Twenty visits ago I thought - oh, just another pizza place in a shopping center. Yup, I was wrong - BJ's puts out a really good pie, especially their white pizza. Still taste the garlic from some I ate a couple hours ago. But the thing that pegged my wow factor was their spinach salad. I get one every time. Best darn one I've tasted in a long time. Usually get take out but when we've eaten in service has been pretty good. Try it, you'll like it. read more

Love this place. I work around the corner and we have lunch here. The food is fantastic. The service is great. Clean, great atmosphere. Price affordable. PLUS they deliver. They have a waitress I can't remember her name. But she excellent. Ms. Deb and I love her. read more

Expat New Yorker here. The pizza at Brooklyn Joe's is legit! I am very happy to have found this place so close to my (new) home. Their subs and pasta dishes are also very good, and it's a great spot to bring the kids and not spend an arm and a leg. Service is also excellent. read more

Hate writing this, but it appears they can't handle a heavy rush of take-out orders. We've been weekly regulars since they opened, so we know what the norm is, but carryout has been a nightmare. They've been rude, dismissive, and taken far longer than quoted. And they don't have a mask policy, which is their right obviously, but with half the folks we saw coming in with masks and half without, the whole experience isn't worth the aggravation or potential exposure. read more

This is a nice place for the lunch menu. The music is set to an oldies station and provides a different atmosphere for a pizza joint. The TV's were set to FoxNews,CNN HLN, and ESPN so there's something for almost any news fan out there. The Ziti Tarangelo is a great lunch choice, pasta, olives, sun dried tomatoes, feta cheese and olive oil. Full of flavor and very tasty. Service is about on par with what you would expect at a fast food place like a TGI Friday's or Chili's. read more

This was my favorite pizza in Milton/Alpharetta until I tried Mama's last week, but I'll still order from Brooklyn Joe's for their food or if I need to have pizza delivered. It is NY style pizza, but something's missing in the crust, it's still pretty good though and I've found it's better if you order it well done. Their Sicilian pizza is pretty good, the taste is right but the crust is thinner than what I'm used to. I guess that makes it reduced calorie, so that's a positive ;) Everything else I've tried has been very good, the only thing I wasn't impressed with were the mozzarella sticks. They tasted fine, they're a pretty standard frozen appetizer, I guess I was just expecting a few more of them for the price especially when everything else on the menu is such a good size for a small price. The Greek salad is HUGE and loaded with toppings, and they don't skimp on the calamata olives - I hate it when I get a huge salad with 3 little olives! The fried zuchini and fried calimari apps are also pretty big and not very expensive. I've also had the chicken parm sub, the stromboli, the calzone, and chicken wings and they've all been good. BTW their delivery is pretty quick, I'm sure it's because I live 5 mins away, but they usually say 45+ mins and they show up in less than 30. read more

This place really needs to step up. You have a great opportunity to be number one in the area. Every time we call to get a delivery .4 miles away it's always ummmmmm an hour to hour and a half. They literally try to talk you out of a delivery with these off the cuff delivery times. It doesn't matter what day or what time of day. You should just stop delivery all together that way there isn't any expectations of a local dinner coming to the door. Instead we're having to call a chain restaurant. Sincerely That guy read more

I am basing my review of 5 stars on only two things: service & Tomato Basil Soup. I know, I'll definitely have to go again so that I can make a more well rounded opinion but to me the Tomato Basil was great and an unexpected surprise to find it at a pizza place. The waiter was also very courteous and kept my drink filled which is always nice, especially since sometimes when you dine alone it seems as though the table gets neglected (which I'm sure is because it's not as big of a tip). So so far so good! read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Yumm - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

Having the name Brooklyn Joe's I would've hoped the pizza would have been reminiscent to pizza in New York/New Jersey. Unfortunately I was disappointed. The pizza was nothing like Brooklyn pizza read more

Great Stromboli's, pizza, pasta and salads are always good. Staff usually very good.

Friends told us about this place last night so we decided to give it a try. All I can say is WOW. Steve got the baked zits and I got the chicken Marsala. Both were delicious. The wait staff was very friendly and the general manager even came over to see how it was. Our waitress was a smiling, friendly Lisa. We will definitely come back. Their menu has a wide variety so I'll want to try other items. read more

There's not a better pizza joint around. Coming from the north, it's hard to find quality pie. When we found Brooklyn Joe's, we knew we hit the jackpot. The pizza is identical to what you would find back home in the north east, all combined with a friendly staff and clean atmosphere. Every time we run into a north Eastern transplant looking for good pizza, we always recommend Brooklyn Joe's and their Sicilian pie. read more

To start out I LOVE ITALIAN FOOD! My husband and I were out in Canton today and looking for a place to eat, I wanted pasta but the only thing around we could see was an Olive Garden. NOPE... We drove through the strip mall and saw Brooklyn Joe's, looked it up and decided to be adventurous. The restaurant has a good comfy cozy feel, nice big booths and we were greeted immediately upon entering. We were seated and waited on immediately and the server and service was excellent! The menu was a little extensive but we focused on the pasta dishes and couldn't believe the awesome prices and selections. They also have lunch and dinner portions, the lunch portion was HUGE, as well as lunch specials. Very affordable! THE PASTA WAS SOOOO DELICIOUS! We have found our new go to for Italian and we can't wait to try the pizza! read more

Wish I lived 10 houses down the street so they would deliver to my house...I guess they don't care about getting any more of my business bc I'm a whole 528 feet too far out of their delivery range. Brilliant business sense...willing to deliver before but "they are too busy tonight" read more

We've driven by this place too many times to count and finally stopped tonight. I'm glad we did. Classic New York style pizza, great wings and my daughter enjoyed her ravioli. We'll be back soon. read more

I go here mainly for the chicken wings. I live on windward for 2 years and finally found my go to place when I'm craving chicken wings. The wings place down the street is not good, wild wings is not good. But this place here cook their wings just right! I always check the bone to see if the wings are fresh, dark bones = not fresh = I won't eat it read more

Stopped for lunch and had a 2 slice lunch special. One pepperoni the other sausage. Very good ingredients and plentiful toppings. The crust was perfect New York style and with a great flavor. Look forward to trying this place again. read more

Went there on Thursday afternoon (2:30) and waited for over 20 minutes to get our pizza and when it arrived the order was wrong. Within a few short minutes of leaving both my wife and I got violently ill. Throwing up, etc. I think the sausage was bad. Add on poor service and we will not be returning even though our address is within a tee shot of the front door. DINER BEWARE!!! read more

I can't speak much for the wait service because I made a to go order. The people that work here are very friendly and helpful. When they brought the pizza out they checked it and asked if it looked good. they looked great. I got a margarita pizza and a greek pizza, XL. Now I will say the pizzas are more expensive than what you may have come to expect but 2 things, the pizzas were huge and tasted great. I felt the price was worth the product. The margarita was pretty much right on. The pizza didn't last long. The greek pizza was pretty good but believe or not we felt there may have been a little too much going on with the pizza as in a little too topping heavy(yes believe it or not we felt there was too many toppings). But regardless if I am ever back in the area I will be ordering from this place. read more

Just the best. I drive from Sandy Springs to get food from here. Eating in is best so you can get Brooklyn Brown on draft. I love this pizza!!! read more

I am a New Yorker , and someone very familiar with Brooklyn. The pizza usually is warm at best and greasy , tastes and looks like it was re heated and not made fresh. I will say that once in a while the pizza does taste like it was just made , just not this time for sure. read more

USED to love Brooklyn Joe's...we have been regulars since they opened, the food is very good (pizza, pasta, salads), nice dining area and kid friendly. We loved dining in and routinely ordered delivery...the staff WAS knowledgable and efficient. However like most places the service has slowly declined to a point where I am finding myself running out of excuses and looking for alternatives. They are clearly living off their early success and have developed into a business with an apathetic staff and clueless management. Tonight we waited over an hour and twenty minutes for a pizza delivery after calling several times and being told they were on their way, which is really the last straw for me. Unfortunately this wasn't an isolated incident and this now appears to be the norm. My wife and I have been hoping that they would get their act together but it would seem that ship has sailed. It's only a matter of time where the quality of the food will disintegrate to match the service. Too bad. They USED to be a really good place...not anymore. read more

Good pizza spot in the area, expected it to be more New York style but it's better than all the other places around.

We love this place and we order EVERY week but tonight I ordered early knowing they would be busy. I called at 5:15 and was told 45 min--- just got my pizza at 7pm. Pizza was good as always but the driver said they were late because they were taking care of walk- ins. I would think that $50 a week every week would put us higher on the service line. read more

Went with a coworker during lunch. Ordered mama's lasagna and lemonade. The lasagna tasted alright. Could have used more meat instead of piling on the the sauce. The garlic rolls tasted okay too. Overall I enjoyed the meal and may return to try another item from the menu. read more

Stopped here for lunch and was very satisfied. I'm not usually a pizza girl unless it's taste of Italy so I was skeptical. I got the two slice special and it was good! The crust wasn't really doughy, it was more flat and crispy. It almost tasted mildly like sour dough. Tasted fresh. The right amount of cheese and pepperoni and sauce balance. The servers were very attentive and I'll definitely be back when I crave Italian food at work. read more

Awful service. Was there around 1:00 for lunch. Took 15 min before we were waited on. Placed our order, never received my salad. Waiter didn't check on us. 20 min for the food to come out, waiter said he didn't know why it took so long, still no salad. After he dropped off our food, he once again never checked on us. Just poor service all around. It will be a long time if we ever decide to give it another try. read more

Only been here for lunch, as it's near my office. Been here probably 6-8 times. The wait staff is hit and miss, depending on who you get, and the food is very pedestrian...what you would expect from a chain, nothing more and nothing less. I would have given 2 stars based on previous experiences, but today's visit was horrible. I sat in the bar area (went by myself so I could get some work done). The waiter barely paid any attention to me at all...spent most of the time talking about his fantasy football team with other members of the staff, when he wasn't talking about this week's episode of Walking Dead (hey...SPOILERS!)*. And the food was terrible...the garlic knots had a texture like they had been cooked yesterday, and the ravioli was cold and tasted like it had been microwaved. This had only been a place that I went to if I had an Italian craving and needed free Wi-Fi....after today, I won't be back. * - Yes, I know The Walking Dead episode was three days ago. That's why God created DVR technology. read more

This was my second visit here and the guy dropped my food on the floor (in the container) but proceeded to pick it up and place it in the bag thinking I did not see him drop it back there... the food was safe inside of the container however, i'm sure you can understand that the presentation was greatly affected. Won't ever go back. read more

This place is out of this world!!! The food is incredible, the prices are very reasonable and the staff is wonderful. Don't miss this place if you're looking for Italian. read more

I'm from south-Eastern Pennsylvania and this is definitely one of the best NY-style (northern) pizza places around!

Awesome food. Awesome service. Great little Italian place. Took a team of 19 players and 3 coaches and we were served and filled with great pizza, pasta, salad, and sandwiches in minimal time. In and out within an hour. The price was right and everyone of the players (who are high school teenage girls and you know how hard it is to please that many teenage girls at a time) liked their food and left full. Thanks Brooklyn Joe's, if we ever play in your part of the state again, we'll be back. All for less than $200! read more

Authentic ny pizza great crust incredible salads! Fast service and super staff by far best pie in Alpharetta

We eat here quite a bit. They have amazing pizza, pasta and salads. Plus, the staff is always friendly and helpful.

Delicious! Best pizza in town so far. I recently moved to the area and tried 3 other pizza places so far and was not impressed. We ordered take out and it was ready on time and correct. When I paid the employee showed me the pizza to confirm - much appreciated. Crust was thinner than I like, but I'm originally from Buffalo, NY and the pizza dough up there tends to be thicker. The flavor was what mattered and it was delicious, as was the sauce and cheese. We'll be back! read more

This is now our family's favorite "go-out-for-pizza" place. The food is wonderful, great pizza and salad. Fun atmosphere. Good service. Fair pricing but not cheap. Loaded toppings, great size portions. read more

I love Brooklyn Joe's! It's the only place I want to get pizza from (and I am a native New Yorker). Service is quick, friendly and the ingredients are always fresh. It's light years ahead of the other NY style pizza joints like Ray's and Johnny's. No, the crust isn't as awesome as in NY, but that's cause we're not in NY. If you want great pizza that is fresh, reasonably priced and served up quickly, this is the ticket! You can't please them all, but the ones who have taste, will like Joes! read more

I love this place. Foods really good and the portions sizes are amazing. Staff is friendly ++. Definitely one of the better pizza places In Milton. read more

We often do carryout or delivery from Brooklyn Joe's. I would highly recommend to cook the pizza"extra crispy", especially for takeout. Their New Yorker pizza is wonderful with pepperoni, meatballs, sausage, ham, and a wide variety of vegetables. They are very generous with their toppings! I have tried a few of their entrees over time, and would recommend sticking with pizza. I would also skip their breadsticks, they aren't the best. Tip: Check online for coupons, because they almost always offer a 15% off coupon. read more

I love their pizza. They have a few other good dishes there as well. The zucchini fries are my boyfriends favorite. The only thing about BJ's is the waiter can take forever if your dining in.. read more