I've been passing this place for years but never had a chance to stop here. My neighbor and I were…read moreout and she suggested coming here. I will say the pizza was amazing! The inside is small and they are hustling with deliveries. I can see why. Great prices, friendly service. Good location. Parking in back. Can't wait to come back.

Another place I went to after seeing a one bite review, and I personally think the pizza is a lot…read morebetter than the score it was given! Always have to get a plain slice as the base to judge off of and their plain slice was amazing. Then also got a pepperoni Margherita slice which was recommended by the guy working the counter and that was a great option. Small old school joint that definitely gets busy on Friday and Saturdays in the fall for Rutgers games! Employees were all super nice and helpful and asked what I thought of the pizza. They chatted with me a lot about the history of the place and all the good specialty slices they have that are a little different than normal pizza places. Definitely recommend stopping in and trying one of their specialty slices!

Local pizzeria. Called in an order for Vito's chicken sandwich and a meatball parm sandwich. The…read moreorder was ready in 15 minutes. Both sandwiches were about 8 inches long. Vito's sandwich dad grilled chicken, arugula, roasted peppers, and fresh mozzarella. Bread was crispy and nicely toasted. The sandwich cane with a side of balsamic vinaigrette. The meatball parm sandwich had good flavor. The bread was also toasted. The staff was friendly. The restaurant isclean and has a seating area. Parking out front. Will come back to try other food items.

I am obsessed with their plain pie, except made with vodka sauce. It is perfection as far as I'm…read moreconcerned. We also got the small Stromboli that was filled perfectly and absolutely delicious. Delivery is a plus! My new go to pizza place for sure

5/1/26 - There's a somewhat new place on Ryders Lane in Milltown called Pasquale Brick Oven Pizza…read more The parking lot has looked crowded the last few times that I have driven by. Tonight, I decided to pull in and give it a shot. The place was packed inside. I'm not sure how word got out to the community that this place is really good. But it has. I ordered a large pepperoni pizza and a large chicken caesar salad. The pizza crust at this place is SPECTACULAR. The outer crust is crispy and crunchy and not even a little bit dry. The undercrust is also crispy and crunchy and stands up straight when you pick up the slice. The cheese is high quality. After just one bite, I understood the reason the place was so crowded. There are a lot of people working in the kitchen and they also have a sit down waitress service area that was full as well. There are plenty of wait staff running around and serving dinner. Everyone is very friendly and the gentleman behind the counter greeted me the second I walked in the door. Now for my negative criticisms and they are borderline petty. The sauce was good but it doesn't blow you away. When you have spectacular crust and high quality cheese, you would expect the sauce to be on the same playing field. It just isn't. It could probably have used a bit more seasoning. I understand that if you have a lot of staff you also have a lot of overhead. I am not opposed to paying up for high quality products but my large pepperoni pizza and chicken caesar salad cost just under $49.00 which is extremely high for this area. It's definitely worth your time to give this place a shot. But it's definitely not a place you can eat at often unless you're independently wealthy. Overall Rating: A

Thank you for helping plan & execute the best party ever for my husband's 80th. All the guests…read moreare commenting on how delicious the freshly prepared food was. Plus we cannot forget to mention the most gracious, friendly & helpful staff & owners who kept everything running so smoothly. The room was spacious enough for our large group plus 2 entertainers.

This is a nice casual dine in or take out spot located near Rutgers, not too far from Rutgers…read moreGardens. A lot of locals and students come by here, and the most popular orders are the pizzas. Each slice looks relatively big and they will heat it back up for you. There are straws, napkins, Parmesan and hot chili flakes on the side. I wish I got the pizza, but my friend and I got some pastas. You can sit anywhere, and there's also a private room in the back. I got the carbonara, and it tasted more like a stir fried noodle dish. The eggs were scrambled and the bottom of the bowl was super greasy. My friend was happy with her pesto pasta however. I think I would come back and try the pizza, but I'm not sure about the made to order dishes yet...

Good meatballs, cheesesteaks, penne vodka, pizza tastes legit.. I would def recommend this spot…read more Reasonable prices too!

We were looking for pizza that was decent before heading back to DE and chose Mancini's to try. We…read moregot way better than decent, the pizza was amazing! The crust was crisp and light, and the sauce was very fresh and very flavorful. We got the Margherita, a white slice and 2 cheese slices. Our 2 granddaughters ate every bit of their slices. We are hooked! Next trip to South River will include a stop at Mancini's.

My company gets this pizza every saturday. And I do mean every, every single saturday. I dread…read morecoming in on Saturdays if I don't bring my own food because I know I'm going to get soggy, tangy and carelessly made pizza. Frozen buffalo wings from a bag, wraps that you need a gallon of water next to you to wash down and salad dressings straight From - The - Jug. I see the receipt every week so I know the profit must be Nearing 85%. What shitty pizza.

A. MAZE. ING The…read morefood was great and came out fast. They were busy when we were there yet still were able to produce the food fast. The service was amazing and super polite. The inside of the restaurant was well decorated with art on the walls.

what a delicious place to eat and the guy who works there Omg great service thank you tacos and…read morequesadillas are delicious pizza of the chain thanks see ya next time!

Ninos is definitely North Brunswick best pizzeria.... The owner is a cool guy , the staff is always…read moreon positive vibes and good spirits which is the best ingredients in any meal.. But don't stop there., they also have the best cheesesteak in the whole Middlesex county... Trust me!!! Highly recommend the buffalo chicken slice !!! Go to Nino's!!!

After being in the area for almost a year, I was so excited to finally try Ninos. With many…read morespectacular reviews both online and through those I've spoken to in person, I had such high hopes that I was going to find my new go-to pizza spot, but I don't think I will ever return after this encounter. We dined in on a snowy evening when there were no other patrons in the restaurant. Very few stopped in to grab to-go orders, but we were the only group to actually sit and eat dinner here. Upon reaching the counter in search of a menu, our first negative encounter occurred. We asked an employee if we could see a menu, and he dismissed us quite quickly in a rude manner, telling us to look on the counter as if we were blind. No menus there, nothing was there actually, leaving us standing confused. Once he realized his mistake, menus were thrown onto the counter without another word spoken. During this time a family did walk into the restaurant to pick up a to-go orders, which was not yet prepared, leaving them to stand and wait. When we decided on our order and approached the counter once again, we were told we had to wait 5 minutes for them to take our order. Understandable if the restaurant was busy and the front of house staff were in the middle of doing something, but no - the person who told us to wait 5 minutes was just standing there, doing nothing. This employee was not actively making the other guest's order (as there was a back kitchen responsible for that), leaving us even more confused as to why we had to stand there waiting, face to face with the employee, who was just standing and staring at us. After a few minutes of standing in confusion, the other employee who we encountered prior began arguing with this one, in front of the guests waiting for food, leaving us in a very awkward position. Only after the employee was scolded by his coworker was our order officially taken down. Once we received our food we sat at the few tables Ninos had to enjoy our meal. Throughout our dinner the two workers remained arguing with each other, outwardly discussing staffing issues and leaving us to feel unwelcome. Upon leaving, we packed up our leftovers and returned to the counter in search of a bag to place our food in. When asking the staff for a bag, we were thrown a stack of paper bags and told to take what we needed. Since the bag looked to be on the smaller end, we asked if this bag would fit the aluminum tray of food that we had leftover, to which the staff replied "I don't know, go figure it out for yourself." The food was decent, the pizza was crispy but nothing to write home about. During the time we dined in the options for pizza were a bit limited (understandably). The penne vodka was just okay, we felt as if it was pretty bland and heavy on the cream. The best thing consumed here was the Philly cheesesteak - messy and cheesy in the best way, but also lacking flavor and could have used a sharper cheese or even some salt. The bread was fresh and soft, which would be great for other hero sandwiches they serve. With the food being mediocre and the service horrific, we definitely did not feel welcome when dining in here. Throwing items at customers seems to be a common activity here, along with dismissive remarks and constant arguing between the staff making you feel as if you've intruded on personal matters. If the service were better my group would have considered returning, but this experience has left a bad taste in our mouths overall.

Small pizza shop is good…read more The pizza is crusty when it gets right out of the oven, there is no flop if that matters to you. The margherita and regular slices are my favs, in general all the slices are pretty good. There is no indoor seating so most orders are to go especially in the colder months, there are a few outdoor picnic tables in front of the store and some backyard cushioned seats on the side of the building. There always seems to be a wait no matter how far in advance I order. It can be maddening if I get a quote for 20 mins, and still have to wait a solid 10 when I get there. It's good pizza if you can wait past the time given.

Family hasn't stopped raving about this pizza since we got it for a gathering…read more Fantastic pizza - best in the area for sure. Huge slices. Had the peppers & onion topping on plain cheese - delicious. Plenty of topping. Also had the buffalo chicken. It's a work of art. It's beautiful and delicious. One slice can absolutely be a meal. Free soda if you buy any two slices for the lunch special.

I haven't been too thrilled with their food lately. Quality has gone down and every time we order…read morefood for our company, they mess up on our orders ..

9/5/25 - It's about time that I did a review on my go to pizza place in East Brunswick, NJ. It's…read morecalled Michelangelo's Pizza. Through the years, if anyone asked me for a recommendation for pizza, I would ask you what style you preferred. And if your answer was thick neopolitan, I sent you here. I grew up on Staten Island and my favorite pizza shop was Al's Pizza (RIP) on the corner of Jewett Ave and Victory Blvd. That's the same style I grew up eating. That's what I prefer. But I do enjoy other types as well. Michelangelo's reminds me of Al's very much. The pizza at Michelangelo's is thick, hearty and heavy. Tonight, we ordered one plain and one pepperoni. The plain is thick and chewy. It has a small crunch to it. The outer crust is thick and chewy with a light crunch as well. It is not dry at all. The cheese tastes premium and there is plenty of it for you cheese lovers. For me, the star here is the sauce. The pie is generously sauced which I absolutely love. You would think a pie this thick would be droopy, but it surprisingly stands up pretty well. And if it does droop a little, the cheese is so abundant that it holds it together and nothing slides off. The pepperoni has all the same traits. The difference here is the pepperoni adds a lot of grease which I'm not crazy about. I dont believe it's the pie makers fault as pepperoni gives off a lot of grease when cooked. I love the staff here. Friendly and competent. I am always greeted by my first name which is appreciated. There's been some happenings here recently which led me to believe there were issues with the business. It was closed for 8 days without any indication as to why. The phone was also disconnected. Finally on day 4, I saw a sign on the door in the distance but I was late for a ballgame and didn't have time to stop and read it. It's such a good pie that I hope they have resolved the issues permanently whatever they may have been. Overall Rating: A-

Celebrated my 70th birthday with 50 of closet's friends. Nella and Pinot did a fantastic job…read more Highly recommend for a nice dinner or celebration. They treat you like family.

My friends planned a baby shower for me here. The food was delicious !!…read more They make such a good sauce and thier pizza has perfect crust, but it was it was a great dinner menu as well!¡ Everything was made right ( authentic and delicious!l ). The chicken is tender , the lobster ravioli had a lot of llobster meat and the stuffed mushrooms were heaven. Nella and Josepe ( Pino) were so accomidating and made us feel very special. It was a little piece of Italy. After all , Pino still has his accent ! This place looks small from the outside , but we had a really nice set up. There is nothing better than food made they way they must make it for thier own family and being reated like family !!Thank you so much!!!