Okay, this may be one of the more difficult reviews for me to write. Why? Because Blue Tomato confuses me as much as it delights me! How do you categorize a restaurant that offers a full menu of Mexican food, a full menu of Italian food, a full menu of local fare and American classics, AND why not throw a little Asian food in as well. Now, do all of it VERY WELL, and you have quite the conundrum when you sit down to eat. "What am I in the mood for?" Luckily, you can mix and match to your heart's desire. Garbage nachos and Thai ribs? Sure! Chicken alfredo with a couple of tamales? No prob. A good steak with a Cuban quesadilla? Why not? The possibilities are endless. Now, mix in some killer drinks, and we're talking about somewhere you'll want to bring all your friends who can't decide what they want. It's all there for them, and if they can't find something at Blue Tomato, you might want to reconsider your friends. The service staff at BT is wonderful and homey. I always feel like a local when I eat there. It's comfortable and quaint whether you're eating seared tuna with a margarita or a batch of wings with a Mic Ultra. Lunch is actually my favorite time to visit. Quick service and reasonable prices make this a lunch destination. You might need to ensure you have a refrigerator at work though...the serving portions are generous. So, what are you waiting for? Is it lunchtime yet? read more

This is a "higher class" dive of a diner with a eclectic menu that jumps into multiple ethnic food genres with a selection of Italian then some Mexican along with some classic American and a nice dash of New Orleans dishes thrown in for good measure. The menu certainly goes all over the map with its dishes and that seems to leave some less than excellent execution but generally they pull off "ok" to "very good" food. The service here always seems to be very good and the ambiance is a unique mix that gives it a fun vibe. The burger and lasagna are decent and the Italian and Mexican style food can often be quite nice. The New Orleans food is typically good and they usually have rotating daily specials. Overall this is great spot when you have a group of people that all want something different. Warren Zevon would really enjoy this place! read more

Let me start with the service is excellent. You're greeted like family. We started with chips and salsa. The salsa was delicious but the chips were the star. They were thin and crispy with some Cajun seasoning on them. I had the smothered burger special that was so yummy. The Cajun potatoes and gravy with onions were just perfect!! Hubby had the honey blackened mahi mahi sandwich and it was so good. I highly recommend this little hole in the wall that the tables are full; but, well worth the wait. read more

Blue Tomato - Smothered burger special! - Mexican Near Me - Jefferson, Louisiana

See all

Servers are super nice and food is always quick. Inside the restaurant is nice but on the small side and parking is a pain sometimes. We mostly do takeout. Burger is great. read more

Great food, true Tex-Mex, great service, love the atmosphere, I love this place. I definitely do not like the requirement for 85 characters to post this review, Yelp gets a 2 for this unreasonable expectation. read more

Every thing from food, drinks and employees! Best margaritas, the shrimp quesadillas with added spinach Alfredo sauce always! read more

Blue Tomato - Margaritas! - Mexican Near Me - Jefferson, Louisiana

I love this place and they never fail to provide a good meal whether it's from their Mexican side of the menu or the Italian. Their margaritas are to die for and are often on a special. I've noticed the freshness and good quality of the fish in their dishes and am always satisfied with the bean dip and other parts of the appetizer menu. I definitely want to try more items on the menu but I've never taken someone here who didn't love it. read more

Blue Tomato - Mexican Near Me - Jefferson, Louisiana

This place is hit or miss at best. People are generally friendly, but you never really know if it's going to actually be open and the food can be great one visit and just okay the next. read more

Been coming here for years most recently last five years because I work so close. Always bring coworkers and friends. No more, over how many times do I ask for a to go container and get ignored before I have to get back to work and leave my food. last visit was today I'll never go back too many other places. read more

Best ribs in town. Great service. Everything is delicious. Quirky environment because it's in an old Time Saver but well worth it

Absolute best burgers in town! We have been eating here my entire life and we have never been disappointed! The food is always amazing no matter you get and the service is fantastic! Highly recommend this spot! read more

It's been well over 10 years since I've been here. I used to come often and it was always busy and good. I was getting tired of the same old same old so the wife and I went to eat. She's never been. She's from the Westbank. The crazy thing about this place is that they offer Italian and Mexican food all the time and they do them both incredibly well. We were craving Mexican. We started with chips and salsa. The chips were freshly fried and hot! I had the 3 enchilada plate with rice and beans. I went with one of each chicken , pork and ground beef. The ground beef was awesome. I wished I'd gotten 3 of them. There's a faint hint of cinnamon I've tasted in Mexican cuisine before and it was really good. Then I tried the pork. Wow!! It was better than the beef. I wished I'd gotten 2 pork and 2 beef now. The chicken was just ok. The last 2 were hard acts to follow. The tables are few but well spaced. I'll go Italian next time and be sure to update. Give this place a try , you won't be disappointed. read more

Blue Tomato - This is my wife's chicken chimichanga with rice and beans. It was good. If you want it crispy, ask for the sauce on the side. - Mexican Near Me - Jefferson, Louisiana

See all

Staff was absolutely amazing!! Food was delicious and the service was impeccable. I observed the staff taking extra special care of some adults that needed a little assistance. Heartwarming experience. read more

Very good food. Sometimes they are rushed but it's worth the wait. The Mexican, or the Mediterranean are all very delicious.

Quite a strange experience at the Blue Tomato. They bill themselves as a Mexican Italian restaurant. The night we were there they had no pork or guacamole: two pretty big components of a Mexican menu. To add insult to injury, we could smell the ribs smoking, wafting through the restaurant, but couldn't have any yet. Rest of the food was pretty mediocre. I had meatball Parmesan. The tomato sauce was super watery, meatballs just tasted a little off. Queso was meh, first time I've seen yellow cheese in a Queso dip. My friends who were eating with us ordered Mexican, one thought the salsa tasted like it was out of a can because it wasn't very spicy; the other enjoyed it. The server was very friendly. Maybe the restaurant just had an off night. But there are enough other choices in our area that I don't know if I'll put this back in my rotation. read more

Have passed this place hundreds of times and finally decided to give it a try. The menu is widespread with Mexican, BBQ, hamburgers and Italian food. My wife decided to try the shrimp tacos and I ordered the fish tacos. Wow! Both of them were excellent. They both came with rice and beans, which were mediocre. That's okay, the tacos made up for it. The service was great and attentive. We will definitely be back. read more

Blue Tomato - Chips and salsa - Mexican Near Me - Jefferson, Louisiana

I ordered spaghetti and meatballs and a side of salsa. My first thought was, why did these people open a restaurant? If you can't commit to making a sauce (which is some time commitment) then just go to the store and get some pre made. It's actually pretty good what you can get in a jar. the sauce was very under par. The salsa was under that. I sent it back, but both waitresses made a snide comment on how I ruined the spaghetti with the salsa. Like I can't tell the difference between sauce and salsa? Hello? So I got Garbage can nachos. I like the name, it has a sense of humor - and an idea that it has all kind of stuff in it. So what did it have in it? Sour cream, cheese, ground beef, jalapenos - exactly what everyone puts in basic nachos. I will say, they didn't put cheez whiz, it was real cheese. But the bar is pretty low when all you can say good is they melted some cheese. read more

This place is like visiting family. We always get their ribs plate and/or their cheeseburgers with everything on it. Definitely one of my favorite go to burgers. The servers are always kind and funny! The ambiance is nice with the lighting for if I want to hit up both a bar and restaurant with great food because they always have the best music playing! When we don't want to think about choosing a place we always say "let's go see our friends" read more

Always a great place for food consistently good and the workers are consistently friendly

Service: The service is nice and good on refills. Food: I have mixed feelings. The food isn't necessarily bad but it's not restaurant quality of any sort. It's all canned quite literally and it's easy to tell. I guess they don't add much more spices to the dishes than what was already in the can. The prices for me aren't worth it although I understand they are priced that way because they don't actually skimp on meat. It's just I simply do not want to pay for the taste quality. The meat isn't actually all that bad it's just the sides that are lacking the most. read more

Like always the food and the service were top notch. When I'm in the mood for a good burger it's my go to.

The food was surprisingly very good here. I've passed this place most of my life and finally decided to try it, the parking isn't great when the restaurant and the feed supply next door is busy. But over all the food is good and the service is good read more

Blue Tomato, located in an old Time Saver building (you can tell from the brickwork outside), serves up big portions of Tex Mex, a few interesting variants such as the house specialty fish tacos, and Italian dishes that can be quite good. They also fix a fine burger. They offer a fairly wide variety of cuisines, though be warned that none are particularly light, and the service is fast and remarkably friendly. It's a nice neighborhood place with a neighborhood feel that would be quite at home on US 90 west of Houston if not for the smattering of competently executed New Orleans specialties. (Unfortunately, they gave up on muffalettas some years ago, but I still remember theirs as an outstanding example for those who like them hot.) Parking can be an issue. read more

Blue Tomato - Dark but friendly dining - Mexican Near Me - Jefferson, Louisiana

See all

It is a mixture of Americana and Tex-Mex and I am happy to have both! I have heard that the burgers are pretty good, but I decided to have the ground beef quesadilla. It was very good and with chips and salsa, more than enough food to keep you filled. My friends tried the beef ribs and enjoyed them as well. I like that they are mixing up their menu selection and just making my trips here different! read more

They were out of EVERYTHING when I was there. Their fish tacos were DISGUSTING. But the servers were very nice.

My Husband and I wanted to go out for cinco de mayo but didn't want to wait long . We decided to go try the blue tomato. It was a 15 min wait with was not bad. We were seated at a wonderful 4 top table with I loved because I like room . My husband and I got the chip,salsa and guacamole for an appetizers. Omg ! The chip were delicious. They were fresh and guacamole was amazing. My husband ordered a mojito. I must say I am picky about my mojito because I am cuban but let me tell you. It was on point. Delish. I order a skinny margarita with I loved . Should have ordered a second . LOL ! My husband ordered the tamales and I ordered the Shrimp Fajitas. So yummy. I wish I would have taken pictures. Maybe next time because there will be a next. This place is very good. Thank you Blue tomato for making my cinco de mayo so wonderful read more

We went there while in the city with my cousin who raved about the place. I think it's better for drinks and apps maybe. Some things were okay. Some were not good. We had a cheese dip, not good. We had fajitas, we could've done the same things at home. Just wasn't what was expected. They had cheese fries and ranch and they said they were good. The chips were good and the salsa was decent. I may would try again but something different. We also went right at opening so not sure if it would be different later in the day. read more

This was my first time here and man was I pleasantly surprised. Everyone was SOOO nice! It was the most welcomed and taken cared of (without being hovered over) that I've felt at a restaurant. Food wise, the ribs were the night's special, so that is what I went for. Half BBQ and half dry (because why not?). These things were flavored just right and we're so tender they definitely fell clean off the bone. The plate included pineapple beans and a crisp slaw. Everything went really well together and had the comfort of home cooking that I like for a mid week meal. In general, I felt like the place was not as busy as it usually is, so there was some extra time the staff was able to dedicate to each table that was there, and the menu is kind of all over the place, allowing couples that don't want similar food to have multiple options but not have to go to multiple locations. read more

Blue Tomato - Ribs! - Mexican Near Me - Jefferson, Louisiana

Pork enchiladas & garbage can nachos. It's never disappointed. One day will try the ribs! read more

Blue Tomato - Garbage can nachos with grilled jalapeños - Mexican Near Me - Jefferson, Louisiana

Got the garbage can nachos togo and they sucked. The chips literally had no crunch. They were soggy! I live about .25 miles from the restaurant so It's not like the food sat a long time. I'd recommend not getting the nachos or just getting them at the restaurant. read more

Blue Tomato - Garbage can nachos - Mexican Near Me - Jefferson, Louisiana

The food is consistently great. The owner is always there and service is speedy and friendly. I've never had anything that wasn't fantastic. I'm not a lover of margaritas but their's are YUMMY!!! read more

This restaurant sits on the corner of Jeff Hwy and Central Ave. At busy times, like lunch and dinner, parking can be tricky. There is an extensive menu, Italian, Mexican and burgers, but I always seem to get the chicken quesadillas. These are my absolute favorite. They are very cheesy and big enough for lunch leftovers the next day. They come with an assortment of toppings. YUM! Big plus-complimentary chips and salsa! Their margarita is delicious and perfect on a hot summer day. The servers are very attentive and friendly. The owner makes rounds to chat and you'll see her frequently helping the wait staff. Love the Blue Tomato and I highly recommend it and the chicken quesadillas! read more

I was a bit disappointed. I had heard SOOOOO many good things about this place and was excited to try it out. The queso was ok. Nothing too special. Same as my chimichanga. It was ok, just nothing special or something I would have to have again. The place was a divey place. I will say this.......every single worker in there had a smile from ear to ear and loved everything about that restaurant. They were some of the nicest people I've ever met, we even could see the chefs/cooks going to town cooking in the kitchen and they all looked like they were enjoying themselves. Wonderful, wonderful, wonderful costumer service!!! read more

See all

Got $5 special margaritas that were tasty and strong. We also got the garbage can nachos, which contains ground beef, jalapeńos, sour cream, pico, olives, and cheese of course. Pretty low prices. Place looks like a dive bar inside but food and drinks are top notch! read more

I thought the garbage nachos would be good considering the reviews on them. It's usually packed every time I pass. The chips were stale, and the nachos were simply average. I was very disappointed. The lemonade was decent so that earned an extra star. read more

Blue Tomato - I thought garbage nachos would be good due to reviews. They were nothing fantastic. Chips were stale. Tasted like average mediocre nachos. - Mexican Near Me - Jefferson, Louisiana

The Southwest Chicken Soup - WOW, nice amount of heat ! Loaded and jam packed with great flavor and I couldn't even eat my entree.... Looks like some good leftovers for later!! :) read more

Blue Tomato - Bean n cheese barrito - Mexican Near Me - Jefferson, Louisiana

See all

The staff were super friendly, so no big complaints about the service. However, I wasn't thrilled with the food. As I'm looking at the menu, I see the window's sign that says "authentic Mexican". So we ordered Mexican food, well it was boring & nothing seemed fresh. I ordered shrimp fajitas, but the shrimp did not come out sizzling on a plate. I'm pretty sure their seafood is frozen & wouldn't be surprised if they used a microwave to cook. And the salsa was odd & tasteless, it's a weird mixture of Mexican salsa meets Italian red sauce. The Spanish rice had no taste at all. And even the guacamole was blah and had no texture. I wouldn't be surprised if it's something they order from a food supply place, instead of making fresh guacamole. I'm not sure why this place has good ratings? It was just disappointing & the prices are too high for the quality of food. read more

I have been to the Blue Tomato many times. This time I saw a new menu item. It was grilled reddish topped with shrimp, artichoke hearts in a light cream sauce. It was served with Smothered Green beans and onions along with crab boil potatoes. This dish was fantastic. read more

Blue Tomato - Mexican Near Me - Jefferson, Louisiana

I thought the food here was pretty decent, with a thing or two being a little above. My fiancé and I went on a Friday night for dinner. We shared a queso and chips appetizer, I got an enchilada plate and he got a chimichanga. The chips were good, and the queso was average. He felt his chimichanga was average, and wished it had been a little more crisp on the outside. My beef enchilada was excellent! The pork and chicken were good but not nearly as good as the beef. The beans were okay and the rice was on the low flavor side. Overall a decent meal. I would like to come back to try the hamburger! read more

See all

Saturday lunch I got there just after eleven and I was initially the only customer. Service was fast and friendly and the soft fish tacos were well seasoned. read more

Blue Tomato - Dining room Blue Tomato - Mexican Near Me - Jefferson, Louisiana