Tried to go to another restaurant in Gettysburg for a party of 12, called ahead on Wednesday and tried again on Sunday and they would not let us to out our name on the 45-60 minute wait list even after I explained the reason being my mother has some medical issues and couldn't drive 20inutes and then wait up to an hour for a table, even offering my credit card to add our name. So we pivoted and called the Bourbon Mill to see if they could accommodate. They said head in over and we will take care of you. We got there about 20 minutes later and they already had a table set for our group out in the patio area and seated us right away. The servers were on point, took our drink and appetizer order, make sure to get the wings and the crab pretzel, both amazing. Drinks were never empty, the food was fantastic and several servers and managers constantly checked on us. It was outstanding service and food. Please support these guys as they take customer service and quality food seriously. Will definitely be back. read more

We had a great time. Good food, great service and awesome atmosphere. They weren't busy so we need to go back again. This is a very cool place. read more

See all

I wanted to love this place. BEAUTIFUL venue. Indoor seating was so nice and well air conditioned. They have a covered patio with fans and a bar. Live music. Amazing bonfire area as well. I drank water because it was such a hot day. So I cannot comment on drinks but I sure hope they were better than the food. I checked out their menu prior to our visit and was so excited to eat. There were four of us. Food was absolutely horrible. I think everything came frozen from Sam's Club (Members Mark was visible) and was just heated up. Super generic. I felt like I was eating a kids school lunch, blah. We did not even finish our food. Employees were nice. I am not sure we would go back unless it was for the wings (they were okay) and atmosphere. Definitely would not order anything else from the menu unfortunately. This place could actually be a fabulous place to visit if they hired a chef and used better ingredients. I know it's a bar but not even good bar food. read more

Loved this place a few months ago, as a 19 year old it's really hard to find a nice place to dance, have dinner, and just have a good time. Recently they added a bunch of new rules, you have to pay if you are under21, leave at 9 (even though we couldn't get our check paid until 10) couldn't dance though. The music has changed so much. I'm just all together disappointed on how it's become. Really feels like they just care about the money now. Wings are good, but everything else is very expensive, and typically not worth it. read more

First time at the Bourbon Mill. We sat at the bar and got some samples of the beer on tap and got some appetizers. The artichoke dip was ok but definitely not worth the price. The bartender was very nice and helpful and let us try beers before we got a glass. I love the atmosphere and selection of drinks. Definitely will come back for that, food on the other hand was ok and very underwhelming. read more

See all

I was here on a Thursday night. It was not crowded. Service was quick to take my order. They have gator bites. This for me is a major plus. They always hit the spot. They were hot with great flavor. Their French onion soup. Is some of the best in the area. However portion size lacks for the price. 10.00 for a bowl. It is about a 1.00 a bite. I hope this is not the norm. I can say I recommend this place more than before. It has good flavor. Value this visit was mixed. read more

Bourbon Mill - This unfilled bowl was 10.00 - Bars Near Me - New Oxford, Pennsylvania

Watered down drinks, if any alcohol in it. Sorry that's real bullshit!!! Service is pretty bad as well.

First time here. I was in for lunch on a Saturday. Service was top notch, and bartenders made excellent cocktail and food suggestions. Wings were very tasty. Cocktails were great and they have a very extensive beer list. Restaurant is clean and spacious. read more

Bourbon Mill - Smores Old Fashioned Cocktail - Bars Near Me - New Oxford, Pennsylvania

Stopped here on our way to Gettysburg when everyone was hungry. Had no idea what to expect but everything we ordered was so good. It was so unexpected and we were thrilled. It was early lunchtime and we were the only ones in there when we first got there and it did take awhile to be served but I figured maybe the server wasn't quite ready yet. read more

Another couple plus my wife and I ate dinner there last nite ... we ate on the covered porch area. Nice ambiance! Food was good, service was prompt but music was so Loud the 4 of us couldn't carry on a conversation. Had to ask twice if they could turn it down. Would consider going back but will eat in the dining room... read more

We went and it was busy but our server took our order and got our 1st drinks and then I watched her visit every other table at least 4/5 times but we never saw her again. The expiditer brought out food and only one person another drink . Then we sat and sat and sat I was ready to just walk out with leftovers on their plates. The I saw our server visiting the table next to us for a 6th time then I tapped her and and said we need boxes and a bill. TERRIBLE SERVICE. The food was meh, the chilli was the worst I ever had and I love chilli. The crab cakes were mostly filling. My wife got a quesadilla and it had bbq sauce and rice...yes rice in a quesadilla (who does that) which absorbs any moisture and made it very dry. The ribs were the only thing that was good otherwise would give food a 1 star. We took food home to try and doctor it but ultimately tossed it were it belonged...the trash.I will not be back. read more

We went there with my family. My very young son ordered chicken tenders. After he started eating them, my brother-in-law noticed that they were totally raw. Not a little undercooked, but not cooked at. all. We brought this up to the waitress who brought over the manager. The manager literally laughed and said I should teach my son not to eat uncooked chicken. He seemed to think it was funny. He was not even slightly apologetic. He reluctantly let my son order something else. Serving uncooked chicken is a major health risk, obviously, and I guess mistakes happen, but after putting my son at risk, I'd expect a different reaction from management. read more

Bourbon Mill - Totally raw chicken. Disgusting and unsafe. - Bars Near Me - New Oxford, Pennsylvania

I stumbled onto this place and was pleasantly surprised. Burgers were good, staff friendly and I liked the atmosphere. Outside dining was available so I thought I would come back on a cooler day :-) It's located 9 miles east of Gettysburg PA in a quaint town of New Oxford. If you like the Country, farms and antiques you should visit. read more

Bourbon Mill - Recently remodeled and it appears they have outside Volley Ball court. - Bars Near Me - New Oxford, Pennsylvania

BEST EVER wings. Service was phenomenal & patrons were friendly. My daughter & is got there around 3pm for a late lunch/early dinner. Even though we sat at a table bartender greeted us waited on us right away. We had wings appetizer & shared crab tacos. Wings (bourbon BBQ) were as meaty as chicken legs. Totally YUMMY! read more

Food is delish, service always with a smile and ambiance, low lighting and could be very romantic. Thanks Nick. read more

Bourbon Mill - Arnold Palmer and happy hour boneless wings with ranch dressing for dipping sauce one of my favorite finger foods. - Bars Near Me - New Oxford, Pennsylvania

Was driving by and decided to try this place as the outside looked very unique. The prices of their food was great and got plenty of food. Also has a great selection of craft beer. Worth trying if you're in the area. read more

We had a great meal here. I've been wanting to try this place for a while but with covid, it's been hit or miss with it being open. We finally drove past last weekend and saw it was packed hence open!! Yeah! We weren't free until Monday but having it calm midday Monday made for an exceptional experience. Red, our bartender, was super knowledgeable about the area, the newly remodeled mill, and of course the food and drink. She was excellent !! We had the seafood quesadilla which was packed with amazing deliciousness. Best I've ever had! The owners have done a spectacular job on remodeling this building. I never saw it beforehand but their attention to detail is impressive. If you stop in, tell Red that Anne & Greg from Oregon say hi. read more

Grab your favorite beverage and a comfy seat. This review is gonna take awhile. This was our first visit to Bourbon Mill. Our first impression was great - chalkboard with today's special, friendly greeting, nicely decorated, good ambiance (except zero music). The hostess let us choose our seat and a server promptly came and took our drink order. We're off to a great start! Then, another server came to take our drink order. We explained that we already had someone getting our drinks. Server #2 ended up being our server for our meal. We order a crab dip/tot appetizer - that was absolutely delicious. My husband and I ordered the dinner special from the chalkboard (crab cake and ribs). Our friend inquired about the crab cake. The server said "It's really big but it's not all crab. Some is imitation." We got a good chuckle but he orders it anyway. A few minutes later, the server came back to inform us that they're out of ribs. We were a little bummed but things happen. Hubby orders the crab cake sandwich like our friend. I order the salmon. A few minutes later the server comes back to let me know they're out of salmon. What???? The server's reply "We run out of stuff a lot here." I order a THIRD meal - a steak stuffed with tomatoes and garlic. No sooner did we put in our order for the third time after order one and order two had to be cancelled because they didn't have it when here comes our friends' meals. They eat their meals while we wait about another ten minutes for ours to arrive. One of our friends asks for mayonnaise for his crab cake sandwich. Our other friend needed a refill of her water. The server comes back with mayo and a refill but it's soda. Before she could tell him she was drinking water he was gone so she decided to just drink it because she's thirsty. She then realizes it's diet soda - blah! My steak which was supposed to be stuffed with tomatoes was paper thin (think shaved steak) and was stuffed with cooked spinach and not a single tomato. At this point, there's no way I'm requesting a change even though I loathe cooked spinach. So I pick I out and eat it anyway. Our friend excuses himself to use the restroom. He returns to the table with dripping hands. You guessed it - no paper towels. We have a good laugh about everything they're out of. The server comes and asks if we want anything else before the bill. Our friend asks for a refill in a to go cup. The server comes back with his soda in a plastic cup with an apology. "Sorry, no lids." We had another good laugh and our friend said "I hope they're out of paper for the bill!" Another server walks by and our friend asks her for a lid. She brings him two! Now it's time for the bill. My hubby was charged for fries even though he asked if his sandwich came with them and was told it did. We pointed it out to our server who said it was his fault because he thought it comes with fries but it doesn't. He said "There's nothing I can do about it now so just take it out of my tip,". Our friend asked why he was charged 25 cents for mayo for his crab cake. The server's reply "because we nickel and dime for everything here"! Oh my! Well, I can tell you that our first visit was definitely a memorable one!!! Oh...and by the way, the ribs that they're out of are still listed on the chalkboard. read more

Great , service , food, and prices. Good live music outside and inside depending on time of year.

Spur of the moment stop after a quick Yelp search. Beautiful day to enjoy the outside bar. Other patrons are super-friendly and made food suggestions. We got the BBQ brisket topped Mac and cheese, AMAZING. Wings were on special for .59, couldn't resist. We got the wings coated with the sweet heat sauce. More sweet than heat, but yummy just the same. We will be back. read more

This venue is gorgeous! You have the option to sit outside or inside- it was hot so we decided to sit inside. There was nothing open at the bar so we opted for a high top, our waitress was great we got drinks in and were able to try a beer on tap. Unfortunately they couldn't find the drink menu so that was unfortunate. We ordered the loaded tots with beer cheese, good but could have used more cheese. We got our appetizers in about 10 minutes. Our dinner took about 45-60 minutes to come out- very slow. For dinner I had the French dip I would give that 5/10. I wasn't a fan of the roll, it tasted more like a cheesesteak with French onion soup for the dip. There was too much bread and not enough meat. My boyfriend got grilled chicken with bbq, jalapeños, and paper jack cheese. read more

Bourbon Mill - French Dip - Bars Near Me - New Oxford, Pennsylvania

See all

They have the most unique set up and the food and service are just phenomenal! I honestly can't express how impressed I was with the genuine and friendly atmosphere! We went there to take my mom out for her birthday and we're not disappointed! it was well worth the hour plus drive!! We will definitely be coming back!! read more

Waited twenty minutes, no one ever greeted us. While I understand that times are tough. Someone still could have said someone will be right with you. We came 45 mins out of our way to try this place because we've heard nothing but great reviews. Never again. Won't try a second time. I'll stick locally. read more

I loved this place! We ate outdoors and felt it was great food for a great price. Loved the lights and patio area, and there were outdoor volleyball nets behind the restaurant. We had very friendly service and would definitely come back! read more

First time dining here since Chuck the new owner bought and remodeled the place. First impression was positive walking in seeing a whole new look. High fives on the makeover. It was 4:30 pm, crowd was thin, less than ten with our three. The greeter at the door was not what I would say the beat first impression, you want friendly, outgoing etc. as your first contact, she put me in mind of someone on work release from jail, just happy enough she wasn't still locked up in a cell. Our waitress was top notch though. Super friendly, pretty knowledgeable of the menu. Could not answer basic questions regarding gluten free item though. That is so important in the world of allergies. She told us the french fry fryer was a dedicated fryer for fries, that was a positive, since some folks can get very ill or even die if they get gluten when they can't have it. She got our orders perfect, was prompt, returned several times to check on us. She earned 4.5 stars alone. She is good for the business. The food we orders was very good. The garlic parm wings were very good. Tasty. Our burgers and steaks could have had more seasoning but thats just our preference. Both were excellent as they were though. Portion size was plenty. The only dislike for us besides the greeter was we don't prefer the hi-top tables, they're too small. Next time we choose a booth. No business can please everyone so really Chuck has nothing to worry about provided he can keep good help and continues to offer good quality food like today!! UPDATE: 45 minutes after we had eaten, my wife is violently sick, vomiting, diarrhea etc. I called back to restaurant to verify the info our waitress told us was correct regarding dedicated fryer for fries, only to be told by a manager that was incorrect information, the same oil is used for a variety of items including items with gluten. This is very bad, giving incorrect information can kill some persons with gluten allergies. Fortunately for us, my wife only gets very sick for a few hours. This could be so bad. The staff needs to be trained properly or the menus need to clearly marked it is not a dedicated fryer. Good luck to him and his new business. read more

8 of us had dinner today. It was a full crowd and the atmosphere was friendly. We got there at 5:30. We were not served until 7pm. When our food arrived only 6 of us got our orders, our waitress never put in 2 of our groups order. We also never got drinks refilled. When our 2 friends got their food it was 8pm. The service and food delivery was awful however the food itself was good. Not sure if we will ever return read more

See all

Food is okay, but nothing great, we tried to order the gator bites but our waiter said they have been out of them for months. The one drink we ordered was wrong but they did remake it and comp the first one. The vibe is kind of strange, it feels like a bar trying to be a fancy restaurant. Overall I don't think it would be worth going again read more

Great food (beef tips out if this world). Great prices. Great outdoor seating. Try the gyro, French onion and Reuben too. Fun place. read more

This is one on my go to comfort places yes it is a bar and grill but this place never disappointed. I go mainly for the food and there wings are big and done very well i recommend the sweet chilli or jerk. Food is very delicious the atmosphere is great, place is big with outdoor bar, firepit and more food menu is great drink menu also great the service is great however they do seems to be short staffed from time to time but they make due and still do excellent. Would highly recommend. read more

First time here and so happy I passed and came back to visit. We relaxed under their pavilion and listened to live music as part of the Gettysburg Rocks event to raise money for childhood cancer. We had very friendly and attentive service from Danielle - ask for her!! Fantastic prices, yummy meal and lots of adult beverage options. It was worth the 45 minute drive!! Thanks Danielle! We can't wait to visit and have you assist us again!! read more

Haven't been in years since before new ownership took over and regret trying it again. Food is not good and service was terrible. Wings were overdone and so dry. Also the establishment is not taking COVID serious at all and is not requiring masks or any social distancing. read more

Bourbon Mill - No social distancing, not a single mask in site. - Bars Near Me - New Oxford, Pennsylvania

Food sucks. Staff is weird and oddly uneducated even for new oxford. Definitely not the best Gettysburg area has to offer.

they didnt have rice when i came. i ordered a meal that came with rice. and they told me they didnt have it. im angry because that was clearly stated on the menu and they shouldve told me that before i placed my order. rest of the meal was good though. read more

Terrible food and most of the food at our table came out cold and the waitress acted like it was a hassle to wait on people. No servers wore masks, actually had ketchup bottle, and salt and pepper shakers on the table. Restrooms were filthy. Bad experience all around would not go back. Better yet they have a pavilion below the restaurant and they were having a private event there, the one and only waitress to wait on the party of approximately 30 people literally walked and carried food, buckets of beer, etc., from the main restaurant/bar down to the pavilion. Owner should be ashamed of himself to actually think this is okay to conduct business in this manner. read more

Chicken wings are out of this world and their French onion soup as well. The waitresses are very nice and friendly. You'll enjoy this place

Decided to have dinner here because my husband won a gift card. We waited an hour for food and when it finally came, it was cold! Definitely will not be returning read more

We stopped in Friday January 31 about 6:30. The place was packed. We were told it was a 45 to 50 minute wait so we decided to stay and were lucky enough to snag some seats at the bar. It took about 15 minutes for someone to acknowledge us. He got us our drinks some menus and that was the last anyone acknowledge us. The couple aside of us told us it took an hour to get a soup and a salad. Another couple told us they had been waiting 45 minutes and still haven't gotten their food. Shortly after that the waitress came over and told him they were out of the item he ordered and asked him to order something else which they were also out of. Still no one even took our order. We decided to leave but it took me another 10 minutes just to waive down a bartender to pay. The place inside was well done but they were way under staffed. We will go back, I am leaving this review letting them know every one at the bar was upset because the staff was overwhelmed. We expected to at least have someone take our food order. We really want to try the food. read more

I called this place cause a good friend said they had the best wings...called once, and got their answering machine, recording said if you want to place an order, call back... called three times! Three strikes you're out!!! read more

This is a go-to spot for drinking, the bar has an extensive display of alcohol and the beer selection is good and very reasonably priced. But as far as the food goes, there's room for vast improvement. Stopped by late afternoon for an early dinner as Gettysburg was just bustling and we knew that the restaurants would be busy. Our mistake. I ordered a day's special-brisket Mac and cheese, a bargain for $8.00. You truly do get what you pay for, and what I got was a plate of Kraft mac and cheese( you instantly recognize that tube shaped pasta) hidden under shredded, tasteless beef of some sort with some streaks of barbecue sauce on top for a lovely presentation. I know that I didn't order from the kiddie menu! I was literally dumbfounded that a restaurant would put this on their menu as an entree. It was beyond awful. My friend's brisket sandwich was lackluster as well, served with a sad looking pickle and generic potato chips. But, our server was very nice. Won't be back to this establishment, at least not for the food as there are many other restaurants along this stretch of route 30 with much better grub. read more

No type of social distancing whatsoever! Went here for food with the wife and i was in shock due to the fact people were crowded with no face mask around read more