I wrote a review before but want to make a new one not about the food but about the owner…read more I lost my mom 4 years ago today and went to honor her and Teddy the owner made me feel better God bless him

Ive been going to this place since I was a kid, the food is great, and honestly the owner really…read moreknows every customer and remembers what goes on in life, truly an amazing place. The mood welcomes all. Highly recommend.

my friend recommended me this pizza place and it was SO AMAZING. I came to NJ wanting to have a…read moredelicious pizza after my 10 travel day and this really hit the spot. The notes of the pizza were unmatchable, first the ricotta cheese on top with the honey melted over the pepperoni, I wish I live around the corner because this was just specular. We also ordered this for pickup was very timely and the staff was super sweet including the owner. Inside is pretty big considering the area but didn't stay in there too long so couldn't say much about that :/. Overall YOU HAVE TO GO

Molly is excellent in the front of house. My son loves to visit her while we pick up our pizza. I…read morealways have excellent service and food. I wish they didn't use third party delivery drivers but besides that everything else is always excellent.

The spaghetti and chicken parm. was great tasting just like I thought nice job. The place is always…read morebusy so that is a good sign that the food is good will be back again.

Been a fan of Plaza Pizza for decades . They were the go to…read moreplace for the football. Well.... We were very disappointed Believe they changed the dough, because the crust was not what we were used too. We order a pie with sausage onion and extra cheese. Think they forgot to add the extra cheese. The pie just seems dried out. Hope they go back to the old dough Or will need to find another pizzeria

Just ok pizza. Oldscool pizzaria/cafeteria vibe inside. The pie was not cut all the way through so…read moreI had to do it myself. It really could have been baked and extra minute or two to make the crust less chewy and rubbery. 3/5 for the cheap price and speed which makes it a good alternative to some of the fast-food options around here. No garlic knots is disappointing though. Looks like they have a few pies to choose from so maybe those are better then the standard. Service charge if you plan on using your credit card.

Hands down, best pizza in town! The staff is nice and friendly. Your typical pizzeria style…read moreseating. Another must-have is the cheesy garlic bread and the chicken parm hero.

Would make it zero stars if possible can't so it's a 1 star. But horrible service . came in with…read morefamily , my wife while placing order was being corrected by some other guy behind the counter on what she was saying . "Gyro" is what she said . guy was saying something nowhere near that. Then after placing order we proceeded to take our seats. 25 minutes roll by and nothing . One of the girls from behind the counter came by after dropping someone's order off who was there way after us and asks us was everything ok? we told her the length of time we were waiting and she wrote down our order to see what happened. she excuses herself and comes back a few minutes later with our stuff . While we're preparing to eat our order , the original order taker comes to the table and says verbatim " you guys cannot drink your drink here . " 2L Diet Coke" and he walks away. We were confused as to why he said that as it is something we purchased at their establishment. Luckily we also had a few canned sodas which were also the wrong type when we initially placed the order. my wife goes ahead and takes one of the sodas and asks to switch it for the correct one. The girl who helped us was going to give us cups but the guy was right next to her so my wife told her no as to not get her in trouble. Food arrived cold and wrong. Gyro was supposed to be a chicken one. ended up with the lamb. Short to say this will be the last time we come to this place . Came with my family because of convenience but left with pure disappointment and dissatisfaction. and for those wondering the order was as follow. Large Pie with wings and 2L Diet Coke Philly Cheesesteak w/ fries (was DRY) Chicken Gyro w/fries (got lamb instead) 2 cans of soda (diet) ended with regular Pepsi and gingerale Just horrible

My local pizza place…read more I would give 3.5 but dint have the option The people are very friendly and the service is always good I love the Sicilian slice but the regular is ok not the best but not bad I go when u work late

I recently visited Pizza Amore Italian Kitchen in Carlstadt after searching for a great meatball…read moresandwich, and they did not disappoint! The owner was welcoming, professional, and kind. As an African American customer, I felt completely comfortable--this gentleman was courteous and respectful the whole way through. And the sandwich? Easily one of the best meatball subs I've had! Don't let other reviews dissuade you--this place deserves a visit for its quality food and great service. And trust me I'm a real person. I never been to this establishment before in my life, but I will be back when I'm in the area. Thanks for the chat!!!

I finally made it here. I came here for one reason and my review is based on that reason…read more This is a small, no-frills establishment. There is street parking available. We ordered via telephone and picked our items up and brought them home. The main event was the meatball parm sandwich. The best meatball parm sandwich I have had. Meatballs were fresh and perfectly seasoned. Not the usual "hard meatballs" you get from a pizza place. Sauce was plentiful and had a great kick to it. Add to it the perfect sound of mozzarella and a sprinkle of parmesan. Absolutely out of this world. The bread, which can ruin a great sandwich, was equally as good. Perfect crisp to the Italian bread. And yes, it was consistent. We ordered 3 meatball sandwiches and 1 sausage sandwich and EVERYONE commented on the bread as well. We also got a Brooklyn Pie. The pie wasn't my speed. A little doughy but I would like to try a traditional round. Again, not my style and we went solely for the meatballs but grabbed a pie as an extra. If you're in the area, you have to try it. If you're an hour away, you still have to try it.

I've been here so many times and they never disappoint! I absolutely LOVE LOVE their fresh…read moremozzarella and everything here. Today I went to their gelateria, they give you a little spoon if you want to try a flavor. I got the Croccantino almond brittle and my son got the tiramisu and it was sooo good super creamy and delicious! We loved it

Found this place through social media. Drive to get there was 45min. The videos from social media…read moreshowed it was a restaurant, casual but classy with a deli next door. It's basically an extension of the deli, not an actual restaurant feel at all. Our table was so close to the soda fridge that we couldn't move the chair back if we didn't want to break the door. Anytime a customer came to get a drink, we had to move so they could open the fridge door. The service was very good. Friendly young man. The food was good but a little pricey for the amount we received. We ordered an appetizer and bread bowl of pasta with bolognese. Their fresh mozzarella is very good. The bread bowl itself was not flavorful at all. We ended up throwing that part out. The sauce was good though. The other bread bowl we got was filled with pasta done in their Parmesan wheel. It was meh. Very dry. Needed more garlic or something for some oomph! The rainbow cookies were good but didn't seem any different than other places I have had them at, just pricier. Overall, it was ok but we wouldn't go back again.

Solid pizza joint Great calamari price and portion!…read moreWings are good. They have good holiday specials like with the super bowl. Etc Would try this out again .

I love this place. Its got the biggest slices! They even have some lunch specials for kids. The…read moreprices are affordable. You can add a topping to the cheese pizzas too. The service is quick. They have a sit down area and its frequented by the locals. Love coming here when I'm in the area.