We ordered 2 appetizers, 3 entrées and a desert and there wasn't anything left on our plates when we finished. That is unusual for us. Our kids finished the meals without a single reminder to eat, that is unusual for us. We finished our meal with very little conversation or small talk because the food was so good, that was unusual for us. The shop is small and unassuming but the food is excellent. Would recommend and come back when we are in the area. We ordered: Bushetta; caprese salad; spaghetti and meatballs; Lasagna; stuff shells; and Cannolis. All were stupendous... read more

Brooklyn Pie & Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Texas

Great pizza. Crispy flavorful crust. Stringy stretchy cheese. Really well made flavorful pizza.

Awesome pizza and garlic knots. The establishment is clean and organized. The service is great.

So two extra large pizza, a large any where else, and 2 slices of cheese cakes, and one tiramisu. 71 dollars and change. One slice was all I could eat of the white pizza, the margarita pizza tastes like card board. Worst pizza I have ever had, I'm a fat kid that pretty much will find something good in anything. I wouldn't eat here again for free. read more

Brooklyn Pie & Cafe - Maybe a margarita pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Texas

It's been an hour and half and my pizza still has not arrived. I called Grubhub and they actually refunded my money. Whoever the grubhub driver was must have been hungry. He left the empty box in my front door (While it's been raining all day) and it was full of ants. Yes I got 40 dollars worth of cart board and ants, thanks GRUBHub you're the worst business anyone can deal with! read more

Brooklyn Pie & Cafe - Sausage Combo Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Texas

Food was not tasty not enough toppings on pizza had no flavor at all want be gone back

Very good pizza. Went in very friendly people sure they're ere the owners food hot and fresh no complaints

This place was amazing. The friendly smiles and on the point sub made the experience perfect. Thank you!

We tried this place for the second time . The pizza was on point. They got everything down just right and the crust was thin and crispy. The most disappointing part of the meal were the chicken wings . They only come in one flavor and they were the smallest wings I've ever seen ; beware baby chicks!! I took a pic next to my thumb and I do not have big hands so you can get an idea if the actual size. I know next time I'll order pizza, mozzarella sticks and jalapeños poppers.. those were all good quality. read more

See all

Some of the best pizza in the area! Friendly staff and the food is great!! Priced well and the restaurant is clean!

Food is so good!!!! And customer service was great! Love this little place! Even leftovers were amazing!

As an original "Jersey Boy" I gotta say this is as close to home as I can find. The crust is perfect crunch and the gravy is authentic. The prices are competitive and portions are worth the price. Small seating and an 'at home' feeling. If you are looking for authentic Jersey pizza, Brooklyn is your best bet. All the others, fuggedaboutit. read more

Should have posted this sooner, but this was my first time having a pizza from here. So glad I did! Called in an order, had the specialty pizza and some fries. I think I ate half that pizza before I got home. Fresh and hot and tasty! The fries were seasoned just right for my taste. The lady I paid money too was really nice and courteous! I'll definitely be back! I'm not sure if they are a branch with the Brooklyns pizza on Green oaks and 360. Both are good. But I'm lookin forward to ordering from this one again. read more

This is NY pizza ! Definitely felt like I was back home. Highly recommended. And last but not least, Brooklyn ( the owner ) is a great guy and was cool to hear about his adventures throughout life. read more

Brooklyn Pie & Cafe - Personal Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Texas

Absolutely bangin pizza! I added garlic to the meatlovers and man did they hook it up! We will definitely be back and I can't recommend them enough! read more

Brooklyn Pie & Cafe - Meatlovers with garlic! - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Texas

had high hopes after reading reviews but this place was not worth it. Will NOT return. Not child friendly. Pizza took One hour. One worker, extremely slow and ZERO service skills. The man doesn't smile- he looks like hates his job. The atmosphere felt heavy & depressing, like walking into a funeral home. It was also super warm, felt like owner doesn't wanna spend money on AC- felt like an oven inside. The grated cheese and pepper on table jars were so old, smelled awful. If you're a family of young children go elsewhere, owner will most likely have rude comments to say. If you still decide to try- just be prepared to wait a very long time so have a snack before lol - I anticipate owner will respond super rudely as he will not accept any truthful feedback that speaks TRUTH about his establishment. I am just writing to inform the public- I do not need anything from this establishment. read more

Moved here from Austin in February and the struggle was real to find a decent pizza place. Was so happy to find this place the pizza is amazing, the crust is crispy and the garlic knots are great! Our new tho to pizza spot for sure! read more

Brooklyn Pie & Cafe - Margarita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Texas

Called in an order for a Hawaiian pizza. Didn't rush to get it. We arrived and they had not made the pizza yet. You could tell there was some disarray and the owner told the young worker not to give anyone else their pizza without his approval. When they gave us our pizza, we could tell they had cooked a cheese pizza and then threw ours toppings on after. They looked uncooked. We asked for it to be re-made. Instead, he added some cheese on top and baked it some more... Just wasn't what we were expecting. The owner explained if we want the toppings under the cheese, we would need to specify that when ordering... but I just wanted cooked toppings, when all is said and done, didn't need to be under the cheese necessarily. read more

Found this place on Yelp. What it lacks in ambiance, it makes up in quality. Staff not super chatty.. but they were efficient and helpful. I will be a regular here. read more

Moved out here from CT and missed that east coast pizza. Tried couple places and Brooklyn was the spot for me. Great Pizza, great service!

Good food and pleasant atmosphere. Our family of four came here after my son's hocket game. Everyone got something different. We got pasta, sandwich, pizza and an appetizer. The bread on the sandwich was fresh. The pizza had a crispy crust. The food was tasty and I can't believe how reasonable the prices were. The restarant is in a shopping center and lacks personality. They do have a tv showing, in our case, sports. However don't let that detract you from coming in. The food is worth it. read more

Made an order for take out, got medium pepperoni and beef pizza. Both pizza was delicious! We loved it. Also got my niece shrimp Alfredo and she loved it. My nephew tried and both were fighting for it. Lol next time, I know to order more. Definitely recommend and glad I found a new delicious pizza place spot. Can't wait to try other dishes. read more

Brooklyn Pie & Cafe - Beef pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Texas

Sauce taste great, could use a smidge more. And very skimpy on the cheese. Love the crust. read more

Brooklyn Pie & Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Texas

Second favorite pizza in Mansfield. Family owned, authentic NY pizza- the crust is delicious and all the toppings I've had have been great quality. Always ask about specials and get some of those garlic knots! read more

A few weeks ago, my husband brought me a meatball sub from here. It was very good-- the best meatball sub I have eaten since we returned to Texas 30 years ago after living in New England for 6 years when he was in the Navy. A good part of that time I worked in a "mom and pop owned" Italian deli, so when it comes to Italian eats, my standards are really high. Last night, we got a sausage and onion pizza so I can officially give this establishment a 5-star review. The pizza was magnificent in every way; perfectly crisp crust (w/o any blackened parts) that is thin- but not too thin, tasty sauce, and adequate toppings. I LOVE how the sausage is sliced from links- the way it should be! Pork or beef can be crumbles, but Italian sausage should be thinly sliced. I sliced about a thousand pounds of it during my time working at the deli, so I aught to know. The folks working, which I assume were the owner and part of his family, were professional. The dine-in area was clean enough to satisfy even picky folks. Certainly a huge improvement over the former tenant in this space. We WILL be returning. Probably often. I intend to sample some of the pasta options next time. I hope the owners keep up the standards because Mansfield desperately needs an option for great casual Italian eats like pizza & subs. Best of all, this isn't a chain. read more

Order was completely messed up, but because I ordered for delivery, they couldn't correct unless I wanted to drive in a get it. The whole reason for delivery was because of surgery and not being able to drive. read more

A couple of months ago I decided to try pizza from this little spot. So glad I did because it was delicious and worth the cost. I keep coming back to enjoy the pizza and now I can add the garlic knots and chicken parmigiana. So glad I live close to this gem and will continue to come back to try new items. read more

If I could leave a zero stars I would. Called last night to order over $50 worth of food to be delivered. He took my order and credit card info. 5 minutes later he calls me back to say they don't deliver to Remington Ranch south of Heritage. After explaining that every other place located at Matlock and Debbie delivered to my house 7 miles away, he started yelling and being belligerent with me. I told him I would never order from them ever again, he laughed rudely say that in his 50 years of working/running a restaurant that none of them didn't deliver that far. Forgot to mention his English was tough to understand. Just want to support a local business but ordered Domino's instead. I guess they are flush with business, good for them :) read more

Good pizza clean restaurant friendly atmosphere with fast service in Mansfield Texas family business with good food and quit nice restaurants read more

Best pizza ever! The crust is the best. I loved the garlic knots and sauce. No beer, but the pizza it awesome. read more

Brooklyn Pie & Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Texas

Family owned and operated, we love small businesses! They were very busy with takeout orders so service was a little slow. Pies were very tasty, their dough was fresh and the crust was perfect. We ordered salads to accompany our pies, fresh and well presented. Thank you for your hard work, we will be back read more

We thought we would try out this new place for lunch today. Both of my kids said it was their new favorite place to eat. The pizza and garlic bread was amazing. And the lunch special was great. We had a small pizza for $5.99 and .99 for a drink. Two pizzas and we were stuffed. I highly recommend giving this place a chance. read more

Brooklyn Pie & Cafe - The small pizza... half mushroom and half cheese. - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Texas

If you like good pizza, it's not flashy or fancy, but it sure is tasty. Make sure you get some garlic knots as well.

Ah where do I begin. I ordered a philly cheese steak sandwich, the onions weren't even sautéed and they use yellow American cheese which just doesn't sit right with me. The actual meat was meh. Bread was nicely toasted. I paid 4$ for a side of Alfredo sauce, not only was it a tiny 3.5 oz container, the sauce was so thin and it was ice cold. Garlic knots are great though. Also, they told me it would be ready in 25 minutes which actually meant 45-50 minutes. Maybe I should have gotten a pizza but this was just bad, if you're going to sell these items you should atleast try to make them good. I will not be back read more

The best NY style pizza in town. Thin crust is very crispy and nicely browned. The regular crust is slightly chewier but still well cooked. Both came with delicious tomato sauce and just the right amount of cheese. Other items on the menu are equally well done. The salads are fresh and well made. Try the mussels marinara. These are my wife's favorite. In a world of pizza chains and carry out service, John's place is a breath of fresh air. Our new go to joint! read more

This past weekend I was driving and noticed Brooklyn Pie pizza place. I like to try new restaurants. Omg! I'm glad I did. Brooklyn Pie Cafe is absolutely delicious. My daughter and I couldn't stop. We did a pie split pepperoni for my daughter and Margherita. The every piece of this pizza was worth it. The sauce was full of flavor! The crust not two thick, not to thin, it was Spot on! You have got to try this place. They have an extensive menu. I enjoyed the pizza so much. I ordered a lasagna to go for lunch the next day. I've included before and after pictures. Also, this buisness is family owned and they live in the community. Be sure to stop by. Grab a bite and leave a review. I'd like to know what you think read more

See all

The customer service here is GREAT. Food is made fresh! Pizza, spaghetti and meatballs, and sandwiches are my FAVORITE.

Stars (see key for details). Pros: Fast delivery, pizza was better than average, sausage was sliced and not the crumble (which I really liked). Cons: Chicken wings - horrible. AVOID them. They were extremely small, and what little meat there was on them was overcooked and dried out. Sauce was average. General comments: I had delivery and the pizza wasn't hot...so that is why I couldn't say it was good. I do think there is a strong possibility that if you ate in the restaurant and got a hot pie, then it would be good...or better. I do think if they could figure out how to deliver a hot pizza, and cook a decent wing, that they might earn a 3.6 or 4 star rating. Right now I would give a 2.8. Key for star rating: 5 stars: Travel worthy - it's a dinning experience worth investing in. I'm already making plans to come back! 4 stars: No tears - your not going to cry (good or bad tears), but you won't be disappointed. This place will always be on my radar, I won't need to look this up next time I'm looking for food. 3 stars: Good - better than average. Positives outweigh the negative. I'll be back. 2 stars: OK - less than average. Negatives outweigh the positive. I won't be back unless a friend really wants to try this place. 1 star: AVOID - skip a meal before going here. No chance I'll be back. read more

Great and authentic pizza! The portions are good and they are really accommodating. BYOB and a good, but casual vibe. Unfortunately for kiddos, all their sauces have a spice to them, so be careful! My baby can't eat here :( the pizza isn't as bad, I just scrap off the sauce. read more

I thought the pizza was good. Trying to support small business where we can. The bruschetta was basically cheesy tomato sub bread which was different/not what I expected but tasted good. Overall a nice change from Typical delivery pizza read more

Brooklyn Pie & Cafe - Bruschetta is different than typical. Tasted good ‍ - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Texas