Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Blue Water Fish

    4.4 (48 reviews)
    Closed Closed
    Updated a few days ago

    Order Blue Water Fish Takeout or Delivery

    Blue Water Fish Photos

    BLUE WATER FISH ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    More like Blue Water Fish

    Recommended Reviews - Blue Water Fish

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Grilled seafood.
    Debbie P.

    Blue Water Fish is a hidden gem, located on the North Shore in Wading River, NY. The staff always greats you with a smile. The crab cakes are fresh and delicious. Choose from a variety of fresh seafood or meals cooked to order. I am not a fan of seaweed salad, but I could acquire a taste for theirs. The atmosphere is very casual. Whether you dine in or take out, I don't think you will be disappointed.

    fish with shrimp
    Kevin C.

    We stopped by here few weeks back as we hardly venture out here. Saw this place on Yelp and it had somewhat of communal parking across the street. Be aware and observe the parking signs. Stepping foot, you could tell this is a mom and pop establishment where the workers know customers' name by first name basis. We were overwhelmed by both the paper menu and what's on the chalkboard. The employees are extremely attentive and friendly and answered any questions we may have. I ordered the seafood over pasta and let me tell you, the amount of assorted seafood of clams, mussels, and large size shrimps on the plate was astounding. I did wish the pasta sauce was a tad thicker. My wife ordered the baked fish along with shrimp and two sides. The presentation and taste was pretty good. All in all, very good place and we would certainly recommend.

    Kunnie H.

    Love this place! We were heading to Wildwood state park for camping, and pass by this seafood market shop. They have all kind of fresh seafood here. We ordered lobster salad and mussels pasta in red sauce for lunch. Portion is great! AND Delicious!! We appreciate the store owner offer some sticker and lollipops on the check out table kids. Definitely recommend this place !

    Fresh salads

    See all

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Joyce W.
    1
    105
    107

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Carl G.
    34
    65
    3

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Blue Water Fish

    You might also consider

    Southold Fish Market - Menu Board

    Southold Fish Market

    4.4(251 reviews)
    25.3 mi
    $$

    This place is busy and for a very good reason, the food is fresh and delicious!…read moreThe service provided by Emily was five star. She told me that the wait for food would be about 45 minutes. I explained I had to get back to Brooklyn, she let me know that I could get salads and soup. I ordered about a small container of shrimp salad my friend ordered seafood salad. Both were delicious l. They had the right amount of red onions, celery, dill, mayo and whatever secret ingredients they put in there. I also had the lobster Chipotle soup, once again great seasoning, warm and comforting. I would definitely drive about two hours back to this place. Hopefully during the week it's not as crowded.

    Can't rate the food. We called ahead in early afternoon for a takeout order. We were told 45…read moreminute wait. We showed up a few minutes early and were told by the counter person that (a) that our order hadn't been started yet and (b) that we were told it would be an hour when we called and we were early. And there was an edge in her voice. So we went to run an errand and came back 25 minutes later and the order still hadn't been started yet. So it's now more than an hour from the time we ordered and now we are in freefall. So we cancelled the order - with more attitude from a different counter person. It wasn't so much the delay in the order - things happen. But it was the attitude that accompanied it that was most off putting. It felt like a learned behavior.

    Photos
    Southold Fish Market
    Southold Fish Market - Corn fritters and warm lobster rolls one with salad as the side, one with fries

    Corn fritters and warm lobster rolls one with salad as the side, one with fries

    Southold Fish Market - My burnt friend eating some fish n chips

    See all

    My burnt friend eating some fish n chips

    Sunny Farms Marketplace - Samples of crackers and hummus and other bakery stuff

    Sunny Farms Marketplace

    3.7(6 reviews)
    6.8 mi

    Vegetables spoiled on display. Store had a terrible odor. I will return to this store.read more

    "Disappointed by a Normally Great Experience"…read more I've always enjoyed stopping by Sunny Farms for lunch and usually have a good experience. However, today was disappointing. I was in a rush during my lunch hour and didn't notice until a few minutes later that I was charged $6.99 for a single bottle of water--not a case. Fortunately, I wasn't far and went back with my receipt and the bottle. What left me unsettled wasn't just the mistake, but how the return was handled. The receipt was snatched from my hands and crumpled, and though I was told I would get $7.40 back, I was initially handed only $5.40. When I questioned it, the cashier turned around, pulled out the $2, and handed it over, explaining the process as if I had misunderstood something. No apology was offered for either the overcharge or the mix-up with the refund. I get that mistakes happen--we're all human--but customer service is about how those mistakes are handled. This time, it missed the mark. I'll continue to shop here, but I'll definitely be double-checking receipts moving forward.

    Photos
    Sunny Farms Marketplace - Daily fresh sushi . Bogo

    Daily fresh sushi . Bogo

    Sunny Farms Marketplace - Sushi department, they make fresh sushi everyday and after 7 there's a promo for buy one get one free!

    Sushi department, they make fresh sushi everyday and after 7 there's a promo for buy one get one free!

    Sunny Farms Marketplace - A wide variety of proteins as well as prepared meat dishes. I saw chicken, meat, lamb, goat, pork and a whole bunch of other proteins!

    See all

    A wide variety of proteins as well as prepared meat dishes. I saw chicken, meat, lamb, goat, pork and a whole bunch of other proteins!

    Captree Clam - Shucked oysters

    Captree Clam

    4.7(29 reviews)
    30.2 mi
    $$
    Locally owned & operated
    Veteran-owned & operated

    I have been going to captree clam for a long time but since Marcus took over the place is amazing…read more They always had good fresh clams but now they have a large variety of seafood and a fresh seafood counter with a large variety of fresh fish, soft shell crabs, oysters and razor clams and much more. The place is clean no fishy smells. Pedro who waited on me said if you don't see it ask for it and he always has a smile on his face with a friendly and helpful disposition.

    Clams, Crabs, Clams, Fish, Other Stuff And if I haven't mentioned CLAMS!…read more First off I am officially claiming this family owned store my favorite small business of all time. I've loved it for over 15 years maybe longer. I've lost count. Buuuut with the new owner Marcus & his friendly knowledgeable staff (Hiiii Pedro!) it has improved immensely! Marcus's passion & dedication to the art of fishing & shellfishery shows. I come from a long line of clammers & eelers. My family does not give a BBQ without clams. We just don't. But Marcus (I can't say his name without hearing Eartha Kitt. If ya know, Ya know. Hahaha) has upped the ante with fresh shellfish & fish options also dry aged items as well. Today I was blessed with Jumbo Soft Shell Crabs! I was lazy & broiled them instead of grilling or frying them. They came out perfect! Called My Dad & he went back for some also. And the new hours!!! I can't say enough about the later hours & being open 7 days! Epic! Thank you CC for providing quality seafood to my local restaurants while also allowing me the same opportunity to get the best Long Island has to offer. 7-6-2025

    Photos
    Captree Clam - Dry aged Faroe Island salmon

    Dry aged Faroe Island salmon

    Captree Clam - Custom shrimp platter

    Custom shrimp platter

    Captree Clam - We offer dry aging services

    See all

    We offer dry aging services

    Alice's Fish Market - 2 lb steamed lobster from Alice's. Delicious.

    Alice's Fish Market

    4.5(11 reviews)
    27.8 mi

    Never answers their phone. Went out of our way to buy fish here and they were working on catering a…read morewedding with nothing to sell to the public. I wouldn't call this a fish market. More of a fish "maybe".

    Alice's fish market is a true Greenport gem. The prices are unbeatable and the quality is…read moreexcellent. Bought our dinner from here for the second time in two days (can you tell we're fans?) Yesterday, we ordered two 2 lb lobsters and 2lbs of Cod. For no extra charge you can get the lobster steamed and partially broken down (made easy for you to crack open and get down to business ty v much) Naturally, we opted for the pre-steamed/broken downfare and passed on the live option. I absolutely love lobster but I don't think I could ever cook (kill) one, myself tbh. This weekend, we were going to go into town for oysters and wine but upon yelping the prices (average price of $3/oyster aka yeah right. No thanks, buddy. When you can get great $1 oysters at many reputable NYC restaurants you find this to be lowkey insulting) we decided we should buy our own bottles and check out Alice's oyster offerings. Jot this down: most liquor stores in Greenport/Southold/Mattituck carry a variety of bottles from various north fork vineyards so wine not stock up. Of course, Alice's did not disappoint! They sell a dozen oysters for $12.50. So basically I could buy three dozen oysters (roughly) for the price of one dozen in town. If you give them an hours notice they'll even shuck them for you free of charge. Hosting an event? Alice's offer a raw bar party option where they'll set up a raw bar table and prepare the oysters/clams etc. in front of you at your event. So to sum up this super long review, Alice's is wonderful, attentive and of the highest quality. Go check them out on your visit to the North Fork

    Blue Water Fish - seafoodmarkets - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...