This was only my second time visiting Brooklyn Pizzas, and while the wait was a little longer than I'm usually used to for pizza, it was absolutely worth it. One bite into the fresh mozzarella, homemade crust, and perfectly cooked vegetables, and you can taste the difference immediately. Everything is made from scratch with real, quality ingredients--and it shows. The extra wait just means your food is being made with care, not rushed. It's delicious, satisfying, and feels like real food. Anytime I'm craving pizza, this is the place I want to go. read more

Just great pizza!!!! I haven't been to the store, yet, but have had it at a party at the mobile home park I live in!! Better than any pizza I have had in a long time!!!! Thanks guys!!! Steve, Sage Point. read more

OK... So I saw this place pop up when I was looking for new pizza place. I was thinking to myself I don't ever remember seeing this place. Ordered pizza and wing combo special. 16 inch pizza and 16 wings, ordered the pizza with pepperoni and spanich, order of fried zucchini. As I drove to the place it came to realization that it was a gas station.. F*$#... Well I couldn't cancel the order so I figure I give it a try. Who knows it could be a best pizza ever. Walk in the gas station and it was empty. Ok I can say this because I am Asian but not a good vibe when I get an old asian guy that comes to help you in a gas station pizza joint.. Lord have mercy. My wings and fried zucchini came he packed it up. He took the pizza out of the oven and it as burnt.. Well at least he had enough pride to say oh I burned it so I'll have to make new one.. So had to wait another 15 mins or so for the pizza, while my wings and zucchini waited in the bag. OK so finally get my food home wife calling me asking me if I am still alive.. . Pizza.. Ok I'm sure I said pepperoni and spinach but he dumped some fresh basil. Pizza tasted like cardboard box with some ragu sauce on top. Very disappointed, wings were ok pretty decent size nothing special. Fried zucchini was pretty good at least. Pizza, wings, zucchini was $57.14. Sad thing is last time I had pizza this bad was when we went to New York long time ago, I ordered pizza for delivery because it was late and hungry and was recommended by hotel staff. It was pretty bad.. read more

See all

My pizza was amazing! The cheese especially was fantastic, and stretched like real cheese should. The service was great. Very attentive and polite, with a genuine interest in making our meal experience was exceptional. I liked the ambiance. Very cozy, yet also roomie Plus, an extra star because they have Mountain Dew on tap. Go check this place out! It's right next to the Harkins Theaters at Gilbert Road & Germann Rds in Chandler. read more

I've been ordering pizza here for a few months now and could not believe it when I found out it was in a gas station. The quality is incredible and had been completely consistent across all of my orders. Don't go in and expect to get the speedy service from a chain that uses frozen ingredients or a fully staffed parlor. It's part of a gas station so even though the pizza is amazing, make your expectations more realistic for large orders. Honestly so glad I found this gem and I hope it never goes away read more

Great pizza and great wings! I recommend you order ahead of time as food takes a little bit longer to prepare but even so,it's worth the wait. read more

Brooklyn New York Pizza & Wings - Honey BBQ & Garlic Parmesan - Pizza Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

Great Italian food here. Marinara so good I want to drink it! Calzones so big and delish! Service has def got better. Lasagna so yummy! Pizza good to and you can buy by the slice.wish they had Diet Coke oh well still love the food read more

Don't be like me and overlook the "gas station" part of the business description. I thought this was a new location of Brooklyn V's pizza and didn't realize my mistake until I was already waiting to pick up the order I called in 20 minutes prior. I waited almost an hour for it upon arrival and thought to myself that I should have just walked out several times but felt bad because I didn't want a small business to waste money if the order had been started already. HUGE MISTAKE. I got 2 pizzas and 2 orders of garlic knots from this place for a friend's birthday several weeks ago. I took the leftover pizza and garlic knots home to my husband for dinner and by the next day I was sick with food poisoning (the bad kind that is too graphic to describe here but affects both ends). I thought it was something else because my husband was fine but by that evening he started getting sick with the same symptoms. This was on a Saturday and we both had to call out sick the following Monday because we felt so bad. When I was finally feeling better, I called my friend to see how she was doing and she said she'd also been sick all weekend. The pizza was the only thing we all had in common and we had the same symptoms. So if you have even a moment of hesitation about ordering pizza from a gas station- LISTEN TO YOUR GUT!! read more

This place is in a gas station and immediately that pushed most away, don't let it be the reason you miss out on a great pizza. This was my first time trying it out and when we got there the owner was so friendly and excited to see me walk in had my food ready to go quickly and it smelled great. I ordered a medium half pepperoni jalapeño half margarita and fried zucchini. The fried zucchini was crispy and honestly better than most places I've had I gave it a solid 9/10. The pizza had a lot of flavor and crust was crispy. I will be coming back for sure. Eat local and give them a try. read more

Brooklyn New York Pizza & Wings - Pepperoni jalapeño/margarita pizza and fried zucchini sticks. Was too good couldn't wait to eat - Pizza Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

Great pizza and service! Easy to order online with custom toppings any way you want! Accurate prediction of time as well. Always ready when I arrive. Can't get any better than this! :) read more

Grub Hub drivers door dash drivers BEWARE..... it's a one person show your going to get here and wait close to 20 to thirty minutes for an order every single time , he doesn't say anything and you end up waiting 20 30 minutes for an order past the time it should have been ready , a small few of us take this serious and work full time 70 hours plus a week for me so i will no longer accept deliveries from here read more

A hidden gem! but really. It's behind a chevron and you'd never know the pizza place is as good as it is! This place was way good. For sure worth the try. Plus you can drive up, wait for your order, and then go! It's delicious and you will enjoy every minute of it! The owner is sweet and knows his stuff. They go pretty light on the meat and you may want to order an extra side of sauce if you get a calzone. It tasted wonderful! read more

See all

Thanks to Yelp, we were able to try delicious pizza tonight. I didn't have time to cook dinner so we decided to grab takeout. I checked Yelp to see if I can find something new and that's exactly what I got. Found NY pizza and wings and it had such good reviews we decided to give a try. I ordered on the phone. We got the Bianca pizza, margarita pizza and the fried jalapeño ravioli. The guy I spoke to on the phone sounded really nice. Not sure he was the owner but he could be. He said food will be ready in 20 min. My husband went to pick up. At first he couldn't find the place. He called me and I sent him the address, still couldn't find it. It turns out it was in the gas station, tucked away in the back! We didn't know that. We thought we were looking for a restaurant! The food was ready by the time my husband got there. So between the time my husband took to find the place and get home, the food was just warm. I would have loved to try it super hot. To compensate for that, I decided to warm up a couple of pizza slices in my small toaster oven so that the cheese was melting again. The ricotta on the Bianca was so soft and delicious. The pizza was very good. It needed just a tiny bit of salt. The margarita was very flavorful, especially because of the fresh basil. It had fresh mozzarella on it which I really like. The fried ravioli was great! It was just the right amount of spicy. It's stuffed with cream cheese and jalapeños. It occurred to my husband and I that we should have ordered some wings since it's NY pizza and wings! We will be trying that the next time for sure. Prices are very good! For everything, we only paid $31. The pizzas are huge! We have left overs for another dinner tomorrow. Definitely worth a visit! read more

See all

Ok this is in a gas station but some of the best pizza. We are obsessed with grandma's - it's garlicky, crunchy, cheesy, and can be customized to your liking. We ask for extra garlic and add pepperoni. You can even specify well done if you want an extra crunch! It comes with 6 massive slices, we get two pizzas for 5 of us though it's that good, we all want leftovers!! read more

Brooklyn New York Pizza & Wings - Grandma's NY Pie - Pizza Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

See all

Ordered hot wings recently. They looked amazing but they didn't taste as good as I hoped. read more

Brooklyn New York Pizza & Wings - Pizza Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

FANTASTIC food. Will definitely surprise you. We got pepperoni pizza Margherita pizza and honey hot wings and we're very happy read more

Brooklyn New York Pizza & Wings - Honey hot wings - Pizza Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

See all

Simply put, our entire order was poorly executed. The medium pepperoni pizza was undercooked and overly greasy. The small pizza was burnt on the edges and nearly raw in the middle. It didn't help that one of our pizzas had to be remade whole we waited because the first attempt had burnt. The wings were underdone and yet dry, somehow. The cinnamon bites were overdone, which resulted in an awkward chewy outside. The cheesecake was frozen solid. The total cost for this disaster was more than $50, almost what you'd pay for some truly 5 star pizza. read more

NY PIZZA AND WINGS in Mesa is delicious! It's located inside the Chevron gas station on SW corner of Recker & Brown. I ordered a few different things to try and everything tasted amazing! Obviously, everything is made fresh there - the crust has just the perfect amount of chew and the cheese is gooey and stretchy, exactly what you want to see and taste on a good NY pizza. One of the things I was interested to try was the keto bowl. All I can say is WOW! A huge bowl of meats and cheese (or whatever you want) with a little bit of red sauce. For me, easily 2 meals and for less than $8, very affordable. I see they have a drive through if you don't want to get out of your vehicle Im looking forward to going again soon and trying other items they offer at NY Pizza and Wings In Mesa Use the Slice app to order, i got 5% off plus I found a code for additional $10 off read more

See all

Summary: forgot half of my order on delivery. I never leave reviews but this experience sucked. Ordered pizza/wing combo, mozzarella sticks, and 2 extra marinara sauces for the pizza. The mozzarella sticks and both of the marinara sauces were not delivered. The DoorDash driver may share some fault for not checking but this restaurant is notorious for this on DoorDash. If you're thinking of getting delivery, please don't. The food was really not great. Pizza was okay and the wings were chewy with no crisp. More upset that I just paid for stuff that didn't come. Like how does that happen to so many people. Just ridiculous. read more

We ordered a meat lovers calzone and a blanco pizza. We received a blanco pizza and a cheese calzone. While it is good, it is DEFINITELY not what we ordered. So the food is good but make sure you check your order before the driver leaves. read more

Brooklyn New York Pizza & Wings - Cheese calzone blanco pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

Wanted to venture out of our normal rotation of Barros, Venezias, and Oreganos. The reviews were decent and the pictures looked great. The actual food, not so much. The margarita pizza had about 4 sliced cherry tomatoes, no cheese, and a plain sauce, with what looked like one basil leaf torn into tiny confetti. The pepperoni pizza looked like a gas station pizza. Neither were awful, but for the price and expectations this misses the mark. The wings were standard deep fried and bottled sauce. The boneless wings were extremely tough and appeared to be frozen chicken tenders cut in half and then fried. If this were advertised as gas station food with the accompanying price tag it would be average. Competing against regular pizza joints, this one misses. read more

If you're looking for a keto food option, do not go here. They don't even understand what keto means. I ordered a keto pizza here, and what I got was soup. Marinara sauce isn't keto, for the record, guys. Also, not that hard to order keto bread. I literally spent $10 and wasted my time. You guys are incompetent. Go research and order keto items before offering these options, good lord. This is embarrassing for a food establishment. read more

Brooklyn New York Pizza & Wings - This is soup slapped together in a tin. This is not pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

Great pizza & wings! CASH ONLY is their preferred method of payment, also offering a discount with it. Wasn't a huge fan of the mozzarella sticks but my friend was. Large pizza & 12 wings is an excellent price that will for sure keep people coming back for more. The day the cheese from $9 to $12 and ran out of wings, I had to just call it a day and say no thanks! Hopefully the prices stay legit so I can stay a returning customer. read more

See all

Burnt pizza. Cold garlic knots. Asked for pizza sauce and got marinara. Why send it out if it's sub par???? read more

Brooklyn New York Pizza & Wings - Burnt pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

We had the lunch special. Salad, spaghetti, and a personal size pizza. The salad was fresh, spaghetti noodles were cooked perfectly and the sauce was delicious. The pizza crust was good and my pizza was one of the best pizzas I've had in a long time. And for only 8.99? Are you kidding me??!! We will be back! read more

Oh yum! Super easy ordering, reasonable prices and pizza tastes great. Nice balance of ingredients for the meat lover pizza and the white pizza. Ricotta adds a nice sweetness to the white pizza and this pizza is not overwhelmed by garlic, which is sometimes typical for a white pizza. The mozzarella on both pizzas does not distract from the chewy crust either. As reviewers are pointing out, its not a glamorous location but the pizza shines! Thank you, thank you for being in the East Valley. read more

We discovered this through our google feed and finally made it over to check it out! Jim and the staff are very personable! While we were waiting we were given a sample of the "grandma's square" and it was fabulous and will definitely be ordering it next time. We ordered the garlic knots and 3 pizzas. The garlic knots were fantastic! All the pizzas were tasty and the crust was yummy!! Our daughter who is very picky loved the cheese pizza! We will definitely be making this our regular go to and want to try the stromboli next!! As for Dessert we had the cinnamon bites!! Yummy Thank you Jim and Staff!! read more

Brooklyn New York Pizza & Wings - Pepperoni & Sausage & Mushrooms, Cheese Pizza and Pepperoni & Bell Peppers - Pizza Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

Located in a Speed Mart, you can order at the counter or use the website. The pizza crust is mixed and formed by hand and toppings added before entering the oven. My order was waiting for me when I arrived at the earliest time posted on the website so it was no longer hot. For the price the quality was good and the crust was not undercooked. This would make a good lunch pizza if you could wait while it was prepared. read more

Perfect crust, great cheese, tasty pepperoni, awesome service, Pamela is cool. You'll need to take out or drive thru, it's a legit gas station so you can't really eat there. read more

Brooklyn New York Pizza & Wings - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

Disgusting. The employee had a gash on his knuckle on his hand and he had blood dripping down his finger and he was making pizza and food. Repulsive. I will never go back there again. read more

Best pizza in all of Arizona, they also have great service and ambiance Highly recommend for everyone read more

It's called Brooklyn New York pizza and wings and it's inside a Chevron gas station but it's a separate business. Great food and great employees and it's someplace that I think will start to get packed pretty soon when people figure out what a gem it is. So yummy!!! read more

It is an amazing experience going in there and ordering very friendly and nice.also the pizza is very delicious I always get the pepperoni the best pizza I get every time they never miss. read more

Food was just ok. Service was not good & I wonder if the older gentleman working was drunk. App told me 20-25 mins for my pizza & wings. I arrived at the store roughly 25-30 mins after completing my order. When I arrived, another gentleman was ahead of me waiting for his food and was extremely frustrated. He informed me he was told his food would be ready 30mins ago & had been waiting the whole time. When I got my turn at the front of the line, the employees told me it would be 9 more minutes. A little frustrated at this point as I had just heard the other gentleman's frustrations & it was clearly past the time I was given. After roughly 20 minutes, they finally brought out my food, well most of it...They had shorted me a pizza. I immediately informed the employee of this error, he grabbed the receipt & confirmed he had messed up. I asked for a refund as my family was at home waiting on this food. They informed me that I would have to call a number for the app, which they could not locate, as they could not issue a refund in store. As we couldn't find this number and they told me they could make the pizza in 9 mins, I told them to go ahead and make the last pizza & I would return. Took me 10-12 minutes to get back & when I arrive they told me 5 more minutes. At this point I am questioning their ability to tell time. After 10 more minutes, they finally had my order complete. I will not be ordering from this location ever again. read more

SO BOMB! Don't let the location fool you. Yes it is located inside the Chevron but it is NOT gas station food! I am from NY, and this reminded me of home! The only thing that was missing was the melba (raspberry) sauce to dip the mozzarella sticks in. The pizza was fresh and delicious, pepperoni, jalapeño and pineapple. It was spicy! The chicken wings were delicious and the sauce was served on the side to keep the wings from getting soggy which I appreciate. We also got the cinnamons for dessert and they were great. We will definitely be back! Remember this is a family owned restaurant so don't forget to tip! read more

We just ordered 2 pizzas to go. Just trying a different pizza place . And this place was not the answer . Didn't care for the ambulance, there's none . We'll not returning ,pizza not that good.. read more

I've been coming here (the Brown & Recker location) since they first opened in June of 2020, and am so glad that they survived everything that was thrown at them (the COVID lockdowns, the supply-chain problems getting quality ingredients, and the lack of snowbird sales for a couple of winter seasons), and are thriving, and that they just opened a full restaurant on Main Street east of Power! I love supporting local businesses that actually care about their customers and supply quality products, and this is one that will continue to receive my business, and support. The food and customer service are both excellent at the Brown and Recker location, and I'm really looking forward to visiting the new restaurant as well. Tonight, I ordered a sausage/anchovy/mushroom/basil pizza, well done, and it's superb! As good as if I had taken the time to make home made pizza, and that is a HUGE compliment coming from me! No photo to attach because we ate it all! *LOL* read more

Right before we got back to our hotel hubby really wanted to pizza just so that we can have one to eat in the morning we love cold pizza. As I look on yelp I found that this was one that was close to our hotel. I searched yelp and this place showed up and it had great reviews. We were still returning from Phoenix when I ordered the pizza I had called in and place an order and they said it would be ready in about 15 minutes. 10 minutes to their close time they had called me back to let me know that the pizza was ready for me to pick up I was a minute away. Now tricky thing was finding the place because we are not from here so it took us a minute to find it because we were driving in circles only one I called him and asked him where they were located they told me they were located in the Chevron gas station and they also have a drive-through that was trippy. I was greeted by a female worker first and then a man they were super Duper nice. It was a really good pizza to have that night and the next morning. read more

See all

If you're looking for true New York pizza, believe it or not, it is inside of a Chevron station in North Mesa. My wife absolutely loves their gluten-free pizza, loaded with toppings. The kids and I like the cheese pizza. The dough, sauce, and cheese are all phenomenal! If you were longing for New York pizza, this is the place. We weren't big fans of the mozzarella sticks, but they weren't bad. The staff there knock themselves out to deliver excellent customer service. We are customers for life! read more

See all

Gas station Pizza is what no one is telling you. I couldn't find it, made a uturn and then realized it's inside the Gas Station. If the photo's showed that I wouldn't of even ordered. I called in to place an order, went to pick it up and saw Gas Station and kept on driving. That's why they said it will only take a few minutes they must microwave it. I'm giving it a 1 star for 2 reasons. 1. It's very misleading. 2. The owner text a nasty text. Who does that. I know it's New York Pizza but we in Arizona and I'm from L.A. That shows horrible customer service. read more