New to Tallahassee and is place has great pizza. The staff is nice to and I didn't have to wait to long.

This place is so good that we came two days in a row. The guy that cooks the pizza is so nice and knows his stuff! This pizza is PERFECTLY crafted and one of the best NY style pizzas I've had. The lunch specials are unbeatable and they have lots of options. I love this place. the first time we got it to go and it was great but we came back for lunch and we're amazed at how large the slices were, we couldn't even finish them! Two slices of cheese and a drink for $6! Overall a great experience, out of all the places we have tried in Tallahassee, this is our #1 for pizza read more

Best pizza in Tallahassee hands down. I've been coming here since my first college days some years back and it's been the same. Great pizza, quick service, always accommodating to requests. Garlic knots are stellar. read more

When it comes to classic New York style pizza, Brooklyn does a pretty good job. Coming from someone who adores pizza more than life, this is definitely one of my go to pizza joints for a late night bite. For one, they are usually open later than other small joints AND they make great pizza. I do have to point out that they once served me Garlic Knots with barely any garlic, BUT they made up for it and now know that Garlic Knots should be DRENCHED in yummy Garlic. I'm a big fan of Pepperoni and Black Olives which is what I'll usually get. The prices are also great compared to the likes of Decent Pizza and Gaines Street Pies. Try em out! read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Pep - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Love the pizza! Very good for tallahassee! We will come back! Closest thing I have had to a real New York style pizza in tally! read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Yummy cheese pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Coming from South Florida (and having family from New York/New Jersey), I was happy to find out that Brooklyn Pizza has roots where the best pizza can be found. As to why they are in Tallahassee, who knows? But who cares?! They have awesome pizza, with the perfect ratio of dough to sauce to cheese. The only thing I wish they did was put more toppings on their pies, but they use quality toppings, so I understand why it isn't done. Still 5 stars in my book. And the calzones are HUGE. Don't overlook them. read more

Overall, a solid, tasty pizza at a more than reasonable price. Brooklyn Pizza offers a no frills meno that gets you exactly what you want, without all the indecision. Having tried the white pizza, I can now say that I was impressed by the quality of the ingredients, particulary the crust. They are happy to deliver, but the specials are the real draw for this place. Try it out! read more

Brooklyn Pizza has not disappointed myself or my partner thus far. There are a ton of restaurants to order delivery from, but this is our favorite. The Stromboli's also taste fresh, I only tried the cheese one, but it was good. I think their marinara sauce has a kick to it and is one of our favs, don't forget to order extra. I've tried the eggplant parmesan sub, it is delicious, steak and cheese and the spinach and feta pizza, like I said, they are all great. I just had to write a good review because we are so happy about this place. If you want delivery, go to www.grubhub.com and it only took 30-40 minutes. You can't go wrong with this place. (kiss the chef for us) :-) read more

I expected Brooklyn style pizza, instead I got canned mushrooms as a topping and soggy center crust. With that said the crust that was edible was very good and the sauce was spot on. Would of been great if a few corrective steps were taken. I will return read more

Pizza crust was pretty good, sauce was tasteless, a bit too much cheese for me. I paid extra for garlic which did not make it on the pizza. read more

Some of the best pizza I have ever had in Tallahassee!!! The salad I also got was fresh and good as well!! I live on the other side of Tallahassee so i never make my way to that side of town but After this visit i will most definitely be coming back more frequently! The owner is also so nice and awesome! When I went I was going for a share it night and the owner had mentioned he loves doing things like this for everyone so don't be shy to ask him!! read more

Probably the best pizza I have had since I moved to Tallahassee. If you are a fan of crispy, thin crust pizza, this is the only place I have found in town that does it. I didn't eat in, so I can't comment on the service. The place was clean and the inside looked friendly. My only issue is that the toppings and cheese were a little thin. The mozzarella had good flavor and was good quality unlike the Elmer's Glue cheese food I have experienced at other places in town. I would have liked a bit more on the pizza, but I will rectify that by ordering extra cheese the next time. All in all I like it. read more

It's been a very long time since I've ordered a home-delivered pizza...it's been a long time since I've had a pizza that I didn't make...so, very excited tonight to ORDER IN!! Brooklyn Pizza...great reviews, etc., and there we went. I know the snafue about the delivery (1 1/2 hrs.) could happen to any delivery business, so, no problem...we totally understand. However, what we DON'T understand is the undercooked crust, the lack of cheese and lack of sauce and the total blah-ness of the pizza that was finally delivered to us. No more a "Brooklyn-style" pizza than I am Angelina Jolie...Is this just a Florida thing or what? Does anyone here know what PIZZA means? In any case, a complete disappointment. read more

Decided to try Brooklyn Pizza again. Due holiday no delivery so went to pickup & ready 15 minutes . Wifey & I love thin pizza dough & Brooklyn didn't disappoint. Supreme ingredients fresh & still better Pizza Hut, Papa Johns & Dominos. Worth a try. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

There's many reasons why this place impressed me. First let's just talk about the fact that they are open until 3am! Wow. I mean, I realize its a college town, but I was still pleasantly surprised. The pizza...very good. Very very good. Small and dimly lit, a good place to grab a bite to eat after drinking or even to catch a bite with friends. Wasn't too hard to find. Great service. The girl who helped us was super nice. Not a lot of parking or seating though. But what's better than a pizza place that stays open until 3am...that actually makes crazy good pizza!? read more

Brooklyn PIZZA is great. Brooklyn Pizza in Tallahassee needs to understand that everyone is not a drunken college kid - people will notice if you rip them off. My total check was $24 - so i tipped $5. They turned my $5 tip into a $15 tip fraudulently. I have been trying to resolve the issue with a manager but have not been successful. Unfortunately I now have filed a claim through my bank because the manager now claims that she can not find my check. We loved Brooklyn - not anymore! Watch out everyone - if this place sees an opportunity to rip you off - they will :*( read more

Pretty OK Pizza. A bit off the mark for NY Pizza though. Was actually a bit too thin. Crust felt like it had been sitting around for awhile, maybe from lunch 7 hours before hand. Cheese was kind of lacking on it, too thin to support any sauce. The flavor of it was good though, I'll give it that, but the consistency was off. Would give it a 3 given the fact it is in Tallahassee which has a lot of pizza places but a shortage of good pizza, if this was up north would be a 2. The sausage was authentic and sliced appropriately long ways. I used to live in Chicago and my gf is from NYC. read more

Best pizza I've found in Tallahassee. It's thin crust NY Style as the name suggests. I've ordered pizza here several times in the past couple of months and service has been great. I enjoy drinking an ice cold beer while I wait for my pizza. The meatball sub is also pretty tasty. My only complaint/suggestion is that I wish they would add an Italian Coldcut Sub to their menu. Bottom Line: I strongly recommend if you're looking for thin crust pizza. read more

Staff was great, food came out quickly, but tasted very mediocre and bland and boring. I got a small calzone, which was still a decent size, but it lacked a lot of flavor and the dough was dry. I ordered 5 wings that were so over cooked they were dry and weird, but the sauce was good... I probably won't give them another try since they're out of the way, but glad I did try. read more

Best pizza place in Tallahassee hands down. Been a regular here for the past four years, the staff is always nice and welcoming, the pizza is ALWAYS delicious! Has the perfect sweet taste to it Can eat here for a week straight and still not get tired of it! read more

one of my favorite pizza in town^_^ thin crust and fresh ingredients ,i usually order cheese pizza that super yummy.

We ordered a small cheese pizza and garlic knots. The pizza had ok flavor and the crust was extremely dry. The garlic knots were bland with huge chunks of garlic covering the top. They also didn't come with marinara. However at $8 for the pizza and $2 for the garlic knots this place is extremely cheap. Although not as good as Mellow Mushroom and Momos, I would consider this place when looking for cheap pizza. (The delivery was also fast) read more

We got delivery from them. It was ok. Then we went in person and the quality was worse, staff was rude, not to mention it took forever!!! Thought this would be our new go to place. Sadly disappointed! read more

Best pizza in Tallahassee! Love the spinach and feta pizza. I love how thin the crust is. They have really great specials everyday.

It is with a heavy heart that I am giving Brooklyn a bad review. I am a Tallahassee local at my roots; I LOVED Brooklyn. Key word- loved. I have returned home after a four month hiatus. My main issue is that THE PIZZA IS DIFFERENT. Half the cheese, half the pepperoni, and HALF THE FLAVOR. My heart is broken. To compound a bad experience both of the employees working this evening were rude to me. The male on the phone made a snarkey comment when I asked what the deal of the day was and the had me repeat my order of a pepperoni pizza TWICE. The snobby girl behind the counter was so unfriendly and didn't even say thank you or have a nice day. I will be dreaming of Decent Pizza when I am away from now on. :-( read more

Decent pizza by the slice. Always a little off when it's reheated w added veggies. Basically put luke warm spinach and mushrooms on my reheated slice. Will come back and try a bagel though. But hey, I guess pizza is never really bad. This was just medium. read more

Not the most amazing pizza in the world, but it's great for Tally. They have an everyday special for a 1-topping LG pizza that's costs around $8-9.. I forget. Haven't really had anything from there except for the pizza, but if you are feeling lazy and want some good delivery - give Brooklyn a call read more

This is the best pizza in Tallahassee. Very thin crust, NY Style. The sauce is mild and delicious and the topping are vast and great.

I've come here many times over the years. If you're looking for good NY style pizza, this is the best you'll get in Tallahassee. And, you can always get it by the slice here. Prices & quality are good. Why bother with the generic chains - just go to Brooklyn. read more

I love brooklyn pizza, but the past 3 times I've ordered the caesar salad I haven't gotten my garlic knots which I look forward to. The salad is already pricey for how much you get so I would assume they say they give 3 garlic knots for the reason. The first two times I ordered over postmates and this time I ordered online and picked up at the store - Again no garlic knots. read more

All I can say is don't do it. I wasn't quite sure if the cardboard was inside the box or on the outside. One of the garlic knots had a thick silver hair in the cheese. Speaking of cheese if the pizza looks like it came right out of a cartoon tv show, don't eat it. Legend has it that this poorly made pizza takes the souls of hungry beings in just under a night. We were fortunately lucky enough to escape with our lives and our bowels just slightly damaged. Do not make the same mistake we made, for your fate may be significantly worse than ours. read more

Best pizza I've had in Tallahassee. Brooklyn sells by the slice or you can get a whole pie, either way, everything is good. The garlic rolls are good but not the ~best~ I've ever had. I'd definitely recommend this place! read more

Brooklyn's best selling point is it's lunch prices - they have ten lunch options for six bucks (including drink). Their wings and mozzarella sticks are both pretty good, but the pizza is a a little light on sauce and has a sweetness to it that I'm not a fan of. Don't get me wrong, it's not bad. It's close to where I work, so I'd definitely do it again for lunch, but if I had the choice I'd much rather head to Decent, Milano's, or Leaning Tower. read more

This place is good as hell. The pizza is fantastic, very cheesy and good quality ingredients, the staff are incredibly friendly and helpful, and everything else Iv tried on their menu tastes great too. (Cheeseburgers, garlic knots, French fries etc) read more

Ordered Brooklyn Pizza tonight. I have had in the past and liked it a lot. Tonight, they weren't on their game at all!! Very disappointing. First, I ordered online a large pizza and it said I was out of their delivery area (and I live less than a mile away from it, so I really doubt that). Secondly, the large Brooklyn Pizza (which are square slices), when I got home were substituted for a pie without my knowledge. The garlic knots were burnt and the tiramisu was frozen. Not only that, their charge system was down, so I got sent away to get cash at the gas station next door (which had a $5 service charge). They had my phone number, so I could have at least gotten a courtesy text about the no charge cards, bring cash option. No tip for them today. Very sad indeed. It was a very unfulfilling $30 meal. read more

If you like soggy pizza that slumps down in your hand while you hold it and pizza that is really greasy that you need to use a napkin to soak up the grease before you eat it, then this place is for you. I know some people that like it but I like pizza with crust that I can hold and not have it flop down in my hand. Not my place of choice. Dont know if all the pizzas are greasy but the supreme is always extremely greasy and oily. Maybe it is from the ingredients they use, but just my personal (3) experiences. The cheesy bread balls are good because they are not as greasy and oily as the pizza. read more

5 stars based on my experiences, which basiclally consists of eating in and mainly during lunch time. Their lunch specials are awesome and you definitely get a bang for your buck. Always fresh and delicious, couple of times I ordered delivery was to a near by location so the pizza and side items were still fresh and did not disappoint. read more

This is the first and last time ordering here. When I called I was out on hold for a long time. I had to hang up and call back. I decided to go with the white garlic chicken pizza with little garlic on only half. When it came time for me to give my card number I was out on hold again. One good thing I can say is the pizza arrived earlier than I expected. The delivery drive wasn't aware I had paid over the phone and he didn't even have a pen for me to sign the receipt with. When I opened the pizza not only was it completely missing garlic but also the chicken. Naturally I decided to call them and the same person answered. She couldn't care less that my order was wrong, and she didn't offer any help. There was no manager for me to speak with, and she might be in in the morning, because she has no set schedule. The pizza was ok but a medium def isn't worth $15. Boo this place and their customers service. read more

Went to this place right after the Florida football game and managed to beat the crowd. The food is awesome and reasonably priced. It can get crowded here and parking is not good when busy. Great spot to come and eat after the game. read more

I love this place. As far as I can tell, it is the most authentic NYC-style pizza in Tallahassee. AND it's cheap. In my opinion, this place is better than any of the other pizza joints in Tallahassee that are all charging significantly more for a pie. Go here, you will be happy that you did. read more