Have loved going there for over 20 years under the previous owner. We were happy to visit yesterday…read moreand we had a great experience. We were seating promptly and the waitress came over within a minute. Drinks were delivered within minutes.entrees came in about 15 minutes, which was perfect for us to enjoy our cocktail. My husband's prime rib was super and his side pasta was delicious. My crab and lobster patty was a unique and very good . Portions are large . So glad the new owners are providing the same excellent experience we have always enjoyed there.

Service was good. Menu was not. The menu on line does not…read morereflect the one you receive at the restaurant. There were a lot less entrees to choose from. I would not have chosen this place based on the menu that I was given at the restaurant.

My family and I visited this quaint little restaurant/martini bar in Sodus Point to enjoy a few…read moremartinis and some snacks. What a delicious experience. The Martini menu is extensive, from savory to sweet flavors. My favorite is the Pear! We were lucky enough to visit on the evening they offered lobster tacos. Boy did they hit the spot. Fresh, full of flavor and plenty of lobster in each taco. It was served with a cucumber pickled salad on the side. It's a very busy place on the weekends and the service is super friendly and welcoming.

This is a must stop for the best cocktail around!!!! The staff are so friendly and just awesome…read moreservice. I recommend the baystreet to everyone in the area and visitors!

Was really excited to try this brewery, their beer is made in Erie Canal village in Weedsport…read moreNY... hours are limited in their Sodus Bay location: Thur-Fri 3-9 Sat 12-9 Sun 12-6 Walking in the place is one room, C Shaped bar with about 8 seats... all filled up with locals so we grabbed a table. Only one bartender but that's all that was really needed. She was very nice. I went with a tasting of their six on draft. Buster a German kolsch at 5.0 was very good. Exit 40 pale ale at 5.8 was full of flavor, my favorite was their Italian Pilsner... disappointed they didn't have their IPA on draft here... they had it on 4 packs but I wanted to sample before buying. They have different food trucks that frequent the back parking lot right up to their outside patio section.

Here for a girls weekend and this is the only near by brewery. Of course they don't open till 12…read moreso I feel like I had to wait a year for them to open. Finally got my tasting and was underwhelmed to say the least. And what's up with no IPA on draft. That's a kick in the head. And, of course, while I was there, a woman at the bar had her little black dog with her and it Peed all over the floor. The kind bartender cleaned it up. I just can't even with that. Shirts for sale were very soft but no prices marked. A food truck pulls behind the location at 1pm. The food truck schedule varies. Plan ahead.

The only way someone could leave a bad review here is if they got too busy. Just my observation…read more We were so surprised by this place. The owner only buys what they will use in that week. Our nar neighbor told us to get the chicken strips. They were so juicy that even the next morning the microwave didnt ruin them. Crispy, crunchy, savory. Never thought id crave a chicken tender but hey, what I know?! Nothing was regular bar food. The menu might seem like just another pub with frozen food to keep you drinking beer, but the owner wont serve anything he doesnt love. Everyone we talked to at the bar were locals and we're both a little sad some tourists found it but also they were too proud that this was their place and told us all their favorite menu items. Truly enjoyed our time and taste buds here.

Great pic while visiting the area from California. I thought the wings were better than the ones I…read morehad in Buffalo at Duffs . Everyone else had Franklin bowls and they weren't disappointed.

Beautiful location! Great spot for large groups as well! Seafood was fresh and so good! I'm craving…read moremore just typing this! We also had the opportunity to meet the owner in person which made the experience even more memorable. We will be back!

CAUTION!!! CAUTION!!! CAUTION!!! DO NOT ORDER THE…read moreLOBSTER ROLL!!!!! So disappointed in my meal. The menu itself wasn't selling me so I scoured the internet for photos of the food choices from this local bar/restaurant. I finally landed on a photo from ONE month earlier via Yelp and it was for a lobster. Looked amazing. A generous portion with lots of lobster meat. In fact this photo sold 3 out of 4 of us to purchase this $27 roll. The served asked if we wanted fries so all 3 of us said yes. Apparently that's an additional up charge of $4 for fries. I had no idea until the bill came. In addition, i asked for them to be well done. They were not--and they were sooooooo peppery so I only had about 5. Actually we all discussed the ridiculous amount of pepper on them. So-- let me get to this "Connecticut lobster roll". DO NOT CHARGE ME $27 for lobster and then give me a roll fill mostly with "LANGOSTINO lobster". This is NOT lobster! These are basically hermit crabs man. They are not sweet like lobster at all. And they are much tougher the lobster. I received the equivalent of one actual lobster claw chopped up on the top of my roll, and the rest of my role was filled with LANGOSTINOS. Also, the description never mentions this cheap substitute filler, and it also describes these to be drenched in butter. They did not taste like they were drenched in butter. Maybe next time you should serve a side of drenched butter that could be dunked into. This is sooo highly offensive to me as well as disappointing and frankly poor taste as an owner. Be honest in your descriptions and pricing or serve what your advertising. My server was kind and friendly. But overall the wait for everything from the second we walked in the door was insane. We walked inside and we had to wait to be greeted and seated outside. Took forever to get seated. Took forever to get our drinks. Took forever for our food when there was nobody inside. There was maybe five tables with guests outside. Not sure what was going on, but it really wasn't busy on this Saturday afternoon. I can't imagine what a busy day would be like for this establishment. Be prepared to wait for 45 minutes to an hour for food on a slow day. Lastly, if you take a trip to the women's room, I do have to say the toilet is nice and high. That's a pro for me, but make sure you don't trip on the extension cords that are running through the bathroom floor to light up the window sign in the bathroom. What a tripping hazard! In the future, save your time and money. Giving 2 stars for the for the personable server alone. Otherwise I'd love to rate this place a big fat ZERO STAR rating.

Amazing location, the scenery in the back area was breathtaking on a warm fall day. The water was…read moresparkling and the trees were colorful. Love it! The place was spacious. We came on a Sunday at round lunch time. The service was great, their weren't a lot of people . I believe the owner servers us. Very nice guy also told us about the "Bluffs " and where to find them. Never heard of it. We didn't go that day but we do plan on it. They have a fall drink menu. I tried an apple mojito for the first time and it was delicious. We ordered a beef brisket sandwich and their Hell Fired Pizza. The brisket was dry. I asked for a side of BBQ sauce and it helped, plus I did really like the sauce. The bun was toasted perfect. The pizza was good, didn't care for the sauce, it needed more flavor but the toppings were great and a lot of it. I also liked the crust. Definitely will be going back.

The Mrs. and I were traveling home when we wanted to stop for a quick pizza. Moderate size place…read morewith awesome outside views. Owners were very nice and they had a bunch of people working. Outdoor games were available, live music (not too loud) and great drinks! Pizza was awesome and plenty to drink. I highly recommend!

First time there we tried the pizza and wings and they were very good. Yesterday we ordered the…read morelobster mac and cheese and it was fantastic, no skimping on the lobster, there was a very large amount of it and the mac and cheese tasted home made. We have been there twice now and will go back again.

Great views of the bay on the deck , great sunsets !! The service was great . We split a lobster…read morebisque, it tasted fishy and wasn't very hot , or had hardy any lobster !! My wife and I both had fish fry's . They were super small and had no taste , good thing for tarter sauce ! I would go again probably, and try something else .

Quaint little diner we stumbled across on our backroads journey,…read more We enjoyed homemade soup, sandwiches and milkshakes!!!! The people were friendly and helpful and the food was perfection. We will be stopping by again when we're making our way through town!

What a treat. A delicious home cooked breakfast in a very unique setting. You walk in to what you…read morethink is an old soda fountain and then realize you are in a local museum with a pool hall in the back. Friendly and welcoming staff. I'm in upstate several times a year and a trip to Fosters is a must.

We went in on the Fourth of July and it was a freaking mess in there, there was no hostess…read moreemployees running around like crazy, like there was no order ..nobody seating guests it was kinda sad they can't hire more staff to deal with that or whatever the issue was, it was absolutely ridiculous.. I have never dealt with anything like that before it was just a complete mess in there.. with that being said the service was great. Our server was absolutely on top of all of that mess and dealt with it I think really good!! We got our food in a timely manner! And it was actually really good food the fish was amazing and was cooked perfectly! I think the fries definitely need a lot of work, cmon French fries! Especially in upstate where the fish fries are good! You need good fries The inside ambience was kind of usual upstate new work wood work cute interior it was cute inside! What made my review stars go up is the bartender Claire that worked upstairs, she was so on top everything regardless of how busy it was, she literally had it down to a T she was quick and personable and just got the job done right by far the best employee I came across there she rocked and got the job done right! Amazing bartender! I think I would have left 1 star if I wasn't for Claire and her service she absolutely rocked

I love they were very nice, very polite. I will be back the drinks are great about me a…read morebeautiful T-shirt. I will be back

This place is a GEM! Well worth a drive into the beautiful countryside to visit. My wife and I live…read morein Washington DC, and the quality of the baked goods, sandwiches, and ice cream at this cafe would outdo most of the fancier places we could find in the city. Great seasonal fruits all summer, including you-pick strawberries. We split two chipotle Turkey and caprese chicken sandwiches and they were amazing! Cannot recommend this place enough.

Bake goods are out of this world!! Love the Cherry Almond cookies. Could not just have one bite. :)read more