saturday Special Half Rack of Ribs, Fries and Coleslaw for 19.99 My wife got a 10 Wings fore 19.99 and she also ordered small Salad for 4.99 Our friend ordered a Ceasar Salad for 15.99 The wife's small Salad came out first. All the ingredients in the Salad looked fresh and tasted great. My Ribs got delivered next. They looked good and so did the Fries. The Ribs were tender, so I used a fork to pull them apart and eat them. They were done to perfection as was the Fries. The Coleslaw was ok nothing fantastic going on there. I did try a couple of my wife's Wings, and they were amazing the best Wings I have had in this area. Our friend's Ceasar Salad was huge and looked fresh as well. We all liked our food. They give you plenty and all our food was hot and very tasty. A couple things to mention on the downside I always ask for something on the side like extra Mayo or Crackers to see if they remember the small items. Lisa forgot to bring Crackers with our Salads which I specifically asked for. She did stop by after we were done with our Salads to see if we still wanted the Crackers, we said no and some of the tables were wobbly. We sat at the first table it was very wobbly, so we told Lisa we were moving she stated take the next one over as the last one wobbles also. The tabletops were not in the best of shape and the chairs were absolutely horrible to sit in very uncomfortable for any length of time. Next time I will ask for a booth it has to be better than the chairs. This place earns 4 out of 5 stars. Follow Me On Fb For More Fun & Reviews. Gulf Coast Terry read more

See all

Bad pizza and rude server who made us feel like a nuisance. Old and needs an update. Typical strip mall trash. Gross!

My hubby and I have been coming to this area for 20 years and the first time we have been here. This quaint place is nestled in this little shopping center. Nick and Stella Family Sports Pub has everything you can think of at a casual restaurant. They have daily specials every day of the week. We shared a house salad and 5 wings with fries. The food was yummy no complaints. Next time we will try something else. Very clean and fun environment. People really were enjoying watching sports and enjoying food. read more

See all

The only pro is the food we ordered. Cons - all the rest. The vibe here is horrible. The bartender clearly looked like he hated being there. Awful service. Nobody smiles or makes you feel welcome. Stay away from this place. If you want to watch football, look somewhere else. read more

We've been here 3 times. Love the place. Got the pizza last time and it didn't disappoint. We went on Wednesday night when it's half price pizza and wine. Stella is really the personality of the place. She stops at almost all of the tables and offered great service. Our waitress must have been having an off day. Friendly atmosphere we loved sitting at the bar. The people at the bar were very engaging and fun. Very reasonably priced and they also have an outdoor area. Nice place. read more

The worst part of the experience was when the bartender, some older man (who I guess is the owner?) insulted and mocked my wife for looking young (she is in her late 30s). We didn't feel welcomed--it was like a bother we were there. Food is below average for bar food. Drinks are overpriced and even so they got our drink orders wrong. We are locals and have been there a half-dozen times but we will not return. There are plenty of better options in the area. read more

supposed to be a "Steeler Bar" ... not! First, we were the only Steeler fans in there . The bartender and manger were not friendly at all.... he was very rude. People sitting next to us, who were locals said "he always grumpy". Menu was typical bar food ... not good food. Where was the "Steeler" food"? Perogies? Permantis "like " sandwich? Pittsburgh Salad? No drink specials with Steeler names... how about IC Light ? A mural of Pittsburgh on the wall (outdated by 20 years ) and a few terrible towels don't make a "SteelerBar". And for goodness sake..... people in Pittsburgh are friendly and fun.... Get new management that can relate... he was miserable . read more

Great bar food, great service and cold beer. Would suggest this place for a casual meal.

I found this place on yelp. I wanted to buy carryout pizza and I went into the restaurant and I saw the big 'carry out' sign to the right of the entrance. The bar was packed so that told me they were open. I stood there waiting for about 8 to 10 minutes and nobody acknowledge me nor did anybody approach me to take my order. So I left, got back on Yelp, and I found Bada Bing pizza right around the corner. I walked in and they greeted me cheerfully and they took and fulfilled my pizza order. Why go to the trouble of opening a restaurant and then don't serve the customer when he walks in the door? I don't understand. Maybe put a little bell or something on the counter that the customer can ring so that you know that somebody walked in the door to do business with you. Anyway, the food might be excellent at Nick and Stella's. But I'll never know. I do know their competitor sells some pretty good pizza read more

Food used to be incredible many years ago. It is now barely edible. We ordered chicken parm subs, slaw and Philly cheesesteak. All were disgusting . Never again. read more

So. Our waitress might have had her first day today. She completely forgot my salad which is included on the menu and says it will be served with the meal and then denied that it says it. read more

Nick & Stella's - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

the service was great; everyone was very friendly and smiling. This is a great place to watch all the games. Food was amazing!

I will never watch football there again. Staff seems so uninterested in helping you. Left at half time and went across the street to Randaos to finish watching. I regret that I gave part of my Sunday Funday football day visiting this establishment. Never again. read more

Definitely a local bar. Everyone supporting their team. Loud , crowded what you would expect a sports bar to be. Menu was traditional pub fare, burgers, pizza, wings,subs, salads. Pizza and wings were great and our server was attentive despite the large crowd. Definitely more of an old school feel with an older crowd and everyone was really nice . Great way to spend a weekend afternoon. read more

See all

DO NOT Go-Walked in with a large group and the bartender was rude from the start. Told us we didn't call ahead so they couldn't serve us. We were in no rush and willing to be patient. He refused to serve us and walked away when we tried to order a drink at the bar. We walked out. Won't be back ever again. read more

Service is below average. Food is below average. Location is in a shopping center. Would pay double to go to the shrimp place next door. Not sure how this is considered a real bar and business. Strange to let such a manageable place go from not that good to really bad Jimmy Sapia 4438128920 Let's talk about it Nick or Stella read more

First time here with friends, it was 1/2 price pizza nite but I'm doing keto & I got the Cobb salad which I could only eat 1/2 of it. Server Nicole was very attentive & great! Will definitely return. read more

Nick & Stella's - Cobb Salad - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

What a fantastic Thanksgiving dinner we had today at Nick & Stella's !! Not only was the food delicious, the service was incredible, thank you Andrew for working today ! We ordered the baked meatballs for an appetizer, so yummy ! And what a value for dinner, $20 per person for a full homemade thanksgiving dinner which included roasted Turkey both white & dark meat, mashed potatoes with gravy, yams, homemade stuffing, cranberry sauce, dinner roll and a slice of pumpkin pie with whip cream ! Thanks to the Chef and entire Staff for working - we will be back this week to try the pizza !! read more

See all

We went with a large group of about 30 of us on Feb 4th and service was outstanding! The burger, teriyaki bowl, flatbread and fried pickles were all delicious. The pizza is always good! read more

I had pizza delivered and it was delicious. I had the Big Ben and it was a great combination. The sauce was flavorful and just right amount; toppings adequate. Will definitely order again. read more

Went to watch football. They had all of the games on and several TV's for each. The bartender looked like he hated being there and had no personality. Had a chicken sandwich and fries. The sandwich was decent and the fries were good. I'll go back but hopefully the service will be better. read more

$12 for a slice of spinach pie. Terrible pizza. I threw most of it in the bin. Grubhub never texted me, and left it outside my hotel room door. read more

St Patrick's day so came for a Reuben - how do you mess up a Reuben? Meat was tough and instead of kraut it was served with the "cold" slaw piled on top... the slaw made the bread soggy. I love Reuben sandwiches and have had them at hundreds of places.... This is hands down the worst I've ever had by a large margin.... Funny thing was it was listed on the menu as "new" in a special box... do not order it. On the flip side... fried cheese was delicious! read more

They have specials every night and happy hour!! Wednesdays is half off pizza night and $10.00 bottles of wine! No it's not top shelf wine, but it's good!! read more

The nightly special was 3 tacos with rice and beans. The tacos had, at most, a tablespoon of beef. The rice and beans were 1/4 cup at best served in a sauce cup. Perhaps something else is better. read more

Nick & Stella's has been a favorite of mine since I moved down here a few years ago. I am always very happy to be able to watch any game on their many TVs and order great food. Hint, the "boneless wings" are actually like chicken tenders so expect leftovers unless you order less than you normally would. We ordered way too many, but we were happy to eat them as left overs for the next day. Love it here! read more

Fun place with a friendly staff and great pizza. Wednesday night specials are the best.

So. After waiting about 10 minutes for someone to take my order....i waited 40 minutes for a Philly cheese steak and fries the sandwich was good fries were nasty.. clearly the fries had been sitting ..she apologized and asked if I needed another drink while I waited on my fresh fries....I had already finished my sandwich as I waited for the drink and fresh fries...it became obvious they were out of the spirit I ordered so she poured another spirit... and no one said a word.... someone was putting away a liquor order and thought it would be acceptable to put boxes on the open chairs at my table...i got fresh fries and waited to pay...it's clear that regular patrons get preferential treatment... I get it..it's a sport's bar...but that doesn't excuse sub par service read more

Just a simple no frills pizza and sports bar. Plenty of TVs to catch your favorite game. Stopped in for a quick and simple pizza dinner. Pizza was nothing special just good pizza and priced right. For dessert we finished the meal off with a slice on confetti cake. Only think that mite be a little confusing is the big ARCADE signage out front. That arcade consisted of a Candy Crane and 1 other old video game. LOL. It wasn't our main reason for stopping but it did help us finalize our decision. With 2 boys an actual arcade would have definitely put this place up a star. read more

Nice place to hang out, have some drinks and watch sports. Staff is friendly and prices are reasonable. Love the Cobb Salad but not crazy about their pizza. The outdoor tables are great on a nice day and the way they have it set up, you don't realize you're sitting next to a parking lot. read more

You can't beat Nick & Stella's! Great staff, clean place, solid and consistent food, great environment. If you're looking for a fun and casual place for a few drinks or a casual meal this is a great place! read more

I really wanted to like this place. It's close to home & would be a great place for a quick dinner. Impossible to sit outside b/c of the heavy smokers glued to the tables out there. Settled into a booth inside. There was one server to serve inside/outside & bartend! The food came out about 35 min after ordering. Cheeseburger was cooked to a hockey puck consistency after asking for it to be "medium". Upcharged for sweet potato fries & they were burnt!! My daughter's boneless wings were so covered in almost raw garlic she couldn't eat them. Sorry to say, definitely will not be back. read more

I recently had Nick and Stella's cater my son's 40th Surprise Birthday Party. Joanne one of the family members was a gem to help me plan the menu and it was ready at the requested pick up time. Even though I asked there to be enough food to serve 20 people there were a lot of left overs that we were able to enjoy for several days later! And it was great!!! I highly recommend Nick and Stella's for your next casual catering event. Sonia Lomano read more

Very nice but had to wait a while drinks. Very good pizza and staff friendly. Nice bar & great place to watch the game.

Great pizza and friendly staff. The pizza special is fantastic especially for those on a tight budget.

I had the Stromboli with meatball. While it is a bit greasy I think it is from the cheese they use. The meatballs were tasty and the crust was tasty. read more

Yesterday, Friday March 5th, 2021 was our first time ordering from Nick & Stella's. We ordered take out since we are still not comfortable eating in restaurants. We should have looked at the order before we left the parking lot to make sure it contained everything that we requested. We ordered wings, which were fantastic, a meatloaf dinner, and an order of Texas Style Spaghetti which was to include salad and garlic bread per their online menu. The entire order was $50.00 including the tip. When we arrived home and unpacked the order, we noticed that the salad and garlic bread were missing. Also when we opened the container for the Texas Style Spaghetti, it was a VERY small portion it was less than half filled (picture attached). For $14.99 we would expect a bit more than we received. It was mostly noodles and beans. I called the restaurant to report the missing items and small portion of Texas Spaghetti, the person on the phone said we would have to talk to the manager, but the manager would not be in until tomorrow (today) and that the manager Joanne should be in by 11:00 on Saturday and they would make sure she called us. It is now 7:00pm Saturday evening and still no call from Joanne. With this kind of customer service, I really doubt we will be visiting this establishment again. One would have thought a $50.00 take out order would be important enough to management to warrant a return phone call. A disappointed customer. read more

Nick & Stella's - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

Greasy pizza was the story and indifferent behavior from bartender named dan. Cakes looked good but tasted dry. Heard it had been remodeled so thought I would go again. Nicer atmosphere but same poor food and service read more

Good service. Just had drinks. It was busy! Food looked good. We decided on sushi rather than pizza, or else we would've eaten there

2 stars because the Cobb salads are huge and really good. Tons of meat and fresh vegetables. Waitresses were nice and short handed of course but the job done. Beer was nice and cold. Also had the Friday fish fry special and it was disgusting. The texture and taste of the fish was slimy and raw inside even though it was deep fried? I just ate the fries and slaw. Not sure if I would give it another try just because it was not really my type of scene. When walking through the front patio area to enter the front doors you have to walk through all the smokers ( also with marijuana smokers which was very obvious by the smell) sitting outside on tables and benches with other loud drunk locals sprawled out being obnoxious. read more