Brooklyn Delights

4.3 (27 reviews)

Bakeries

Closed • 9:00 am - 3:30 pm

Add Review

Call

Directions

Brooklyn Delights Photos

Brooklyn Delights - a box of chocolate drizzle crumb cakes - Bakeries Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

Brooklyn Delights - two pieces of dessert on a wooden table - Bakeries Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

Brooklyn Delights - a box of assorted cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

+49

Brooklyn Delights - a box of thin chocolate chip cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Brooklyn Delights

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.

Start your review...

Browse more easily on the app

Reviews With Photos

Kenneth B.

I had a tasted for a good black and white cookie. Nothing notable in the part of Florida where I live, so when I ran across the ad for Brooklyn Delights I had to give them a try. I was worried about shipping from NY to FL, but their packaging ensured safe arrival. Sturdy boxes, cool packs, lots of bubble wrap. I decided to opt for the cheapest shipping, which took about 4 days to get here. But, upon arrival these hefty delicious cookies were in perfect condition, and were the best I have had. They have several other bakery products which I fully intend to try out in the near future. Highly recommended.

See all

Kristy R.

Elite 26

489

2127

246

7 months ago

We recently came here for a Too Good To Go pickup. Inside is a small but sizeable warehouse full of delicious treats. A ton of women appear to work there which hell yes. Pickup was fast, especially since they don't have a true parking lot. This is definitely not a bakery setting. You go in, you receive a box of goodies to take home with you. The rainbow cookies are great! Very light but tasty! The black & white cookies are just as good and freshly made. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Terese C.

0

5

2

5 months ago

I've been buying the Italian Chocolate Chip cookies at Stop & Shop for over a year and recently the quality has gone way down. Some cookies have very few chocolate chips and others look not baked well and are very light in color. The taste is a little off too. Very disappointed as these cookies were a favorite. read more

Brooklyn Delights - Bakeries Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

Helpful 0

Thanks 1

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Janet S.

0

1

0

6 months ago

My son is deployed and he requested I mail him black and white cookies in the next care package. I googled best NY black and white cookies and Brooklyn Delights came up. Not only were they so helpful, bubble wrapped the cookies and supplied me with a mailing box they would not take $ for the cookies. It's good to know there are kind and caring people in the world. Thank you to the owner Frank and the staff at Brooklyn Delights! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Alan Z.

9

170

4

2 years ago

Brooklyn Delights sells Good memories from home now that we live where decent baked good can not be found

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Bonnie G.

Elite 26

1476

1326

4391

4 years ago

I received a beautiful box of black and white cookies as a Mother's Day gift from my family back in Brooklyn. Now, I can't comment about their experience regarding placing an order, etc.....I can only tell my side. The black and white cookies I received were packed in two so it was really easy to share if I wanted to- not saying I did...but it's possible. There was a handwritten note with the cookies in a beautiful wood box. The cookies were delicious and really brought me back to Brooklyn every time I ate them. I peeked at their website and they have a nice variety of baked goods! Big thanks to Brooklyn Delights for shipping a little piece of home to this SoCal resident! read more

Helpful 12

Thanks 0

Love this 9

Oh no 0

Valerie P.

0

1

0

1 year ago

I had a problem with the cake that I bought in the supermarket, and when I called the store, I spoke with Frankie. He apologized profusely and asked my address, and because we were so close he had a package of goodies sent to my house as a measure of Goodwill. I was very impressed!! This man really knows how to run a business! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Nina L.

0

1

0

1 year ago

I got their blueberry muffins as part of my shop at home order from Shop Rite. These were awful. They had an odd taste and dense texture. There were only a few blueberries in the whole muffin and they were hard as a rocks .Took a couple of bites and tossed the whole box read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kenneth B.

Elite 19

1493

170

462

6 years ago

I had a tasted for a good black and white cookie. Nothing notable in the part of Florida where I live, so when I ran across the ad for Brooklyn Delights I had to give them a try. I was worried about shipping from NY to FL, but their packaging ensured safe arrival. Sturdy boxes, cool packs, lots of bubble wrap. I decided to opt for the cheapest shipping, which took about 4 days to get here. But, upon arrival these hefty delicious cookies were in perfect condition, and were the best I have had. They have several other bakery products which I fully intend to try out in the near future. Highly recommended. read more

Brooklyn Delights - Their 4 oz Black and White Cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

Helpful 26

Thanks 0

Love this 22

Oh no 0

Christine P.

0

18

4

4 years ago

If I could give 15 stars I would!!! My daughters 11th birthday is in a few days and when I asked her what kind of cake she wanted, she told me "I don't want a cake, I want rainbow cookies." Specifically, Brooklyn Delights rainbow cookies. We live in Missouri but I am originally from Long Island. I was there a little over a year ago for my Godmothers funeral and when getting Italian treats to take home for my girls, my cousin brought me to Brooklyn Delights. She assured me they were the best, and she was so right. A month or two after that, I ordered black & white cookies and rainbow cookies for Easter and we had some happy kids! For the birthday, I ordered the cookies kind of late- my own fault, I was traveling for work all last week and totally spaced. I messaged the company on Facebook and they told me to call the warehouse when they were open. I called today and explained the situation and they took care of getting them shipped to be here on time AND wished my girl a happy birthday. THANK YOU for saving the day for an almost 11 year old and for having the best Italian treats on the planet!!!! -A Customer for Life Christine Paige read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

C J.

70

205

42

2 years ago

Not Brooklyn Bakery quality in any way. As someone who grew up in Queens and lived in Brooklyn for five years before moving to Long Island I had high hopes for this bakeries products considering there isn't any quality Italian bakeries in my area. My mother-in-law who still lives in Queens actually bragged about how great the Crumb Cake is and the Black & White Cookies as well. I should have known better to purchase any other products after trying these two. So first off, the crumb cake tastes like plastic coated in fake sugar. Was AWFUL!! Now the Black & White Cookies - ever so slightly less gross. With these all you taste is fake sugar - no flavors at all, just sugar. Had a party for my daughter's 17th day last weekend, didn't have the time to bake lots of cookies, so I purchased the Italian Butter Cookies with Chocolate Chips and the Italian Butter Cookies with raspberry jam & dipped in Chocolate. OMG - maybe it's because I'm Sicilian and used to top quality but these are DISGUSTING!! No butter flavor, actually no flavor except sugar and the chocolate had this funky burnt plastic flavor. From now on, if I don't have time to return to the city for authentic Italian Bakery products, I'll have to find the time to make them homemade. This bakery is disgusting and it's embarrassing they try to claim the Brooklyn name considering the mass production factory is in Farmingdale read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 1

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Martin L.

0

5

0

3 years ago

I have been having this bakery ship me some cookies to my home in Tucson Arizona, a long way from Farmingdale Long Island. The food always arrives promptly and delicious. While most of my shopping has been online I've had occasion to deal with then on the phone. The telephone is always promptly answered. The service has b read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Darlene K.

0

1

0

3 years ago

I called with several questions recently and spoke with Frankie. He was extremely helpful and friendly. He answered all of my questions (I had several). lol I ordered the box of mini black and white cookies. I had them sent to my home and they then traveled to Spain with my son as a thank you gift for his host family. My son messaged me that the cookies were a huge hit with the family as well their extended family. They come in a beautiful wooden box. I will definitely be ordering from Brooklyn Delights. Great Product and Customer Service! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 1

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Sun M.

1

67

13

2 years ago

best rainbow cookies i ever had!! will def be trying the other cookies as well! yummmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmy!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Belma F.

0

26

21

6 years ago

My first time ordering online. I was not disappointed. The cookies arrived well packaged and fresh cookies. I got them within 48hours. I am glad I ordered them. read more

Brooklyn Delights - Cookies well packaged - Bakeries Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

Brooklyn Delights - a box of bread buns - Bakeries Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Christine P.

0

1

0

4 years ago

If I could give 15 stars I would!!! My daughters 11th birthday is in a few days and when I asked her what kind of cake she wanted, she told me "I don't want a cake, I want rainbow cookies." Specifically, Brooklyn Delights rainbow cookies. We live in Missouri but I am originally from Long Island. I was there a little over a year ago for my Godmothers funeral and when getting Italian treats to take home for my girls, my cousin brought me to Brooklyn Delights. She assured me they were the best, and she was so right. A month or two after that, I ordered black & white cookies and rainbow cookies for Easter and we had some happy kids! For the birthday, I ordered the cookies kind of late- my own fault, I was traveling for work all last week and totally spaced. I messaged the company on Facebook and they told me to call the warehouse when they were open. I called today and explained the situation and they took care of getting them shipped to be here on time AND wished my girl a happy birthday. THANK YOU for saving the day for an almost 11 year old and for having the best Italian treats on the planet!!!! -A Customer for Life Christine Paige read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Day S.

0

11

4

2 years ago

the best of the best!! rec'd my order today and all was fresh and delicious!! thank you for extra box (6) raspberry linzer cookies. thats very kind n sweet of you! will be back in few weeks to bless my local bank with your goodies. wish i still lived in n.y. i would definetly visit them. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Elizabeth H.

1

34

1

3 years ago

Best black and white cookies anywhere. Convenient walk up window and reasonable prices.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Harlee D.

143

7

2

5 years ago

The best black and white cookies around! Extremely attentive customer service. Very fast shipping- I like to send cases of cookies for gifts.. always packaged well and arrives quick! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

C A.

0

2

1

5 years ago

best Black and White cookies around. Great spot to buy just about anything a deli sells . Muffins are on point also. Staff is great to deal with. Frank thanks for bringing your store to main st . 5 star but would be a 10 read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Lisa G.

58

7

3

5 years ago

They have great snack choices! My favorite is the Linden's cookies or the red air heads. I love this place! The staff are very nice.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Deb S.

0

2

0

6 years ago

Best baked goods in NYS. So tasty and fresh. Absolutely delicious. Highly recommend. The customer service is also amazing. Very good people. Also, nice to be able to support a small business. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

DJ D.

0

8

6

5 years ago

They have a great variety of items to choose from. I have ordered several gift crates as Christmas gifts and got rave reviews from the recipients. This is a great alternative to sending flowers or booze as gifts. This can be enjoyed by all. Customer service is very responsive. I'll be ordering more. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Erika B.

0

1

0

4 years ago

I recently purchased a box of your banana muffins which happen to love. However, yours lack the taste of banana are very sweet and have a spicy taste which is not tasteful - sorry guys better luck next year read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Russell R.

0

4

3

4 years ago

I ordered online. I purchased black and white cookies which were great. I also ordered the regular pound cake and the banana pound cake. Both tasted burnt. Yuck yuck read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Dee L.

1

18

1

6 years ago

Got my shipment of black and whites and corn muffins here in San Francisco. Well packaged and sent out quickly. What a taste of home for this ex- New Yorker. Will definitely be ordering again. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

David B.

0

1

0

5 years ago

I just ordered my forth order only this time I sent my two nieces an assortment box. They loved each cookie as I do! Black and Whites and Linzar Tarts are my favorite, but they are all amazing!!! Thank you BrooklynDelights read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Laura L.

0

1

0

5 years ago

Hello, I've heard so many wonder things about Brooklyn delights. I was just wondering if you made anything gluten free?

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

More info about Brooklyn Delights

1 Frank Ave
Farmingdale, NY 11735
Directions
(516) 586-8007
Call Now

Full menu

Hours

What time does Brooklyn Delights open?

Brooklyn Delights opens at 9:00 AM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday and Friday.

What time does Brooklyn Delights close?

Brooklyn Delights closes at 3:30 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday and Friday.Brooklyn Delights is closed on Saturday and Sunday.

Mon-Fri 9:00 AM - 3:30 PMSat-Sun Closed

Payment methods

Does Brooklyn Delights take credit cards?

Yes, Brooklyn Delights takes credit cards.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Brooklyn Delights have parking?

Yes, Brooklyn Delights has parking options.

From the Business

Specialties

Pound Cakes, Turnovers, Linzer Tarts, Black and White Cookies, Cinnamon Rolls, Muffins, Palmers, Rainbow Squares, Italian Chocolate Sprinkle Cookies, Chocolate Chip Cookies, & MORE!!

Review Highlights - Brooklyn Delights

“best rainbow cookies i ever had!!”

Mentioned in 4 reviews

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Bakeries 7,374 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Explore benefits

Dortoni Bakery

3.8(775 reviews)

4.1 mi

•$$

We got married last year and we are STILL getting compliments from our guests about how amazing our…read morewedding cake was, and rightfully so!! We did a complimentary tasting with Pedro to decide what flavors would best represent us in cake form and it was such a cute experience. We decided on a quilted 4 tier cake with white buttercream filled with vanilla mousse and dulce de leche. The flavors were absolutely perfect and the cake was so visually appealing. I'm drooling just thinking about it lol. Thank you for creating such an unforgettably delicious and truly beautiful cake for our winter wonderland wedding!

Unfortunately, the visit did not meet the level of cleanliness, professionalism, and personal…read moreattention that we are looking for as we were making a decision for my daughter's wedding. When we arrived, we noticed flies inside the bakery, as well as a spill on the floor. We were then asked to sit directly in front of the area where the spill was located, which was uncomfortable given the circumstances. In addition, our interaction with a staff mmbr felt very rushed. She spoke extremely quickly, and the presentation came across as somewhat rehearsed and impersonal. We understand that she may have been trying to efficiently walk us through the process, but we were hoping for more of a personal consultation and a genuine sense of care and enthusiasm for such an important part of the wedding. The place needs an all around makeover. Btw, The cake was plain and the frosting was nothing to brag about.

Photos

Entrance to Dortoni Bakery

Best black and white cookies and cakes.

See all

Elise’s Niece’s Cafe

4.8(57 reviews)

0.8 mi

•$$

very friendly staff and delicious baked goods with a nice variety. Very good cappuccino and lattes.read more

What an amazing cozy space for family and to shop or just sit quietly to have a cocktail or coffee!…read moreNicest people there are and the baked goods were delicious

Photos

A super cute and cozy cafe

See all

Super cute.

Merritt Bakery

4.6(49 reviews)

1.1 mi

•$$

Merrit Bakery delivered a wonderful display for my niece's engagement party!…read moreAll the guests loved it! I recommend this bakery!!

I have got a few items from Merritt Bakery and they all have been delicious…read more Some of our favorites to order are the: Italian and Irish apple cake and Italian cookies. This is a small and quaint bakery so it is a take out place just FYI. They have long hours usually 6:30 AM to 7pm on weekdays. If you are looking for something in particular, I would definitely call ahead! One time I wanted a cheesecake and I was able to place an order ahead of time so it would be ready! A perk here is you can order for delivery if you do not live locally! Check out their website!

Photos

Cheesecake and cake (cookies are homemade)

Easter Bread

See all

Cupcakes

Moscato Bakery and Cafe

3.9(54 reviews)

2.9 mi

When you walk in It's as if you go vacknin time to the 1960s when Sal one of the owners and the…read morebaker was a young boy learning the trade. Everyone is treated like a longtime friend. The counter staff is generally cheerful, kind and helpful. The decor is as it was in the 1960s. Everything displayed fresh and in cases. A couple of tables to sit and wait or enjoy a yummy bakery item while waiting for the train. Most people order and go. The service is fast and friendly and the bakery items are delicious!!!

First time trying this bakery, we got a cannoli and a black and white cookie and they were both…read moredelicious but definitely smelled good like a bakery and clean. Service is was quick. Prices were good.

Photos

See all

Uncle Joey's Rainbow Explosion

4.6(61 reviews)

0.8 mi

•$$

Rainbow cookies are outrageous. The chocolate covered rainbow donut hits just right.read more

I was nervous about my visit to Uncle Joey's because the hype is so strong, and I figured there was…read moreno way it would live up to my expectations. Somehow, it still managed to exceed them. First and foremost, these were hands-down the best rainbow cookies I've ever eaten. Such a decadent chocolate layer, a generous amount of jam, and a perfect flavor to every element of the cookie. Rainbow cookies are my favorite cookies, and I've never had anything close to as good as these. Then, there's all the other rainbow inspired items that I couldn't resist. The cheesecake square is SO rich and decadent, but a must-buy - just don't try to eat it all in one sitting. The rainbow crumb is phenomenal as well, and the jelly layer at the bottom really hits the spot. The rainbow stuffed brownie was incredibly rich and fudge, the chocolate chip cookie was excellent, and the rainbow black and white is up there for one of my favorite items from the day! The chocolate covered donut was also incredible. I'm glad that I don't live too close, or I'd put on so much weight, but that I live close enough that I can stop by on occasion for some delicious treats.

Photos

See all

Outside

D & D Bake Shoppe

3.2(38 reviews)

0.4 mi

•$$

I used to go there especially christmas. This year is total disappointment!!!! The Apple turnover…read morewas Not flakey pastry like it should be. It was like a cookie dough. The Italian clamshell were awful - hardly any filling and hard. The lemon cookies were absolutely terrible - they had a foul taste. The butter had no butter flavor. The biscotti with the cherries were not red but a purple color ???? I will not be going there ever again.

Very authentic and high class designed Tres Leches! I come from a Puerto Rican and Dominican…read morebackground and was looking for something for a celebration with my family. This did just the trick. And as someone just stopping by Long Island for the first time, this place left an AMAZING first impression. Support your local businesses !!!

Photos

Specialty desserts - bread pudding $2/pc

Cookies - $16/lb

See all

Cookies $16/lb

The French Workshop

3.6(92 reviews)

3.9 mi

•$$

Very cute, bright and sophisticated French bakery that operates more like a cafe. I don't expect…read moreplaces like this in my hometown, so I was happy surprised when I was looking for a place to meet a colleague that was close to my father's house. And they have a few vegan options! Don't expect macarons nor tarts, but that blueberry croissant I had was so delicious. It was more of a whole grain pastry than a traditional buttery croissant but because the blueberry filling was so sweet, I was happy for a less decadent pastry. I love that they have a nice array of coffee and matcha drinks too. I'm pretty sure the word has been out for some time now, but when that Starbucks line in the parking lot is just too much, The French Workshop is a better option (however, on a rainy Saturday in May, that line inside was considerable. People know what's good!) There's plenty of seating, too and if you are good at pretending, you almost feel you're in Europe (ignore the suburban strip mall that surrounds you).

I was just there today with a friend for coffee at 530pm. By 723pm a girl walks in with a big…read morebull dog, she plants her dog with its duty hole and balls resting on the seat to us was utterly disgusting. Children and other customers sit in these seats. How is it that management says nothing?? When are we going to stop praising the dog as the go anywhere animal and allow others separation and peace? Something should have been done. I didnt appreciate it. The Review Guru* Long Island NY

Photos

Croissant with Pistachio Cream

Outside tables

See all

Espresso bar area

Francesco's Bakery

3.2(247 reviews)

4.3 mi

•$$

I wanted so much to like Francesco's. It was our first time visiting and the bakery held an old…read moreschool charm, but after trying a variety of items, a 2.5 seems most fitting. The displays were filled with a nice variety of butter cookies, cakes, doughnuts and other classic pastries. Everything "looked" good, but the taste was just average. I would have pushed it to a 3 star review, but the young man behind the counter wasn't very friendly. The store was as empty when we went in so it wasn't like he was busy trying to take orders quickly. We told the young man that we would be ordering a variety of butter cookies and he looked at us annoyed and continued to serve us with a similar attitude. I guess maybe this is the expected service from the generation nowadays? I just expected more from a place that appeared so charming. The rainbow cookies seem to have anise in it, which is a bit odd for a rainbow cookies, and the chocolate coating was not very cocoa forward. It was also lacking jam. We were also really excited about the chocolate sandwiched butter cookies, but while the cookie itself was fresh, the ganache was missing the rich chocolatey flavor. Instead, it almost tasted like carob or some sort of diluted chocolate instead. The cookies itself were also not buttery enough, though they did taste freshly baked. All in all, Francesco isn't something to write home about and it's not a place I'd visit again.

I was getting my car serviced at Honda & looking for a coffee place. I needed a place I could walk…read moreto. This place was very close. I got a pistachio latte and a biscotti. It was only a bit more than $5. Very reasonable and really good. The young man that helped me was very pleasant. There was seating inside and out. Very nice experience. This will be my spot when I have to deal with Honda repairs in the future

Photos

$2.95 jelly donut. Soo much jelly!

Cake Tasting

See all

Butter cookies $17.99/lb as ofOct 16, 2022! Donuts are $2.95/ea.

Sweet Surrender Bake House

4.2(203 reviews)

3.2 mi

•$$

They have my favorite cake the candy bar cake. But times are hard bc they keep getting less and…read moreless on it over the years. I hope people continue to support small businesses so they don't close down one day. Great cakes

Had the red velvet cake for my birthday! Absolutely delicious. Moist cake and amazing cream cheese…read morefrosting. I will always recommend this place as everything I've ever tried has been fresh and tasty.

Photos

Strawberry Shortcake

Rainbow Cannoli Crumb Cake

See all

Brooklyn Delights - bakeries - Updated September 2026

Best of Farmingdale

Things to do in Farmingdale

People found Brooklyn Delights by searching for…

People who viewed Brooklyn Delights also viewed

Batter Up Bakery

4.3

(92 reviews)

My sister in law ordered a birthday cake for her dad. The strawberry shortcake was very good. Cake…read morewas moist and whipped vanilla frosting. We would check this bakery out.

I'm a Long Island bakery snob - the cakes and cookies here are great, not the absolute best I've…read moreever had, but would definitely come back if I was in the area again! Pastries are also good, I'd probably heat up some of them at home for flakier crusts! Displays were beautiful, clean and filled with the usual favorites! Staff is a little quiet / introverted but overall kind, which is all that matters! The flavors are on point for sure! Would've taken more photos but my family ate everything too fast and this was all I was able to get lol

Uncle Joey's Rainbow Explosion

4.6

(61 reviews)

•$$

Rainbow cookies are outrageous. The chocolate covered rainbow donut hits just right.read more

I was nervous about my visit to Uncle Joey's because the hype is so strong, and I figured there was…read moreno way it would live up to my expectations. Somehow, it still managed to exceed them. First and foremost, these were hands-down the best rainbow cookies I've ever eaten. Such a decadent chocolate layer, a generous amount of jam, and a perfect flavor to every element of the cookie. Rainbow cookies are my favorite cookies, and I've never had anything close to as good as these. Then, there's all the other rainbow inspired items that I couldn't resist. The cheesecake square is SO rich and decadent, but a must-buy - just don't try to eat it all in one sitting. The rainbow crumb is phenomenal as well, and the jelly layer at the bottom really hits the spot. The rainbow stuffed brownie was incredibly rich and fudge, the chocolate chip cookie was excellent, and the rainbow black and white is up there for one of my favorite items from the day! The chocolate covered donut was also incredible. I'm glad that I don't live too close, or I'd put on so much weight, but that I live close enough that I can stop by on occasion for some delicious treats.

Mama's Custom Cookies

5.0

(24 reviews)

•$$

AMAZING cookies! I asked for new house themed cookies for a friend and they went beyond…read moreexpectations. Cookies were very good size, more bigger than expected which was fantastic, and they made them so fast. Within 3 days after payment. I really would recommend anyone who is interested in buying. The packaging for the cookies was even so professional and secure. I am definitely gonna be ordering from here again.

Ordered 50, very fancy/detailed cookies for a bridal shower and cannot say enough positive things…read moreabout our communication, interaction, the quality of the end product and the taste of the cookie. Each one was perfection from icing to wrapping to ribbon. Bonus was that they were delicious !! Thank you co much.. No pictures because ALL the cookies were snatched up before I could get one.

Sweet Surrender Bake House

4.2

(203 reviews)

•$$

They have my favorite cake the candy bar cake. But times are hard bc they keep getting less and…read moreless on it over the years. I hope people continue to support small businesses so they don't close down one day. Great cakes

Had the red velvet cake for my birthday! Absolutely delicious. Moist cake and amazing cream cheese…read morefrosting. I will always recommend this place as everything I've ever tried has been fresh and tasty.

Capri Bakery

3.9

(86 reviews)

•$$

We go on great Italian bakery hunts whenever we go into NY. We visited a bakery earlier in the day…read morethat will remained nameless here, and had disappointing pastries. Our main goal is always to find a fabulous cannoli- they failed- but Capri did not. Capri had delicious cannolis! We bought two big boxes of cannolis and ate them for three days after we drove back to our home state. We also bought a box of an assortment of pastries and cookies. They tasted good every day. We would definitely return. We didn't give 5 starts because the bakery itself lacks a little quaintness and magic. It's a bit generic and bland and could use some refreshing and imagination.

Asked for specific cake decorations for a 60th birthday. Picked the cake up and the cake was…read morenothing at all what was ordered. The baker tried to convince me the cake looked better the way he made it. After I said no he tried to fix the cake. It still looked nothing like what I ordered; very sloppy! He still had to get his last word in how it looked better the other way after me paying for a cake that was amateurish and subpar in taste. Will never use this bakery again

Smallcakes - Syosset

4.4

(89 reviews)

This is one of my favorite dessert spots in Syosset…read more Pros: + Amazing cupcake flavors - the peanut butter cup by far is my favorite + Cupcake smash is my go to by far + Great selection of baseline flavors + Rotating daily flavors too! I love that there are several seasonal ones + Friendly staff - generous portions Cons: - Limited seating inside IG: QueenOfAdventureNYC

I love these cupcakes so much that I chose them for my birthday celebration this year. We don't…read morelive near here, but we happened to be celebrating with family on L.I. this year, and this is what I chose. Specifically, I ate 1/2 of the hot fudge sundae cupcake that I shared with my grandson, and I also had 1/2 of the peanut butter chocolate. Two excellent flavors. So much flavor and so incredibly fresh and moist. LOVE THIS PLACE !!

Sweet Karma Desserts

4.3

(176 reviews)

•$$

I cannot say enough about how impressed I was with this bakery! From the knowledable staff to the…read morequick responses to all of my questions and their patience, they created the perfect cake for my baby's first birthday. I will be back over and over again. Not only was the cake magnificently beautiful, it was also delicious. I was able to get two different flavors for the tiers as well. One flavor was chocolate with salted caramel and the other was vanilla with chocolate mousse. My guests kept coming back for more. The cake shop is small and located in a shopping center 5 minutes from my house. It's decorated with their beautiful cakes and they sell some desserts as well as create custom. When I picked up the cake, they even went out of their way to teach me how to properly transport it as well as cut it. I will be running back

I ordered a Too Good to Go bag from Seert Karma the other week, and was happy with the variety of…read moreitems my family was able to try. When entering the bakery, you get to see all of the decorated cakes on the counters and shelves. These were pretty cool to see up close. When waiting for the bag, the owner came. He was really nice and seemed genuinely excited about the items in his shop. The desserts we tried were great. The doughnuts and cookies were soft, the cake pops were tasty, and the rainbow cookie croissant was an extra bonus!

Trace of Sweetness

4.8

(6 reviews)

Trace of Sweetness has delicious baked treats and confections. I love ordering as Tracy is very…read moresweet herself and a joy to deal with. It's encouraging that besides being a baker, she's also a licensed nutritionist. Having discussed the ingredients she uses in detail, I've been impressed that she uses the healthiest, freshest ingredients. Among my favorites include her pink sandwich cookies which are bursting with flavorful jam fillings; her fun-sized mini muffins which are fruity and yummy; and her tasty and subtly buttery little sprinkle cookies. You can taste the love and joy she works into all her creations. You won't be disappointed.

Amazing cookies amazing even had sugar free tracy is nothing but a amazing pastry and cookie chef…read morekeep up the good work Tracy !! We will order again !!!!!

ZuckerBaker's Bake Shop

4.1

(39 reviews)

•$$$

We travel from Flushing when we can & load up on goodies, especially the Challah, pastries &…read moreHamantaschen! :)

Best vegan cookies on Long Island. I bought a handful of each kind and left with a pound. Some with…read morefruit fillings, some chocolate chips and cinnamon sugar cookies that were awesome with coffee. I was so surprised at how delicious they were. It brought back memories of growing up in Queens and having bakery every weekend that my Dad picked up. I was so sad when I looked in the bag and found none left. Great stuff. Looking forward to trying their vegan Napoleon pastries next time they make some. Yum!

Senora Pastries

5.0

(10 reviews)

I have to say, my husband and I were so pleasantly surprised by the flakey crust and unbelievable…read moreamount of berries packed into this pie. I NEVER eat the crust in anything, not even pizza, and this crust was so buttery and delicious, i was amazed. This business gets 4 hats from us. Betty Courtenay

Everything is baked with such love and care . Only healthy ingredients. No additives simply…read moreoutrageous. She also makes gift baskets, platters, and holiday orders that can be picked up or delivered. How awesome is that

Brooklyn Delights

Brooklyn Delights Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Brooklyn Delights

Reviews With Photos

More info about Brooklyn Delights

Payment methods

Outdoor Amenities

Ask the Community - Brooklyn Delights

Review Highlights - Brooklyn Delights

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

Dortoni Bakery

Elise’s Niece’s Cafe

Merritt Bakery

Moscato Bakery and Cafe

Uncle Joey's Rainbow Explosion

D & D Bake Shoppe

The French Workshop

Francesco's Bakery

Sweet Surrender Bake House

Brooklyn Delights - bakeries - Updated September 2026

Best of Farmingdale

People found Brooklyn Delights by searching for…

Trending Searches in Farmingdale, NY

Browse Articles

Browse Nearby

Browse Brands

Related Searches in Farmingdale, NY

People who viewed Brooklyn Delights also viewed

Batter Up Bakery

Uncle Joey's Rainbow Explosion

Mama's Custom Cookies

Sweet Surrender Bake House

Capri Bakery

Smallcakes - Syosset

Sweet Karma Desserts

Trace of Sweetness

ZuckerBaker's Bake Shop

Senora Pastries

Brooklyn Delights

Brooklyn Delights Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Brooklyn Delights

Reviews With Photos

More info about Brooklyn Delights

Payment methods

Outdoor Amenities

Ask the Community - Brooklyn Delights

Review Highlights - Brooklyn Delights

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

More businesses like Brooklyn Delights

Dortoni Bakery

Elise’s Niece’s Cafe

Merritt Bakery

Moscato Bakery and Cafe

Uncle Joey's Rainbow Explosion

D & D Bake Shoppe

The French Workshop

Francesco's Bakery

Sweet Surrender Bake House

Brooklyn Delights - bakeries - Updated September 2026

Best of Farmingdale

People found Brooklyn Delights by searching for…

Trending Searches in Farmingdale, NY

Browse Articles

Browse Nearby

Browse Brands

Related Searches in Farmingdale, NY

People who viewed Brooklyn Delights also viewed

Batter Up Bakery

Uncle Joey's Rainbow Explosion

Mama's Custom Cookies

Sweet Surrender Bake House

Capri Bakery

Smallcakes - Syosset

Sweet Karma Desserts

Trace of Sweetness

ZuckerBaker's Bake Shop

Senora Pastries